Первая группа (42 000 чел.) прошла за 2 часа 25 минут по Ленинградскому шоссе и улице Горького (ныне Тверской) к площади Маяковского, затем по часовой стрелке по Садовому кольцу до Курского вокзала. Среди этой группы были 1227 пленных с офицерскими и генеральскими званиями, в том числе 19 генералов, шедших в оставленных им орденах и форме, 6 полковников и подполковников.
@Nikitns read a book dumbass any book on Stalingrad do the simple math...98,000 prisoners, only around 5,000 ever came home ....some not for 15 years...
@birdmanofbooze Stop wasting my time, out of those 98000 prisoners all but the officers and higher ups were starved and frozen. They wouldn't have survived if they were captured by Russians, British or Japanese.
The rate of dead German POW in Soviet hands was 16-18%. The rate of Soviet POW dead at the hands of Germans is close to 75%. Also, Germans (Wehrmacht too) killed ~15 million Soviet civilians. Soviets killed ~0.6 million German civilians.
Go figure who was a bitch here, exactly these gentlemen marching here.
About Stalin's purges, first it was internal to USSR, they didn't go rampaging and killing every nation they dislike, second, the purges amounted to ~1.5 million dead.
Both were wrong nazi soviet...but I still have a hard time with the german mindset of how a country that is christian like Germany had such a low self esteeem of itself it would promote a evil nationalistic dictator like Hitler and feel they are supiorer to other human beings ....just makes me wonder at all times.
poor bastards. i know they are the enemy but they fight for their country just like any other nation did during ww2 they did not deserve a dead in siberia
PS: not al the germans fighting in ww2 where nazi's
Fuck you. The wermacht worked in complicity with the ss on the eastern front and were responsible for deaths of 20 million Russian women and children. I can provide german sources to verify this . All you cocksuckers that feel sorry for germans and nazis can fuck right off and go blow your brains out. My Grandfather fought those rapists and gangsters. Look up what Lebenstarum means. Thats the policy that germany marched in with into Russia. Eternal glory to the Heroes of the Motherland
What is the matter with you. Look at what germany did to Belgium in 2 world wars. Are you retarded or are you a nazi ? What does Russia's internal policies have to do with Giving Germany justification for murdering and raping 20 million Russian women and children? Nothing at all. Belgium should hold its head in shame for not fighting the nazis in the Great Patriotic War -Shame on Belgium !
@VisionarysDomain belgium did fight the nazi's commie but we had a to small and to weak army to fight against a country that hold the world for 6 years in terror when belgium was defeated the survivors en volunteers joined the army of great britain and helpt defaeting the germans also belgium had a resistance movement that sabotagd alot of german infrastructure like the partizans did
Okay so why do you belittle the heroism of the Russian people for beating up the nazis. Just because you disagree with Russian internal politics at the time that is no excuse for germany to go in and kill . murder and rape millions of people. Even that fat nazi german cHANCELLOR bitch mERKEL ADMITTED THAT Germany killed 60 million Europeans in ww2. The germans are crazy bastards. They think they are the Master race and believe even to this day they are superior to everyone else.
Some Americans. I can tell you since I spend half of my time here in America, many Americans are suffering because of 5the retarded poicies of Bush. The economy is a mess and Belgium has a better credit rating than America right now. I never thought that this would ever happen to a country like America. But remember, America gave lots of monet to Germany after the war to rebuild new industries and now Germany does not want to help its European member countries when its economy is strong
@VisionarysDomain I have no idea what the germans have pay back from this money what america with the marshall plan have give in the 60´s-70´s-80´s-90´s and still now ? The 30-the 40-the 50-the 60 or more ??
@VisionarysDomain You have to be one of the most ignorant Liberal college educated idiots I've ever seen here. Eternal glory to heroes of the MOTHERLAND? Stalins Ghouls who enslaved Eastern Europe for 60 years, and made Hitlers henchmen look like choirboys? You suck as a human and suck even worse as a spokeman for the Commies.
Actually the Red Army performance during the WW2 was very, very poor. Their air force was also amazingly uneffective comparing to western allies and Luftwaffe. If i was a russian i won't hype the army loosing 14,7 million soldiers died and with loss rate of 1:4 or 1:5. Actually I would be more likely shame on such a crap, shabby and stinking army.
Superb !!!!! Excellent shout from Uncle Joe Stalin and his Red Army for putting on such a great exhibition of captured German Hitlerite European Unionists. Are you watching AnGela Merkel ???!!!! :-)
@LottoWinner999 Never said the germans had thwe right, however you are quite the apologist for Stalin and his murderous regime...You are as bad as the Nazis, maybe worse...
@LottoWinner999 Tell us how many people Stalin killed.. Let's just start with the purging of his own army, murdering all the officers, then move to Poland...Waiting?
@LottoWinner999 Never made apologies for the nazis...Historically though they certainly killed less people than your demented hero Stalin. Calling regular german troops nazis is very telling of your ignorant head stuck so far up your Commie ass. When are yopu leaving for Russia? You stupid son of a bitch, you know that great place that has contributed so much to freedom...
@LottoWinner999 hey ignorant Stalin lover..Just because you spent your welfare check on lottery tickets, it doesn't make you a history expert. take your sorry Russian loving ass back to Moscow. Where you can be proud of The millions Stalin enslaved for 60 years. Your revionist history speaks volumes about your lack of education. Fuck off Ruskie
How about the thousands of Russian POWs killed by Stalin? After liberated , Stalin killed them for being captured or surrendering..He was a stinking pig.......
More than a Million Soviet POW's survived Nazi Concentration Camps, and did not collaborate with the enemy. They were first freed, and then sent to "Filtration" Camps in USSR, yes they were detained here for months, but majority were soon released after it was determined they were not going to be a threat to national security.
