I wish the music of this decade would emulate what this song Melanie did back then to motivate this younger generation . We need less violent protests and more peaceful and positive sit ins . As John said Power to the People and Give Peace a Chance ! Where is the "John Lennon" of this younger generation or are they too self absorbed in having the latest ipod or ipad to give a damn ?
I Love this song,I grew up in the 70s and my mother played this song a lot.The vocals and harmony plus the funky quality of the song make it memorable. Plus I always found the lyrics fascinating as a child and hard to figure out yet compelling.
Also the Edwin Hawkins band just really made this song so special!!!! It gives me goose bumps as well! It makes me just want to dance around! Someone filmed Melanie in Miami in the 70's to this song and it was perfect!!!! Thats kid of the way I feel when i hear this song! The band is just totally AWESOME!!!! Noe better than Melanie and Edwin Hawkins! I wish I could go back in time again!
@sassykynurse My sister is an RN.....YAH bless all nurses.......found your post very "profound"...Let's just remember who really "LAID IT ALL DOWN" for all of us!!
Legend has it this was a prodigy of Woodstock having to do with the crowd holding candles in the dark and /or rain. It's very spiritual in it's presentation
I was about 5yo when this song came out.. it was played to a group of us young hoodlum during summer camp at the boy's club...until recently i didn't know who sung it...with today tech you can find any song....thanks for posting it
I was about 5yo when this song came out.. it played to a group of us young hudlum during summer camp at the boy's club...until recently i didn't know who sung...with today tech you can find any song....thanks for posting it
WOW, such memories.......Atlanta, 1969/70, spending a lot of time in Piedmont Park and 14th/15th street! A Hippie wanna-be but driving a new car and wearing $200 boots (shame on me).
The thought that a group of unrelated people can change something--is that a mind blowing thought or what? Have we lost the ability to believe in this idea?
@joelunchbox1 I look around at all the bad going on in this world and I KNOW that we have lost the ability to care about peace in this world. We need someone to light a fire under us again.
I believe out of all of the prominent female vocailsts out today, K. T. Tunstall could make soulful, relevant music like this if she chose. She won't though because it won't sell...what a shame.
This song was written after Woodstock. She gave a interview explaining that she wanted to capture the Woodstock moment and she sure did. Classic song of peace, drugs and companionship.
It's 1970 all over again! I remember hearing this song many times back then. I think it got up to #6 on the charts. Melanie did a great job on it, and so did the Edwin Hawkins Singers backing her. I hear this usuallt at least once a week on my local oldies station. It still sounds good today!
always loved melanie's take on the movement provided in the expression let it all down, embracing compassion, celebration, love for life & the brotherhood, coupled with peace, always having each other's backs
I LOVE singing this song when I hear it. I'm only 34. I don't know about any political junk associated with it - I just know that I love my fellow man and this song inspires me to be a loving, more caring person. Go, Melanie! That voice of hers pierces my soul!
syntarro get with the year 2010 i'm from the woodstock days you have no idea what your saying kiddo you can't live your future by living in the past!that line is also from a melanie song
what ever you are below syntarro get up and smell the delicious coffee melanie has written only 368 songs since laydown in fact she's just written a song recently till they all come home stop, with the past and get with the program person below what a joke you are who are you kidding this is a beautiful gospel song you know nothing about has nothjing to do what your talking about in fact syntarro melanie never touched a drug in her life
Well so did , poltics, our own colonialism, Alcohalism , lies and our young laying dead in Vietnam , Peace , Love and Dove's are still something to shoot for against our lower natures, many doctors , lawyers, teachers smoked pot back then or tried it most grew up to have families and careers which pokes your constipated opinion just where it belongs.right it the kaboos!! have a cocktail cheer up, let us enjoy a fucking song ok?
It is a shame we are so self centered that we cannot feel the paranoid oppression of our brothers and sisters accross the sea . Facisum is alive and well . In the form of some religions . Can we say Islam ? Shiites want to dominate Shia and vice a versa . Homeland Security was maybe set up to thwart these kind of threats . God Bless .... Joe Kolaski III U.S.A.F.
@ bboice02: Homeland Security was set up by your very own government to keep tYOU silent, blaming terrorism. Look what Bush did: how many cicilians and good soldiers have been killed in Iraq, in a war that has been started by Bush with LIES??? It is disgusting.
And yes, fascism is alive, even in my own country (Holland). We gotta raise our candles higher brother!!! Love, Sam
What the fuck are you doing man , this song is about Peace not anger. As long as you have anger and resentment Peace will struggle to the forefront . Put the past behind and move forward.
aww flashback LOL i remember the hippies in brooklyn blasting this song. i was in first grade in private school uniform lol hippies scared me back then lol
This is the song that started it all for me as a fan of Melanie! I saw her live in concert way back in March 1974! It was an enchanting time in my life that I shall never forget! She held us all captivated with her presence on the stage at Valley Forge Music Faire in Pennsylvania that year! What magical memories!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I wrote in my 1979 graduation book,God help us when the 60,s generation takes power.Its so sad that the good people that really believe in what they want to accomplish, do not look at what their actions will accomplish.You will bring down the middle class.Raise up the Upper class,give the politicians more power over you and you will be more poor than you where,less freedom and poorer.Please wake up and look at what you are doing to your selves
Before Stevie Nicks and Heart there was this Lady! Her voice is unbelievable. I have NEVER heard another woman Howl like she does in this song. Probably could be re released now and still be a hit. Will they ever write em like this again?
