@jorjethezebra Wow, look at you w/ the SAT word of the day! Now go get educated on what good music is because Korn will just waste your precious brain cells.
@piscesean85 I'll submit that my attempt at being funny was pathetic, I am known for trying a little too hard, and I respect that you have different taste in music than I do, but this song is apparantly something we have in common, and I like it too much to let it be ruined by associating it with an argument that I'd rather not have. Truce?
I just discovered Peter Murphy through my bf and I find that the more I listen to him, the deeper I fall. His voice touches places I didn't know possible. He is beautiful.
Murphy's tortured scream into crazy note at 02:55 - woooahhh. The tortured, ripped up, strained edge to his voice fits NIN and this track to perfection. I love watching top musicians live, stripped down - that's when you can see (and hear) who's got the real talent. Also weird how he manages to sing a lot like Trent, but with his own twist. Trent is one of the best songwriters of all time (IMO) and has a unique, eerie, powerful voice. What a track, what a performance!
@TheDocJayz - I'm pretty sure sexuality doesn't have to do with the sexiness of this song, but congrats to you for coming out of the closet and enjoying this amazing song.
@Macumated Entitled to your opinion mate. Just disagree with you...tried to see it from your side and I guess i can see why you wouldn't like it I suppose. Murphy is a bit of a legend though and "ruining beginning to end" is a bit over the top don't you think?
Peter Murphy adds incredible depth and dynamic to one of my fav NIN songs. Something I can never have, Terrible Lie, and Reptile, are poems put to music and are f'in incredible, so u might want to get off this page and go listen to whatever music u might like. Im not even a Peter Murphy fan, but here he is incredible...what do you guys think?
@WDHJR2007 I'd never heard of Peter Murphy before seeing this, although I've been a NIN fan for a while. Murphy and Reznor harmonise perfectly, Murphy's vocal range and the way he uses his voice like an instrument here is just too good to put into words. Incredible. Having said that I listened to one of his albums, and it wasn't my thing. But here, his voice is just one of the greatest I've ever heard - this live set is musical perfection. Makes me say wow every time I hear it.
@pkitty22 the word comment does not imply something positive I guess you can't take criticism because "Commenting on Youtube NEEDS to be positive and everyone should have the same opinion"
@eltiempoteeny - No. This is what happens when your name is Reznor and you are the singularly most musically and lyrically talented individual of your century.
Atticus Ross has an uncanny ability of not getting enough recognition. Would it really hurt the title by squeezing his name in there w/ the 3 gents? Even in the social network OST everyone keeps talking about it like it was only one guy that did it. I mean TR is definitely an awesome artist, and it's not his fault he overshadows Ross, but damn, he's also a very exceptional musician. Anyway, yes, I agree w/ the comment below, I'd give a nut to be in this very room w/ them. Awesome.
You know...when i was little...i used to sing using the same...almost, same estyle than Peter murphy...the thing is...this is the first time i actually listened to this guy...and i stopped singing like that because everybody i knew told me it sounded ugly. think i should retake...should have never stopped singing...i lost a shitload of practice and to top it all started smoking.
Peter Murphy is unconditionally qualified to always be able to sing NIN songs, anywhere, anytime. He is an excellent performer. If you ever have a chance to see him live, take it at all costs.
best partwhen i found this song on you tube i did summer salts ..! wow my fave rate n.i.n song with good old goth peter.the why this song morphs with these guys but the best part is when the break in to haunted buy love and rockets.that must have been trents sugestion.wonderfull!
awesome video i like the idea of him going with Pete Murphy and Atticus and Jeordie best live video ive seen of him that is if you dont count in concert after Slip was released
@dredataaiwa I think it's just distortion...maybe the smallest bit of phaser. Of course there's no real way of knowing for sure without asking them. Atticus and Trent are both audio wizards.
I like all of trent reznor's collaborations. The character of Peter murphy's voice throws the song into an entirely new (and interesting) light and perspective. It's not a replacement, but as a companion piece... we all have the old version
Sucks donkey balls. The faggot singer has that "david attenborough" discovery channel, matter of fact british-kick in the crotch-toffee nosed accent/voice. I don't give a shit who he is and what's he's done for the music world. get the fuck off and let Trent sing.
