Dalit are the original inhabitants of India. These communities were categorized as ‘outcastes’ or ‘untouchables’ by Hindu hierarchy. Hindu society had also called them ‘avarnas’ (ones without color, category or class), ‘chandalas’ (filthy ones) and ‘low-castes.They were also identified as ‘panchamas’ (fifth ones) or ‘outcasts.’ Mohandas Gandhi referred to them as ‘Harijans,’ a title used for the children of temple prostitutes who could only be identified as children of God
Hindustanis, i.e. indians, pakistanis and bangladeshis, shouldn't fight against each other. because THIS is exactly what those imperialists want us to do.
we should rather keep together and help each other.
@AmjadKhan7861 u are right! we must unite! i dont see why we both Pakistan & India should fight! The americans sell weapons to both countries! one for free because they cant afford it & to India because they can! so it proves they are out to destroy us! all these capitalist & imperialist corrupting our people & spreading hatred....i see some people on u tube like 'Seekingpeace07' have succumbed dot their propaganda! just want to see a reunification! Jai Hind
Partition is the best thing that happened even though bastard cow piss drinking hindus killed many muslims today Pakistan is a independant soverign muslim nation where Islam is evident everywhere Mohammed Ali Jinnah Qaide Azam Zindabad He may have passed away but his dream and vision will never end Pakistan will NEVER NEVER belong to the hindus
@thepaksoldier1 Hindus&sikhs are just 2%today in Pakistan &enjoy excellent freedom.In the film Jinnah,hindus & Sikhs r shown killing Muslims while Muslims are given a clean chit.Mullahs demand religious column in Passports,no where in the world u will come across.Everything is heavily ILSMICIZED’ in the land of pure.U name it Trade, Commerce, History, Geography,Next in line is Islamic Banking.In history book it is written Islam is the only superior & true religion while others are inferior.
wish india had nuclear weapons then and wiped out all the miscreants from the muslim league and flattened out pakistan..today there would have been no jihad, no kashmir issue and everyone would have been peaceful!
india and pakistan should unite with eacother. therer should be no border. but the country which we all people lived should be name a islamic republic of pakistan.
@Rahulioo not every brown ass more likely the asses of ugly smelly hindu cunts dat get bashed n mobed in australia bahahaha bcoz australians hate hindus n indianz ugly cunts
partition was inevitable, go to Hyderabad ( my home city) you would see that the communities are highly segragated. One area with Urdu banners and pakistan's flag and another area with the Indian Flag and Telugu. The partition was already there in communities, but it was not there officially until 1947....
if 30 million Christians 138 million Muslims can live in India alongside 800 million Hindus, then this partition was not inevitable. The taliban, muslim extremists needs to be removed from India's land, India should have never been under rule frm another country to begin with, the UK just like Portugal were there to exploit India's riches &take over continent! with guns!) 800,000 sq miles of land. granted wars were on&off in India btwn Hindus/Muslm, but partition=wars forever
thats the thing, they don't live alongside , the situation was not merry for Muslims in India and for Hindus in Pakistan.. Infact a Pakistani friend told me that in Lahore, there were two train carriages, one desiganted to Hindus and the other for Muslim and Sikhs. The same concept applied to almost everything jobs, residence, and other areas.
There are radical elements in both sides, Hindus see us as outcastes or something like that and muslims see hindus as idolaters.. And about the cultures, let me tell you, they are very different and its not only a matter of faith....
I would say this that the partition should have happened over a period of time and not suddenly. It could have avoided the bloodshed......
U R Right,we R VERY DIFFERENT cultures indeed, wht really happened in India thru out the centuries ws wars were on&off,I cn tell you personally frm my own families history,our grandparents were living in Sindh(both my parents side)they had temples,businesses,I am Sindhi Hindu,Partition led to massacres,we are very lucky tobe alive,my parents were babies! but just ask how were they living peacefully alongside?and now in India? what is cause of extremism? Get extremists out &get back our land!!!!
Then, it should be easy for you to understand why the partition was ultimately the right choice... Like I have metioned earlier, I hope the partition happened slowly not swiftly... I don't hope for war between the two countries considering they are both nuclear, it can potentially lead to the extinction of south asia.... One good thing about being nuclear is that now both countries have no choice but peace.........
we will partition islam into 20 religions,...some of them will shit on quran,some of then will piss on quran someof them use abusive words to allah your pig god,...indian scientists have proved that allah is pig face animal...and he was slave of lord shiva.....hahahahaha
when u r pigs ruled,it was Hindustaan,u said we're one.When the natives are ruling u hold Paki flag,traitor,don't ever come back,drug peddler.I've seen many junkies like u at Niagara recently.Urdu was a cross between Sanskrit and persian.U r mom available?I live in New York,I'll pay.