Collaborators, that is those non-Axis citizens who had helped the enemy during the war, were not released. Collaboration was considered a crime by most countries who were occupied by the Axis. In France former WW1 hero and later traitor Philippe Petain was to be executed for treason(he was not because he was already elderly). Many collaborators were executed by partisans/guerillas/resistance, including in USSR.
In Russia/USSR Andrei Vlasov and Petr Krasnov(both Generals) are what Petain and Laval were to France, they collaborated with the Nazis and helped kill their own countrymen, those who served under their command were and should be considered traitors. And these were the ones who were executed or imprisoned for more than a decade. Not all of them died.
@SiggyStern I agree with you. The Russians suffered terribly due to the German army. They fought valiantly against them. How can you make fun of human misery. I wish u could go back in time and spend time in a camp. Sicko
Victory - it is when your army has its victorious flag on the roof of the highest building of the capital of the enemy country.
And it doesn't matter how much it costs.
Even if you have less casualties, if your disarmed generals are walked down the streets of the capital of you adversary as cattle - it's a humiliating defeat.
all your talk about nazi pagan pigs! who lost the fucking war? who got there asses beat? they deserved to perish. they got a taste of their own medicine from the enemy, (INHUMANITY).
@gjay700 you must be so smart..the smartest man in the usa... never seen eu and so smart... too much movies retard!! WERMACHT!!!! is in this video not Wafenn SS...if you know the difrence... stupid jenki!! first learn history..then comment!!
Better die on you feet that to live on your knees. Whel that goes for the red army. american army and nazi army and who ever is taking prisoner during the war. I would bite scratsh Kick hit what evcer i had. Everything is better that working in the cold waiting for my weenee to freese bewteen mah legs. And i know how cold it is in russia in the winter. The netherlands is Just Hole compared with russia. Russian people know the understanding of cold weather i guess. hehe
I would rather die fighting rather than surrender to the Bolshevik scum.
Anyway every German soldier was much more efficient than Soviet, Germany had 10 million soldiers throughout the war, and fought against 29 million Russians wimps, 4.6 million English. I do not know the number of Americans who fought in Europe, but I know that in total amounted to 16 million.
yeh and all what i see reminds me of german politics motto "drang nach osten" .. now they get what they wanted and marching to the east, but not as winners :D
Yes, you are right! Germans put a lot of Soviet POWs to concentation camps. They were treated very badly. On 27th January 2010 in former German Concentration Camp Auschwitz Russian minister of science opened a new exhibition about Russian people who were improsoned there. Next week I'm going there to see it.
You're totally right - unfortunately,THE VERY FIRST EXHIBITION ON SOVIET POWs killed in Auschwitz concentration camp was opened ONLY IN JANUARY 2010.
Before that they had been talking only about Jews who were killed there,but almost nobody knows that the first people killed by gas were Soviet POWs - that's how the system had been tested and only after it they began to gas Jewish people.
The data on 146,000 Christian Poles is also kept away from international public making Jews the only victims
@Heightofhate Thank you for the information. I was wondering why it is a crime to even question the Holocaust in some European countries. Not only jews, gypsies, gays, mentally handicapped. I give thanks to all the allies who fought. They were brave souls.
@empressoffrance But even gypsies, homosexuals and mentally challenged get more international and political attention than the Slavic victims of the German Holocaust.
@Heightofhate I think the only ones that get attention are the Jewish race. The above are noted at the bottom of the pile and I feel everyone who died should get attention, irregardless of race, religion, nationality, etc. Anyhow it is over with now. I just thank the allies.
@empressoffrance In the words of the Israeli PM A. Sharon Oct 3/2007, the US says it will do this and do that, let me make this perfectly clear the US answers to Israel not the other way around and you know I believe it. You cannot get elected in the US unless u are pro Jewish. I am pro free ppl. Agreed they need to protect themselves but do they have to kill all those innocents? No justification whatsoever for their deeds. That is where the war will start again. No-one will write history
@Heightofhate I do not know why. Furthermore, even the above that you mentioned get very little attention, if any. The Holocaust gets a lot of attention.
@Heightofhate I have to agree with you. I do not deny the Holocaust happened to that extent no However, many other nationalities, including yours suffered at the hands of the Nazis. As u stated the Holocaust is kept in the limelight always and it will never be put to rest Personally, I am tired of hearing about it. Look at Zionist Israel and what they are doing to the Palestinian ppl creating a ghetto just like in Warsaw and killing them for no reason. Another war will start unless Isr stops
If the world had admitted Poles, Russians, Ukrainians, Belorussians etc. were the first to suffer under the German Holocaust and the Jewish Holocaust came later in 1942 after the Wannsee Conference where the "Final Solution" (Endloesung) was proclaimed the whole post-WWII history would have been different for the reason Jews wouldn't be able to state they are some special victim with special rights.
Anti-Slavic racism never really disappeared after the Cold War. Many Western Elites still consider people from Eastern Europe to be some kind of "sub-humans".
Is Stalingrad a german city? So the soviets just came to kill them and ruin the city, right? What about 40000 Stalingrad's civilians died by german bombings?
The prisoners of the battle were injured and nipped by excessive cold, Russian army had no chance to save them all. 5000 of them returned home, why they weren't killed like others?
As awful as it is that thousands were killed during the war, I don't equate it with what happened after the war........These German POWs were being worked to death until 1948.................
@msk0001 "... 5000 of them returned home, why they weren't killed like others"?
They had to send SOME home....pretty hard to justify sending no one back. Even the russians knew this. I am curious as to why they were sent back home so many years after the war?
But, let us not bullshit here....the Germans AND russians treated POW's poorly. Hitler AND stalin were both first rate assholes and it was THEIR policies that lead to mistreatment of prisoners on BOTH sides.
