@slimshadyrealrealrea ay man if you dont like nirvana thats fine, but you dont have to go being a douche on their vids. I do admit, I like the wipers version of this song better as well but I dont complain! k?
the wipers version is the best what I don't like about this version is when he says better watch out it's out of key listen to the wipers version and you'll here what I'm talking about and no I'm not slagging Kurt off he's one of my hero's I think he did a great job on D7 I used to like that version over the wipers version but I prefer the wipers version now with the way it sound's so dark it makes you feel there's more going on in that version
all i listened to was nirvana, like i didnt listen to another band for a year, so im sooo tired of them, i have every shirt and poster of kurt, u wanna buy some?
@doodoobrown1 sounds like my year haha. I go through phases where I get so into a band or musician and Nirvana has been going on for a while now... I hope it ends soon lol
what up, why don't you listen to nirvana anymore?..hell, I I started listening to the wipers too after a while, but never would if it wasn't for nirvana.
He was actually more then solid IMO. Cobain, Thurston Moore, Lee Ronaldo, Greg Ginn, Greg Sage (writer of this song/The Wipers), East Bay Ray, KimThayil, and Hendrix just made some of the craziest sounds I have ever heard.
I think Cobain's skills on guitar really shined on the song Areo Zeppelin.
NO!!! no he wasnt, dont get me wrong IM a BIG fan, but his sloppy playing was an expression of sorts. music need not be great to be good nor good to be great
I know. i said solid,not great,not a guitar "god",solid,and i agree with you,
his sloppy playing was an expression it's called grunge,a whole genre based on feedback,distortion,and mistakes.but back to my point,he didnt even have to play flawlessly to make ppl listen,MAKING HIM A SOLID GUITAR PLAYER
@Untouchable787 i agree. I dont get why everyone says kurt cobain was such a bad guitarist. He definitely knew his way around the fretboard. He may not have been fuckin jimi hendrix, but he had some crazy solos and catchy riffs. Plus he intended not to sound like he was that good. that was part of the style. Its called "grunge" for a reason.
he was amazing,I'd like to see most of the people who criticize even play a guitar.
Nevermind playing one under the influence of heroin,while completely improvising a solo.
Everyones so quick to judge,Nobody ever just said "fuck it" and really really did what they felt until Kurt,And noone has the same way since,now it's all auto-tune and pyrotechnics..it's a sad time for real music i'm afraid :(
@Untouchable787 Nobody??? Seriously youre a fucking idiot the whole underground scene bas a big fuck you to popularity, Nirvana was one of the few that turned out famous. Do you have to wanna suck Kurts dick just because youre a Nirvana fan?!?
Yes,I do play guitar,and i personally enjoy the chaotic,grungy sound they always had.
It's the style of music I like...and seeing as how your on this video..most people would assume you like it too..not assume your going to be a little bitch who just argues with someone because they have the highest rated comment..so feel free to put up a cover or guitar video..since your OBVIOUSLY such a proficient musician...?
@Untouchable787 I'm not a proficient musician myself, but I don't stick my foot in my mouth either...
K. was known in the whole industry as being NOT a solid guitarist, or composer; what he was good in was arranging his peculiar sound.. not that ANYONE could hear all the mistakes he regularly made at live shows.. and yes since my 'opinion' ( as others would call by .... TRUTH ) has more sense in it than you're obviously biased and emotionally attached ignorant comment.. yes, it DOES count hahaha
@Untouchable787 furthermore.. you assume right.. I wasn't being a li'l bitch who just argues with someone because they have the highest rated comment... 2nd place lsrrr!! LOL
while kurt did a nice cover of the Wipers you've never seen the original band do it live I suspect.. you should have had a chance to see the Wipers do their music live.. as 'jenius' as kurt was, Greg Sage is the writer of THIS song.. the genius is his..
while this is a good cover of the Wipers song Return of the Rat.. not even Nirvana could do it total justice.. The Wipers were one of a kind.. Greg Sage is genius and one of the most amazing live performers.
I agree. This doesn't even really seem like a full effort, anyway, this cover. I hear a lot more anger and conviction in the original...the overriding feeling in this cover is "lazy punk"...I dunno what I'm trying to say...