our nation produces world class intelligentsia of modern world unlike cheap terrorist junkies u r madrassas produce.U r the world's biggest beggars and criminals.
aap ka diya huya??? sorry whatever we have, we have earned it.... plus you don't have to give anything, just look after yourself and i'll look after myself.... take care...
seriously though, i am tired of this childish nonsense... if you want me to say that you are better than me just so that you can revive your dying ego; i'll do it.. cuz i am a nice guy......
not to generalize but why muslims all over the world want to rule.. why dont they let other religions be... seriously... stop preaching and start practicing your own goodness and we will see how beneficial it is to us and we will respect you then...
the partition was not justified, many indian territory presently, belonged to pakistan, but brits were bribed by hindus, so unjustified partition took place
India was divided into two countries because of narrow minded Hindu leadership of India. They alienated their Muslim fellows. This mindset was based on the "democratic" formula of "majority rules". One can guess the Hindu mindset by the name of India. Congress decided to give title of the country after independence as "Bharat" not India or Hindustan. Bharat is a religious terms whereas India or Hindustan was secular one. One can easily read the mindset of Hindu leadership with this simple fact.
I am a Pakistani and I really did like this video. However I am in favor of partition I think it was needed as Muslims in India constantly face harassment. I am not saying Pakistan is perfect but for Muslims it is a much better option then living under constant fear. Also I wish both countries would act like adult and sigh a peace deal already and get on with improving the lives of their population.
People are forgetting that, before the British came,whole of South Asia was never one country. The Mughals at their height never rules from Peshawar to Tamil Nadu and Assam. There were provinces like maratha and southern states that were princely states
So it is wrong to blame the British for partition as they are the ones to bring the whole region together in the first place Without them, the whole region would have comprised of dozens of individual nation states based on ethnicity like Europe
Actually, the Mauryan empire with its capital in Pataliputra in modern day Bihar did cover 95% of modern day India, all of Pakistan, and a sizeable chunk of Afghanistan. Pakistan is the creation of the British. They wanted to maintain their presence in the Asia to counter the looming shadow of the USSR.Since the Congress would not tolerate them in free India,they worked to carve out a pliable state-Pakistan.
@imtiaz82 that is blessing in disguise....the people chose to come together....they could have revolted when the British left so its not a fact...its like saying thank the British for our railways....when they did it to loot the country of natural resources on not for the welfare of the people! Partition happened cause of the British...the riots were staged...It was not the British aim to unite the people that is dreaming! The fight against the imperialists brought states & religions together!
@imtiaz82 U sir r picking out what u want to tell people! i think u are forgetting that the struggle for overthrowing the British,united the nation & the subcontinent & not their grace or goodwill...Country or nation states were a new phenomenon in Asia. Brits had a parliament way back when in Asia they ruled us or we were ruled by our kings! U need to look at Grey areas...Lets not thank them it is ridiculous! Partition was a shame created by propaganda & hatred spread by the whites!
this video is made by the pseudo secular idiots from India..check the end credits and you will understand what i mean..all are some bengal commies...not a single paki is ever gonna deny that they are not happy from partition..bcoz the muslims always wanted to break the country and they still do want the same...
the best solution is an EU like setup...however, fanatics from either side won't like this solution since it brings the common man from either side together
Maybe, but I don't think that it would ever happen. I don't think the rest of Pakistan would agree with it. I personally think it would be nice, but I don't think they would agree to it.
I am pakistani born living in US..after reading the unbias history thanks to internet and knowing the history..i say partition should never have happened...my parents and grand parents migrated from india and they never forgot the place of their birth...this video makes me emotional...we lived for thousands of years and we could have live together for thousands more...the british never wanted to leave..but reluctantly left..but they divided us..
I am a Sindhi American and my grandparents lost everything they had because they were Hindu. My grandparents migrated to India and then to many other places around the world to find work and support their family. I think that it should have never happened.
I truly agree. This video brought tears into my eyes. The partition should have never happened. We would have been a much stronger nation as ONE INDIA instead of Hindustan and pakistan. I wish and truly wish that someday we could be one again (It feels like a dream that may never come true though).
idiot. muhajirs are ones who created pakistan. Jinnah, Liaquat Ali khan and all the top brass of muslim league were muhajirs. Muhajirs are most educated and have made Karachi what it is...By the way, I am an american ciizen with pakistan origin and indian heritage.
go back to utter pardesh in hindustan where you came from. never say your origin is pakistan..you are hindustani and always be hindustani, just like ur leader mota kalu altaf hussein.