I think the strongest of those who became prisoners survived I do not think that they sent some few thousands home because they would not have been able to justify to send non home,considering how the German army had raged amongst millions of civilians, they would not have needed a cause for non to return,one of my grand uncles was one of those who returned,the average time in Russia for POW was 7 years knowing how the Russians were treated as POW,I am surprised he returned
Your grand ucles can survive after all their crimes. My grandfather was not return from the War. Don't need to say, that I must feel sorry for your grand uncles.
you did not understand me hyper, I understand what you are saying and I see it the same way but you misunderstand me,so I will reply to your PM´s.......I never said you should be sorry for my grand uncle, I feel very sorry for your people ,it was a horrendious crime that was committed against so many millions of civilians, don´t think I try to find excuses for the Nazis, I know what was done during that time and I will not forget it..
@msk0001 Ten years after the war they came home ...used as bargaining chips, after being used for slave labor...stop getting your info from Liberal history professors...
Thats what happens when you invade Russia you lose. Russia had a superior military force in comparison to the Germans, they survived the critical first 6 months of the eastern front which allowed the Russians to recruit a half a million soldiers each month, mass produce tanks, air craft, artillery pieces, machine guns, etc...
yep, all Hitlers generals knew that victory had to be reached within the first months in a surprise blitz krieg.. But the generals lost control of "operation barbarossa" to Hitler himself, a disaster.
One very important fact about Operation Bagration. When it started the Luftwaffe got only 40 serviceable fighters in Belo Russia, later little bit more. As most of historicians in Germany and west have noticed - it was airforces of western allies which opened the sky in east for Soviet Air Forces, because at the same time (june 1944) Luftwaffe got over 1200 fighters in Reich, over 500 in west and some 400 in Italy.
Yes, and german reserve tank divisions have gone to save hopeless situation in Belorussia, instead of turn alliens back to the sea in Normandie (there was then a small local operation in comparison with Belorussian). Take this too.
57.000 prisoners marched thru MOSCOW , nice , 70% of all GERMAN army was defeated in CCCP .. GERMAN generals warned HITLER not to go in CCCP , he did not listen ,, a lot of people here , Where was the video of 6th German amry prisoners , they said there were 600.000 priseonrs which were encirlced around Leningrad ..
It's silly to speak of German war atrocities on behalf of the Russians, when the Russians were at least as guilty. Placing POW's in parades is a violation of international law. So is using them for forced labor.
Talk about German war crimes all you want. But, NEVER do that from a Russian perspective... it's the height of raving hypocrisy.
One last thing.... German soldiers are no more "nazi soldiers" than Russian soldiers were "Bolshevik soldiers." They were just soldiers all.
No nation, save the Russians, would parade its handiwork of maltreated prisoners in front of the world for political purposes. I couldn't do it to a sick dog.
Germany lost 1.4 million of its soldiers who fell into Soviet hands during the course of the War, and who died before ever reaching registration stations to even leave a record of themselves... like they never existed.
Of 91,000 German prisoners from Stalingrad, half were dead within a month; 40,000 buried in a single mass grave.
But, we are not talking about a sick dog, we are talking about a different kind of animal--though comparing these Nazi fiends to animals is an insult to four legged creatures.
No we are discussing muderous ghouls that burned alive 10s of thousands of Soviet people in barns and churches across the steppes.
I'll save my sympathy for the soviet people murdered by these pigs, and the German civillians who were unfairly killed in retributtion.
Except a small number of volunteers, for most germans, romanians, hungarians, italians troops, the the east front was not an option. You have no right to judge them because you was not there!
How can people here praise the Soviet system of those days...
They were in many ways worse then the Nazi's (allready before there was any war).
The Soviets used their own people and soldiers just as worse as the Nazi's used them during the war.
Soviet PoW's who were "liberated" when the Germans were pushed back got the same threatment as captured enemy soldiers and many were singed as traitors and went straight from the German camps to the Russian Gulag camps, how nice is that?
This is just anti-soviet propaganda. Fucking rat Solzhenitsin faked it for CIA money and Nobel prize.
Less than 3% of ex-POWs were sent to Gulag (it wasn't prison, it was rustication). And everybody of them for really serious crimes. And most of them survived and got back to normal life. Renegades, nazi politsais, cowards and spies - most of them end up like respected Soviet citizens.
As they were marched through Moscow, the defeated Nazi barbarian criminals were followed by a brigade of large motorized street cleaners. Too bad this isn't shown in this video. Wonderful symbolism. I love Russia!
To wipe out all Slavonic states,especially Russia, from Rein to Ural Mountains. To enslave or just to slay most of Slavonik nations, especially Russians. No reading and writing, no education and culture for slaves... Those Nazies who survived never regreted about what they have done. Did they? I don't think so.
After taking some 85% casualties before surrendering at Stalingrad, Von Paulus' Sixth Army of about 600,000 men became POWs of the Soviets. About 5,000 made it back to Germany alive, some ten years later.
These POWs were doomed, they were sent to Siberia. Basically noone ever came back from there including these 57,000 germans. Please take in mind that most of these Germans were not Nazis as they were part of the Wehrmacht which
No, 99% of them were nazies. Those who collaborated with Russians usually were ignored and even killed by their Kameraden. Germans got what they were looking for. Wise people said hunderets of times: "Don't mess up with Russians".
When I see these images (and that of allied and soviet pows) it makes me think that we humans haven't evolved much more from 'caveman days'. The brutal comments on thi page confirms this. Am I really the only one here who sees just simply suffering human beings? No particular group (jew or otherwise) has ownership on suffering... but I think I waste my time posting this.
funny thing is this is still happening all over the world today...its not about evolution as long as men let greed and lust for power take over this will always be part of our world
Superior losers. The nazi leaders abandoned their soldiers and fled to South america like cowards. They should put these nazis to the same ovens that they themselves built and gas them!
17 миллионов мирных советских граждан были зверски убиты этими "несчастными людьми", которые за несколько лет до этого привели к власти Гитлера на совершенно свободных и демократических выборах.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Если бы в этом марше участвовали лишь старшие офицеры, тогда я поддержал бы его идею. Унижать рядовой и сержантский состав, а так же младших офицеров - свинство со стороны советского руководства.
