Every song she sang during the show fits Eponine :) I'm sure she knew Cameron was working on Les Mis lol it wasn't auditioning for Nancy it was auditioning for Cameron and Andrew's work!
I thought she acted this really well, much better than Siobhan in HDYSAPLM. I completely got the emotion from her. I don't think the song choice is enough a of a show-stopper for the final though.
How did she not win??? Seriously. and what was with that Singing in the rain ong choice for her an dHarry. There was no connection, and that had nothing to to do with her. The song choice was just dreadful I blame who ever chose that song. It shouldn't have been judged on the same level as the songs from the other two.
Sam should have won. everytime she opened her mouth and sung it made me cry. No one has ever done that before.
Can't believe she didn't win... she was def the best one in the final!!! Especially for being so young! The girl who won can't even sing that good, she makes me so angry!
Check out John Vooijs with this song in the dutch tv-show, in search of Joseph (Op zoek naar Joseph, John, Anyone who had a heart) It's amazing, way more heartbreaking..
She was deffo the Siobhan of this comp, as in they were both gorgeous and known for that rather than their brilliant voices. John also described them both as "dead behind the eyes" lol.
Yeah, this sits in Samantha's range better, she is a Mezzo I would say and where Siobhan was a soprano, it was too on the low side, sounding quite screechy and muffled. Samantha's a fantastic Sally Bowles.
This brought me out in goosebumps. The song naturally brings tears to my eyes and Sam carries this off beautifully. It isn't my favourite, I prefered her singing Defying Gravity but this is still an amazing performance.
Trully emotional performence! And her vioce is just different from both Jessie's and Jodie's. But just as good.
I think she'd be suited to a role where the songs are mostly happy and cheerfull and emotional though. Like Maria in the sound of music.. I think that she'd be good at that. I'm not sure if her vioce is suitable for Nancy. But it's just my oppinion
For me... Sam is Nancy! No way I'm going to watch Jodie play Nancy! Sam will definitley have a successful career and I can't wait to get hold of her album soon as it's released! She's got a voice that I could play on my ipod over and over and over again! Luv ya Sam!
When Samantha Started Singing This Song, I Was Like, Hey, Siobhan Sang This!! Siobhan Got Kicked Out With This Song In The Finals, And So Did Sam. Anyone Think It Was A Fix Giving Her That Song??
I thought that too. And Sam and Siohan r both quite simular as in the way that they were both known as the beutiful Maria/Nancy and had the srongest voices.
that's because she is nice- she acted through a few agressive songs and people identified with that rather than the person behind the performance - a shy 17 year old.
When she said "The public believed in me before I believed in myself" and "I can go out there and be me" it made me cry! I know it's stupid but yeah :)
Loved this performance...But does anyone remember when Siobhan sang it for HDYSAPLM? That was really good too! Both versions were so much better than the original!
This girl is super talented and certainly did this complex song justice. I don't agree that she performed it better than Cilla Black - rather I think she gave a very theatrical performance which was entirely appropriate. Lovely lovely performer. Hope she does well.
I found Samantha's performance very moving, she showed such dignity and graciousness in leaving the competition. If she can mature and develop so much in ten weeks what couldn't she achieve in six months? Good luck to Sam and all the girls.
If Jessie didn't win I wanted Sam to win because Jodie is too bubbly to play Jodie and just does not fit the criteria. My first choice was Jessie but this was a good performance. GBP are loony's!!! x
Actually, if you watch Jodie's acting missions, she can ditch the bubbly nature. She might not be able to get quite as much grit as Rachel, but she's still capable.
I know that and I wasn't intending to put that message across. i know she'll be a brilliant Nancy and probably worth watching but imo Jessie and possible sam fitted the criteria much better and would have been more Nancylike. Where did Rachel come in??
Rachel could dance well, her acting was by far the best, and she had an absolutely lovely voice. Maybe not as good as Jessie's, but she was incredibly well rounded and well above the normal.
I agree but I didn't like her personality and I don't think if she would really captivate the Nancyness on a WE stage playing Nancy, she would struggle. I cou;dn't warm to her throughout the whole competition.
Ok. I am a fan of all three girls and all three had their strengths and weaknesses. Sam was not the best singer. She was the best dancer. Despite my issues with Jessie, she was the best singer.