Ricky, it would be hard to match the intensity of Greg Sage live.. he had an amazing ability to interpret his music, and I think sometimes he wasnt with us in the audience at all but in a place far away.. just my opinion..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
greg sage, will always be better than nirvana, nirvana is over-rated, I would rather hear J mascis do a wipers covers than Cobain, Cobain is a junkie, hiz wife killed him for stardom, so let it rest with the doll parts that remain for that the crooked junkie heroin fuck loving slut that she is............good luck to courtney love, .....you need some sort of naqrcostic assistance,....bitch
The wipers version does not suck at all its just different both are great songs in different ways ! and seeing as kurt loved the wipers youd really piss him off talking like that ^_*
JimBob is a fuckin' asshole and who thinks that Wipers' version sucks is a vomit.I like Nirvana version but i have respect for artists and music in general and don't understand who says "this sucks and that sucks".The Wipers never suck!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Great song! I wish Nirvana would have done more kick ass covers like this. When I first heard this song I was like kick ass. The Wipers Version Sucks! Nirvana Kicks more ass with this song!
THE WIPERS
!!!!!!!!
SnakeChannel12 1 month ago
That was definitely not the end of the song.
0158014 2 months ago
this is horrible wipers rules!
slimshadyrealrealrea 2 months ago
@slimshadyrealrealrea ay man if you dont like nirvana thats fine, but you dont have to go being a douche on their vids. I do admit, I like the wipers version of this song better as well but I dont complain! k?
discochicken2000 1 month ago
the wipers version is the best what I don't like about this version is when he says better watch out it's out of key listen to the wipers version and you'll here what I'm talking about and no I'm not slagging Kurt off he's one of my hero's I think he did a great job on D7 I used to like that version over the wipers version but I prefer the wipers version now with the way it sound's so dark it makes you feel there's more going on in that version
wipers86 5 months ago
Comment removed
wipers86 5 months ago
0:37
Why are there some versions of this song with Kurt's cough and some without it?
Videogametube 5 months ago
The Wipers were awesome.. hence why Nirvana covered their songs.
Just Greg Sage aint no Kurt Cobain is all ^_^
bgenaral 5 months ago
I love that this video has no dislikes =)
jackman8122 6 months ago
@jackman8122 And now will come some idiot and dislike the video.
4zr489 6 months ago
What video is the one at 22-26 like what concert and song
axlesteel12 6 months ago
Damn, this guitar solo is so sad... The guitar just sounds like it's crying out in hopelessness... Guitars are so kick ass.
Fyrzon 11 months ago
@Fyrzon listen to hearbreaker - by nirvana it's a cover of led zepp's song but kurt creates a great guitar solo
sk8xdan 10 months ago
i would never be obsessed with nirvana or kurt cobain. NEVER!!
andywarstarforever 1 year ago
Kurt cobain may not be an amazing musician but he has an extremely good taste in music
fogoverflame 1 year ago 2
@fogoverflame one of the best,honest and most sensible comments on you tube!! :-)
torpid2 1 year ago
great.murder.coverup
MUSIC55551 1 year ago
HEY PEOPLE,
just check out the song "Oh My Juliet" By the band LM-C, it's the same exact riff..
I hate the way japanese people steals songs.
ryuchou666 1 year ago
good cover. Kurt had impeccable taste in rock.
jek21 1 year ago
all i listened to was nirvana, like i didnt listen to another band for a year, so im sooo tired of them, i have every shirt and poster of kurt, u wanna buy some?
doodoobrown1 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 Sure or you can just give them to me for free.
Aussiebloke297 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 keen bro for some posters n shit
RedHotChiliPrimus 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 i will and how can you get tired of Nirvana ??
laxrat123 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 i will buy shirts . what sort youhave
bbrraaddlleeyyrr 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1
WHAT SIZE
DARKSTER1ER 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 sounds like my year haha. I go through phases where I get so into a band or musician and Nirvana has been going on for a while now... I hope it ends soon lol
rasputozen 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 hell yeah ill buy some. im grounded and my parents wont let me go anywhere for like a month.
nirvana4evr11 1 year ago
@doodoobrown1 can I burn all those posters and shirts for my amusement?
BieberJustinl 4 months ago
@BieberJustinl pfff get a life idiot
MyNameIsXanthie 3 months ago
@doodoobrown1 And you're still looking them up on youtube!
MrMagicEyeLens 4 months ago
@doodoobrown1 seeing that this comment about posters for sale is about a year old, i may be too late but i want some
nirvana4evr11 1 month ago
@doodoobrown1 hey can i get some posters and shirts? well seeing that the comment was about a year ago, i may be too late
nirvana4evr11 1 month ago
@doodoobrown1 i've been listenign to'em for about 3years straight now, still great :P don't have a shirt, or a poster. but i'm still a true fan.
philipismeXD 1 month ago
2:04 hahaha
DangoTeff 2 years ago
what up, why don't you listen to nirvana anymore?..hell, I I started listening to the wipers too after a while, but never would if it wasn't for nirvana.
farmhandfilms 2 years ago
tHIS SONG WAS WRITTEN BY WIPERS
danfreerock 2 years ago 20
you do know that this is a cover song right?