You fabatic mullah should leave USA or hopefully will get thrown out. I Hate altaf hussain but I hate mullahs more..May all the fanatic mullah die...Secularism forever!
Go back to Hindustan..never call yourself a Pakistani..your an indian mohajar traitor from utter pardesh just like ur leader Altaf Hussein.
Pakistan is for MUSLIMS of Punjab, NWFP, Kashmir, Sindh, and Balochistan..rest go back to hindustan where you came from. we should've never welcomed you traitors into our homes.
Not true. I'm not a Muhajar.. I'm of Pakistani Punjabi origin, and I think it would have been better if the partition did not happen. Look at how many people died and how many people were uprooted from their homes! Many people not only lost their families and friends through the violence that occurred, but also their property and everything they knew. All of that could have been avoided if the partition did not occur. I wish Ghandhi had more influence on this situation, but sadly he didn't...
you're crazy brownie..look at how many muslims were slaughtered by hindus after partition? if it wasn't for partition, we would see the same violence al over punjab like the violence in gujrat 2002.
the region of pakistan was majority muslim for over a thousand years, different than what is now india, we didnt come from different region like israelis did we always lived in our land and we decided the fate of our land.
as for muslims being killed in partition. whose fault is taht? why didnt the sikhs/hindus just let muslims pass through Pakistan instead of killing them. you're giving criminals a reason to murder?
besides if you knew history, the british awarded ferozpur to india which was majority muslim population and borders pakistan's punjab today, and muslims dont even exist in that district anymore cause sikhs/hindus slaughtered them all.
if tht area was given to pakistan like it was supposed to, we wudnt hav tht many killings of muslims during partition, but the british gave it to india because it was an entrance to jammu and kashmir. and we all know how well india is controlling their only muslim dominated area kashmir.
get out of bollywood world brownie, not everythings easy like a simple bollywood dance.
Yes but if there were more Muslims in India racist parties like the RSS and BJP could never have the power they now wield. Muslim civilization in South Asia was largely urban, and by draining the Muslim communities of Lucknow, Delhi, and Hyderabad, the very people who wanted to preserve South Asian Muslim society ended up destroying it. Look at Karachi and Islamabad. India would have 400 million Muslims if we were one nation, no wars oveKashmir. But we're independent now, so lets fix Pakistan.
I'm a Muslim, and I believe that you have to live with non-Muslims for tabligh right? Before the Muslim League transformed being Muslim into being anti-Indian Hindus converted to Islam in large numbers. And in the end does piss drinking and cow worshipping hurt anyone? In Swat little girls have acid thrown on their face for going to school. If Pakistanis spent 1% of the energy they spend hating India on building our country we'd be amazing.
Also remember Babur and Akbar were Emperors of India.
Indian Muslim girls were thrown acid in their faces by hindu mobs in 2002 gujrat rioting. We all see how Muslims were treated, how they tore down Babri Masjid and killed Muslims who were trying to protect the Masjid.
We have problems in Pakistan but its a thousand times better than living with 800 million hindu haters in world's largest aids country.
"Indian Muslim girls were thrown acid in their faces by hindu mobs in 2002" who was running SIMI in india and with whom support , Please answer this? and there will more babri like incidents if indian muslims didn't stop supporting FUCKISTAN.
@SeekingPeace07 we also know that Lahore church was blasted...Hindus & Sikhs are fleeing form pak! so dont save ur self for this disgrace....ur equally guilty if not more!!! No one in India is proud of these hooligans!im a muslim wat ur talking about..even Muslims are seeking asylum in India & marrying Indians to get citizenship so ur totally wrong! wat is right for u may not be right for our nations...we should have been one then peace would have been there.partition created discord!
@SeekingPeace07 partition created discord between the communists so babri or lahore church blasts would not have taken place...no mumbai terror attack no Kashmir problem...people uses to live in peace before partition,until the partition idea was spread & people brainwashed by the brits! don't create discord on basis of religion! this is the mentality the rioters had when they killed innocent people form both communities! so wat ur saying makes no sense it just closet racist talk! Jai Hind
@SeekingPeace07 wat a name [seekinpeace07] for a person with ur attitude! how are u seeking peace by talking like this.....Pakistani govt & army is innocent saints & havent done anything...how many Hindus u killed in Bangladesh! OH THEY DINT TEACH IN SCHOOL! ONLY PROPAGANDA AGAINST INDIA IS FOUND IN UR TEXT BOOKS! ur low IQ so chill at home....U CANT WIN PEACE THROUGH WAR OR HATRED, so go get a life...u jobless? Utube is place for people to interact not for u to act dumb! Jai Hind.