Exceptional performance. Possibly the best of the whole show. Suddenly I thought she could do it. What is wrong with the public...Jody? She shouldn't have been in the last 4 let alone the final.
she's nancy in Oliver right now
WelshDudette91 1 week ago
Best of luck to her in Hollywood!
oakyannas 3 weeks ago
i love her but her biggest area that she still needed to work on even before she did Eponine was her acting. She tends to play things very flat.
DarthxErik 1 month ago
She is absolutely stunning, I love her!
courtneyluvsglee 2 months ago
And to think that two years later she became Eponine...
ChloeMcLellan 2 months ago 5
How many of these Andrew Lloyd Weber shows have there been? I found
"over the Rainbow" by mistake since this is a BBC show that I don't get in America.
bobbollu 3 months ago
@bobbollu AS far as I know 4 for Maria, Joseph, Nancy & Oliver, and Over The Rainbow - I haven't yet seen Rainbow here in Australia yet.
suzij756 1 month ago
I love her reaction when Webber said he had to go with her and when he said she could be Nancy.
SexinessIsMine 9 months ago
Did she win the show!? :D
mbod92395 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mbod92395 No, she came in third.
linda12021 11 months ago
@mbod92395 no but shes in les mis. jodie won
megamerryn 10 months ago
She is so beautiful. Absolutely love her as Eponine.
MsMandaPanda101 11 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Go to your address bar, after the word YOU and before the word TUBE, type in "win" then press enter
Pifniii 1 year ago
oh she's so great (wonder if she has a boyfriend:P )
tom53332 1 year ago
@tom53332 She does. Nick Jonas is her boyfriend :)
TheJonasEmpire 1 year ago
@TheJonasEmpire Really? Is she still dating him?!?! :)
Hollstaa3xx 7 months ago
@Hollstaa3xx no, Nick is dating with Delta now
ncisgigfan 4 months ago
Every song she sang during the show fits Eponine :) I'm sure she knew Cameron was working on Les Mis lol it wasn't auditioning for Nancy it was auditioning for Cameron and Andrew's work!
thefiercefalcon 1 year ago 2
:/... x ehjpdijgifj.. xxxx
mileycyrusfan310 1 year ago
Comment removed
mileycyrusfan310 1 year ago
I thought she acted this really well, much better than Siobhan in HDYSAPLM. I completely got the emotion from her. I don't think the song choice is enough a of a show-stopper for the final though.
placeboeffect2004 1 year ago
i was disappointed Samantha didn't win....she is the most talented young woman in this competition.
tinnsell 1 year ago 3
I preferred Siobhan's (from Maria) voice in this song, but Sam is amazing
HKE4 1 year ago
What is the name of the song that she sing here?
faithtifa 1 year ago
i think that she was good but not 4 nancy
megamerryn 1 year ago
How did she not win??? Seriously. and what was with that Singing in the rain ong choice for her an dHarry. There was no connection, and that had nothing to to do with her. The song choice was just dreadful I blame who ever chose that song. It shouldn't have been judged on the same level as the songs from the other two.
Sam should have won. everytime she opened her mouth and sung it made me cry. No one has ever done that before.
RoseT7100 1 year ago 8
wow i just started watching this and the lil excerpt of defying gravity gave me chills!!
mRino4 1 year ago
sam was the best, jodie shouldnt have won, either Sam Niamh or rachel
natz9996 2 years ago 5
I want to give you a thumbs down b/c Jodie is amazing and I want to give you a thumbs up b/c I think that Rachel should have won
notiachaos 2 years ago
i know right
purplecarrot123 2 years ago
This is so so so good!
emilyyboo 2 years ago
She lives near me on isle of man :)
xxxoneinamillionxx 2 years ago
Isle of Sam
LootzO 2 years ago
i live on the isle of man too ;P
kellysusannefirth 2 years ago
she is such a fantastic singer!! and seems like a lovely girl too and soo pretty! :)
sianybobs 2 years ago
I love Sam <3
Chenzellis 3 years ago 5
ME TOO, plus i love your Youtube name. =)
x
RaraTheGoodXx 2 years ago
Can't believe she didn't win... she was def the best one in the final!!! Especially for being so young! The girl who won can't even sing that good, she makes me so angry!
idinaBALLET 3 years ago 6
yeh i know, sam should have won, she was the best. i voted for her =(
purplecarrot123 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out John Vooijs with this song in the dutch tv-show, in search of Joseph (Op zoek naar Joseph, John, Anyone who had a heart) It's amazing, way more heartbreaking..
maritxx0210 3 years ago
ahahah agreed with the weird strap :P
but whats wrong with wearing high heels? lmao XD
strange.
pinkbananasmmoothie 3 years ago
She was deffo the Siobhan of this comp, as in they were both gorgeous and known for that rather than their brilliant voices. John also described them both as "dead behind the eyes" lol.
lucie777 3 years ago 3
@lucie777 and they both places 3rd.That's what I thought and Siobhan sang this song in the final 3 too!