Not every German was a "nazi" you idiots. They fought for their comrades. Just like not every U.S. soldier believes in the war in Iraq, but they do it it anyway because they are fighting for the guy next to them.
Artur Axman,the simple fact of Barbarossa is that the Germans invaded the Soviet Union and committed many atrocities unprovoked. And though the Russians in 1939 to 1945 and indeed beyond 1945, showed themselves to be very cruel one must take account of the well known proverb, "you reap what you sow."
If your going to conquer Europe at least do it with some sort of chivalry and elan like the French under Napoleon.
Hotel Siberia, numbers lux at their order.
Vanyaaynav 1 month ago
17th of July 1944,
watch?v=yBksub0DYRM&feature=related
kashakrus47 2 months ago
Первая группа (42 000 чел.) прошла за 2 часа 25 минут по Ленинградскому шоссе и улице Горького (ныне Тверской) к площади Маяковского, затем по часовой стрелке по Садовому кольцу до Курского вокзала. Среди этой группы были 1227 пленных с офицерскими и генеральскими званиями, в том числе 19 генералов, шедших в оставленных им орденах и форме, 6 полковников и подполковников.
kashakrus47 2 months ago
Germans finally occupied MOSCOW. Adolf Hitler dumb scum bag , but he had the balls no VISION.
aviomaster 2 months ago
where is the marsh? somewhere in louisiana? or florida? are there prisoners in those marshes?
WeekNightGaming 3 months ago
Did u know that from those 57 000 German pow`s only 6000 returned home....
The majority off them died marching trough siberia and later in Gulags ...
Learn a bit off history before u come on you tube and start commenting stupid things....
badboyauu 4 months ago
@badboyauu did you know that you're making shit up? deathrate of German prisoners was around 20%, not 90%.
Nikitns 3 months ago
@Nikitns read a book dumbass any book on Stalingrad do the simple math...98,000 prisoners, only around 5,000 ever came home ....some not for 15 years...
birdmanofbooze 2 months ago
@birdmanofbooze Stop wasting my time, out of those 98000 prisoners all but the officers and higher ups were starved and frozen. They wouldn't have survived if they were captured by Russians, British or Japanese.
Nikitns 2 months ago
@birdmanofbooze
The rate of dead German POW in Soviet hands was 16-18%. The rate of Soviet POW dead at the hands of Germans is close to 75%. Also, Germans (Wehrmacht too) killed ~15 million Soviet civilians. Soviets killed ~0.6 million German civilians.
Go figure who was a bitch here, exactly these gentlemen marching here.
About Stalin's purges, first it was internal to USSR, they didn't go rampaging and killing every nation they dislike, second, the purges amounted to ~1.5 million dead.
anaplastic 4 weeks ago
@badboyauu closer to 98,000 POWS tortured, starved, and worked to death in gulags etc..
birdmanofbooze 2 months ago
Yes this is just fun to watch these Nazies marching as losers!
RubenHogenhout 5 months ago
i killed many nazis
slyrader1 7 months ago
white people should NEVER kill each other !
battlestroke7 8 months ago
2,4 millions german pows were held as prisoners in Russia for years after the war.
"Gefangen im Kaukasus - 1/10 - Wehrmachtsoldaten erzählen ihre Geschichte"
tusenkunstneren2 9 months ago
Both were wrong nazi soviet...but I still have a hard time with the german mindset of how a country that is christian like Germany had such a low self esteeem of itself it would promote a evil nationalistic dictator like Hitler and feel they are supiorer to other human beings ....just makes me wonder at all times.
Dojocho 10 months ago
@Dojocho Proof that Christianity is the most fallible.
Wolferenful 7 months ago
poor bastards. i know they are the enemy but they fight for their country just like any other nation did during ww2 they did not deserve a dead in siberia
PS: not al the germans fighting in ww2 where nazi's
nowp1 10 months ago
@nowp1
Fuck you. The wermacht worked in complicity with the ss on the eastern front and were responsible for deaths of 20 million Russian women and children. I can provide german sources to verify this . All you cocksuckers that feel sorry for germans and nazis can fuck right off and go blow your brains out. My Grandfather fought those rapists and gangsters. Look up what Lebenstarum means. Thats the policy that germany marched in with into Russia. Eternal glory to the Heroes of the Motherland
VisionarysDomain 5 months ago
@VisionarysDomain stalin kild more than 20 milion of his own people. And so what russians enough
nowp1 5 months ago
@nowp1
What is the matter with you. Look at what germany did to Belgium in 2 world wars. Are you retarded or are you a nazi ? What does Russia's internal policies have to do with Giving Germany justification for murdering and raping 20 million Russian women and children? Nothing at all. Belgium should hold its head in shame for not fighting the nazis in the Great Patriotic War -Shame on Belgium !
VisionarysDomain 5 months ago
@VisionarysDomain belgium did fight the nazi's commie but we had a to small and to weak army to fight against a country that hold the world for 6 years in terror when belgium was defeated the survivors en volunteers joined the army of great britain and helpt defaeting the germans also belgium had a resistance movement that sabotagd alot of german infrastructure like the partizans did
nowp1 5 months ago
@nowp1
Okay so why do you belittle the heroism of the Russian people for beating up the nazis. Just because you disagree with Russian internal politics at the time that is no excuse for germany to go in and kill . murder and rape millions of people. Even that fat nazi german cHANCELLOR bitch mERKEL ADMITTED THAT Germany killed 60 million Europeans in ww2. The germans are crazy bastards. They think they are the Master race and believe even to this day they are superior to everyone else.