hi bro u are much concered for indian muslims u must know they are more safe than they are in pakistan who are killed in siya suni conflit
check out the history after partion about 13% of population in pakitan were non-muslims(hindus & sikhs) but check wat is their no. now in present era almost <1% where hav they all gone hav u ever thought. Almost 50% among them were forcely converted to muslims and rest were killed but check out in india muslims were 10% during partition but now they r 14%
most of the non- muslims wer in east pakistan,that is why it was 13% and after th civil war when east pakistan became bangladesh the overall % decreased down to 2% which already existed and still live in pakistan
thats why the numbers of hindus,christians and sikhs decreased in pakistan..if u still include bangladesh with pakistans statistics then yes between them they still have around 15% non-muslim population
i agree with u, my grandparents migrated from east bengal too and cud never forget their birthplace. Its but natural. Only ppl who bore the brunt of partition can understand the true pain.
This has been flagged as spam show
Dalit are the original inhabitants of India. These communities were categorized as ‘outcastes’ or ‘untouchables’ by Hindu hierarchy. Hindu society had also called them ‘avarnas’ (ones without color, category or class), ‘chandalas’ (filthy ones) and ‘low-castes.They were also identified as ‘panchamas’ (fifth ones) or ‘outcasts.’ Mohandas Gandhi referred to them as ‘Harijans,’ a title used for the children of temple prostitutes who could only be identified as children of God
IamGodnLord 1 year ago
Stop dreaming indians!! :P
HusainMd 1 year ago
@HusainMd we are not dreaming !! we are improving not like u terrorists ..
mrrakeshji2008 7 months ago
@mrrakeshji2008 Hahahaha Chusssss! We are not terrorists. Your daddies (Afghanis) are terrorists.
HusainMd 7 months ago
@HusainMd im INDIAN , chuss le mera loda poorkis terrorist
mrrakeshji2008 7 months ago
partition was done by those stupid brits
Hindustanis, i.e. indians, pakistanis and bangladeshis, shouldn't fight against each other. because THIS is exactly what those imperialists want us to do.
we should rather keep together and help each other.
AmjadKhan7861 1 year ago 2
@AmjadKhan7861 u are right! we must unite! i dont see why we both Pakistan & India should fight! The americans sell weapons to both countries! one for free because they cant afford it & to India because they can! so it proves they are out to destroy us! all these capitalist & imperialist corrupting our people & spreading hatred....i see some people on u tube like 'Seekingpeace07' have succumbed dot their propaganda! just want to see a reunification! Jai Hind
azandhind4eva 1 year ago
awesome job dude 5 thumbs up
IndianKafir 1 year ago
Partition is the best thing that happened even though bastard cow piss drinking hindus killed many muslims today Pakistan is a independant soverign muslim nation where Islam is evident everywhere Mohammed Ali Jinnah Qaide Azam Zindabad He may have passed away but his dream and vision will never end Pakistan will NEVER NEVER belong to the hindus
thepaksoldier1 1 year ago
@thepaksoldier1 Hindus&sikhs are just 2%today in Pakistan &enjoy excellent freedom.In the film Jinnah,hindus & Sikhs r shown killing Muslims while Muslims are given a clean chit.Mullahs demand religious column in Passports,no where in the world u will come across.Everything is heavily ILSMICIZED’ in the land of pure.U name it Trade, Commerce, History, Geography,Next in line is Islamic Banking.In history book it is written Islam is the only superior & true religion while others are inferior.
suresh1773 10 months ago
for your inforamation jinnah never was in favor of a seprate homeland but it was hindus attitude who led him thnk that wat.
1manhoos 1 year ago
India and Pakistan are two independent countries... live your life and let others to live.
aggresive1queen 1 year ago
Very nice .. Few divided us due to political interests and you people are fighting.
You people are the pillars of political leaders.
suvojitbanerjee1977 1 year ago
man i hate it .....if today india nd pak would have been one country....just imagine what strength we would hold.....MIGHTIEST OF ALL COUNTIRES
just imagine....
duniya ka sabse taktwar desh ke bare me.....jiske samne chin kya america bhi jhuk jata
ikshukrchugh 1 year ago
@ikshukrchugh
You are correct..my brother.
Can you imagine Sachin and Afridi playing for a joined nation.
suvojitbanerjee1977 1 year ago
wish india had nuclear weapons then and wiped out all the miscreants from the muslim league and flattened out pakistan..today there would have been no jihad, no kashmir issue and everyone would have been peaceful!
carolinaindian 1 year ago
@carolinaindian yes, in your dreams bastard. Those rusty no-use russian weapons that brought the russia down will bring you down too. InshaAllah.
mrosamakhalid 10 months ago
india and pakistan should unite with eacother. therer should be no border. but the country which we all people lived should be name a islamic republic of pakistan.
firabbani 1 year ago
maaa chodooo ugly hindus ki monkey n cow fuckers
Nara-e-Takbeer Allaho akhber
salla gandoooo mahadev
Jaigandjeeki 1 year ago
@Jaigandjeeki I HEARD THEY KICK BROWN ASSES IN AUSTRALIA?.......... A TRUE BROWN MAN REGARDLESS OF THERE NATIONALITY WILL SHOW THE TRUE BLOOD.....
