American Idol Top 8 - Seasons Of Love (HQ)

[MagiKungen]

Or in times that she died? WTF is that supposed to mean?

[ark5428]

@MagiKungen dumb ass

[MagiKungen]

@ark5428 do you mean me or him?

[ark5428]

@MagiKungen i mean you,how could not know what that means

[MagiKungen]

@ark5428 It makes absolutely no sense.TIMES that she died?

[yomattsivo2468]

cool even though it was in 2008 and David Cook won

[AmazinAsian1097]

They really need some work on articulation. It's "Sea-SONS" not "Sea-SINS"

But overall, it could've been worse. They need some serious work with harmony though. It sounded awkward as they all tried to... outpower the other :p

[applered12334]

It wasn't bad it was okay.

[fabriyk96]

like if you think yhat the gauy for rastas looks like samuel from gleeproject

[everwoodxoxo]

DC DC DC!!!!

[MrEricBivens]

David Archuleta had the right part. His voice was the best part in that.

[poopieflys]

not terrible not great but not terrible

[devdev2697]

it wasn't that bad...

[leacelmanuevo]

the version from the movie is way way better than this.

[macie10126]

they need to loosen up

[LosPonysRifan]

hahah que horror de versión :S la hicieron de mega hueva y no propone absolutamente nada!

[BloodsuckingLover]

people need to stop trying to be lead and start going with the melody instead of missing so many beats

[AnimeFreakazoid11117]

For 3 minutes and 4 seconds I believed I was going deaf. Scared the hell out of me.

[piscescarodine]

you are right not thagood at all

[Weazelon]

My Left ear enjoyed this...

[mateogw]

The song was perfect the way it is! Why did they have to make so many changes in the melody? And I agree with you. None of them harminize with each other, they're all trying to shine on their own and they don't realize what the song is about: life next to the people you love, and for that they need to complement each other and they just don't!

[pianoisloved]

... They'd sound awesome if they harmonised. WHY DIDN'T THEY?!?!??! D: D: D:

[alexlee137]

David <33333

[tactyler]

David archuleta was pretty boss.

[allieandannmarie]

kristy lee cook was SOOOOO off key.

and archie may have messed up the lyrics, but his part is the only part that saved the whole performance. his voice is amazing!!!

[TheVieasaur]

Carly! <3!

I think they did a pretty good job!

[ItsFaltzer]

Doesn't matter how bad this rendition was; they can all sing very well, except at that point they had no training or real experience whatsoever. This goes to show it takes more than just a nice voice to sing great. It was all over the place and there was no real blend. The only good solo was David Archuleta's, although in the lyrics it's "way that she died", not "times that she died." - I think this was just rushed and nobody could perfect this in time. In my opinion.

[appl3lov3r]

the choir was better than them xD im sure that they could all sing it lovely alone, but together its ehhhh

[gemnikkic]

Kristy's mic was too loud.

[carlozralen]

EPIC FAIL :(

[Godzgirl4life96]

Too low... e.e But nice. :#

[MissDevPink]

FAILLLL!!!

[MsMusiclover024]

SPOILER ALERT DAVIDS WIN!

[huskyclaw]

woah, woah, woah... what the fuck? why is the description giving away a MYSPACE link?!?!

[Itzblancas]

Wow way to mess up a beautiful song. I especially love how nobody even attempted to hit that high note at the end.

[mmog8mer]

that was shit....waist of 3 minutes

[immrcool1000]

who was the one with the buzzy voice???

>=(

[tonyherndon]

david was BEAST!

[DiamondFreak22]

what season was this?

[PhantoMPhreeK92]

Carly sucked. Period. Just re-enforced my loyalty as an AMy Lee fan.

[Supafongboon]

the piano was nice

[MagicUnicorn9870]

my 7th grade chours sing this song sooooo much better

[CrazyZebraGirl89]

@MagicUnicorn9870 lol

[MagicUnicorn9870]

@CrazyZebraGirl89 hey gab its true hve u eva herd us sing the song..... we amazing

lol

[KaptianChad]

i think the choir is there to block out the eights singing

[Sheutyee]

This is so sad...They sound terrible and try so hard to stand out

[TheNowmoon]

I freaking love David A!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[fluergirl1]

How did he get the lyrics wrong? He had a sentence long solo, and he got it wrong. What?

[Javjean]

@fluergirl1

"The times that she died"?

Really? What a snksehgrlsiuhskerjghsi.ergn. That random sequence was to show my anger at these amateurs. Everybody knows its "THE WAY THAT SHE DIED".

[ViaVirtus]

How come these "American Idols" can't do what they managed to do for the Hollywood Bowl in 2010 (look it up: its on YouTube)

[musicx33love]

the beginning...one girl ruined the whole beginning.

once the choir joined it got a little better.

no one should sing rent songs if they are gonna ruin them O.o

[kennylee12313]

They tried. At least.