@JustinReznor hey, fuck both of you. you're just fans of the music, so listen to the fucking music and quit trying to "have trent's back" in a youtube comments section.
@fishbone7100 If your talking to me ?? I never said anything about having Trents back . I was responding to the homophobe who called me a girl and told me to fuck off . So fuck you back
TWIGGY O JEORDIE COMO SEA ERES MAGNIFICO EXELENTE GRANDIOSO
PENELOPE3LIBRAS 2 days ago
I love twiggy
InSingularity 1 week ago
THERE'S AN EVIL FLY
GERMANBAJO 1 week ago
Jorjethezebra do you even know who peter Murphy is?
nizc0rvan 1 week ago
its like nine inch nails combined with korn combined with neil diamond, its like a..... nine inch korn diamond
jorjethezebra 2 weeks ago
@jorjethezebra
You did not just fucking put NIN in the same sentence with Korn, much less fucking Neil Diamond.
piscesean85 2 weeks ago
@piscesean85 that statement is completely fallacious, i most definitely did put NIN korn and Neil Diamond in the same sentence
jorjethezebra 1 week ago
@jorjethezebra Wow, look at you w/ the SAT word of the day! Now go get educated on what good music is because Korn will just waste your precious brain cells.
piscesean85 1 week ago
@piscesean85 I'll submit that my attempt at being funny was pathetic, I am known for trying a little too hard, and I respect that you have different taste in music than I do, but this song is apparantly something we have in common, and I like it too much to let it be ruined by associating it with an argument that I'd rather not have. Truce?
jorjethezebra 1 week ago
@jorjethezebra I see no Neil Diamond. And as much as I love KoRn, I see none of that either.
BackwardsT 1 week ago
Haunting, sexy. Just fucking amazing. OMFG. Imagine being there when they actually did this.
BlondieGrrl65 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
abbeyroad1980 3 weeks ago
how orgasmic is that bass!
CoVeRxXxJuNkEe 3 weeks ago
What was the second part of the song from? i've not heard that before.
MephProduction 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
abbeyroad1980 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
abbeyroad1980 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
abbeyroad1980 3 weeks ago
@MephProduction "Haunted, When The Minutes Drag" by Love and Rockets =]
abbeyroad1980 3 weeks ago
@abbeyroad1980 Nice on, I've never bothered listening to them before.
MephProduction 2 weeks ago
I just discovered Peter Murphy through my bf and I find that the more I listen to him, the deeper I fall. His voice touches places I didn't know possible. He is beautiful.
aame1212 3 weeks ago
Eargasm
Clabeus 4 weeks ago
Murphy's tortured scream into crazy note at 02:55 - woooahhh. The tortured, ripped up, strained edge to his voice fits NIN and this track to perfection. I love watching top musicians live, stripped down - that's when you can see (and hear) who's got the real talent. Also weird how he manages to sing a lot like Trent, but with his own twist. Trent is one of the best songwriters of all time (IMO) and has a unique, eerie, powerful voice. What a track, what a performance!
mrgmakin 1 month ago
I'm gay and I can honestly say this is one of the sexiest songs EVAR! ;D
TheDocJayz 1 month ago
@TheDocJayz - I'm pretty sure sexuality doesn't have to do with the sexiness of this song, but congrats to you for coming out of the closet and enjoying this amazing song.
TheAlyssaCocaine 1 month ago
love the moog voyager he's casually thrown in front of himself. haha and Ross on that machine! Anyone know what he's using?
V19torrent 1 month ago
peter murphy with twiggy owned this song to me this should have been released on the cd
bencurry24 1 month ago
one of the greatest things about Trent - no ego when it comes to letting someone else sing his songs with him. Amazing.
Zorsha 1 month ago
TRENT ON THE BASS - YES!!!!!!!!
lordamiba101 2 months ago
Atticus ross?
violentmoxie 2 months ago
@violentmoxie yes that's him.