Rahulioo 1 year ago
@Rahulioo not every brown ass more likely the asses of ugly smelly hindu cunts dat get bashed n mobed in australia bahahaha bcoz australians hate hindus n indianz ugly cunts
Jaigandjeeki 1 year ago
fuck off india, pussy countryyyy
ShazProd 2 years ago
we have fight with pakistan
999homosex 2 years ago
fuck india fuck india
fuck india
pk13285 2 years ago
partition saved India from sharia law.
Hinduismglance 2 years ago
a very fair and intelligent account given here. Thanks uploader
jatt440 2 years ago
partition was inevitable, go to Hyderabad ( my home city) you would see that the communities are highly segragated. One area with Urdu banners and pakistan's flag and another area with the Indian Flag and Telugu. The partition was already there in communities, but it was not there officially until 1947....
xjaat 2 years ago
if 30 million Christians 138 million Muslims can live in India alongside 800 million Hindus, then this partition was not inevitable. The taliban, muslim extremists needs to be removed from India's land, India should have never been under rule frm another country to begin with, the UK just like Portugal were there to exploit India's riches &take over continent! with guns!) 800,000 sq miles of land. granted wars were on&off in India btwn Hindus/Muslm, but partition=wars forever
india000000000 2 years ago
thats the thing, they don't live alongside , the situation was not merry for Muslims in India and for Hindus in Pakistan.. Infact a Pakistani friend told me that in Lahore, there were two train carriages, one desiganted to Hindus and the other for Muslim and Sikhs. The same concept applied to almost everything jobs, residence, and other areas.
xjaat 2 years ago
There are radical elements in both sides, Hindus see us as outcastes or something like that and muslims see hindus as idolaters.. And about the cultures, let me tell you, they are very different and its not only a matter of faith....
I would say this that the partition should have happened over a period of time and not suddenly. It could have avoided the bloodshed......
xjaat 2 years ago
U R Right,we R VERY DIFFERENT cultures indeed, wht really happened in India thru out the centuries ws wars were on&off,I cn tell you personally frm my own families history,our grandparents were living in Sindh(both my parents side)they had temples,businesses,I am Sindhi Hindu,Partition led to massacres,we are very lucky tobe alive,my parents were babies! but just ask how were they living peacefully alongside?and now in India? what is cause of extremism? Get extremists out &get back our land!!!!
india000000000 2 years ago
Then, it should be easy for you to understand why the partition was ultimately the right choice... Like I have metioned earlier, I hope the partition happened slowly not swiftly... I don't hope for war between the two countries considering they are both nuclear, it can potentially lead to the extinction of south asia.... One good thing about being nuclear is that now both countries have no choice but peace.........
xjaat 2 years ago
If u want to hold a Pak flag and spk urdu,go to Pakistan which was created for the specific purpose.U've no place in Hyd.
mtmraj 2 years ago
urdu is spoken by 100 million indians, i don't really care about the flag.....
xjaat 2 years ago
we will partition islam into 20 religions,...some of them will shit on quran,some of then will piss on quran someof them use abusive words to allah your pig god,...indian scientists have proved that allah is pig face animal...and he was slave of lord shiva.....hahahahaha
girllondon9 2 years ago
LMAO at your desperation...........
xjaat 2 years ago
I'm not desperate we know u traitors,namk haram most of u beause it comes thru' u r religion.
mtmraj 2 years ago
indeed...
xjaat 2 years ago
ya,lowlife.
mtmraj 2 years ago
indeed again lol.....
xjaat 2 years ago
my dick in u r mom's puss again.
mtmraj 2 years ago
hahahaha
xjaat 2 years ago
when u r pigs ruled,it was Hindustaan,u said we're one.When the natives are ruling u hold Paki flag,traitor,don't ever come back,drug peddler.I've seen many junkies like u at Niagara recently.Urdu was a cross between Sanskrit and persian.U r mom available?I live in New York,I'll pay.
mtmraj 2 years ago
lol get a life.... like I really care about what you have to say.... lol
xjaat 2 years ago
you live in new york , and willing to get laid anywhere in the world.......i guess ur nations produces desperados, shitheads
shemak909 2 years ago
our nation produces world class intelligentsia of modern world unlike cheap terrorist junkies u r madrassas produce.U r the world's biggest beggars and criminals.
