魏如昀 Smells Like Teen Spirit - 星光大道 第二季 20強 我的主打歌 20070907

[ilovehonglong]

牛嚼牡丹,聲線怎美亦徒然

[sws123123]

ON 9

[j789456123000]

好想念 Nirvana!!!!

[TheSlashHuang]

................

[kazaf9316]

好聽是好聽..但我接受不了...

[grez14]

i bet she lived in eeuu whe she was litle

[90452968]

痴撚線



[Kurt0316]

我暈了......

[st502007]

歌詞的意境真的對不上...

但是真的還滿好聽的(如果不知道歌詞的意思的話)

還是 Kurt 原版的最能表達這首歌~



[f1279101]

@st502007

完全對不上阿

只會覺得他在幹麻

[wangzaii]

Well i think it's nice. To each his/her own, i think. Anyway i forgot who claimed this but Kurt DID NOT write this song bcos his gf died u bloke. He wrote it bcos his friend sprayed "Kurt Smells Like Teen Spirit" on a wall. Teen Spirit was a brand of Deodorant his then gf was using at that time, ok? Bledy hell

[jason7952]

Kurt 哭了

[v84454243]

真的很噁心,很矯情 我要把早上吃的豬肉蛋堡吐出來了

令人反胃><

[tzcoba01]

不插電就算了

還搞流行樂版本

難聽死了

[englishtp65p4]

聽了有點不舒服 感覺應該更....MAN更強悍一點

上廁所的時候在聽 差一點便秘= =

但是就歌上 感覺還是不錯的拉~~~

[francex10]

fuck

[kerry80928]

整個不知道要說什麼

kurt cobain是在愛人離去

整個憤恨還有面臨精神崩潰下寫出這首歌的

把它唱成這樣整個變了調.........滿分20的話我給10­分吧

[psychomunnity88]

its not her style, she copied tori amos, poseur

[yuichi0083]

良いカバー

[evergreendream]

@andrewpsych5

maybe she did...LOLZ

[scott01113]

她是在做自己的表演

不是模仿Nirvana的表演

我兩種版本都很喜歡阿

[sk992085]

我不覺得值20分..

15分吧

[nkpytelzhor]

@andrewpsych5 wow, really, btu she is right, nirvana was a good shit

[tom820428]

雖然一般對Smells Like Teen Spirit的的既定印象是頹廢、憤怒

但我想，她把音樂換成不一樣的方式去詮釋，也有不錯的感覺

整體氛圍還蠻好的，而且她的聲音令人十分舒服。雖然我不是

Nirvana的歌迷，但我覺得管他能不能改成怎樣，爽就好嘛！­

[apeguy66]

asian women are so beautiful

[westlife1000]

she suck at this song

[jack15876]

這種歌就是要頹廢....哪來狗屁抒情

[thefutureA]

Hmmm Interesting Take i suppose. I can respect it.

[shadowmoonx]

its a diffrent take on the song, i think i like it

[loveisle78]

不好聽，這是我最直接的感受

[MrMountainshore]

Well to be honest I looove Wei Ru Yun (A.K.A. Queen) 's songs, and I think she sings beautifully, but she's not very good at covering other people's stuff. Dunno, maybe it's not original enough.

Well then I again I'm a big fan of Tori so I might be a bit biassed with that :P

And somebody said she's like Onitsuka Chihiro but I think they're completely different in a good way.

[MissD520]

對阿=  = 這是Tori Amos的版本吧= =

不過如果要唱這版本的話幹麻講Nirvana阿= = 害我以為是搖滾= =

[RaigonGaki]

想到鬼束。

[kanekane28]

More like "Smells Like Teen Crotch".

[lia19920630]

這是Tori Amos自己改成抒情版。

要罵就去罵 Amos 而不是 魏XX。

我也不是說聽抒情版聽得很習慣，但要罵對人好嗎? 台灣病了? 自己見識淺薄吧?

[stonecold978]

what the............

[9sweet]

OMFG.....she just ruin the song with that sticky rythm....

[v84454243]

我看傻...Nirvana...kurt被他糟蹋成這樣..

台灣樂壇 模仿 改編 翻唱就罷

為何要選超脫?

唱就算了,還唱這麼爛,這首歌,妳根本無法表達出,超脫想表達的­東西,我覺得非常離譜 台灣病了

[07241128]

這歌並不是她改的.是她學Tori Amos 的改法.Tori Amos 又是改Nirvana的.....

[AmemiyaRX8]

WTF.....

[bemyself146]

最前面的歌词唱错了！！！

[lonelyran]

她唱的應該是用鬼束千尋的方式吧？整體來說類似度非常非常的高。­

[jamesPerez1980]

i was waiting for her to drop that beat and scream. but sadly she never did and kept the whole song slow. i wouldve really enjoyed a female asian rock kirk's song.

[allaroundtheword]

不論如何我還是支持nirvana

畢竟這首歌kurt唱還是有另依翻風味

[skullker405]

魏如昀頻道文音 黃美珍 賴銘偉 魏如昀 曾沛慈 葉瑋庭 李千娜 林宜融 林道遠 辛巴 戴安娜 吳忠明 李繶蒨 林佩瑤 吳兆 丁衣凡 安欽雲 賴聖偉 劉軒蓁 方志友 巴冷 巴冷公主

[penguinla]

i don't like her treatment of this song...it's not exactly teen spirit

[lesity]

她的聲音其實比較適合唱電子多于搖滾

[kamyuir]

good..