Zorsha 1 month ago
VOTE Ron Paul
glajl 2 months ago 3
its a sexy raping in the alley that continues into a basement---and screamin twiggy to finish..its just soooo sexy
dwightfamily 2 months ago 11
@dwightfamily What... the...
feloniousbutterfly 1 month ago 8
@dwightfamily it's not rape if u like it;p
CoVeRxXxJuNkEe 3 weeks ago
Haunted when the minutes drag
snowblindu 2 months ago
does anybody know what peter is using at like 4:11 to alter his voice?
nitschke 2 months ago
@nitschke : Looks to me like he is using a Korg Kaoss Pad KP3 on his vocals.
DJGUAPOMTL 3 weeks ago
Wow - Trent, Peter, AND Twiggy!
DarkHorizonStudios 2 months ago
i love his bass playing in this
WarriorDudePerson 2 months ago
Does someone know what kind of synth and sampler Atticus is using?
ryanb113n 3 months ago
Hope I get to meet Peter before Death takes either one of us...
CyberBioStein 3 months ago
Twig...
kurtsentrik 3 months ago 2
Saw him last Friday live...,- he's still fantastic and his voice incredible...!!!
Quiane1000 4 months ago in playlist Liked
reznor is the man
CyberWallX 4 months ago
i got the same ikea lights fuck yea
mulambo420 5 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Can i buy this video or get it on itunes??????!!!!!!!! and the other vids like warm leatherette???????
wizarda7x 5 months ago
Can i buy this video or get it on itunes??????????? and the other vids like warm leatherette???????
wizarda7x 5 months ago
@wizarda7x use youtube downloader
alyxkerr 1 week ago
flippin love this!!
Her0twiNzstevil 5 months ago
This is so freakin awesome!!! I listen to this 3 times a day!
wvumab 5 months ago 2
blast sound!
MsFeuerfee 5 months ago
The only one who could talk crap about this video has to be either a homophobe or someone who has never had sex with this song blasting...
greendaypic 5 months ago
Transition to Haunted was so fucking sick.
Logarithmic33 6 months ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Peter murphy fucking ruined the song beginning to end even at 0:47 when he said twiggy
Macumated 6 months ago
@Macumated Entitled to your opinion mate. Just disagree with you...tried to see it from your side and I guess i can see why you wouldn't like it I suppose. Murphy is a bit of a legend though and "ruining beginning to end" is a bit over the top don't you think?
JesusMakeUpMyDyinBed 5 months ago
@Macumated
Peter Murphy adds incredible depth and dynamic to one of my fav NIN songs. Something I can never have, Terrible Lie, and Reptile, are poems put to music and are f'in incredible, so u might want to get off this page and go listen to whatever music u might like. Im not even a Peter Murphy fan, but here he is incredible...what do you guys think?
WDHJR2007 5 months ago 28
@WDHJR2007 exactly the same
eruseron 4 months ago
@WDHJR2007 I'd never heard of Peter Murphy before seeing this, although I've been a NIN fan for a while. Murphy and Reznor harmonise perfectly, Murphy's vocal range and the way he uses his voice like an instrument here is just too good to put into words. Incredible. Having said that I listened to one of his albums, and it wasn't my thing. But here, his voice is just one of the greatest I've ever heard - this live set is musical perfection. Makes me say wow every time I hear it.
mrgmakin 1 month ago
@pkitty22 the word comment does not imply something positive I guess you can't take criticism because "Commenting on Youtube NEEDS to be positive and everyone should have the same opinion"
Macumated 6 months ago
i wish i could grow chops like peter
milebryc 6 months ago
Hey Macumated! Take your "faggot" comment and shove it up your ass. Go to Hell-and stop spreading your stupid hate on-line. You are unwanted.
pkitty2219 6 months ago
Can't say i've listened to Peter Murphy before but his voice is quite interesting, his voice reminds me of a rock opera
TequilaTommy 6 months ago
@TequilaTommy
Check out "Repo the Genetic Opera"
jayromeromusic 6 months ago
@jayromeromusic
Aye already seen it, it's a good film
TequilaTommy 6 months ago
I like the part at 0:41 to 0:44 where he leans back like a faggot
Macumated 6 months ago
Comment removed
stormc1nd3r 6 months ago
@Macumated I thought faggots leaned forward? (You know, to "receive.")