mtmraj 2 years ago 7
urdu born in india munna
hamara diya huya khatey ho or boltey ho
jai hind
msdhoni12345 2 years ago
aap ka diya huya??? sorry whatever we have, we have earned it.... plus you don't have to give anything, just look after yourself and i'll look after myself.... take care...
xjaat 2 years ago
we are superior in everything
bus terrorism ko chod ker
nobody can win in this field .
india gave money to pakistan in partion time .
sar chupane ke paise nahi or goli chalaney ki batein kertey ho
msdhoni12345 2 years ago 2
so if you are so superior why are you even talking to an inferior person like myself.... get busy with something more superior lol...
xjaat 2 years ago
seriously though, i am tired of this childish nonsense... if you want me to say that you are better than me just so that you can revive your dying ego; i'll do it.. cuz i am a nice guy......
xjaat 2 years ago
not to generalize but why muslims all over the world want to rule.. why dont they let other religions be... seriously... stop preaching and start practicing your own goodness and we will see how beneficial it is to us and we will respect you then...
hnicky 2 years ago
I wish the sub-continent was never divided. We could all have been part of a great and colourful nation.
But I guess, I am living in a dream.
MWSARSCA 2 years ago 5
shiton you...
hnicky 2 years ago
the partition was not justified, many indian territory presently, belonged to pakistan, but brits were bribed by hindus, so unjustified partition took place
hammadthegreat 2 years ago
India was divided into two countries because of narrow minded Hindu leadership of India. They alienated their Muslim fellows. This mindset was based on the "democratic" formula of "majority rules". One can guess the Hindu mindset by the name of India. Congress decided to give title of the country after independence as "Bharat" not India or Hindustan. Bharat is a religious terms whereas India or Hindustan was secular one. One can easily read the mindset of Hindu leadership with this simple fact.
punchfromnorth 3 years ago
I am a Pakistani and I really did like this video. However I am in favor of partition I think it was needed as Muslims in India constantly face harassment. I am not saying Pakistan is perfect but for Muslims it is a much better option then living under constant fear. Also I wish both countries would act like adult and sigh a peace deal already and get on with improving the lives of their population.
Moe10101 3 years ago
nice vdo man...nice thoughts..
rajiljain 3 years ago
People are forgetting that, before the British came,whole of South Asia was never one country. The Mughals at their height never rules from Peshawar to Tamil Nadu and Assam. There were provinces like maratha and southern states that were princely states
So it is wrong to blame the British for partition as they are the ones to bring the whole region together in the first place Without them, the whole region would have comprised of dozens of individual nation states based on ethnicity like Europe
imtiaz82 3 years ago 12
Actually, the Mauryan empire with its capital in Pataliputra in modern day Bihar did cover 95% of modern day India, all of Pakistan, and a sizeable chunk of Afghanistan. Pakistan is the creation of the British. They wanted to maintain their presence in the Asia to counter the looming shadow of the USSR.Since the Congress would not tolerate them in free India,they worked to carve out a pliable state-Pakistan.
trak2121 3 years ago
Agreed. Both India and Pakistan have people from so many different ethnicities. The sub continent has probably more ethnicties then those in Europe
jatt440 2 years ago
@imtiaz82 that is blessing in disguise....the people chose to come together....they could have revolted when the British left so its not a fact...its like saying thank the British for our railways....when they did it to loot the country of natural resources on not for the welfare of the people! Partition happened cause of the British...the riots were staged...It was not the British aim to unite the people that is dreaming! The fight against the imperialists brought states & religions together!
azandhind4eva 1 year ago
@imtiaz82 U sir r picking out what u want to tell people! i think u are forgetting that the struggle for overthrowing the British,united the nation & the subcontinent & not their grace or goodwill...Country or nation states were a new phenomenon in Asia. Brits had a parliament way back when in Asia they ruled us or we were ruled by our kings! U need to look at Grey areas...Lets not thank them it is ridiculous! Partition was a shame created by propaganda & hatred spread by the whites!
azandhind4eva 1 year ago
this video is made by the pseudo secular idiots from India..check the end credits and you will understand what i mean..all are some bengal commies...not a single paki is ever gonna deny that they are not happy from partition..bcoz the muslims always wanted to break the country and they still do want the same...
cabewalker 3 years ago
sorry..as a pakistani..i don't think partition should have happened...so your statement that of a single pakistani is false
ednan9 3 years ago 2
do you agree to a united punjab.
stategist 3 years ago
the best solution is an EU like setup...however, fanatics from either side won't like this solution since it brings the common man from either side together
ednan9 3 years ago 3
Maybe, but I don't think that it would ever happen. I don't think the rest of Pakistan would agree with it. I personally think it would be nice, but I don't think they would agree to it.