RulerOFmany 2 years ago
Kurt Cobain was a SOLID guitar player
i dont care what anybody says
Untouchable787 2 years ago 35
he's one of the best in my book, very interesting player. he made his guitar come alive and sound moody, angry.
We lost something really great when Nirvana 's run ended
JonnyCapricorn 2 years ago 7
i couldnt agree more
Untouchable787 2 years ago
He was actually more then solid IMO. Cobain, Thurston Moore, Lee Ronaldo, Greg Ginn, Greg Sage (writer of this song/The Wipers), East Bay Ray, KimThayil, and Hendrix just made some of the craziest sounds I have ever heard.
I think Cobain's skills on guitar really shined on the song Areo Zeppelin.
This is an awesome cover.
DeadKennedysNirvana8 2 years ago 5
Everything in this comment is.....yea. I approve. Haha.
russelgman 1 year ago
NO!!! no he wasnt, dont get me wrong IM a BIG fan, but his sloppy playing was an expression of sorts. music need not be great to be good nor good to be great
confuseTHEmasses 2 years ago
Yeah,
I know. i said solid,not great,not a guitar "god",solid,and i agree with you,
his sloppy playing was an expression it's called grunge,a whole genre based on feedback,distortion,and mistakes.but back to my point,he didnt even have to play flawlessly to make ppl listen,MAKING HIM A SOLID GUITAR PLAYER
Untouchable787 2 years ago
@Untouchable787 i agree. I dont get why everyone says kurt cobain was such a bad guitarist. He definitely knew his way around the fretboard. He may not have been fuckin jimi hendrix, but he had some crazy solos and catchy riffs. Plus he intended not to sound like he was that good. that was part of the style. Its called "grunge" for a reason.
jacxdaless 1 year ago 5
@jacxdaless yeah exactly,
he was amazing,I'd like to see most of the people who criticize even play a guitar.
Nevermind playing one under the influence of heroin,while completely improvising a solo.
Everyones so quick to judge,Nobody ever just said "fuck it" and really really did what they felt until Kurt,And noone has the same way since,now it's all auto-tune and pyrotechnics..it's a sad time for real music i'm afraid :(
Untouchable787 1 year ago
@Untouchable787 Nobody??? Seriously youre a fucking idiot the whole underground scene bas a big fuck you to popularity, Nirvana was one of the few that turned out famous. Do you have to wanna suck Kurts dick just because youre a Nirvana fan?!?
Ekyvvsaq 8 months ago
@Untouchable787 you obviously don't play guitar.. and even if you do, you couldn't be any bit educated in it..
shortlimb1 5 months ago
@shortlimb1 because your opinion matters?
Yes,I do play guitar,and i personally enjoy the chaotic,grungy sound they always had.
It's the style of music I like...and seeing as how your on this video..most people would assume you like it too..not assume your going to be a little bitch who just argues with someone because they have the highest rated comment..so feel free to put up a cover or guitar video..since your OBVIOUSLY such a proficient musician...?
Untouchable787 5 months ago
@Untouchable787 I'm not a proficient musician myself, but I don't stick my foot in my mouth either...
K. was known in the whole industry as being NOT a solid guitarist, or composer; what he was good in was arranging his peculiar sound.. not that ANYONE could hear all the mistakes he regularly made at live shows.. and yes since my 'opinion' ( as others would call by .... TRUTH ) has more sense in it than you're obviously biased and emotionally attached ignorant comment.. yes, it DOES count hahaha
shortlimb1 5 months ago
@Untouchable787 furthermore.. you assume right.. I wasn't being a li'l bitch who just argues with someone because they have the highest rated comment... 2nd place lsrrr!! LOL
u=fail.
shortlimb1 5 months ago
yeah.. and what are you listening to now? linkin park?
Calinn86 2 years ago
lol yeah 0:36 is like the single worst pic of kurt ever
REMslave0318 2 years ago
why dont you go fuck yourself
mothsloth 2 years ago 5
No way! He's ALWAYS beautiful. <3
Neverfadeaway27 2 years ago
i made this video so long ago! i cant beleive how many views it has
doodoobrown1 2 years ago 2
the production is more raw than other stuff . . . what session was this from?