(Oh, and at the person who inevitably says "YOU'RE A HOMOPHOBE!!!!11", I'm not, I just have a sense of fucking humor.)
stormc1nd3r 6 months ago
@stormc1nd3r YOU'RE A HOMOPHOBE!!!!11
br0nc096 6 months ago
@stormc1nd3r Really?
When we expect to hear something funny then?
iCodev2 4 months ago
@iCodev2 Just as soon as you develop a sense of humor. ;-)
stormc1nd3r 2 months ago
@stormc1nd3r Done. Now say something funny.
iCodev2 2 months ago
Twiggy playing guitar?
Trent playing bass?
Atticus playing keyboards and programming?
AND Peter on vocals?
:D my day was just made
MansonNiles11 6 months ago
this is hilarious...theres always people wanting to kill eachother in the youtube comments section
jaytor15 6 months ago
LOVE that they go into "haunted when the minutes drag"!!
peetrwilson 6 months ago
This man has one of the greatest voices I've ever heard ! Damn righteous accompaniment as well.I am totally blown away.
vintagezigg 6 months ago
This man has one of the greatest voices I've ever heard ! Damn righteous accompaniment as well.I am totally blown away.
vintagezigg 6 months ago
Trent Reznor's a fuckin genius when it comes to marketing and business. He developed the only working business model for successful bands.
6stringedkiller 7 months ago
BANANA BANANANANANANANANANA <------I played da riff on a banana
Smeschies 7 months ago
BANANA BANANANANANANANANANA
Smeschies 7 months ago
please stop drinking.... PLEASE!!!
Anastiana1 7 months ago
peter murphy dances like a boss
danielanddaniellable 7 months ago
amazing
danielanddaniellable 7 months ago
I thought that piece of hair in from of twiggy's face was a thin copy of Peter murphy's... Thank god it moved hahah funny while it lasted tho
giuliamania 7 months ago
Peter murphy's dancing.....no
giuliamania 7 months ago
Um 4.49 looks like Trent is doing the no pants dance
McMakisha 7 months ago
Twiggy unffffff
McMakisha 7 months ago
I wish i could be the fly in the room ;_;
Abril12 7 months ago
love this
silverwolf2061 7 months ago
SWEET!!!
lyndamatt 8 months ago
I really cannot get enough of this version of this song. I cannot get enough. I want this in my ears when I wake up and when I go to bed.
tiffanyme001 8 months ago 2
I love Peter Murphy is he in NIN now?
blackgoetia 8 months ago
@blackgoetia there is no NIN but look for HDA :D
xBryanTechx 7 months ago
I love this version of the song. very heady
HereticalDelight 8 months ago
those guys should have butt babies together. it'd be a powerful breed
blackgoetia 8 months ago
he missed up the clap @ 4:32 ! lol
Med0115Tounsi 8 months ago
@Med0115Tounsi why did you lol exactly? he just clapped once. he didnt want to clap the second time
polidosk8 8 months ago
@kornholioa
Agreed, hence, ''One'' of the last :)Tool and NIN, Deftones,SOAD, and not many others.
twiztidlestat 8 months ago
Really guys!? REALLY?!?!? WALMART LAMPS!
Also, Trent is a badass.But, this version of the song.... should have stayed hidden.
TheMsRavenBlack 8 months ago
i love trent's voice........ that bass go hard too
MoWEeziE 9 months ago
while watching "akira" :)
jrmhill76 9 months ago in playlist Nine Inch Nails
simply: AWESOME!!!!
stIQue404 9 months ago
Trent ♥
luuycalareso 9 months ago
Comment removed
seanneal1983 9 months ago 2
@seanneal1983 WOW mine too. What a fuckin small world.
oceanking79 8 months ago in playlist Nine Inch Nails
is this what happens when u dont know any drummers???
eltiempoteeny 9 months ago
@eltiempoteeny Everyone knows a handful of drummers; they deliver the pizza!
snsScotch 9 months ago
@eltiempoteeny sorry nut a drum kit wouldn't fit in my living room....
