Yea. The guy who posted this makes it sound like MM came up with all this as much as Trent did, bullshit of course. All Manson did was pretend to play guitar on a version of the Gave Up video, that's it.
how come the "help me I am in hell" part is missing? Its supposed to depict a dude eating some steak and drinking some wine covered in flies.Such a great part, and its missing.
ok i don't feel like reading through all these comments to see if anyone else said this, but i don't think marilyn manson had anything to do with this video. this is old skool early 90s NIN
I love Manson, but frankly, Trent Reznor is just the fucking master. He is and always has been incredible, going places others feared to tread and somehow being both commercially viable and darkly disturbing. Love that man.
bullshit. reznor did all his music in the early days. after their falling out he dropped him. you cant tell me there isnt a difference between antichrist superstar and golden age? its cos trent isnt there to make him cool any more. manson sucks these days
what the hell do you mean taught? taught what? Ya he signed them to do some albums and he helped with production on some of them, but what else are you talking about.....taught
The mainstream music video for "Gave Up", as shown on Closure, features a young Marilyn Manson playing guitar, appearing sans makeup and eye contacts. This was filmed before Reznor signed Manson to Nothing Records.
All credit for above information goes to Wikipedia.
Marilyn Manson had exactly dick to do with this video. I know it's been said, but since the uploader has stupidly refused to change his comments, I think it bears repeating.
manson was in the "gave up" video itself, search "NIN Gave up," he is in it. This film doesn't really sho much of that video, just the video playing while that guy is being tourtured. In gave up manson just pretends to play guitar, trent played guitar on the track, I believe.
este video merece una review en toda regla pero no seré yo quien la haga q no tengo ganas además, yo lo tengo claro, es lo mejor q ha hecho NIN visualmente hablando con diferencia, no creo q nunca lo iguale en transgresión y originalidad. Musicalmente hablando, pues escucha las putas canciones (si, son jodidas putas canciones cabronas) y mirame en el espejo. Soberbio, sobretodo happiness in slavery.
lawlcopters. Other than the fact you pointed out that he didn't do anything for the movie or NIN, you're quite a moron.
Leechinf off the "genre"?! And what genre is NIN? Industrial? Oh, I know: POP! Just like Marilyn Manson! They're both in pop rock bands! Stfu and get off my internet.
Oh and also the gave up video was live in the studio and they turned around and made a video for it. and manson was involved in this but not the broken movie itself.
Dumb ass, Manson is a total cock smoker that had nothing to do with this, in gave up he made an appearance but thats not here, even so He never even played guitar in the video, he strummed like a dumb ass. Manson= gay.
The only Marilyn Manson in "this" movie is the real version of the video "Gave Up". But since the real video is not featured, it is not MM. But anyway, this video is disappointing, I have two copies of it and only watch it when I'm bored with nothing better to do. XkukolX
never seen this movie until now. Absolutely brilliant though (as one would expect from Trent) :3
darkcircuitry 3 years ago 4
yeah MM wasnt involved with it at all champ
joel94543 3 years ago 2
the movie was meant to look real - that is, like a home video. It's bad quality on purpose. This is as good as it gets
MasterJurgen 3 years ago 2
theres a dvd quality version but honestly i dont liek it as much
kaperisk 3 years ago
MM had absolutely sweet fuck all to do with this!
cheers
happihedz 3 years ago 4
Lol, he played some guitars on some tracks, but that's about it ;)
Oderus24 3 years ago 4
Yea. The guy who posted this makes it sound like MM came up with all this as much as Trent did, bullshit of course. All Manson did was pretend to play guitar on a version of the Gave Up video, that's it.
toddpinkstonisgod 3 years ago 4
how come the "help me I am in hell" part is missing? Its supposed to depict a dude eating some steak and drinking some wine covered in flies.Such a great part, and its missing.
happihedz 3 years ago 3
ok i don't feel like reading through all these comments to see if anyone else said this, but i don't think marilyn manson had anything to do with this video. this is old skool early 90s NIN
rattyrockstar 4 years ago
your right, he had nothing to do with this at all....
The only reason he is in the original Wake Up clip is that Trent at the time obviously didn't hate him at that point...
WillowAelfin 4 years ago
trent's fuckin gnarly. straight up gnarly
sandninja1990 4 years ago 4
I love Manson, but frankly, Trent Reznor is just the fucking master. He is and always has been incredible, going places others feared to tread and somehow being both commercially viable and darkly disturbing. Love that man.
nastypins 4 years ago 6
where can I download a version thats not to complicated, and perhaps I can transfer to my ipod?
KINS138 4 years ago 3
wow i ve been looking everywhere for this, ill still buy it , but first time ive seen it
devoydisme 4 years ago
you can't buy it (yet, if closure is released on dvd, it may be added as an extra feature)
sheepdean 4 years ago
Hmm
Snuff film?
Hahaha
God, twisted though
And Manson wasn't "taught" by Trent...
That's an incorrect statement.
Trent PRODUCED, and basically got him started.
Manson was born with his talent...he wasn't taught.
autumn145 4 years ago
bullshit. reznor did all his music in the early days. after their falling out he dropped him. you cant tell me there isnt a difference between antichrist superstar and golden age? its cos trent isnt there to make him cool any more. manson sucks these days
MaliceMizery1 4 years ago 6
He was born with his talent indeed...
But he wasn't born with those titties.
JackPhoxxllyyy 4 years ago
He was born with his talent indeed...
