Added: 3 years ago
From: DerDantey
Views: 157,139
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (246)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This video kills ego, and really makes you realize how even the human race really is.

    We are all control seaking, animalistic creatures. No different than animals, just more intelligent in some ways. Fuck conformity, and be who you want to be. This life is too damn short to waste it on impression others.

  • Tret Reznor is god

  • this song changed a lot in my life

  • Guess one of their daughters joined in the dislike!

  • 10 times better than the recorded version man. The hairs on the back of my neck are standing on end.

  • the atmosphere in this video is unreal. Absolutely incredible

  • @LiteFtomBelow1993 it is not the same as they use at cinemas. People shouldn't bullshit on the Internet... You should have real friends for that

  • Wow its Amazing especially to see all those people sharing the same passion for this song and its EPICness.

  • This is amazing

  • Hey does anyone on this know what the thing being projected on is made out of, is it a screen or a sheet of something ? :)

  • @HystericsMusic A silver curtain, the same thing they use at cinemas

  • Look at all the middle fingers <3

  • The tears always come at 2:30.

    I never cry.

  • i was there for this song. i was in the crowd

  • . . . diesen song sende ich virtuell an die selbsternannte "Laborratte" von der Thomatenwiese. Suck it ant see ;)

    =^.^= . . . you know who i am.

  • My favorite NIN song by far. So good

  • fuckin beautiful and meaningful

  • In my opinion, Hurt is to Downward Spiral, as Right Where It Belongs is to With Teeth

  • @mythkid1208 Hurt - The downward spiral

    Right where it belongs - With teeth

    Zero-sum - Year Zero

    Something i can never have - Pretty hate machine

    Somewhat Damaged - The fragile

    :D

  • @hallorand9 well played sir

  • my seemingly outspoken opinion:

    bush= mediocre president/trying time period/failed. not a damn sith lord lol.

    obama= ok president/trying time period/doing ok. not god.

    great song with a meaning that could be applied to whatever you want because it is INCREDIBLY deep

  • People's logic is retarded. They go apeshit over a picture of Bush, yet the pictures of dead people and murder they calmly watch and do nothing. Idiots.

  • @ThePoonerBooner read the lyrics and try to understand what the song is about. the entire song is a giant "what if..". basically it's asking: what if the reality you see isn't reality at all. what if you could see passed your ignorance? would you really want to see that you're the bad guy? you think you're doing right because of the ideas you already hold but in reality you're the bad guy because of your jaded, ignorant point of view.

    Bush was likely a large inspiration for this song.

  • @ThePoonerBooner

    lol I think you're the idiot here.

  • @ThePoonerBooner I get what you're trying to say but what would you have them do? Boo? Cheer? I think that particular shot of The Bushs was put in for contrast to the other shot. On other hand you have the war shots, gritty, real and showing the plight and human suffering and death it causes, all while the people who conspired it dance in a ballroom as if nothing were happening. I have to think most NiNs fans at this show understood such a concept. Which is why they reacted the way they did.

  • you can make it different!

    /watch?v=4Z9WVZddH9w

  • so strong!

  • I named my bong trent resin er

  • I am in. We only live on one planet.

  • this song makes me cry everytime.

  • when i saw this live in concert it made me cry. but then trent played BURN live...made it all better.

  • exelent performance spectakular light rigging

  • Many great songs, but this is his masterpiece.

  • Seen this in concert. God I love you Trent. Please come back and do more!

  • this is god's theme

  • i dont think this song is meant to depress people its meant to provoke reflection and introspection

  • Yeah, bush and his wife think this movie is cliched

  • Could those video clips BE any more cliched? Give me a break.

  • @garrad could u BE an even bigger douche

  • Only a legend could do something as beautiful as this

  • ♥ This song, this movie and the sound of this performance.

  • I love how Trents' voice sounds like crying at the end of the song..

    It always gets me, no matter how often I play it.

  • This song is so damn beautiful, I feel like my heart is going to rip through my chest every time I hear it. Like my my body can't handle the emotions it's feeling. It's unexplainable, discomforting and somehow fulfilling at the same time. I love it. I love how this song makes me feel.

  • Everything is energy. We all emit energy unseen. 98% of your reality is how you choose to perceive & react to the chemical reactions happening inside your brain. These chemical reactions comprise our vision, touch, taste, smell, emotions. We manipulate our reality with the power of our minds. If you were able to truly understand & tap into this ability, what would you choose to do with your energy? What would you choose to become? Would you be too afraid to break free?

  • Bush and his wife disliked this.

  • Comment removed

  • And one of his daughters

  • @RightHookJoker

    Oh look! Obama added one too O_o

  • @RightHookJoker

    And one of his daughters

    

  • @RightHookJoker

    so did cheney

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @Providius yeah it was filmed in America. The DVD menu says New Mexico and Colorado.

  • Its so sad that America flips off the ex president...sad thing.

  • @SuperTimeStretch This wasn't filmed in America. Plus, fuck bush.... with penis!

