Added: 3 years ago
From: craftyoverdose
Views: 164,101
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (371)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @thejazzyjazz2009 that was actually in the book. It was one of the things Ingrid did in Barry's home to show him that she was there.

  • I thought she cut her hair cause she knew she was beautiful with the long blonde hair so she tried to make herself ugly so guys wouldn't like her

  • @BURRR478 Yes that's why.

  • Poor little Davey and Owen. :(

  • @THEQIR she cut her hair was because the girl that she was fighting boyfriend said it looked good on her so she cut it all off and that was the reason why they were fighting. The book explained that. Too bad they didn't in the movie.

  • she looks like Justin bieber with her hair short.. lol

  • Starr had every right to be angry at Astrid for having sex with Ray, because what Astrid did was incredibly wrong. However, Starr took her rage to the extreme when she shot Astrid. There is no excuse for what Starr did, and even though she was very upset, it does not make shooting Astrid okay. She never should have done it, at all. The woman clearly needs to be locked in a mental institution, placed in a strait jacket and possibly on medication.

  • @WithAVoiceOfAnAngel3 -- Astrid is a kid, she should have just been mad at Ray. He should know better.

  • Feel so sorry for astrid. =\

  • Comment removed

  • where did ray and starr go after she shot astrid?

  • @HPfan75 I don't know if you've read the book or not, but in the book they BOTH wanted to be together. She started things between them.

  • putting flowers in a cup full of milk..they r tryn too hard to make this movie deep.

  • I never understood why Davey was in a cast until I read the book.Starr actually dislocated hitting him while she was drunk.

  • read the book. it has all the details

  • "They have all sorts of activities for young people." I'm pretty sure that didn't include the fighting and getting beat down.

  • actually her hair is shaved.. she's using wig in the entire movie

  • umm ppl that is a wig.

  • how is this movie actually making me homesick for L.A.?

  • can the top comments please stop spoiling !

  • @magicrystalina If you had read the book then it wouldn't be a spoiler. Actually I don't remember that being in the book...hmmmm

  • oh my gahhhhhhh...patrick fugit!! he is pretty much my ideal guy.

  • i love her short hair

  • The hair was way better long.

  • Paul is adorable 

  • i kinda like her hair short

  • she should of kept her cut of hair as extentions if she regretted it

  • I'm sorry about her hair :(

  • @Cuteblondie1972 that was the point, she didn't want to get beaten up again

  • fucks a kid up when theyres no daddy

  • that piano player got paid some mad money to do this film:)

  • wow paul has really bad acne..... NOT!

  • hmmm no Olivia or Marvel huh?

  • @kaminov1 I hated those two bitches in the book they sucked big time

  • OMG!!!!

    this drunken crazy white bitch has a gun & has kids in her care and child welfare didn't know she's a heavy drinker plus has a loaded gun...then she takes a pop shot at Astrid and then Ray & Star takes off leaving her to bleed to death, but astrid was pretty lucky that little boy saved her. That woman "Star" should be charged with: "Reckless Child Endangerment", "Assault with a Deadly Weapon" & "Attempetd Murder".

  • Lol bitch has a gun:o

  • cole so hot.

  • Am I the only person who was like "OMG, the chick from Gilmore Girls!" when she woke up? lol

  • wait, so did they have sex then?

  • the music reminds alot of the music in 'american beauty' film

  • @toyworld872 Both soundtracks were composed by Thomas Newman, so theres a similarity in sound

  • @toyworld872 omg totally!

  • @toyworld872

    it's the same piece by Thomas Newman :)

  • In real life. ray is 5 yrs older than her. and alison was 22 when she did this this movie. wah she look young:)

  • Comment removed

  • ASTRIG IS BAD ASS ! PUTTIN THE KNIFE TO HER NECK !

  • @SincerelyDebonairre I will agree but it's Astrid I think lol :)

  • @SincerelyDebonairre pretty sure it's Astrid...Google it

  • i don't think he's a pedophile, she's been through some shit but she knows what she wants

  • @pitterpatterson He is a pedophile. You can never talk thing straight if they are crocket.

  • Comment removed

  • Its funny how people freak out when a younger girl and an older guy are together. I personally dont see anything wrong with it especially if they truly like eachother and not ment for any pervert intentions. I say Ray was better off with Astrid then Starr. and my name is Astrid btw!

  • @Lararevelute People don't freak out, you freak. They have real concerns. Remember that this is a book, and not reality. I hope you don't have any childeren cause you would give them to pedophiles because they "love" them.

  • @RoadlessPathWow i bet ur just so full of urself!Ur such a good person!Its so great that people like u just have the answer 2 evrything and have 2 judge evrybody on wat seems 2 u as bad morale.So I say 2 u,the next time u judge a person n tell them"I hope u dont have kids one day"u should think again bcuz maybe sumthing bad might happen 2 u?Maybe u wont have kids 1 day?Because if i have kids 1 day ill do my best 2 take care of them.So stfu and stop lecturing cuz there's no point.

  • star: believer of Christ and a foster mom of 4 kids...what a hypocrite!

  • Ha! 2.08 (how did that remind me of Lord Farquaad in Shrek?)

