for all those writing how fish cant sing ...look not every performance is an epic one but the video i viewed here showed a crowd that was definatly into it.. whatcha got to say about that ? jackasses....
Very good. His vocals aren't what they were though, are they? First time live since 1986? For Fish maybe. Marillion have played it with Hogarth many times since then. He does a great job of it. Then again, his voice is still there, isn't it?
As regards him being 24 years older - so? Hogarth still hits the notes on the Seasons End material from 20 years ago. Geddy Lee still hits the notes on songs from 1980, John Wetton still hits the notes on songs from the mid-70s.
What did I expect? Not much to be honest, especially after seeing the 'Return To Childhood' Tour where he (to put it politely) struggled.
Then again, he struggle on some of the 'Misplaced' material a few times when i saw Marillion do it back in '85/86.
To be honest, I don't think that his voice ever totaaly recovered atfer he lost it in the Autumn of 1985 and caused the tour to be cancelled and rescheduled for the new year.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm not convinced. Fish vocally sounds awful, he cant hit notes anymore and has dropped them to the point they have lost their vibe. I am sure it was a great gig, and top guy but musically he wouldn't get past the first round in my pubs karaoke..
He had no monitors, you know. Something went terribly wrong with them and he couldn't hear himself (you can notice him touching his ear trying to hear anything)
for all those writing how fish cant sing ...look not every performance is an epic one but the video i viewed here showed a crowd that was definatly into it.. whatcha got to say about that ? jackasses....
unstabledavid 1 year ago
american fan here good to see they are back together!!!
unstabledavid 1 year ago
@unstabledavid Who is back together ?
Silmarillion1973 1 year ago
@Silmarillion1973 i thought marrillion was realizing afterwards this was just fish not marrillion...
unstabledavid 1 year ago
@unstabledavid Ah ok, no problem. It's a great song
Silmarillion1973 1 year ago
gooooooooooooooooooooooood fish the best
albanlanfant 1 year ago
Very good. His vocals aren't what they were though, are they? First time live since 1986? For Fish maybe. Marillion have played it with Hogarth many times since then. He does a great job of it. Then again, his voice is still there, isn't it?
DrL0206 2 years ago
What did you expect ? FFS he's 24 years older !!!,
Fish's voice has changed but this was recorded on a dodgy mobile phone, I was there and it was fxxkin awesome.
RPZ501 2 years ago 6
As regards him being 24 years older - so? Hogarth still hits the notes on the Seasons End material from 20 years ago. Geddy Lee still hits the notes on songs from 1980, John Wetton still hits the notes on songs from the mid-70s.
DrL0206 2 years ago
What did I expect? Not much to be honest, especially after seeing the 'Return To Childhood' Tour where he (to put it politely) struggled.
Then again, he struggle on some of the 'Misplaced' material a few times when i saw Marillion do it back in '85/86.
To be honest, I don't think that his voice ever totaaly recovered atfer he lost it in the Autumn of 1985 and caused the tour to be cancelled and rescheduled for the new year.
This is still a great song though.
DrL0206 2 years ago
It would appear that I've suddenly forgotten how to spell.
DrL0206 2 years ago
Comment removed
RPZ501 1 year ago
He is still GOD
forestdad 1 year ago
he doesnt sound awful at all he will always be the best to me
chucklegal001 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm not convinced. Fish vocally sounds awful, he cant hit notes anymore and has dropped them to the point they have lost their vibe. I am sure it was a great gig, and top guy but musically he wouldn't get past the first round in my pubs karaoke..
shimmer1 2 years ago
He had no monitors, you know. Something went terribly wrong with them and he couldn't hear himself (you can notice him touching his ear trying to hear anything)
EdinB555 2 years ago
As a 15 year old boy at his 4th Fish gig, this was a truly magical moment :)
Torch6661 2 years ago
Was there but by "That time of the night " was a little bit worse for wear !!,
But I do remember that shirt !!
RPZ501 2 years ago
all the best freaks were in leamington spa to see fish play last weekend ! thanks for posting this .
irishmanufan 2 years ago 4
All the best freaks are here!
lesterdfunct 2 years ago 3