But he wasn't born with those titties.
JackPhoxxllyyy 4 years ago 3
Marilyn manson was taught by trent reznor
i love them both alot but marilyn didn't
anyone know of any snuff films are the internet
i remember when this first came out it was over the news as a snuff film
jew789000 4 years ago
what the hell do you mean taught? taught what? Ya he signed them to do some albums and he helped with production on some of them, but what else are you talking about.....taught
pulsating123 4 years ago
Would i be able to get this thru ebay?
Velvetgoldmine92 4 years ago
Well Marilyn Manson was Trents former protoge and did contribute to a lot of his work showing wise.
dantedarco 4 years ago
lol im glad dantedarco gets his facts from other nin videos on youtubes... the whole "former protege" thing was on the starfuckers interview.
360apples 4 years ago
manson had nothing to do with the entire video, idiot.
missmurder99 4 years ago
[edit] Personnel
Martin Atkins - Drums
Trent Reznor - Vocals, Keyboards, Programming, Producer
Chris Vrenna - Drums, Programming, Beats, Artist
The mainstream music video for "Gave Up", as shown on Closure, features a young Marilyn Manson playing guitar, appearing sans makeup and eye contacts. This was filmed before Reznor signed Manson to Nothing Records.
All credit for above information goes to Wikipedia.
asinifutoba 4 years ago
Marilyn Manson had exactly dick to do with this video. I know it's been said, but since the uploader has stupidly refused to change his comments, I think it bears repeating.
JesusKrispies 4 years ago
manson had nothing to do with this...
cfmanipulate 5 years ago
i concur
BackwardsAttraction 5 years ago
manson was in the "gave up" video itself, search "NIN Gave up," he is in it. This film doesn't really sho much of that video, just the video playing while that guy is being tourtured. In gave up manson just pretends to play guitar, trent played guitar on the track, I believe.
inkjetresurrection 4 years ago
Trent teamed up with a poineer (Peter Christoperson) to create this fuc*ed up wannabe snuff film-
Ottodd 5 years ago
Its not supposed to be a snuff film. It's art.
Velvetgoldmine92 4 years ago
I Like The Flying Head About 19:45 19:59 , I Looked Real, But I Couldnt Help But Laugh
AverusMusashi 5 years ago
este video merece una review en toda regla pero no seré yo quien la haga q no tengo ganas además, yo lo tengo claro, es lo mejor q ha hecho NIN visualmente hablando con diferencia, no creo q nunca lo iguale en transgresión y originalidad. Musicalmente hablando, pues escucha las putas canciones (si, son jodidas putas canciones cabronas) y mirame en el espejo. Soberbio, sobretodo happiness in slavery.
scanner1978 5 years ago
lawlcopters. Other than the fact you pointed out that he didn't do anything for the movie or NIN, you're quite a moron.
Leechinf off the "genre"?! And what genre is NIN? Industrial? Oh, I know: POP! Just like Marilyn Manson! They're both in pop rock bands! Stfu and get off my internet.
jackyll 5 years ago
Apologies, Bill...
KnjazNazrath 4 years ago
the shity quality makes the video more industrial
Refusedrog 5 years ago
completamente de acuerdo, aunq merece la pena verlo con algo más de calidad para apreciar "detalles" q pasan desapercibidos en este...
scanner1978 5 years ago
God I haven't seen this in forever!
jennyjenocide 5 years ago
Oh and also the gave up video was live in the studio and they turned around and made a video for it. and manson was involved in this but not the broken movie itself.
mitchellb348 5 years ago
I have the broken movie on dvd with twice the quality of this.
mitchellb348 5 years ago
well post it on youtube please
Superman1969 5 years ago
Good vid, bad quality
Laddil 5 years ago
I suppose you could always download it from Limewire or something....if you want, obviously....no?
JadeDracul 5 years ago
I suppose you could always download it from Limewire or something....if you want, obviously....no?
JadeDracul 5 years ago
thank you for this!
TriciaGnosis 6 years ago
Christopherson did some great work with Trent in this video.
SineWaves23 6 years ago
Um, no. No manson involved.
Please correct the listing or back up your claim, and in future try to do the research first. =/
cephal0p0d 6 years ago
I've been looking for this one casset (the original) for so long now but i can't seem to find it. ever since they took it off the market of course. .
Dante801 6 years ago
Dumb ass, Manson is a total cock smoker that had nothing to do with this, in gave up he made an appearance but thats not here, even so He never even played guitar in the video, he strummed like a dumb ass. Manson= gay.
halo20only 6 years ago
THANK YOU SO MUCH!!
uzatrip 6 years ago
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
uzatrip 6 years ago
wow...
im impressed...
everywhere i look on the net, i always find the crappy quality version.. this one is a bit better.. but yeah...
and about your description... collaboration between NIN and MM?
YOUR ON MAD CRACK!!!!
heresydude 6 years ago
The only Marilyn Manson in "this" movie is the real version of the video "Gave Up". But since the real video is not featured, it is not MM. But anyway, this video is disappointing, I have two copies of it and only watch it when I'm bored with nothing better to do. XkukolX
XkukolX 6 years ago
collaboration between trent reznor and marilyn manson??
Broken: The Movie... it has nothing to do with MM...
Its based on Nine Inch Nail's "Broken"...
http://www.nin.com/halo/05/index.html
once again, marilyn manson has nothing to do with this...
shagg187 6 years ago