  • @SuperTimeStretch Its more sad that he was president

  • 2 Dislkes?????????? WTF is this shit, i'll change anytime sex for this 5:15 minutes

  • I cried so bad...

  • This is so beautiful and such a moving performance. It speaks directly to the situation that this world has been spiraling down. Thank you for uploading this video.

  • This song is genius. Always makes me tear.

  • This is great!! Thanks for sharing :)

  • I Cried!

  • This man. This song. I want to go back to the day of their Wave Goodbye Tour in PA so damn badly.

  • Comment removed

  • as powerful as Hurt, if not more so. Desolate but brutally honest, the high vocalization at the end always gets me... thank God that war monger is out of office.

  • Trent is a motherfucking genius

  • I WAS THERE!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Lateralus1019 Lucky motherfucker! I would give my life, to be one of the lucky ones who saw this perfect show! ;)

  • @Hausartikel - I ate a bunch of shrooms before the Show too....Words can not describe it, literally!!!!!!

  • Does anyone know where the footage from the supermarket and the aerial footage of the housing is from?

  • @renfist

    the footage from the supermarket looks like a clip from 'fake plastic trees' by radiohead.

    go check it out :P

  • i got to see this tour but we didnt get a super fancy light show :(

  • how so many people gave bush the finger.

  • Are we sure what side we're on ? In front of a stage with Trent performing I'm sure I'll always feel on the good side

  • It was amazing seeing this live!

  • It was amazing seeing this live! 

  • Can definitely see the influence of Roger Waters here with the stage production - The Wall anybody?

  • JUST KEEP GOING AND DONT STOP WRITING, PLAYING, OR WHATEVER! WE HAVE NOTHING TO LOOK FOWARD TO MAN... THIS SONG IS JUST PLAIN AWESOME.

  • This describes how stupid and vulnerable humans are.Religion and politics killed the human spirit.How sad?

  • This is GENIUS!

  • Musical perfection

  • This is one of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard.These Lines wakes the Mind and Soul.The message is that only thing that matters are Money and to Rule,and its Hystory Present and the Future of whole Humanity..The whole planet should finaly realise that..and we should stay concens,learn more about whole world,know the games wich ''Big''people are playing above our heads..like we are just a number and a name in ID.Knowledge,MUSIc(people like Trent ),Arts are the only ways to fite Against

  • i hate how the crowd can't shut the fuck up even during this incredible beautiful piece of art -.-

  • this looks like the hurt video

  • I hate having politics taint music...

  • lol did you recognized that there is no 480p avaiable ? ^^

  • I see 2 negative votes. It must be Bush and his lady.

  • @wiliuzl haha, its gotta be the Bushs'

  • What is the clip at 4:19?

  • Right Where it Belongs Is my favorite/ Most loved song ever distributed to the public. It is a near reflected image of my psychosis. truly beautiful. This is what helps me sleep at night.

  • Bush disliked this piece of art twice.

  • The Allegory of the Cave by Aristotle reimagined....

  • @Ridethelightning94 wasn't it by Plato?

  • @animenice yeah I meant plato. My bad

  • Am i the only one that isnt pleased with the crowd fipping off Bush?

  • @mrmama456

    I am A nin Fan but i have always been a Bush supporter I didn't agree with his spending and immigration policy's but I did like him as a president.

  • @mrmama456

    Yes you are. I can't wait for Bush to die so I can piss on his grave. Well, I have to visit Jerry Falwell's grave to lose five pounds on it if you know what I mean

  • @SexyArcanine666 Damn.

  • 3.45 " FUCK YOU"

  • anyone can send me some guitar tabs for this particular vers?

  • unbelievable.. a song wich sounds so warm, but fills you with such a cold darkness... trent reznor is one of the rare kind of people you can call modern philosopher!

    even if i prefer it loud and fast, i have to say that reznor is a great talent in writing ballads..

  • Fuck Bush. A motto we should all strive for.

  • This song makes me want to do something meaningful in this world

  • Fucking Brilliant!!!! <3

  • (...) And damage. And what's more large. Oh, I would forget, my English is weak, what as a matter of fact very well you can see. I apologise to everyone which read it. ^^"

  • I don't know why, but when I'm listening to this song, tears alone will swarm for my eyes. I'm simply not able to control myself, I'm not able to stop it... Strange. I'm alble to cry only under the influence of listened songs... And the one is unique, similary as "Hurt" which entirely is chanching my humour and is inducing to very deep reflections. Oh, NIN is something, not this way, as this contemporary mess listened by lots of people not being able to understand for some reason specific. (...)

  • beautiful song, amazing performance

  • i love the middle fingers@ w !!!!

  • Genius!

  • When I hear this song I always freeze..

    To me the world seems like a totally fucked up place with a lot of fucked up humans.

    But everything is right where it belongs, hate, love, war, peace..

    The world has to be like this, I know.. But sometimes I just feel like killing myself because of all the pain and suffering still going on.

    This masterpiece is so important, it reminds me that I'm not alone with my thoughts and feelings, that there are still people out there, like me..

    Thanks for reading.