ShannonGaGa 1 year ago
I'm going next Friday, a week after she starts in Birmingham, so excited!
MissiCharli 3 years ago 3
this is better than siobhan
peprilen 3 years ago 2
Yeah, this sits in Samantha's range better, she is a Mezzo I would say and where Siobhan was a soprano, it was too on the low side, sounding quite screechy and muffled. Samantha's a fantastic Sally Bowles.
scootyscoot4 3 years ago 2
This brought me out in goosebumps. The song naturally brings tears to my eyes and Sam carries this off beautifully. It isn't my favourite, I prefered her singing Defying Gravity but this is still an amazing performance.
RoseTylerxx 3 years ago 7
Wow. This Is making me cry. Wow samantha u would make a good nancy. i liked all three finalists
Rihannaiskool1 3 years ago 5
go girl
u r the best
sam should have won
ban88ana 3 years ago 6
high heels yet again
greengrass450 3 years ago 2
I loved this song but I hate that dress, it looks like she is wearing a handbag with that strap that goes over her chest........
anyone agree?
marenghiorgan 3 years ago
Ye, I agree. Tbh, they all had different voices and imo Jodie had the least Nancy like voice! It's weird how things turn out.
MissiCharli 3 years ago 2
Yeh, they all have different vioces. Trying to defend Samantha, here.
Obviously Jessie's vioce is different too.
I'd say wonderfully different. Probably my favourite. Nah definatly.
Rowan07001484 3 years ago
agreed. :)
xoloverlyxo 3 years ago
i think jessie has the most different voice, in a good way. :)
xoloverlyxo 3 years ago 5
Trully emotional performence! And her vioce is just different from both Jessie's and Jodie's. But just as good.
I think she'd be suited to a role where the songs are mostly happy and cheerfull and emotional though. Like Maria in the sound of music.. I think that she'd be good at that. I'm not sure if her vioce is suitable for Nancy. But it's just my oppinion
Rowan07001484 3 years ago
Aww..she is just soooo sweet.
The speech was really emotional *cries*
Yep 'xHiddenxx' it made me cry too.
You just gotta love Sam! :)
xxBarkateerKimxx 3 years ago
I love herrrr!!! She is so amazing. :-D
MyLifeIsAMusical 3 years ago
For me... Sam is Nancy! No way I'm going to watch Jodie play Nancy! Sam will definitley have a successful career and I can't wait to get hold of her album soon as it's released! She's got a voice that I could play on my ipod over and over and over again! Luv ya Sam!
cuteybear73 3 years ago 6
is it me, or does andrew lloyd webber look really p***ed off with this performance? i mean i love it, but he looks annoyed.
sockthing0610 3 years ago 4
sockthing0610, he was probably just gutted that it wasn't 'sexy' enough or something, haha.
xHiddenxx 3 years ago
She's so sweet and talented. Go for it Sam! I'm sure you will get a great role in the west end.
emmam16 3 years ago 2
When Samantha Started Singing This Song, I Was Like, Hey, Siobhan Sang This!! Siobhan Got Kicked Out With This Song In The Finals, And So Did Sam. Anyone Think It Was A Fix Giving Her That Song??
iblamelily 3 years ago 5
I thought that too. And Sam and Siohan r both quite simular as in the way that they were both known as the beutiful Maria/Nancy and had the srongest voices.
Jessyanna 3 years ago 3
i hated her but she seems nice in this :)
AleshaCrouch 3 years ago
that's because she is nice- she acted through a few agressive songs and people identified with that rather than the person behind the performance - a shy 17 year old.
sampayo101 3 years ago 3
When she said "The public believed in me before I believed in myself" and "I can go out there and be me" it made me cry! I know it's stupid but yeah :)
xHiddenxx 3 years ago 31
its amazing
jabba3051 3 years ago
Samantha had the best voice on the show! She deffenitly was the sexiest =] i really think she could TOTALLY fit Nancy
Elphieunderstudies 3 years ago
Loved this performance...But does anyone remember when Siobhan sang it for HDYSAPLM? That was really good too! Both versions were so much better than the original!
waliice 3 years ago 3
No offence but i think this version is better!!!
