Composer and performers, Bravo! Shaham, you are a great musician, and a generous and astute chamber player, watching you work eyeball to eyeball with the other players when it gets down to chamber ensemble size is a lesson for all who think of soloists as 'stars.' Bravissississimo.
@musoderelict Yep: joy; exhuberance; an irrepressible sense of the dance; humor; deep and expressive pathos (were you brave enought to make it through the middle two arias and abandon your preconceptions? They are as wrenchingly beautiful as some Haendel arias.). Yep Just because it seems you have Those Emotions tied to something else (let me guess, great but patently obvious late romantic fare?) Does NOT mean they aren't present in later music - and especially here.
@MuseDuCafe H'm. Just one point - I may have preconceptions, but certainly NOT that there is no emotion in 20th century music - Bartok, for instance, I know has intense emotion. Whatever my problem is, it's not that. But thank you for trying though.
Mr Shaham is a great violonist and the conductor and the orchestra are good, but in my opinion, the tempo is definitely too slow and "pesante". This music needs more vitality.
I didn't really like this at first, I was never really into moderns, but after gaining much more appreciation for stravinsky, I see that this concerto is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING
I think it is because of the verticality of his bow strokes. Most of his landings are just uo and down, so he needs more room for his bow to compress. Just a thought...
yeah.. i just saw him do this concerto in lexington and he does it brilliantly but im not sure that stravinsky is my style yet.. none the less he is extremely talented..
actually I notice that in europe a lot of the performances have sheet music present for the soloist but doesn't mean they don't have the music memorized, you try performing in front of thousands of people and having the performance also televised all over the world
well isn't the job of violin playing to make things easy to execute...why would you intentionally make something difficult. Unless the music calls for it, for example, using difficult fingering to express tension in the music, simple is best.
I got to play in the orchestra for a performance of this. It is SO strange...but charming! Much like Stravinsky's entire body of work I guess...I got hooked on it though. :)
While we're on the subject, I don't view this as one of Gil Shaham's stronger performances (coming from a HUGE fan of his). It just seems a little unrefined compared to his usual output, with respect to intonation and articulation. And his hair isn't looking too good this time. In fact, he's not looking too good. Doesn't seem to be in the best of health when this video was made. Hope he's okay.
And that is the tightest his bow's ever been. It's a miracle he didn't break it.
probably reading the music because it's so dang hard to count! probably the most rhythmically challenging violin concerto (that gets performed regularly).
Asombrosa interpretación muy buena me encanta ^_^
MrClasicstar 3 months ago
Composer and performers, Bravo! Shaham, you are a great musician, and a generous and astute chamber player, watching you work eyeball to eyeball with the other players when it gets down to chamber ensemble size is a lesson for all who think of soloists as 'stars.' Bravissississimo.
MuseDuCafe 5 months ago 2
i am so glad i saw gil shaham live playing this masterpiece of strawinsky =D
i even got an autograph!!
Mustrad 7 months ago
did Stravinsky ever feel anything at all?
musoderelict 8 months ago
@musoderelict He did, but he pretended that he didn't and tried to suppress it.
"Composers combine notes. That is all." Despite him saying that, that would seem to apply to the serialists more than him in my mind, however.
MaestroTJS 6 months ago
@MaestroTJS That is interesting. - And all the more seeing that he later became one himself!
musoderelict 6 months ago
Comment removed
MuseDuCafe 5 months ago
@musoderelict Yep: joy; exhuberance; an irrepressible sense of the dance; humor; deep and expressive pathos (were you brave enought to make it through the middle two arias and abandon your preconceptions? They are as wrenchingly beautiful as some Haendel arias.). Yep Just because it seems you have Those Emotions tied to something else (let me guess, great but patently obvious late romantic fare?) Does NOT mean they aren't present in later music - and especially here.
MuseDuCafe 5 months ago
@MuseDuCafe H'm. Just one point - I may have preconceptions, but certainly NOT that there is no emotion in 20th century music - Bartok, for instance, I know has intense emotion. Whatever my problem is, it's not that. But thank you for trying though.
musoderelict 5 months ago
What's Prokofiev doing playing the bass at 3:51
oneofgodsfrozenpeopl 9 months ago 6
@oneofgodsfrozenpeopl
LOL
jamesdongvideos 9 months ago
people should be able to clap after movements!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hamporkcheese 11 months ago
@Hamporkcheese It is kind of a stupid tradition, especially when you have a movement that really gets people's adrenaline pumping.
MaestroTJS 6 months ago
my god.... to have this mans music memorized is amazing.....
Hamporkcheese 11 months ago
First time to listen to Mr. Shaham and he looks down to earth, confident, pleasant, and a regular guy. He's also very good.
MrAkihiros 11 months ago
5:43 to end. holy shit
gabrielthemarine 11 months ago
i love this piece and i love this artist.
cuddlebuttons 1 year ago
skip to :23
Anathemael 1 year ago
the right man for the right concerto.
minasgekos 1 year ago
What a bizarre rendition of Bach's Magnificat.
MusicaRicercata 1 year ago
Stravinsky and Shostakovitch........need I say more?
peppersax 1 year ago
loooool wrote in 10 mins
OrpheusJRK 1 year ago
Long live russian music
y7u7r7i 1 year ago
what kind of trumpet was that at :29- :33 i never saw an instrument like that
awsomedrummer100 1 year ago
@awsomedrummer100 I've heard that it is a rotary valved trumpet. It is supposedly more common out of the US. Don't quote me on it though.
Stringy007 1 year ago
@awsomedrummer100 It is a regular rotary valve trumpet, a standard for the German and Austrian orchestras.
dmitrislepovitch 6 months ago
Mr Shaham is a great violonist and the conductor and the orchestra are good, but in my opinion, the tempo is definitely too slow and "pesante". This music needs more vitality.
clarinetjo 1 year ago 2
I'm pretty sure the autobowing is on purpose (for overtone effect).