Ehh...... D-D

[TwinMonsters1314]

David Archuleta, David Cook, and dreadlocks guy <3

[gavrochestarkid]

omg---i'm jewish and fluent in hebrew so i understood the Hebrew captions at the beginning!

[22Skuly]

This was horrible, flat, and painful to listen to. I know Highschool Glee clubs who could nail that song better than these fools. What was the purpose of the back up choir? It didn't help their harmonies one bit. Also how does dude for get the words of the song? "Times that she died?" I thought it was "Way that he died."

[kakairuislove]

@22Skuly the way that she died

[22Skuly]

@kakairuislove

OK she but they still sang wrong lyrics!

[kakairuislove]

@22Skuly lol i know dont you just feel like slapping him its such a good song

[VFKMissLizzy]

hey it's david a.

but they suck no offence.

[11melonhead]

wow this is old, i thaught this would be really new. lol i reconise all of em.

[WeeworldIsFun]

THEY KILLED IT ! D;

[EmberrHD]

Ouch. They changed so many lyrics..

[kdxgurl123]

goo heaadd......

[sophia321123]

who was the bitch who was singing so fuckking low?!

[steelawake923]

can't finish...too excruciating...i tried...hard...

[scheufeli]

Also did anyone notice the black guy in the choir is singing better than all of them!

[scheufeli]

I love the token black chick. If this show was about real talent there would be more black people and overweight people because you know they can sang it !

[yentokh]

it's soooo awful

[ashleylynnbullard1]

creepy how all of them are wearing red and black except that one chick with the frizzy hair

[earlyjoyful]

Vowels are musician's friend. Good god.

[jnaisabel]

DAVID A!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

[jelliclekat24]

@jnaisabel DAVID C!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

[TennizBall14]

LOW JESUS

[kumorifennikusu]

Ouch. That was painful.

I think the issue here is that not many of these people are professionally trained and they're used to being the lead instead of harmonizing with the group. It's a shame that such a talented group wasn't yelled at in practice for not harmonizing.

[sgtbilkoette]

@kumorifennikusu yeah i totally agree....i think that the main problem is that their voices just aren't strong enough....they're all wishy-washy....

[emirmeza]

awefall! far far from it showld be. sleepy, lazzy!

[emirmeza]

awefall! far far from it showld be. sucks!

[jllik]

What are you talking about? Who was singing low?

[KaylaSaysRawrx3]

1:55

^doing you all a favor^

[superrockstar411]

I think it's kinda slow haha

[shipeiheartsdbsk]

this is crap

[leeyoorae]

only david could survive

[kaykay42able]

DAVIS ARCHELETTA!!!!!!!!!!! OMG IM SINGING THE SOLO FISRT ONE!1 BUT NOT ON THIS VIDEO

[66simpson]

damn they really skrewd up this song

[leilanihanaike]

Who ever it was that was singing low was fucking up the song.

[francymazzi]

It's really impossible to listen this...next time I think you have to choose a simpler song... please...

[PinkkPretty]

I Can Barely Hear !

[Jazzzkidd]

David sounded pretty good

[joaj95]

整個大降KEY耶= =The key was lowered so much!

[jaquen1977]

What an embarrassment.

[KyleOgilvie1]

well, um i believe i vented all my anger in my previous comments, oh wait there is more, but my mamma always said if you don;t have anything nice to say, don't say it at all...so um, the choir was good. th-th-th-th-thats all folks.

[KyleOgilvie1]

they are just singing it, this song Needs Passion. they have taken all the passion and emotion and sadness and anger, and love out of the song. it is a horrible rendition.

[FireflyFairy1]

i like it its pretty good i think

[joanne19891107]

the girl with the lowest voice sucks ..... RENT <3

[euan112358]

respect the singers' effort no matter what they sound like, and if they sound even remotely good, respect their effort even more.

[MadisonLUVS4ever]

Lol this isn't very good....oh American idol -.- I don't even remember half of these people..smh

[X0ohenryo0X]

the original is so much better than this

[ArchuletaFanj11]

David<333333

[kissrk2]

ummmm....no comment

[davidmoye]

holy shit this his horrible

[ShaNaeJolleyMusic]

Go David A! :D

[AvaM12]

Where is the solo!!!??? D: D: D: D: Joannes solo! :( :( wtf! That solo makes the song!

[AvaM12]

This sucks... :/ I thought it would be quite good.. that's dissapointing.

[TheStar2bella]

Why are they all screwing with the melody on their solos?

[roundallaround]

...booo!!!

[theEc2crew]

David archueleta messed up

[sweetiegrl41]

Haha David's the only one who's singing this right :) gosh I wish they'd have let him sing it by himself...that would make it 10 times more sexy/good! xD just saying

[theEc2crew]

@sweetiegrl41 LOL HE SANG THE LYRICS WRONG

[tatum635]

brooke is the one singing too loudly, she is the white girl sitting in the chair with the red shirt on.

[MrBukketz]

HORRIBLE

[soso104]

Bad.