WickedTRX 8 months ago
@eltiempoteeny - No. This is what happens when your name is Reznor and you are the singularly most musically and lyrically talented individual of your century.
S4BIO 7 months ago
@S4BIO i dunno. i like reznor, but u jumped out the window with that one. the century??? i think not.
eltiempoteeny 7 months ago
@eltiempoteeny - I realize that it's only my personal opinion, but I believe it is a valid one backed up by a slew of Halo evidence :)
S4BIO 7 months ago
Trent, one of the LAST real artists left that still gives a shit, and cares about his music AND his fans
twiztidlestat 9 months ago 2
You know who that fly in the room is, don't you? ;)
doubleas2380 10 months ago
Atticus Ross has an uncanny ability of not getting enough recognition. Would it really hurt the title by squeezing his name in there w/ the 3 gents? Even in the social network OST everyone keeps talking about it like it was only one guy that did it. I mean TR is definitely an awesome artist, and it's not his fault he overshadows Ross, but damn, he's also a very exceptional musician. Anyway, yes, I agree w/ the comment below, I'd give a nut to be in this very room w/ them. Awesome.
komunista94 10 months ago 4
Definitely giving it at 2:02 /faint
Thana8088 10 months ago
FOR THOSE ALL BEAUTIFUL LIARS
Altazorfire 10 months ago
FOR THOSE ALL BEAUTIFUL LIARS,
Altazorfire 10 months ago
Love. OMG.
angelplurbaby 10 months ago
someone kill that fuckin fly.
dman2566 10 months ago 40
@dman2566 he let the insects in
skfromhell 9 months ago 41
@dman2566 it goes good with the song though lol
AllLuvVibes 9 months ago
@dman2566 but why?
14jwh 8 months ago
You know...when i was little...i used to sing using the same...almost, same estyle than Peter murphy...the thing is...this is the first time i actually listened to this guy...and i stopped singing like that because everybody i knew told me it sounded ugly. think i should retake...should have never stopped singing...i lost a shitload of practice and to top it all started smoking.
thehornypuppy 10 months ago
I busted a nut at 5:30 hotdamn Peter Murphy!
VictorAbsinthe 10 months ago
the vocals irked me.
novocainerr 10 months ago
Trent Reznor!!!
6adama9 10 months ago
O_O i fucking love this rendition
xBryanTechx 10 months ago
I wonder what's going through Trent's head during this performance? Sick ass colaboration between veterans of the goth and industrial scene.
spcsalas138 10 months ago
Jeordie looks drunk xD
lovestospooge646 10 months ago
super geile mucke
LeetheLemon 10 months ago
Que buena cancion!!
ale24022000 10 months ago
Look at the drummer. play those preset beats like a champ.
Speedoman1978 11 months ago 2
@Speedoman1978 That's Atticus Ross and he's actually a damn fine composer. He won an oscar y'know.
KradProductions 11 months ago 2
@Speedoman1978 hahahhahahahhahahhahahaha this made my day! CHEERS TO PRESET!
VictorAbsinthe 10 months ago
Peter Murphy is unconditionally qualified to always be able to sing NIN songs, anywhere, anytime. He is an excellent performer. If you ever have a chance to see him live, take it at all costs.
chargermaniac 11 months ago 2
dude this is actually pretty good......i never thought to actually to listen to it but now that i did its actually quite badass
vickersify 11 months ago
best partwhen i found this song on you tube i did summer salts ..! wow my fave rate n.i.n song with good old goth peter.the why this song morphs with these guys but the best part is when the break in to haunted buy love and rockets.that must have been trents sugestion.wonderfull!
blindblueeye 11 months ago
didnt anyone notice the little fly flying around in the room??/ that was me. hahaa
uleavemecold 11 months ago 2
@uleavemecold The fly gave it that NIN feel
StickyInADarkBlueCut 11 months ago 3
@StickyInADarkBlueCut indeed!
uleavemecold 11 months ago
This is a great interpretation from the original mix on "The Downward Spiral." It's truly beautiful.