  • Damn, she got shot so now she's *hardcore* with her new hiarcut -_-

  • Awww, Dave :<

  • Do they have sex in the movie Astrid and "Uncle Ray"? Or in the book only? I never read the book.

  • @joriefoy They have sex in the movie, too.

  • I'd be all up in his stuff too.

    He is gorgeous.

  • 'don't know the guy'

    god, i love the character development in this movie.

  • sookie!

  • How'd she get into that fight ??

  • uhhh that poor excuse for a woman. The little boy is so cute

  • No Olivia? :/

  • Where The Hell Is Marvel Nd Olivia???!!!

  • what happened to claire? victoria? doing acid? i hope its later on in the movie, or ill be soo pissed

  • i am not understanding this movie.......

    the scenes are cut ?????

  • did astrid and ray sleep together

  • @allisonromine In the movie it's hinted that they slept together. Luckily I read the novel. In the novel it's more explicit and their love affair is described in graphic detail. Ray was definitely attracted to Astrid. But Astrid was the one who seduced him and they both secretly begin a brief but obsessive love affair in secret right under Star's nose. Star shoots her in the novel just like she does in the movie but in the novel she doesn't get away with it and gets arrested and convicted.

  • @jadedlovely818 did star end up in the same prison as astrids mom? and did her mom kill her in the novel?

  • @DecaPierce Err no. After Star is apprehended by police we never hear about her again. The only reason she gets caught is because she visits Astrid in the hospital out of remorse. But they were able to recognize her (she was in disguise)

  • @jadedlovely818 thats cool

  • @jadedlovely818 Sick..Astrid, but I still see a mestup girl in the big world. No fatherfigure. Not seeing clear between. I recognzed that due to growing divorce number I noticed Stephfather and fosterfather do sexual molested, kill a young girl in real time to often, and so to they do young boys.

    Pay attention and you will see.

  • It's Sookie!

  • holy shit she shot her...

  • heh, that guy is from the movie Almost Famous!!

  • why did she cut her hair?

  • Why did she shoot Astrid?

  • @britneyrihanna101 because she suspected an affair with Ray and Asterid, which there was

  • @veexxxronica Oh, I figured that out after I read the book lol..xD

    Thanks anyways (:

  • @britneyrihanna101 you're welcome

  • I wish I had Astrid's strength.

  • did astrid sleep with ray?

  • If I were Astrid, I would have been wanting get out of that situation since I would have been afraid of Star and I would have had the creeps around Uncle Ray. Other than Davey, I would have been glad to get away.

  • If I were Astrid, I would have been wanting get out of that situation since I would have been afraid of Star

  • Hollywood film about adoption-real appropriate 4 the case of least 2/3 stars from LA.Skinny,superficial,extravag­ant,full of themselves,drugs,free love...Even VanGogh never called himself an "Artist" in public,but a woman that made some polaroid installation foto's is already proud of the self-attached label.Illya Kabakov(installation guru)after reaching recognition once said 2b happy not 2b called anymore an artist(worked all his life as an illustrator 4 school books in Soviet Russia).

  • A question, but did the movie imply that Ray and Astrid had sexual relations? Because we don't really see them doing anything other than eyefuck each other, and that one instance when Ray touched her face.

  • @mundanelifeof oh yes. they did, A LOT, in the book it's incredibly graphic. They cut way too much out of this movie, but I guess it was for sake of keeping the film under two hours.

  • @mundanelifeof Well, what do you expect...it's a movie...would you really want to see an older man have sex with a minor.  If yes, then why???? That's just gross.

  • When I first saw this movie I was so sad that Astrid got shot. Now that I've learned she was doing uncle ray. I think it's funny that Star shot her. LOL!

  • Haha, Paul's so cute :] He looks familiar though, doesn't he play in some current TV show?

  • this is different from the book...as usual...

  • Well, she was screwing Starr's boyfriend.

  • @hjb103055 I think she was on the movie but they didn't show it but they hinted it.

  • i´m sorry my english is not so well, is  there something going on with astrid and unkle ray??

  • @MsBazouka yeah but the movie isn't really descriptive so you can't tell. If you read the book you'd know, it's more detailed and more explained. You should totally read the book, it's really really good. :)

  • Isn't he the guy from Almost Famous?

  • @omgilikejelly yes, Patrick Fugit. He's wonderful :)

  • Poor girl. She's so beautiful too...and talented. So sad that shit like this has to happen because some shit-head people can't get their act together.

  • I love this movie, but never read the book. Can someone tell me what the glass of milk with the flowers means?

  • @jessikagurl101 The flowers are mentioned in the movie, the are poisonous. "Beautiful and deadly" like her mother. Astrid's Mom was leaching the poison into milk. She also boiled it down and painted poison around Barry's house mixed with the chemical from Mexico that increased the body's tendancy to absorb them - Barry dies of poisoning.

  • why did she go to his work place and ask if everyone is gone?

  • poor astrid

    it probly broke her heart to leave those boys shereaaly loved em like brothers

  • poor davey

  • poor astrid. :(

  • I can't believe she was so mean to Patrick Fugit, he's so cute.. But I guess it's because he's not a hick in his mid 30's

  • awwwwwh.