[FantomLightning]

David fucked up the lyrics in his pathetically small part too...

[phonyreal]

The soprano voice isn't loud enough and the middle voices are too loud. Sounds busy and sounds like it has no real melody.

[EruvieBruinen]

Some girl is singing really awful there. Sorry I don't know who... didn't follow this Idol.

[DaViDcOokRoX115]

@EruvieBruinen its brooke......haha thus the top comment yes she is screwing up all the harmonies

[momorization]

simply awful....

[wickedsinger99]

awful just awful



[tietiana34]

Rent should have been turned into series !

[familycooltimes]

THT ONE GUY LOOKS LIKE DAVID ARCHELETA I THINK IT IS......

[treemoka]

@familycooltimes holy shit...

[familycooltimes]

@treemoka 0:16



[treemoka]

i said Holy shit because David Archuleta became famous because of American Idol and you were like, "I think thats David Archuleta!" lol

[familycooltimes]

@treemoka lol!!! im slow sometimes!

[123456tess1234567890]

1 day ago when you are reading thid do not stop or else something bad will happen! (sorry about this) this girl's name is summer, she is 15 years old and has blonde hair,many scars, and she has no ears. she is dead. if you don't copy this to more than 5 videos, she will appear one dark quiet night when you are not expecting it beside your bed with a knife and going to kill you. this is no joke. if you send this on 5 more videos something good will happen to you

[lotusflower421]

@123456tess1234567890 STFU

[p3rf3ct0n3]

i think the choir singing backup helped them alot or else it would be a horrible performance

[rahrahravannah321]

....um david archuletta got the words wrong xD

[tovahtovahtovah]

The pace dropped when ever a soloist sung.... - shocking!

[kolorfulbrit]

DAVID!!!!!!!!

[redmusic99]

its not that good :{

[bubblegum6175]

not being mean but my chorus sings better than them in this song! ha!

[eunicedianetulang]

who the hell was so low?!

[ilvlp]

@eunicedianetulang sounds like a girl.......if you listen it's coming from the left side

[Sweetmuffins0018]

@eunicedianetulang I'm going to guess Kristy Lee Cook. She had the weakest voice of the girls. Although Brooke White could be shaky at times.

[Pikacuteness1]

wooo!!! go dude with sexy lookin dreds

[Blaawen]

Those choir members are better than the idols XD

[KurapikaZer]

they can't sing together. they're not in unisons very well. i think the solos were okay but it was only the solos.

[Elsiebelse]

SOB. Just... no.

[ClipsFromMyPhone]

what show is this again. cuz they cant sing for shit

[Wolfzareawsome]

oh my gosh they are horrible. my ALL girls choir can sing this better and we have only had the music for 5 days including today.

[cyn1378]

They started way too low,some were singing way too loud over others,some of the notes were just wrong and too top it all off they never hit the high note.

[Noobsdontknow]

No way could they stand up to the cast of rent. Its unfair to even let them do that song!

[theVolunteersfan]

They'll be accompanying that akita "Evita" to hell.

[skjumpers]

WHERE'S THE HIGH C? LAME!

[britthinse]

1:55 wait- the TIMES that she died? um, no.

[MTCal25]

@britthinse LMAO i thought the saaame thing :D

[sophia321123]

@britthinse lol! that's what i thought lmaooo

[VeryStrangechild]

This is awful. 

[jesseshorror]

this is crap!

[xoxcheekyxox]

who has that really deepish/out of tune voice thats draining everyone else out?

[BHSPLAYER23]

Vote Up If Your Ears Started To Bleed Just A Little....-__- Terrible

[Ficus1493]

boooooooooooo this is sad

[primera1616]

what a disappointment, the blending doesn't seem right/fit when they sing it.

[Sissy950]

Booooooo!

[aquinova]

I love them but this is sad.

[BHSPLAYER23]

this is horrible....how disrespectful

[steel99999]

Absolute CRAP they missed the high notes because half of them cant sing worth crap. ALSO they were never together just trying to one-up eachother the whole song. In my opinion this couldn't have been worse

[anyguess01]

I love this song, The idol contestants did not have the uhmmf that is needed for this song! You feel me? They all sing well but di not gel together for this performance.Just my opionion.

[AlexisDarkgiver]

Ugh... Totally ruined it, my school's vocal ensemble is WAY better at singing this then these ADULTS. Seriously!

[dani92hl]

that really is heartless.it sucks...

[milliehwilkes]

THIS IS CRAP

[Muggafatz]

SOOOO BAD!!!!

[RIOTinyourface]

This sounds so dead.

[MrJunglestalker]

A complete disgrace!!!!!!! Archuleta what did you just say?? times that she died? ha? die!

[ADAylonG2]

LOL, just LOL



[alexuskmau334]

david cook and david archuleta!!! <3

[MrPlopkop]

isrealian ?

[TheLAShowCali]

I LOVE JASON CASTRO!!