Added: 4 years ago
From: filtronio
Views: 74,349
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (51)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Only the end is playback, its shakira falsetto note, and to go into the falsetto register is hard to maintain a note that long and perfect, I dont blame her for lipsyncing because she dances alot she has alot of energy, and only does it for the last notes.

  • mas playback please!!

  • awsome performance...i love it so much...i love her so much....she is so so amazing

  • live? estas loco tio ..!! no way this is live..

  • lov her style  its kinda amazing

  • Shakira te deseaba desde antes de nacer!!!

  • para mi este video

    esta editado

    y le pusieron el audio original de la cancion

    arriba del audio del video..

    si fuera playback no creo q se notaria tanto en una artista como shakira!!

    primera vez q veo un video asi d ella.

  • de hecho tienes razon, esta presentacion esta del todo editada en el audio, todo el recital es igual :( y la verdad resulta un poco aburrido por que es como escuchar el cd

  • i wish i was the girl that shakira kissed in the end on the song :*_*:

  • en algunas ocaciones se escucha muy a lo lejos y muy bajo su voz, detras del playback, y tambien si mi mente no falla ese vestuario es el que ocupo en el concierto ALAS de argentina

  • jaja q tonteras q decis:)

  • @NearbykMC siiii! esto usó en el concierto de ALAS

  • Playback...but good performance.

  • But i think it is really playback because the first time she sings this sons live was at Rock in Rio and i think that was before but of course it isn´t bad that it is playback!

    Shakira is so beautiful and her performance is amazing!

    Shakira is the best of the world!

  • But i think it is really playback because the first time she sings it live was at Rock in Rio 2008 but it isn´t bad that it is playback. Shakira is so beautiful and her performance is amazing!!

  • soy seguidor de shaki pero me da rabia cuando hace playback y mas cuando se nota.....

    la verdad esta muy mal esto

  • she is beautiful and her voice is the best

  • es playback

  • woow eso si es un verdadero performance

    tan espectacular

    ademas juega con las camaras

    seduce al publico baila geniaal y se ke es playback pero no me importa

    ya que muchas veces asi se lo piden

    si lo notan en ciertos programas de Tv

    o pekeños performances lo hacen asii

    pero cuando es concerto

    siempre canta en vivo y geniaaaaaaaaaal

    SHAKIRA TE AMO

  • Bueno, yo amo a shakira, no me importa q sea live, o playback o lo q sea, sencillamente es la mejor.

    Well, mmm i love Shakira, i dont care if she is doing playback or not, she is just the best.

  • omg! :O when was thissss!????????

  • ya dejen de poner spams pls!!!!!!!!!!!:S

  • Shakira es lo mejor talentosa bella ingeniosa seductora una artista de verdad Thalía Paulina Britney Cristinita agarrense por que esta chica es una Fregona eh y le pese a quien le pese es la mejor

  • ¡no he intendido! ¿una mezcla de live y playback? ¿como puede ser?

  • expectacular esta canción e interpretación

  • please guys check my video of take bow by rihanna and don't forget to leave comments

    xoxo

  • What do you know about performances any ways, and by the way how do you expect her to smile while singing? You are such an ASS! fucker!

  • eSA BLUSA LA USO EN EL CONCIERTO ALAS EN ARGENTINA ESTE AÑO OMG!

  • a veces es necesario el playback pero x los programas mas no x los artistas y shakira no es un artista de playbacks asi q kreo q fue x el programa

  • shakira dont do playback the point in this performance is that u can still hear her voice so its not playback ok thank u lol

  • it IS playback :\

  • estoy de acuerdo que shakira se arrepintio de cantar en play back lo suyo no es cantar en play back si no en vivo apoco no

  • canto en playback, no lo creo y espero k no

    SHAKIRA RULES

  • perdon, hablo poco ingles xD asi q si alguien me entiende en español xD...

    Yo creo que iba a cantar en playback, pero a ultima hora se arrepintio, y canto con la pista mezclado con su voz en vivo xD pero igual la amo xD.

    Viva Shaka

  • guys if you want to know my oppinion (the poster's) i think that her record IS plying in the background while she sings with th emic turned off i still like her but everyone does that this days SO WHO AGREES WITH MEE?????

  • she is doing playback but u can hear her real voice..

  • It's playback, it sounds exactly the same as the cd track. And she doesn't know how to do playback. It's very obvious.

    I don't know why she did so much playback on this era. Even half of the tour was in playback.

  • she doesn't do many playback on tour... only just several unimportant elements were from pleyback in tour... you must by deaf...

  • Playback in music: Estoy Aquí, Ojos Así, Whenever Wherever, Ciega Sordomuda, Obtener Un Sí.

    Playback in voice: Ojos Así, Ciega Sordomuda, Don't Bother, Whenerver Wherever, Estoy Aquí, La Tortura, HDL.

    That's a LOT of playback for a LIVE concert.

    I really like Shakira since 1997, but Oral Fixation was the worst tour I've seen in years. I don't know why everybody was so pleased with it.

    And this era had so much playback... I don't understand why. Billboard criticized this as well. A lot.

  • So since u know it that well, why don't u just tell us the exact parts?

    And what I wonder is that mostely people who like Shakira since a shitload of time critzise her on anything. She did way more playback back then, than she actually did in the OF era or does now.

  • You're completely wrong. She never did so much playback until 2005. That's a fact.

    And I can show you perfectly which parts of the concert are in playback. It's very obvious. In Don't Bother, for example, just after the bridge you can hear perfectly the transition from playback to live. I know truth hurts. But Shakira is no longer that great artist we once knew. Now she's more worried about being a fashion icon and a silly pop star that only shakes her ass.

    This era was a joke.

  • Well, I don't say she doesnt do any playback, the spoken part of Don't Bother (..and learn about footbal) was playback on the DVD, thats what u hear, the beginning of Ciega Sordomuda was playback on the whole tour as some parts of the chorus. Same for Suerte/Whenever, Whererver.... but wheres the problem? With almost 400 shows she did on this tour she got all the right to do some playback. And I guess truth may hurt for u cauz u're the one complaining and not me.

  • Shakira is a Pop Icon! She is still the great artisit that we love. I listen to her Oral Fixation Tour daily on my way to work. She is just talented. I loved this concert. Many other people did as well since most of them were SOLD OUT! Shakira did not have playback in the concert until HDL. ITS HER SONG...SHE IS SINGING IT...EVEN IF ITS PLAYBACK. She is awesome and is becoming a better artist as she matures. GO SHAKI!

  • EXCUSE YOU, but I have watched this concert over twenty times now and she is not doing any playbacks. The only pre-recorded songs were the intro's like in Estoy Aqui in the begining.

  • You are correct. On her tour, she did not have playback, except HDL I think. On Se Ti Vas, it was obvious this was not playback by the way she changed her voice in the beginning.The only playback I will agree with is HDL. All other songs were live. The tour was awesome.

  • playback!!!!!!!

  • Dude, its obviously not.

  • I love her!! This is my fav song!!!

  • she's perfect

  • crossover??, what a shame!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more