    'thats easy for you to say, youve never been ugly' <3

  • she cuts her own hair well!

    Lol!

  • patrick fugit is awesome

  • The scene where Astrid cuts her hair... Idk why but I can still remember how strong the impression it had on me was XD

  • That guy with the long hair seemed so ugly at first, but when he was talking to her he seemed so......cute...XD

  • soo where did they have sex? in a half built house? lol

  • @smiggle185 stop, you're sick and an ass.

  • @smiggle185 in the book they do

  • @smiggle185 if dat ain raunchy

  • In the book, "Uncle Ray" was in his fifties, and Astrid was only 13. She is about 16 in this movie, and Ray is obviously a lot younger. I guess the old man-little girl thing was too scandalous for Hollywood

  • @shellecat89 nothing's too scandalous for hollywood

  • @bbiancass good point. Maybe it was just too scandalous for this particular director.

  • @shellecat89 no, you're right, it was too scandalous. just think about lolita. it's annoying really

  • @shellecat89 she was 14 not 13

    the author didn't make it THAT scandelous

    they should have stuck to the book more

  • HEY GUYS NOTICE IT DOES NOT SHOW THE PART WERE SHE SUKS THE FAT MANS BALLS ON THE BOOK

  • Wow, what an amazing character.

  • @WitheringChild which one?

  • does anyone know the music playing at 3:28?

  • she is 23, playing a 15 yo...

    but damn she's cute

  • I rarely get into movies but damn this movie makes me emotional. Every time.

  • thanks for uploading! <3 :D

  • sookie!

  • Fuck Starr. I highly prefer Ingrid over her. My own mother is very, very similar to Ingrid, in more ways than one, perhaps that is why. Having a parent in jail or prison is a horrible thing, especially when you rely on each other like they did. First hand experience.

  • she is commited to her job to do that to her hair. wow. still beautiful tho.

  • ok she knows what she is doing ,what a stupid girl..but the man should have been decent and let her be..

  • i think that astrid is still beautiful with short hair, its very natalie portman :)

  • I feel so sorry for Davey And it's sad that Ingrid raised Astrid w/o any morals b/c no matter how flawed Starr was she was trying to make a decent home for her children and the foster kids and Astrid swore on a Bible that she wasn't interested in Ray and then slept w/him anyway To me that is very wrong She was causing all kinds of turmoil in that family. But I don't blame Astrid completely she was a victim of her mother's rearing and Ray was a grown man he should of stayed away from a kid

  • @TheBetsy78 She was 13...no father, mom in jail for murder, thrust into a foster family. Starr was telling her to think one way, her mom was telling her to think another way, she was probably very confused. Although the character who plays him is hot, he should know better than to bone a 13 year old girl.

  • 8.30 Puta means hooker in Spanish

  • When did the boy hurt his arm?

  • @stjxp it was a deleted scene in the movie, it was supposed to happen around when Starr's daughter left, Starr beat him and twisted his wrist

  • @Deathscythe210 actually it was that she dislocated his sholder *re-watched it*

  • patrik should cut his haiir

  • astrid kicked that girl's ass go girl :) its always the quiet ones........

  • Oh! at 6:37, that guy was in Saved! No wonder he looked familiar.

  • @ReelSwedishFish Patrick Fugit! <3 I love him! he is awesome lol

  • Great foster mom with a gun

  • so they have sex but they're not really showing it in the movie

  • she also got shot in the hip, they left out the cane and going to the house with the fat woman who sells mary kay

  • in the book she also fired alot more shots than just one... they seem to have left out alot. and the Oleanders in Barrys house, it doesn't show how scared he was or anything

  • whatever happened to her......ive heard of few films. She is much better than some of the crap young actresses around these days.

  • @gobsmack10 Are you talking about Allison? I know you posted this awhile ago, but she is in a great movie called Drag me to hell

  • this movie is good so far, but they shouldve insenuated the had sex a littleeeeeeeee better. If i hadnt read the book i would've been lost

  • @cobraacademylove they probs would have had serious rating problems with the whole underage thing. There's also only so much the actress is allowed to portray i think.

  • @cobraacademylove i think that books are ment for that and in movies of course they will leave it to our imagination and also it forces people that didnt read the book wondering, in all movies that was based on a book its always going to be like that, it cant exactly be told from book but yeah this was pretty well made i enjoyed this film

  • @RaptorLuv well said.....absolutely

  • Hi Sookie

  • i think astrid looks beauiful with short hair. :)

  • I think so too..

  • astrid is the most beautiful girl i have ever seen

  • patrick fugit is so hotttt

  • i love his personality.. so sweet, gentle, caring :) thats what makes him hot i rekon :)

  • in the book star trys to show up at the hospital to finish her off but plain clothes cops stop her.

  • they shoul have made a sex scene, u can barely understand they had sex! .

  • geez, poor astrid :(

  • i love paul!

  • me too! he's such a cutie :D

  • Comment removed

  • im sorry but what idiot takes that long to jump out a window if there life depends on it?