Daveydee7 1 year ago
I didn't really like this at first, I was never really into moderns, but after gaining much more appreciation for stravinsky, I see that this concerto is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING
werq34ac 1 year ago 4
OH MY GOSH! i LOVE this. :DDDDD
stravinsky is so creative!!
FaygoAddict 2 years ago 2
good job igor, one of the best violin concertos ive ever heard =]
Korsair777 2 years ago 11
yea something original for a change
pviola314 2 years ago 4
Great job by Shaham--thanks for posting, I really enjoyed this
OriginalMoonbeam 2 years ago 2
yayyyyyyy! I'm so glad this is up! I love this concerto AND Gil Shaham! I wish more people played this thing.
frostishosti 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
1. Cover your mouth with you hand
2. Make a wish
3.Close your hand (fist)
4. Hold you hand at heart for 5 seconds
5. Send this to 3 more videos
6. Tommorrow will be the best day ever
it actually worked
discis 2 years ago
i wonder why he always tightens his bow so much?
xXLeafXNinjaXx 2 years ago
I think it is because of the verticality of his bow strokes. Most of his landings are just uo and down, so he needs more room for his bow to compress. Just a thought...
Stringy007 2 years ago
He plays with a lot of pressure ;)
AlicanYilmaz1991 2 years ago
because when you're THAT good, you can do whatever the f you want haha.
sijas 2 years ago 3
This starts exactly like one of Bartok's solos.
ironmagma 2 years ago
Tri-tone master Stravinsky.
Gil Shaham plays this very beautifully.
cfeAncient 2 years ago 3
this concerto it's very funny i like it¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
carlosking007 2 years ago
haha i know its so humerous
xXLeafXNinjaXx 2 years ago
Обожаю скрипичный концерт Стравинского! ! ! И очень люблю этого замечательного скрипача! ! !
Krasafftcik 2 years ago 3
Mr. Sharam is one of the greatest names of the violin nowadays. I was in Lexington too and saw how brilliant he is!
cardoso282 2 years ago 2
yeah.. i just saw him do this concerto in lexington and he does it brilliantly but im not sure that stravinsky is my style yet.. none the less he is extremely talented..
bigern545 2 years ago
i have yet to understand this concerto.
dxhaloxc 3 years ago
que cuerdas usa gil shaham? gracias
leibnizsulbaran 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
USA CUERDAS PARA VIOLIN XD
arreolacarlos92 2 years ago
que buen concierto.el sonido de ese violin es tan suave.
leibnizsulbaran 3 years ago
hey he isnt playing frm memory..
vlhere 3 years ago
so?
xXLeafXNinjaXx 3 years ago
thats always the custom in concertos...the sosloist plays from memory...oh yah I get it, for modern works you can use the sheet music!!
vlhere 3 years ago
actually I notice that in europe a lot of the performances have sheet music present for the soloist but doesn't mean they don't have the music memorized, you try performing in front of thousands of people and having the performance also televised all over the world
austinViolaboy 3 years ago
he doesn't do a single bowing that Stravinsky indicates, also he has chosen very "safe" fingerings for the hole thing, making it lose its charm...
quite boring in general...
JVQ8Y 3 years ago
well isn't the job of violin playing to make things easy to execute...why would you intentionally make something difficult. Unless the music calls for it, for example, using difficult fingering to express tension in the music, simple is best.
AquariangyrL15 3 years ago
When Shaham is playing at 2:38, what instrument is doubling the flute? I'm assuming trombone?
ThaSchwab 3 years ago
I saw him play this piece with the BSO the other day...
He was amazing as always...
fatrump123 3 years ago
I got to play in the orchestra for a performance of this. It is SO strange...but charming! Much like Stravinsky's entire body of work I guess...I got hooked on it though. :)
MrNoelJMIS 3 years ago 2
how is did he not snap his bow in this concerto
ellegin88 3 years ago 2
Actually, he did. Right after the performance. It was a $70000 Tourte.....what a loss.
issavestheworld 3 years ago
OMFGZZZ!
i would cry if i broke my bow especially a tourte :O
xXLeafXNinjaXx 3 years ago
... i'm not sure he actually uses a Tourte... though that's besides the point of your slightly condescending comment. you could have nicer.
concertolover81291 3 years ago
....my condescending comment?
i wasnt being mean.
xXLeafXNinjaXx 3 years ago
damn, after that I just want to run outside and scribble STRAVINSKY WAS A GOD DAMN GENIUS all over the fronts of other peoples houses
nathan87 3 years ago 25
While we're on the subject, I don't view this as one of Gil Shaham's stronger performances (coming from a HUGE fan of his). It just seems a little unrefined compared to his usual output, with respect to intonation and articulation. And his hair isn't looking too good this time. In fact, he's not looking too good. Doesn't seem to be in the best of health when this video was made. Hope he's okay.
And that is the tightest his bow's ever been. It's a miracle he didn't break it.
frankborder 3 years ago 2
probably reading the music because it's so dang hard to count! probably the most rhythmically challenging violin concerto (that gets performed regularly).
frankborder 3 years ago 2
i luv shaham , he is incredible
onlyfederer 3 years ago 2
wow shaham is reading the music he probably learned it on short notice
carloslaran 3 years ago
thanks for posting great stuff on youtube.
shaham needs to have more videos here
gimaru1 3 years ago
Glad you liked it!
Gil Shaham is one of my favourites too!
Oxy151268 3 years ago 7
thanks for posting this amazing performance.
seebelious 3 years ago
Great performance!Thank you!Gil Shaham is my favourite!
adrianavioline 3 years ago 2