VisionarysDomain 5 months ago
@VisionarysDomain ik know many germans and they dont think that at all! only americans think so
nowp1 5 months ago
@nowp1
Some Americans. I can tell you since I spend half of my time here in America, many Americans are suffering because of 5the retarded poicies of Bush. The economy is a mess and Belgium has a better credit rating than America right now. I never thought that this would ever happen to a country like America. But remember, America gave lots of monet to Germany after the war to rebuild new industries and now Germany does not want to help its European member countries when its economy is strong
VisionarysDomain 5 months ago
@VisionarysDomain I have no idea what the germans have pay back from this money what america with the marshall plan have give in the 60´s-70´s-80´s-90´s and still now ? The 30-the 40-the 50-the 60 or more ??
finsterwald181167 4 months ago
@VisionarysDomain You have to be one of the most ignorant Liberal college educated idiots I've ever seen here. Eternal glory to heroes of the MOTHERLAND? Stalins Ghouls who enslaved Eastern Europe for 60 years, and made Hitlers henchmen look like choirboys? You suck as a human and suck even worse as a spokeman for the Commies.
birdmanofbooze 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Actually the Red Army performance during the WW2 was very, very poor. Their air force was also amazingly uneffective comparing to western allies and Luftwaffe. If i was a russian i won't hype the army loosing 14,7 million soldiers died and with loss rate of 1:4 or 1:5. Actually I would be more likely shame on such a crap, shabby and stinking army.
pelontorjunta 11 months ago
Comment removed
pelontorjunta 11 months ago
Didn't Hitler promised the german soldiers a parade in -Moscow? They got one in this clip.
SingleStar1 1 year ago 27
Superb !!!!! Excellent shout from Uncle Joe Stalin and his Red Army for putting on such a great exhibition of captured German Hitlerite European Unionists. Are you watching AnGela Merkel ???!!!! :-)
RedGoblinus 1 year ago
@RedGoblinus Of course it was filmed Communists. But where do you see the lie in these frames Explain to me.
Imprudentman 10 months ago
@Imprudentman As an earlier poster has rightly stated, the German Army got their parade in Moscow but minus their weapons.
RedGoblinus 10 months ago
@LottoWinner999 Never said the germans had thwe right, however you are quite the apologist for Stalin and his murderous regime...You are as bad as the Nazis, maybe worse...
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
@LottoWinner999 Tell us how many people Stalin killed.. Let's just start with the purging of his own army, murdering all the officers, then move to Poland...Waiting?
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
@LottoWinner999 Never made apologies for the nazis...Historically though they certainly killed less people than your demented hero Stalin. Calling regular german troops nazis is very telling of your ignorant head stuck so far up your Commie ass. When are yopu leaving for Russia? You stupid son of a bitch, you know that great place that has contributed so much to freedom...
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
@LottoWinner999 hey ignorant Stalin lover..Just because you spent your welfare check on lottery tickets, it doesn't make you a history expert. take your sorry Russian loving ass back to Moscow. Where you can be proud of The millions Stalin enslaved for 60 years. Your revionist history speaks volumes about your lack of education. Fuck off Ruskie
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
These Nazis was occupants of Belarus. In Belarus were killed 2 millions people. This was QUARTER of population of Belarus.
hyper1282 1 year ago
Most of all are going into the death
SchrottTube 1 year ago
@SchrottTube
Yes, it's death penalty for the murderers.
hyper1282 1 year ago
How about the thousands of Russian POWs killed by Stalin? After liberated , Stalin killed them for being captured or surrendering..He was a stinking pig.......
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
and 2 per cent of civilians and 15 per cent of the POWs (226,127 out of 1,539,475 total) transferred to the Gulag.
Only major traitors like Vlasov were really sentenced to death, but all his army survived and freed after Gulag.
msk0001 1 year ago 17
@msk0001
all his army or all what was left from them ... how many of them died there???
some camps had death rate more than 50% ..
klaabu99 1 year ago
What about Soviet POW's, have you known any?
More than a Million Soviet POW's survived Nazi Concentration Camps, and did not collaborate with the enemy. They were first freed, and then sent to "Filtration" Camps in USSR, yes they were detained here for months, but majority were soon released after it was determined they were not going to be a threat to national security.
Maloross 1 year ago
Collaborators, that is those non-Axis citizens who had helped the enemy during the war, were not released. Collaboration was considered a crime by most countries who were occupied by the Axis. In France former WW1 hero and later traitor Philippe Petain was to be executed for treason(he was not because he was already elderly). Many collaborators were executed by partisans/guerillas/resistance, including in USSR.
Maloross 1 year ago
In Russia/USSR Andrei Vlasov and Petr Krasnov(both Generals) are what Petain and Laval were to France, they collaborated with the Nazis and helped kill their own countrymen, those who served under their command were and should be considered traitors. And these were the ones who were executed or imprisoned for more than a decade. Not all of them died.
Maloross 1 year ago
@birdmanofbooze very true
unclemort1960 2 months ago
Just imagine to first spend 6 years in war and after that 10 years in russian POW camp.. That's a long time to be away from home
pyllywaltteri 1 year ago
hahaha russian lost 27 million people in ww2, and they think that is victory??
what happened with 3.5 million of russian pow in german hands???!
erdutos 1 year ago
erdutos,
you know what happened to them,is this something to make fun about??? I think not!!!
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern I agree with you. The Russians suffered terribly due to the German army. They fought valiantly against them. How can you make fun of human misery. I wish u could go back in time and spend time in a camp. Sicko
empressoffrance 1 year ago
About 3 million it is losses of Red army. The others of 24 million are victims of civilians of the USSR from occupation.
BoyFromHell1000 1 year ago
Victory - it is when your army has its victorious flag on the roof of the highest building of the capital of the enemy country.
And it doesn't matter how much it costs.
Even if you have less casualties, if your disarmed generals are walked down the streets of the capital of you adversary as cattle - it's a humiliating defeat.