BrownSpice85 3 years ago
BTW, thanks for posting the video...its lovely but sad..cheers
ednan9 3 years ago
I am pakistani born living in US..after reading the unbias history thanks to internet and knowing the history..i say partition should never have happened...my parents and grand parents migrated from india and they never forgot the place of their birth...this video makes me emotional...we lived for thousands of years and we could have live together for thousands more...the british never wanted to leave..but reluctantly left..but they divided us..
ednan9 3 years ago
I am a Sindhi American and my grandparents lost everything they had because they were Hindu. My grandparents migrated to India and then to many other places around the world to find work and support their family. I think that it should have never happened.
JaZzTaStIc303 3 years ago 2
I truly agree. This video brought tears into my eyes. The partition should have never happened. We would have been a much stronger nation as ONE INDIA instead of Hindustan and pakistan. I wish and truly wish that someday we could be one again (It feels like a dream that may never come true though).
MichiganSingh 3 years ago 2
yea only muhajars say partition shouldnt have happened.
why dont you just go back to india then traitors?
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
idiot. muhajirs are ones who created pakistan. Jinnah, Liaquat Ali khan and all the top brass of muslim league were muhajirs. Muhajirs are most educated and have made Karachi what it is...By the way, I am an american ciizen with pakistan origin and indian heritage.
ednan9 3 years ago 3
go back to utter pardesh in hindustan where you came from. never say your origin is pakistan..you are hindustani and always be hindustani, just like ur leader mota kalu altaf hussein.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
You fabatic mullah should leave USA or hopefully will get thrown out. I Hate altaf hussain but I hate mullahs more..May all the fanatic mullah die...Secularism forever!
ednan9 3 years ago 2
Go back to Hindustan..never call yourself a Pakistani..your an indian mohajar traitor from utter pardesh just like ur leader Altaf Hussein.
Pakistan is for MUSLIMS of Punjab, NWFP, Kashmir, Sindh, and Balochistan..rest go back to hindustan where you came from. we should've never welcomed you traitors into our homes.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
LOL 'SeekingPeace07' is just as hawkish as Donald Rumsfeld's chacha!
Akupara1 3 years ago
seekingpeace...u dont sound that peaceful..LMAO
abhiincanada 3 years ago
Not true. I'm not a Muhajar.. I'm of Pakistani Punjabi origin, and I think it would have been better if the partition did not happen. Look at how many people died and how many people were uprooted from their homes! Many people not only lost their families and friends through the violence that occurred, but also their property and everything they knew. All of that could have been avoided if the partition did not occur. I wish Ghandhi had more influence on this situation, but sadly he didn't...
BrownSpice85 3 years ago
you're crazy brownie..look at how many muslims were slaughtered by hindus after partition? if it wasn't for partition, we would see the same violence al over punjab like the violence in gujrat 2002.
the region of pakistan was majority muslim for over a thousand years, different than what is now india, we didnt come from different region like israelis did we always lived in our land and we decided the fate of our land.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
as for muslims being killed in partition. whose fault is taht? why didnt the sikhs/hindus just let muslims pass through Pakistan instead of killing them. you're giving criminals a reason to murder?
besides if you knew history, the british awarded ferozpur to india which was majority muslim population and borders pakistan's punjab today, and muslims dont even exist in that district anymore cause sikhs/hindus slaughtered them all.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
if tht area was given to pakistan like it was supposed to, we wudnt hav tht many killings of muslims during partition, but the british gave it to india because it was an entrance to jammu and kashmir. and we all know how well india is controlling their only muslim dominated area kashmir.
get out of bollywood world brownie, not everythings easy like a simple bollywood dance.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
how can your name be seeking peace when you call someone brownie? Both sides are guilty. You are completely misinformed bro.
hardmoneygiant 3 years ago
Yes but if there were more Muslims in India racist parties like the RSS and BJP could never have the power they now wield. Muslim civilization in South Asia was largely urban, and by draining the Muslim communities of Lucknow, Delhi, and Hyderabad, the very people who wanted to preserve South Asian Muslim society ended up destroying it. Look at Karachi and Islamabad. India would have 400 million Muslims if we were one nation, no wars oveKashmir. But we're independent now, so lets fix Pakistan.
asunaj 3 years ago
in ur dreams. keep ur ghandustan..we dont want india.
india is all about aids and hindu shiva cow rat worshippers, we dont want that shit in Pakistan.