Lifevirus4 2 years ago
36 - there is cough lol listen...
selfkillman 2 years ago
00:36
selfkillman 2 years ago
that's smart...only Nirvana can cover The Wipers and sound great...it was the same musical spirit.Great Impact
djsundancekid 2 years ago 2
noooo...
nirvana is the best
kurt is a jenius
akiri18 2 years ago
while kurt did a nice cover of the Wipers you've never seen the original band do it live I suspect.. you should have had a chance to see the Wipers do their music live.. as 'jenius' as kurt was, Greg Sage is the writer of THIS song.. the genius is his..
FannyBogdanof 2 years ago 2
Hey Genius... its spelled genius... Genius.
Savedleech 2 years ago
while this is a good cover of the Wipers song Return of the Rat.. not even Nirvana could do it total justice.. The Wipers were one of a kind.. Greg Sage is genius and one of the most amazing live performers.
FannyBogdanof 2 years ago 2
I agree. This doesn't even really seem like a full effort, anyway, this cover. I hear a lot more anger and conviction in the original...the overriding feeling in this cover is "lazy punk"...I dunno what I'm trying to say...
RickyWagons 2 years ago
Ricky, it would be hard to match the intensity of Greg Sage live.. he had an amazing ability to interpret his music, and I think sometimes he wasnt with us in the audience at all but in a place far away.. just my opinion..
FannyBogdanof 2 years ago
lol @ when he coughs after the first chorus.
calsonicSTi 2 years ago
wow i've never heard this song before... thanx 4 posting this! : )
kurtcobainluver27 2 years ago
Cool,it´s a great song !
kakbratze97 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
greg sage, will always be better than nirvana, nirvana is over-rated, I would rather hear J mascis do a wipers covers than Cobain, Cobain is a junkie, hiz wife killed him for stardom, so let it rest with the doll parts that remain for that the crooked junkie heroin fuck loving slut that she is............good luck to courtney love, .....you need some sort of naqrcostic assistance,....bitch
ellay911 2 years ago
Please just end your sad life.
ps3quinn 2 years ago 3
haha...GENIUS!
ryanstamen 2 years ago
This has the same ''feeling'' to it as the D-7 By The Wipers
Ampex101 2 years ago
You know that they did that song too right?
imjustkidding24 2 years ago
Yeah :P
Ampex101 2 years ago
whoa, fuck yeah. I can't believe they covered this one. I like the original better, but this version is badass as well.
willquito 2 years ago
yeah it's a wipers-cover.. of course it is..
maultra1 2 years ago
i love this song, also its funny you can hear someone cough at :39 probably Kurt haha
whizer5454 2 years ago
Comment removed
1993name 2 years ago
AT 37 IT CAUGHTS BAD ASS SONG THO
1998c3po 2 years ago
Nirvana cover for return of the rat? D:! Nice!
Myzarik 2 years ago 4
when did kurt have blue hair??
evilemoelmo69 3 years ago
he dyed his hair red white and blue for some concert but idk wen it was all blue
popcornstand39 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is Best NIRVANA Forever
NIRVANApe 3 years ago
Is Best NIRVANA Forever
NIRVANApe 3 years ago 4
good cover
slapdaddyc 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
battagliero79 2 years ago
yeah dude, greg sage wrote the song in his band called the wipers.
slapdaddyc 2 years ago 2
thnx man!!! i think i have to refresh my nirvana memories......
battagliero79 2 years ago
Nirvana at their best!
sideshow6360 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
this song rocks check out my page
Keawe123456 3 years ago
this is one badass song
mymusiciswaybetter 3 years ago 2
one of the greatest song ever all over the universe!!!!!!!
battagliero79 3 years ago 3
wow that solo rocks ive always thought it did
catering2cowards 3 years ago 2
you are a jerk
criminyjimjims 3 years ago
yeah ur right
doodoobrown1 3 years ago
The wipers version does not suck at all its just different both are great songs in different ways ! and seeing as kurt loved the wipers youd really piss him off talking like that ^_*
dhermon 3 years ago 31
JimBob is a fuckin' asshole and who thinks that Wipers' version sucks is a vomit.I like Nirvana version but i have respect for artists and music in general and don't understand who says "this sucks and that sucks".The Wipers never suck!!!
djsundancekid 3 years ago 11
I agree 100%
GlueyPorch 3 years ago 3
@dhermon Who the hell think that the original version it's worst than this?
cut your ears and fill it with your own cum.
xasdrubalex 1 year ago
@xasdrubalex btw i'm not talking to you about the cum stuff. :)
xasdrubalex 1 year ago
i know i lov this song
doodoobrown1 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Great song! I wish Nirvana would have done more kick ass covers like this. When I first heard this song I was like kick ass. The Wipers Version Sucks! Nirvana Kicks more ass with this song!
JimBobTp82 4 years ago
u gota be stupid to say that.
Member9999 3 years ago 5