Heightofhate 1 year ago
poor germans
MegaGERMANFREAK 1 year ago
Hitler Caput. Nazi s were dreaming to march in moscow. hey they dream became a reality.
mylove1618 2 years ago
all your talk about nazi pagan pigs! who lost the fucking war? who got there asses beat? they deserved to perish. they got a taste of their own medicine from the enemy, (INHUMANITY).
gjay700 2 years ago
@gjay700 you must be so smart..the smartest man in the usa... never seen eu and so smart... too much movies retard!! WERMACHT!!!! is in this video not Wafenn SS...if you know the difrence... stupid jenki!! first learn history..then comment!!
saannddii1984 2 years ago
Better die on you feet that to live on your knees. Whel that goes for the red army. american army and nazi army and who ever is taking prisoner during the war. I would bite scratsh Kick hit what evcer i had. Everything is better that working in the cold waiting for my weenee to freese bewteen mah legs. And i know how cold it is in russia in the winter. The netherlands is Just Hole compared with russia. Russian people know the understanding of cold weather i guess. hehe
Metalguyful 2 years ago
@Metalguyful You do not know what you would do. I suspect you would cry like a baby. That is what you sound like.
empressoffrance 1 year ago
wel indeed i can say i would do things but if sombody is pointing some big gun right in my face i guess i would just say yes sir and no sir.
People have made wrong disissions in the past en well im just glad most countrys live in piece with each other.
Metalguyful 1 year ago
I would rather die fighting rather than surrender to the Bolshevik scum.
Anyway every German soldier was much more efficient than Soviet, Germany had 10 million soldiers throughout the war, and fought against 29 million Russians wimps, 4.6 million English. I do not know the number of Americans who fought in Europe, but I know that in total amounted to 16 million.
TheAponov 2 years ago
Marsh of prisoners!!!!!!!!!!-СЛАВА РОССИИ!!!!!
dokus57 2 years ago
drang nach osten
Bonkajs 2 years ago
u better watch the clip again
RUSLON2008 2 years ago
yeh and all what i see reminds me of german politics motto "drang nach osten" .. now they get what they wanted and marching to the east, but not as winners :D
Bonkajs 2 years ago 8
Nach Osten! Nach Siberia! Only a few has come back in the 50' to GDR & BDR.
radled 2 years ago
yeah :D LOL
Bonkajs 2 years ago
All Germans who were not SS-members or war criminals were released in 1949.
The others were released in 1956.
Of German prisoners only about 20 % has died in the Soviet captivity.
It's nothing compared to 70% of dead Soviet POWs.
Heightofhate 1 year ago 2
@Heightofhate
Yes, you are right! Germans put a lot of Soviet POWs to concentation camps. They were treated very badly. On 27th January 2010 in former German Concentration Camp Auschwitz Russian minister of science opened a new exhibition about Russian people who were improsoned there. Next week I'm going there to see it.
Greetings from Poland.
radled 1 year ago
You're totally right - unfortunately,THE VERY FIRST EXHIBITION ON SOVIET POWs killed in Auschwitz concentration camp was opened ONLY IN JANUARY 2010.
Before that they had been talking only about Jews who were killed there,but almost nobody knows that the first people killed by gas were Soviet POWs - that's how the system had been tested and only after it they began to gas Jewish people.
The data on 146,000 Christian Poles is also kept away from international public making Jews the only victims
Heightofhate 1 year ago
@Heightofhate Thank you for the information. I was wondering why it is a crime to even question the Holocaust in some European countries. Not only jews, gypsies, gays, mentally handicapped. I give thanks to all the allies who fought. They were brave souls.
empressoffrance 1 year ago
@empressoffrance But even gypsies, homosexuals and mentally challenged get more international and political attention than the Slavic victims of the German Holocaust.
Why?...
Heightofhate 1 year ago
@Heightofhate I think the only ones that get attention are the Jewish race. The above are noted at the bottom of the pile and I feel everyone who died should get attention, irregardless of race, religion, nationality, etc. Anyhow it is over with now. I just thank the allies.
empressoffrance 1 year ago
@empressoffrance In the words of the Israeli PM A. Sharon Oct 3/2007, the US says it will do this and do that, let me make this perfectly clear the US answers to Israel not the other way around and you know I believe it. You cannot get elected in the US unless u are pro Jewish. I am pro free ppl. Agreed they need to protect themselves but do they have to kill all those innocents? No justification whatsoever for their deeds. That is where the war will start again. No-one will write history
empressoffrance 1 year ago
@Heightofhate I do not know why. Furthermore, even the above that you mentioned get very little attention, if any. The Holocaust gets a lot of attention.
empressoffrance 1 year ago
@empressoffrance The Holocaust of Jews gets a lot of attention.
The Holocaust of 20 million Slavonic people gets no attention at all.
Even from your words one could think that Holocaust is something connected only with Jews.
And the killing of non-Jews was not a Holocaust but, well, just something ordinary and normal for a war.
Double standards - once again...
Heightofhate 1 year ago
@Heightofhate I have to agree with you. I do not deny the Holocaust happened to that extent no However, many other nationalities, including yours suffered at the hands of the Nazis. As u stated the Holocaust is kept in the limelight always and it will never be put to rest Personally, I am tired of hearing about it. Look at Zionist Israel and what they are doing to the Palestinian ppl creating a ghetto just like in Warsaw and killing them for no reason. Another war will start unless Isr stops
empressoffrance 1 year ago
@empressoffrance That's what I'm saying.
If the world had admitted Poles, Russians, Ukrainians, Belorussians etc. were the first to suffer under the German Holocaust and the Jewish Holocaust came later in 1942 after the Wannsee Conference where the "Final Solution" (Endloesung) was proclaimed the whole post-WWII history would have been different for the reason Jews wouldn't be able to state they are some special victim with special rights.
Heightofhate 1 year ago
Anti-Slavic racism never really disappeared after the Cold War. Many Western Elites still consider people from Eastern Europe to be some kind of "sub-humans".
Maloross 1 year ago
Stupid bastards 95,000 germans were taken prisner at Stalingrad only 5, 000 ever made ot home.....They were beaten and worked to death....
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
@birdmanofbooze
Is Stalingrad a german city? So the soviets just came to kill them and ruin the city, right? What about 40000 Stalingrad's civilians died by german bombings?