The standard is so much higher this year! This could havebeen Cilla black singing this and i wouldnt know the difference!
4eva4given 3 years ago
No offense taken! It is just different people's opinions. I just prefer sam's voice!
.x.x.
waliice 3 years ago 4
This gives me goosebumps everytime I watch it
DiaryOfADreamer 3 years ago 7
This girl is super talented and certainly did this complex song justice. I don't agree that she performed it better than Cilla Black - rather I think she gave a very theatrical performance which was entirely appropriate. Lovely lovely performer. Hope she does well.
Pinupip 3 years ago 25
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think she did not fit nacey
but i did not like her cuz she bobs her head up and down or side to side it dives me crazy
jessie should of won
Gahrez 3 years ago
I found Samantha's performance very moving, she showed such dignity and graciousness in leaving the competition. If she can mature and develop so much in ten weeks what couldn't she achieve in six months? Good luck to Sam and all the girls.
sampayo101 3 years ago 7
If Jessie didn't win I wanted Sam to win because Jodie is too bubbly to play Jodie and just does not fit the criteria. My first choice was Jessie but this was a good performance. GBP are loony's!!! x
MissiCharli 3 years ago 2
Actually, if you watch Jodie's acting missions, she can ditch the bubbly nature. She might not be able to get quite as much grit as Rachel, but she's still capable.
koriley 3 years ago
I know that and I wasn't intending to put that message across. i know she'll be a brilliant Nancy and probably worth watching but imo Jessie and possible sam fitted the criteria much better and would have been more Nancylike. Where did Rachel come in??
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Oh. I was just commenting that Rachel probably had the most grit of them all.
koriley 3 years ago 2
Oh right, ye i agree Rachel had the most grit but was probably lacking more in other areas. x
MissiCharli 3 years ago
Rachel could dance well, her acting was by far the best, and she had an absolutely lovely voice. Maybe not as good as Jessie's, but she was incredibly well rounded and well above the normal.
koriley 3 years ago
Yeah i thought rachel was probably the best acting, but i don't think she had as strong a voice as the others, but still a nice one
robynheartbroken 3 years ago
She didn't have as good a voice as Jessie but it was quite good.
koriley 3 years ago
I agree but I didn't like her personality and I don't think if she would really captivate the Nancyness on a WE stage playing Nancy, she would struggle. I cou;dn't warm to her throughout the whole competition.
MissiCharli 3 years ago
I don't know why. I warmed to her slowly. Although I don't think she's Nancy. She has aspects, as did Jessie, but I don't think either was Nancy.
koriley 3 years ago
i well wanted Sam to win. she was the best singer out of the three and had great stage presence.
robynheartbroken 3 years ago
Ok. I am a fan of all three girls and all three had their strengths and weaknesses. Sam was not the best singer. She was the best dancer. Despite my issues with Jessie, she was the best singer.
koriley 3 years ago
thought that this was an ace song
the best one of the night but i was expecting jodie to win and i was so glad when she did. :D
rachiebabies1993 3 years ago
didn't siobhan sing this song in the maria finals?
s065002 3 years ago
Exceptional performance. Possibly the best of the whole show. Suddenly I thought she could do it. What is wrong with the public...Jody? She shouldn't have been in the last 4 let alone the final.
graemecbet 3 years ago
i know. Samantha was much better
robynheartbroken 3 years ago
I really loved this, she really touched me with it.
07Hopeful 3 years ago 2
she did well with this song
spotlighted91 3 years ago 3
this gave me goosebumps
sockthing0610 3 years ago 2
Me Too!
BestFriendIsAPromise 3 years ago 2
I have to admit... I'm not the biggest Samantha fan.. but this is remarkable
beyondthestars1985 3 years ago 3
Are there going to be mp3s of these performances?
koriley 3 years ago
there better had be
they were absolutely BRILL
rachiebabies1993 3 years ago
love samantha, i think she is so talented.
kay2454350 3 years ago 3
she is very talented
jaromir 3 years ago