Don't think so! Modern youth don't have a social conscience nor the balls to voice their beliefs. It's all about getting what you can out of life and FUCK your neighbour and fellow man. But like all cycles it will return, the social conscience I mean.
Great song and Melanie is a wonderful artist/vocalist, but the Edwin Hawkins Singers (usually ignored) really did a fantastic job backing her on this track.
Outstanding.....I'm old now, but remember 1969, 1970 like it was yesterday.....Melanie never got the recognition she deserved. Maybe someday she will....Thanks!!!
she gets the recognition she deserves with every view on you tube,as more people are exposed to her,perhaps they will pass this artst from friend to friend as was done in her emergance.and oh yeah the song is fabulous.
This was a big hit on the big 89WLS radio in Chicago. I bought the 45 at Roseland Music on michigan ave. The record was in a photo sleeve. She was sitting cross legged in her baggy dress playing her 6-string. Long brown beautiful hair, beautiful brown eyes, sweet angelic face&voice. I've been in love with her ever since that day. My beautiful hippy girl you will always have a special place in my heart.
@lancechamplain -- Same here... I fell in love with her the second I heard her and saw her. I had quite a few of her vinyl 45s and albums, when I was a kid.
She did some song about having brand new roller skates which was pretty cool but what is really cool about her is that at the Powder Ridge Music Festival in the mountains of Connecticut which was cancelled after 200,000 people had gathered and all bands scheduled to appear were told they would not get payed and were forbidden to perform, she was the only one to defy the ban and played under a tree near the stage. She became the heroine of Powder Ridge.
My mother, who recently passed away, always had a hippy vibe about her. I remember the almost Powder Ridge Music Festival, the traffic it caused, and giving out bottles of pop to the "hippies" that were coming through the area. I think I was 10 and it was the coolest thing coming to CT. I only wish I could have seen her.
By far the best version of this song I've ever heard. I didn't realize there even was an extended version. Love it! I've always been a big Melanie fan, and this confirms it! Thanks for sharing this with us!
I've never heard the extended version before. Thanks for posting it. I've always liked this song. She had a beautiful voice and was a beautiful girl as well. Her music is no long available. I can not find it anywhere on the market, so Thanks!
Didn't know there was an extended version of Candles In The Rain.....outstanding!.....thank you for uploading it & peace.
peacewavenow 2 months ago
I can't describe the feeling of re-dicovering a song from 35 years ago. Smiles and tears
TheHippyMike 1 year ago
I wish the music of this decade would emulate what this song Melanie did back then to motivate this younger generation . We need less violent protests and more peaceful and positive sit ins . As John said Power to the People and Give Peace a Chance ! Where is the "John Lennon" of this younger generation or are they too self absorbed in having the latest ipod or ipad to give a damn ?
altatoth1958 1 year ago
Lay down, lay down, lay it all down let your white birds smile at the one's who stand and frown.
vanjane 1 year ago
From the music to the lyrics this song is all emotions, bring tears to my eyes everytime I hear.
Ajarthis 1 year ago
I Love this song,I grew up in the 70s and my mother played this song a lot.The vocals and harmony plus the funky quality of the song make it memorable. Plus I always found the lyrics fascinating as a child and hard to figure out yet compelling.
linny50 1 year ago
I LOVE your music
jollymonsng 1 year ago
I love women
,we all need them-I love MELANIE\
jollymonsng 1 year ago
Comment removed
myspeedis69 1 year ago
Thanks, well done ! 11***********
CharlesBarry 1 year ago
It makes me cry and has always brought tears to my eyes even as a child. Her folky voice and the black gospel are so perfect here.
saw1261 1 year ago
Most fantastic Song.....reveals the feeling of the 70's that the young had for each other..........
carpetcle 1 year ago
Three slipped on the like button.
ClownShadow1 1 year ago
Fucka buncha berthigginbottom. Melanie is the real deal - always was, always will be. 60 yrs old and still playing to a full house.
HalfFastChevy 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
An incredible, timeless classic! Great to hear the full, 7:43 version of this song again after many, many years!
gorickard319582010 1 year ago
An incredible, timeless classic! Great to hear the full, 7:43 version of this song after many, many years!
gorickard319582010 1 year ago
She's playing at Amazing Things In Framingham Ma tomorrow
ayrishrose 1 year ago
She spoke for those of us who can't sing. We thought it, she sang it - and so beautifully too. What a talent.