The prisoners of the battle were injured and nipped by excessive cold, Russian army had no chance to save them all. 5000 of them returned home, why they weren't killed like others?
msk0001 1 year ago 8
As awful as it is that thousands were killed during the war, I don't equate it with what happened after the war........These German POWs were being worked to death until 1948.................
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
@msk0001 "... 5000 of them returned home, why they weren't killed like others"?
They had to send SOME home....pretty hard to justify sending no one back. Even the russians knew this. I am curious as to why they were sent back home so many years after the war?
But, let us not bullshit here....the Germans AND russians treated POW's poorly. Hitler AND stalin were both first rate assholes and it was THEIR policies that lead to mistreatment of prisoners on BOTH sides.
starlinghunter 1 year ago
@starlinghunter
I think the strongest of those who became prisoners survived I do not think that they sent some few thousands home because they would not have been able to justify to send non home,considering how the German army had raged amongst millions of civilians, they would not have needed a cause for non to return,one of my grand uncles was one of those who returned,the average time in Russia for POW was 7 years knowing how the Russians were treated as POW,I am surprised he returned
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern
Your grand ucles can survive after all their crimes. My grandfather was not return from the War. Don't need to say, that I must feel sorry for your grand uncles.
hyper1282 1 year ago
@hyper1282
you did not understand me hyper, I understand what you are saying and I see it the same way but you misunderstand me,so I will reply to your PM´s.......I never said you should be sorry for my grand uncle, I feel very sorry for your people ,it was a horrendious crime that was committed against so many millions of civilians, don´t think I try to find excuses for the Nazis, I know what was done during that time and I will not forget it..
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@msk0001 Ten years after the war they came home ...used as bargaining chips, after being used for slave labor...stop getting your info from Liberal history professors...
birdmanofbooze 1 year ago
Die meisten deutschen Kriegsgefangenen wurden von den Russen ermordet.
carinhall1 2 years ago
Hitler - deutsche gay!!!!
nilpak2000 2 years ago
Не куй в Россию нашу ходить!!!!!!!
Gorsvet5 2 years ago
В Союз, в Союз.
MacIn173 2 years ago 3
after what the nazis did, if i was a guard guarding nazi pow i would shoot them all too
bratan07 2 years ago
Your a dick head.
Cyric1358 2 years ago
aha u know what happend with the wilhelm gustloff?
RechteRichterin 2 years ago
Thats what happens when you invade Russia you lose. Russia had a superior military force in comparison to the Germans, they survived the critical first 6 months of the eastern front which allowed the Russians to recruit a half a million soldiers each month, mass produce tanks, air craft, artillery pieces, machine guns, etc...
quest8899 2 years ago
yep, all Hitlers generals knew that victory had to be reached within the first months in a surprise blitz krieg.. But the generals lost control of "operation barbarossa" to Hitler himself, a disaster.
clarkcolt45 2 years ago
Nice! so it will be with all who will go to Russia
ThunderTropic 2 years ago
One very important fact about Operation Bagration. When it started the Luftwaffe got only 40 serviceable fighters in Belo Russia, later little bit more. As most of historicians in Germany and west have noticed - it was airforces of western allies which opened the sky in east for Soviet Air Forces, because at the same time (june 1944) Luftwaffe got over 1200 fighters in Reich, over 500 in west and some 400 in Italy.
Take this under consideration.
tranmere789 2 years ago
Yes, and german reserve tank divisions have gone to save hopeless situation in Belorussia, instead of turn alliens back to the sea in Normandie (there was then a small local operation in comparison with Belorussian). Take this too.
lexey2002 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lol, russians:
"If you come to our country again, we'll nuke you and get nuked back to shit because we can't fight a conventional war anymore, our army sucks. so...
NUKENUKENUKENUKE BTW NUKE!"
Sums it up, that's all they have on us now.
Tmineff 2 years ago
57.000 prisoners marched thru MOSCOW , nice , 70% of all GERMAN army was defeated in CCCP .. GERMAN generals warned HITLER not to go in CCCP , he did not listen ,, a lot of people here , Where was the video of 6th German amry prisoners , they said there were 600.000 priseonrs which were encirlced around Leningrad ..
aviomaster 2 years ago
It's silly to speak of German war atrocities on behalf of the Russians, when the Russians were at least as guilty. Placing POW's in parades is a violation of international law. So is using them for forced labor.
Talk about German war crimes all you want. But, NEVER do that from a Russian perspective... it's the height of raving hypocrisy.
One last thing.... German soldiers are no more "nazi soldiers" than Russian soldiers were "Bolshevik soldiers." They were just soldiers all.
mnpd007 2 years ago
No nation, save the Russians, would parade its handiwork of maltreated prisoners in front of the world for political purposes. I couldn't do it to a sick dog.
Germany lost 1.4 million of its soldiers who fell into Soviet hands during the course of the War, and who died before ever reaching registration stations to even leave a record of themselves... like they never existed.
Of 91,000 German prisoners from Stalingrad, half were dead within a month; 40,000 buried in a single mass grave.
mnpd007 2 years ago
No, I wouldn't parade a sick dog either.
But, we are not talking about a sick dog, we are talking about a different kind of animal--though comparing these Nazi fiends to animals is an insult to four legged creatures.
No we are discussing muderous ghouls that burned alive 10s of thousands of Soviet people in barns and churches across the steppes.
I'll save my sympathy for the soviet people murdered by these pigs, and the German civillians who were unfairly killed in retributtion.
somersetdc 2 years ago
Except a small number of volunteers, for most germans, romanians, hungarians, italians troops, the the east front was not an option. You have no right to judge them because you was not there!
iarion 2 years ago
poor somersetdc
you are a victim of allied american propaganda.
you can write and rewrite everything you like.
russians did ten times worse than the nazis you idiot.
american killed with no mercy thousands and thousands of pow germans soldiers, pow and prisoners, during the war.
many many were only children of 13-14-15 years old. evil people were you then.
your propaganda system lied to you.
but OF COURSE you will NOT read this in your history books.
aronron2727 2 years ago
"russians did ten times worse than the nazis you idiot."