LungFuMoShe187 11 months ago
WHERE CAN I BUY THIS? PLEAZ RESPOND <3
PLURadelphia 11 months ago
@PLURadelphia you can use a converter [google clipconverter and its the one that says Youtube converter - clipconverter]
Just copy and paste the url to a video and make sure you hit mp3 [or whatever]
slipknotmaggot54 11 months ago
really bad. awful.
dk0r51 11 months ago
@dk0r51 is peter murphy for god sake ¡?¡?¡?
CMACHT000 11 months ago
awesome video i like the idea of him going with Pete Murphy and Atticus and Jeordie best live video ive seen of him that is if you dont count in concert after Slip was released
ps3matsergamer 11 months ago
@ps3matsergamer jeordie walker of killing joke?
DivisionbyZer0 11 months ago
Wtf is this!? Where the fuck is this? Trent's basement?
dirtshirt63 11 months ago
@dirtshirt63 I think it was at a radio station
15kalas15 11 months ago
the singer looks like a reptile
bryanreize1 1 year ago
This is amazing! I love how Trent is wearing shorts, and Twiggy forgets to turn his mic around for the backup vocal :-P
rasputin7095 1 year ago
@rasputin7095 Not like you could hear him or anything...
JohnnyCindahouse 1 year ago
WHAT IS THE BASS EFFECT?...THX
dredataaiwa 1 year ago
Comment removed
groundzer077 1 year ago
@dredataaiwa I think it's just distortion...maybe the smallest bit of phaser. Of course there's no real way of knowing for sure without asking them. Atticus and Trent are both audio wizards.
groundzer077 1 year ago
Peter Murphy! Maestro!
Santinferno 1 year ago
hell yes......rock on
clintxoxox 1 year ago
I like all of trent reznor's collaborations. The character of Peter murphy's voice throws the song into an entirely new (and interesting) light and perspective. It's not a replacement, but as a companion piece... we all have the old version
VulgarRhymester 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sucks donkey balls. The faggot singer has that "david attenborough" discovery channel, matter of fact british-kick in the crotch-toffee nosed accent/voice. I don't give a shit who he is and what's he's done for the music world. get the fuck off and let Trent sing.
kharnvelzyghur 1 year ago
@barnslou hey thanks man!!! You saved my life haha
blackxican121 1 year ago
4:30... My mind is going....
redrumkarmen 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love the ending with "Haunted When The Minutes Drag". I mean, how often does Peter Murphy sing a song from his ex-bandmates' band?
Morgodth 1 year ago
Not gonna lie , this version makes me kinda wet
whistlepig75 1 year ago 75
@whistlepig75 Thought it was just me....... ;)
gsnapyt 11 months ago
@whistlepig75 me too, and im a guy
hahayoudied123 10 months ago
@whistlepig75 me too and I'm a guy!
dman2566 10 months ago
@whistlepig75
maybe you should let the insects in
blackgoetia 9 months ago
@whistlepig75 - Please tell me you're a female.
S4BIO 7 months ago
@whistlepig75 are you a fucking girl
JustinReznor 7 months ago
@JustinReznor move out of your parents basement and enjoy the music
whistlepig75 7 months ago 10
@whistlepig75 hey ASSHOLE YOU DONT FUCKING KNOW ME
JustinReznor 7 months ago
@whistlepig75 fuck you
JustinReznor 7 months ago
Comment removed
fishbone7100 7 months ago
@JustinReznor hey, fuck both of you. you're just fans of the music, so listen to the fucking music and quit trying to "have trent's back" in a youtube comments section.
fishbone7100 7 months ago
@fishbone7100 If your talking to me ?? I never said anything about having Trents back . I was responding to the homophobe who called me a girl and told me to fuck off . So fuck you back
whistlepig75 5 months ago