Thank God for Partition.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago
I'm a Muslim, and I believe that you have to live with non-Muslims for tabligh right? Before the Muslim League transformed being Muslim into being anti-Indian Hindus converted to Islam in large numbers. And in the end does piss drinking and cow worshipping hurt anyone? In Swat little girls have acid thrown on their face for going to school. If Pakistanis spent 1% of the energy they spend hating India on building our country we'd be amazing.
Also remember Babur and Akbar were Emperors of India.
asunaj 3 years ago
OH SHUT THE HELL UP.
Indian Muslim girls were thrown acid in their faces by hindu mobs in 2002 gujrat rioting. We all see how Muslims were treated, how they tore down Babri Masjid and killed Muslims who were trying to protect the Masjid.
We have problems in Pakistan but its a thousand times better than living with 800 million hindu haters in world's largest aids country.
SeekingPeace07 3 years ago 6
"Indian Muslim girls were thrown acid in their faces by hindu mobs in 2002" who was running SIMI in india and with whom support , Please answer this? and there will more babri like incidents if indian muslims didn't stop supporting FUCKISTAN.
coolwaves4all 2 years ago
@SeekingPeace07 lol and you are seaking peace?
RealHinduMadrid 1 year ago
@RealHinduMadrid
once a hindu student asked jinnah why muslims are asking for a separate homeland?
jiannah drank a half glass of water and then asked the hindu to drink the remaining half of that . but he refused
then jinnah said thats why
1manhoos 1 year ago
@SeekingPeace07 we also know that Lahore church was blasted...Hindus & Sikhs are fleeing form pak! so dont save ur self for this disgrace....ur equally guilty if not more!!! No one in India is proud of these hooligans!im a muslim wat ur talking about..even Muslims are seeking asylum in India & marrying Indians to get citizenship so ur totally wrong! wat is right for u may not be right for our nations...we should have been one then peace would have been there.partition created discord!
azandhind4eva 1 year ago
@SeekingPeace07 partition created discord between the communists so babri or lahore church blasts would not have taken place...no mumbai terror attack no Kashmir problem...people uses to live in peace before partition,until the partition idea was spread & people brainwashed by the brits! don't create discord on basis of religion! this is the mentality the rioters had when they killed innocent people form both communities! so wat ur saying makes no sense it just closet racist talk! Jai Hind
azandhind4eva 1 year ago
@SeekingPeace07 wat a name [seekinpeace07] for a person with ur attitude! how are u seeking peace by talking like this.....Pakistani govt & army is innocent saints & havent done anything...how many Hindus u killed in Bangladesh! OH THEY DINT TEACH IN SCHOOL! ONLY PROPAGANDA AGAINST INDIA IS FOUND IN UR TEXT BOOKS! ur low IQ so chill at home....U CANT WIN PEACE THROUGH WAR OR HATRED, so go get a life...u jobless? Utube is place for people to interact not for u to act dumb! Jai Hind.
azandhind4eva 1 year ago
SeekingPeace07 ur name talks of peace but u contradict ur self...........typical paki
INDIA gave u that land
INDIA gave u the funds to set up a government.........u selfish fuck........
and u make fun of other religions? what about urs u guys marry ur own damn cousins ur religion is based on lies, deciet, selfishness and backstabbing!
Fuck u and ur Porkistan crew > asshole!
LethalHathyar 3 years ago
sorry india cd'nt gave us land v cut india n get it the land.....
fundamentlist 2 years ago
i agree these bloody loosers.. they are from our country and they sit there and fuck us over..
hnicky 2 years ago
Comment removed
callandloveme 3 years ago
hi bro u are much concered for indian muslims u must know they are more safe than they are in pakistan who are killed in siya suni conflit
check out the history after partion about 13% of population in pakitan were non-muslims(hindus & sikhs) but check wat is their no. now in present era almost <1% where hav they all gone hav u ever thought. Almost 50% among them were forcely converted to muslims and rest were killed but check out in india muslims were 10% during partition but now they r 14%
rknair07 3 years ago 2
shia sunni fassada 20 saal pehlay hotay thay ab aa k dekho dono saath hain
fundamentlist 2 years ago
most of the non- muslims wer in east pakistan,that is why it was 13% and after th civil war when east pakistan became bangladesh the overall % decreased down to 2% which already existed and still live in pakistan
navsta90 2 years ago
thats why the numbers of hindus,christians and sikhs decreased in pakistan..if u still include bangladesh with pakistans statistics then yes between them they still have around 15% non-muslim population
navsta90 2 years ago
i agree with u, my grandparents migrated from east bengal too and cud never forget their birthplace. Its but natural. Only ppl who bore the brunt of partition can understand the true pain.
abhiincanada 3 years ago