That's quite interesting. How is here a victim of propaganda? :D
MacIn173 2 years ago 4
57.000 German prisoners ,, ooo Shit ,, that is a lot of soldiers ,, NEXT time yuo come to RUSSIA we will NUKE YOU ... there will be no prisoners ...
aviomaster 2 years ago
How can people here praise the Soviet system of those days...
They were in many ways worse then the Nazi's (allready before there was any war).
The Soviets used their own people and soldiers just as worse as the Nazi's used them during the war.
Soviet PoW's who were "liberated" when the Germans were pushed back got the same threatment as captured enemy soldiers and many were singed as traitors and went straight from the German camps to the Russian Gulag camps, how nice is that?
Clausewitzz 2 years ago
This is just anti-soviet propaganda. Fucking rat Solzhenitsin faked it for CIA money and Nobel prize.
Less than 3% of ex-POWs were sent to Gulag (it wasn't prison, it was rustication). And everybody of them for really serious crimes. And most of them survived and got back to normal life. Renegades, nazi politsais, cowards and spies - most of them end up like respected Soviet citizens.
msk0001 2 years ago
Come up here , Iˇll make you march to your grave , motherfucker , Australian neonazi shitkicker .Nazi must die ..
kurbanovm 2 years ago
As they were marched through Moscow, the defeated Nazi barbarian criminals were followed by a brigade of large motorized street cleaners. Too bad this isn't shown in this video. Wonderful symbolism. I love Russia!
somersetdc 2 years ago
In a couple of weeks after the pleasant Moskow Marsh those 'heroes' were eating each others frozen ears and cocks in Far, Far Siberian Fairyland.
mishacol 3 years ago
Wow so much hate... you must have some real problems and insecurities, eh?
duttysingers 3 years ago
To wipe out all Slavonic states,especially Russia, from Rein to Ural Mountains. To enslave or just to slay most of Slavonik nations, especially Russians. No reading and writing, no education and culture for slaves... Those Nazies who survived never regreted about what they have done. Did they? I don't think so.
mishacol 3 years ago
Oh, year. Gebbels's dead, but his propaganda is still alive.
There were 3576,3 thousands German POWs in total. And only 12,4% died in prison.
msk0001 3 years ago
After taking some 85% casualties before surrendering at Stalingrad, Von Paulus' Sixth Army of about 600,000 men became POWs of the Soviets. About 5,000 made it back to Germany alive, some ten years later.
Boethus 3 years ago
These POWs were doomed, they were sent to Siberia. Basically noone ever came back from there including these 57,000 germans. Please take in mind that most of these Germans were not Nazis as they were part of the Wehrmacht which
Eprime123 3 years ago
No, 99% of them were nazies. Those who collaborated with Russians usually were ignored and even killed by their Kameraden. Germans got what they were looking for. Wise people said hunderets of times: "Don't mess up with Russians".
mishacol 3 years ago
When I see these images (and that of allied and soviet pows) it makes me think that we humans haven't evolved much more from 'caveman days'. The brutal comments on thi page confirms this. Am I really the only one here who sees just simply suffering human beings? No particular group (jew or otherwise) has ownership on suffering... but I think I waste my time posting this.
jrrylpz 3 years ago 2
funny thing is this is still happening all over the world today...its not about evolution as long as men let greed and lust for power take over this will always be part of our world
kakahass 3 years ago
Many of them deserved to be killed right there on Red Square. Sorry, don't waste your time.
mishacol 3 years ago
Superior losers. The nazi leaders abandoned their soldiers and fled to South america like cowards. They should put these nazis to the same ovens that they themselves built and gas them!
wilknocy 3 years ago
Эти несчастные люди были вынуждены участвовать в боевых действиях на стороне своей страны, которой руководили военные преступники.
Fnaqer 3 years ago
17 миллионов мирных советских граждан были зверски убиты этими "несчастными людьми", которые за несколько лет до этого привели к власти Гитлера на совершенно свободных и демократических выборах.
fantozzi80 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Если бы в этом марше участвовали лишь старшие офицеры, тогда я поддержал бы его идею. Унижать рядовой и сержантский состав, а так же младших офицеров - свинство со стороны советского руководства.
Fnaqer 3 years ago
Not every German was a "nazi" you idiots. They fought for their comrades. Just like not every U.S. soldier believes in the war in Iraq, but they do it it anyway because they are fighting for the guy next to them.
uboat1918 3 years ago
Artur Axman,the simple fact of Barbarossa is that the Germans invaded the Soviet Union and committed many atrocities unprovoked. And though the Russians in 1939 to 1945 and indeed beyond 1945, showed themselves to be very cruel one must take account of the well known proverb, "you reap what you sow."
If your going to conquer Europe at least do it with some sort of chivalry and elan like the French under Napoleon.
1546592 3 years ago 2
Yeah, French under Napoleon, Germany under Hitler and after all that shit "KALINKA-MALINKA" in Paris and Berlin...
mishacol 3 years ago
So funny to see the superior race walking like scared cowards. :)))
pegasouno 3 years ago
Yes it is.
PimpDaddy000007 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Right on man!
mishacol 3 years ago
Nazi must die. bresztlitovszk, ArturAxmann.. you too.
Snezhinec 3 years ago
Put this in English ... so we can understand.
mrchic 4 years ago
ooo,, yeaaahhh.. march to the siberia, assholes!
nedra777 4 years ago
So funny the fucking bastards nazi marching :)))))
pegasouno 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
From the 220.000 german prisoners - only 55.000 came back !
ALLDALI 4 years ago
Comment removed
archanticipator 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Soviet barbarians. German deaths will be avenged.
ArturAxmann 4 years ago
we are waiting u ))) to take ur punish )))
yokanga77 3 years ago