  • @damianhess I know exactly what you mean, you're not alone bro.

  • My favorite song before x-mas every year... I don't know why!

  • Comment removed

  • Fucking powerful.

  • Comment removed

  • Awesome

  • this song is so deep and emotional ... ohmygod i almost cried, too much life problems in my head and it's all just makes me wanna cry when i listen to this song

  • Beautiful.... Just absolutely amazing.

  • AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • spectacular.

  • ....Fuck....this make you think.....

  • I still remember the first time I heard this. Shivers.

  • @cherrywaves77 i get em everytime i hear it.

  • For all his anger and shouting, he can really write beautiful songs.

  • This video has been added to your Favorites.

    Nuff said.

  • Brilliant clip!!! And I loved the way the crowd reacted when Bush appeared =]

  • @DSidrao liked that too, though, he only did what he was expected by the public. people want and demand more and more, so in democracy that was what was needed to do, to keep this show going till the end when everything is cycled through shelves of shops to carpage dump, while many ended up with lots of cash and nothing to buy. Sure, rules are made by humans and for humans.. now its different, now humans are for rules.

  • one of them, or maybe the best song i've ever heart. I assume that this song is telling exactly what Trent thought, during he wrote it. Everytime I hear that song, it touchs at the bottom of my heart. Touching people with songs and not doing the 110 same song with a different lyric makes it worth to hear it. thanks trent!

  • me encanta este concierto aparte es mi banda favorita demonios tocan tan bien!!!!!

  • i think seeing NIN is one of the few times its okay to not be close... otherwise you'd miss this incredible show.

  • Trent Reznor, the most amazing songwriter?

  • This is one song that I think everybody has to listen to ... Makes one wonder .. .

  • I never seen an artist put emotions, genius, quality, meanings in one song. Trent Reznor done it...

  • The visuals set to this song are almost an affront to me. Couldn't believe what I was watching. It felt like my brain was vomiting on itself while my heart broke.

  • idk y this wasnt in inception

  • Aside from Hurt and We're in this Together, this could be Trent's masterpiece. Brilliant.

  • buddhism ! 100% buddhist concepts about reality !

  • Serious !

  • I want to take this moment to tell you Trent, that you are a beautiful human. Thank you for this and everything else you've done and continue to do.

  • @Cutflood I agree, trent reznor is the only real musician I know of so far

    I've been listening to his music since i was a 2 year old in the car, He is my idol and my musical inspiration.

    Everything about him and everything he does and makes is pure beauty, too bad we don't have more people like that...

  • ART ! ART ! ART ! ART ! ART ! ART ! ART !

  • what if everything... was an elaborate dream!

  • i have once been a sufferer of depression. i can feel the emotion, the hopelessness, of this song from the inside. trent's creations really touch me. thx trent.

  • I'd love to hear an Acoustic album from Trent; just piano and acoustic guitars.

  • First time I cried in 20 years. Was watching the DVD when I first got it, and that newlywed couple started dancing in all those frames and everything just welled up.

    Changes my perspective on the world.

  • Nine Inch Nails always play different versions in live. =D

  • thats rite

  • 4:20...brilliant. so many layers

  • @Atix1950gt You Should totally buy 'Beside You In Time' DVD. its soo worth it.

  • chris favorite sone

  • What a great performance by one of the best bands ever!!! This song is so deep!! It makes you think and reconsider the world as you look at it!

  • This is soo great..Bush on the Screen, and all Middlefingers are going up :-))

  • @blacksails he was the worst leader of a nation behind hitler, he deserves it

  • @Annonymus121

    Yes

  • Trent Reznor-Without him,how could we flip off George Bush during a concert?

  • best song ever

  • Tears? Well, I'm not far away. My mind stunned suddenly by listening this song and I can't figure out how to unblow it, just have to listen it to again and again.... Nine Inch Nails is pure music.

  • Trent is probably one of the last true musicians that haven't sold out. I find it so amazing that one man can spur so much talent and genius in his music. Truly on of the last "greats" of this generation/

  • these guys are awesome, trying to send the messages of important issues of the world through their music and stage shows. Sucks they dont play live now but hey at least their still making music!

  • I Saw this Live on Shrooms....OMG!!!!!!!!

  • HOW FUCKING AWESOME IS TRENT AND NIN!!!!!

    this song & video reminds me HURT... :D

  • This video gives me the chills man, so fucking epic.

  • Does anyone have words, to describe this? I don't have, its just fucking beautiful!

  • AMAZING! thank you, Trent <3

  • Comment removed

  • Ho la prima strofa tatuata su un fianco...sta canzone significa tanto per me..senza parole questa esibizione..Reznor è un genio

    I have the first tattooed strophe on a side...this song means so much for me..without words this exhibition..Reznor is a genius

  • i think i'd like the vid more if the american people didn't screamed so much, but either ways if i was there i'd probably scream too

  • É de ir às lágrimas... Lindo...

  • theres more truth in this song than any speech given by our "fearless leaders", Thank you Trent........you will be remember for centuries to come................