[lu7215883]

..... 他最好是因為沒人懂這首歌,這麼簡單才死!!! 對nirvana有多了解?? 一定比你了解...= = 第二:我沒特別討厭他...@@ 我倒是覺得他nobody's home唱的很好 但是..我還是覺得他這樣唱很不好 想一想,假如說事你剛剛說的那樣,沒人懂這歌,他才死的話...­那她怎麼還唱成這樣... 我們聽的應該不太同領域@@ 我專聽punk 這樣@@

[lu7215883]

看歌詞也知道,這是首憤怒,而且帶有暴力言詞

什麼?

每首唱成抒情是怎樣?

kurt看到一定抓狂!!!

那個幫魏xx讚聲的人阿!!

去解一下nirvana還有kurt好不好!!

重點!!這首曲風最好是搖滾啦!!

是grunge(油漬)好不好!!

他是在唱情歌喔?

[henry5252515]

冏 不是只有rock n roll才是搖滾 punk grunge shoegazing等等其實說到底都是不同型態的搖滾 然後同樣的感情可以用不同方式表達 因為基本上魏如昀不可能唱的出kurt的聲音 所以就選了tori amos的版本 感情也有表達出來 真的算是不錯了 重點 魏如昀在聽的音樂的範圍沒比你廣也絕對是跟你差不多水平 kurt就是因為沒人了解他的歌詞才自殺 你又能多了解nirvana

[vincent200455]

kurt寫這smells like teen spirit是為了諷刺那些專聽主流"商業"音樂的人

而且kurt大部分nevermind的歌詞都是最後五分鐘才寫­的..

他自殺跟沒人了解他歌詞沒關係好不好

他以前還曾說過別人太注重他歌詞裡面的意思了..

而且也有一說他不是自殺的...

-.-

[henry5252515]

kurt自成名以後就活在反商業但是Grunge又流行起來 Nirvana唱片賣的爆好的這種矛盾

當然他自殺很多因素 包括他毒癮 精神問題等等

不過一般是認為大眾對他的誤解 不管是歌詞還是人格 扮演了蠻大的角色

他殺那個因為一直也沒查出來

大家也只好相信自己想要相信的

囧

[vincent200455]

基本上只要是Nirvana 的Fans

都是站在kurt被courtney love殺死的那一邊吧= =

不過在youtube看到他nevermind之前的video­都玩得很high...所以他之前也是有快樂過吧XD

這是Kurt生平的總整理嗎...-.-

[lawchihei]

Kurt Cobain appreciated the cover of Tori Amos and said the cover was "a great breakfast cereal version"

[MrMountainshore]

@lawchihei Well, who knows he might have been criticizing it in a different way.

[kakkakakaksnsnnn3eoe]

自己喜歡把歌唱的怎樣是他的事

把搖滾唱成抒情還唱的這麼好已經很棒了

世界總要一些新鮮的事

不是一昧的古板

魏如昀不落窠臼別出心裁的唱

請你們閉嘴

魏如昀好棒!!!!!!!!!!

[sevenmonkeys]

a very strange arrangement, kind of awful I have to say...

[airows123]

WHAT THE FUCK

[morrisontseng]

慘慘慘........4/5 kurt 自殺15周年的今天看到........真的超生氣......­......

[willie70440]

不算多芭樂八

很有他的個性風格  算他自己的風格八

[stevenkuo22]

非常贊同這首歌不該改成抒情曲調 太芭樂了 nirvana的忠實樂迷聽了大概八成不能認同

[SiomioneiSushi]

Queen is so cool~ She is so unique, I love this cover.

[MJBou]

This is Tori Amos version.

[eforblue1]

I dont think other people here notice that....

Tori Amos version was such a great cover

[jane199141]

no rock ,no good,so bad

[rogerex2003]

Nirvana這首歌不應該改成這樣~!!

[mimomichelle]

she sings the second line wrong..."It's fun to lose and to pretend she sang "It's always been until the end"or something...tho this song rly doesnt suit her style

[vincent200455]

wheres the screaming lol..

[dumbglasses]

I think Kurt Cobain just died again in his grave.

[miao94]

The album she design is so nice :]

[kusonana]

好想念Queen!!

[lij1990]

she is a really unique and good singer!!

my favourite one in this singing competition!!

[acctgeek1]

except Tori Amos didn't murder the song

queen is such a wannabe

even her new t shirt design ripped off margiela

[mi036]

i like it when she sings English,, its better than chinese

[evilturtles]

whys she singing an english song when shes in an asian country where everysingle person speaks whatever asain language that they speak? good job anyway..

[forever333]

i luv her style!! shes my favorite in this season!! she did awesome in this song, ive been hearing it over and over again!!

[smallwheat]

好利害！！！

超喜歡的！！！

[luisme719]

It's sooooooo enjoying listening to her songs!!! Her style is sooo unique... I will definitely buy her CDs if she release one.... By the way... i think her english improved quite a lot! No accent and no subtle pronounciation, very splendid.

[witnesso]

i like her style...really soft...

[rosemars8]

She is quite unique.........although not with the best voice nor skill, she still made her performance attractive.

[arevl]

Very Good! :) She already looks like 3/2 a star...