HalfFastChevy 1 year ago 3
reminds me of summer 1970 Los Angeles. They played this one alot - always loved it. Music like this is the real deal.
torahislife 1 year ago
Also the Edwin Hawkins band just really made this song so special!!!! It gives me goose bumps as well! It makes me just want to dance around! Someone filmed Melanie in Miami in the 70's to this song and it was perfect!!!! Thats kid of the way I feel when i hear this song! The band is just totally AWESOME!!!! Noe better than Melanie and Edwin Hawkins! I wish I could go back in time again!
sassykynurse 1 year ago
This woman is incredible!!!! I have listened to her music as a child!
It seems as if this song has taken a 380! She talks about PEACE in this song!
MMMMM .........seems we should be talking about some of that NOW!!!!!!!!
She was a legion before her time! I think she was full of futuristic knowledge!!!
And I also compare some of Alanas Morrisette modern day music to Melanie's!
sassykynurse 1 year ago
@sassykynurse My sister is an RN.....YAH bless all nurses.......found your post very "profound"...Let's just remember who really "LAID IT ALL DOWN" for all of us!!
313Mema 1 year ago
I see why they edited the track down, it goes on way too long, but that jam in the second half is epic.
Machiventa 1 year ago
Legend has it this was a prodigy of Woodstock having to do with the crowd holding candles in the dark and /or rain. It's very spiritual in it's presentation
capitolemiproducer 1 year ago
this lady,s voice made me name my daughter melanie. the power and the beauty of her sound is what i saw the frist time i held my little girl
196raider 1 year ago
thanks that is awesome!!!! I love this song!
jchallan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I was about 5yo when this song came out.. it was played to a group of us young hoodlum during summer camp at the boy's club...until recently i didn't know who sung it...with today tech you can find any song....thanks for posting it
wilwilly 1 year ago
I was about 5yo when this song came out.. it played to a group of us young hudlum during summer camp at the boy's club...until recently i didn't know who sung...with today tech you can find any song....thanks for posting it
wilwilly 1 year ago
WOW, such memories.......Atlanta, 1969/70, spending a lot of time in Piedmont Park and 14th/15th street! A Hippie wanna-be but driving a new car and wearing $200 boots (shame on me).
korbelbrut11 1 year ago
The thought that a group of unrelated people can change something--is that a mind blowing thought or what? Have we lost the ability to believe in this idea?
thank you melanie, love this song!
joelunchbox1 1 year ago
@joelunchbox1 I look around at all the bad going on in this world and I KNOW that we have lost the ability to care about peace in this world. We need someone to light a fire under us again.
josiek55 1 year ago
to bad, there will never be a edwin hawkins singers again -man they really worked it, and mellonie--what a doll---!-Bravo
jimmatera 1 year ago
I truly remember this i live in the south and being afro american no one understood what it meant but me. I loved all her music...she was so deep....
mspeace59 1 year ago
saw her and her son perform this about 3-4 years ago................loved it then and now
Themin1 1 year ago
saw her and her son perform this about 3-4 years ago................loved it then and now
Themin1 1 year ago
I believe out of all of the prominent female vocailsts out today, K. T. Tunstall could make soulful, relevant music like this if she chose. She won't though because it won't sell...what a shame.
BreezelyBruin 1 year ago
This song was written after Woodstock. She gave a interview explaining that she wanted to capture the Woodstock moment and she sure did. Classic song of peace, drugs and companionship.
Truthpolice9698 1 year ago
would stevie nicks do this song?
alexiskisses4u 1 year ago
@alexiskisses4u I don't know, hold on I'll ask her.
Hey Stevie.......
cheswic 1 year ago
It's 1970 all over again! I remember hearing this song many times back then. I think it got up to #6 on the charts. Melanie did a great job on it, and so did the Edwin Hawkins Singers backing her. I hear this usuallt at least once a week on my local oldies station. It still sounds good today!
fordude60 1 year ago
always loved melanie's take on the movement provided in the expression let it all down, embracing compassion, celebration, love for life & the brotherhood, coupled with peace, always having each other's backs
sekhmetraptah 1 year ago
Decades later this song still resonates and connects with a part of me that's inexplicable.
rla3853 1 year ago 2
The music and the message are as relevant today as it was then.
rpwilsox 1 year ago
Awesome
rwflash1 1 year ago
she's perfect!
mrslilijam 1 year ago 3
So Electric with such Emotion, So Conscientious !! R&B Gospel .
JAETERRI 1 year ago 6
I LOVE singing this song when I hear it. I'm only 34. I don't know about any political junk associated with it - I just know that I love my fellow man and this song inspires me to be a loving, more caring person. Go, Melanie! That voice of hers pierces my soul!
crazysingingchick 1 year ago 8
well im 22 and i also love here voice so its not a age thing haha!!
Ratjuh1988 1 year ago
syntarro get with the year 2010 i'm from the woodstock days you have no idea what your saying kiddo you can't live your future by living in the past!that line is also from a melanie song
1955c 1 year ago
what ever you are below syntarro get up and smell the delicious coffee melanie has written only 368 songs since laydown in fact she's just written a song recently till they all come home stop, with the past and get with the program person below what a joke you are who are you kidding this is a beautiful gospel song you know nothing about has nothjing to do what your talking about in fact syntarro melanie never touched a drug in her life
1955c 1 year ago
Well, peace, love, dove---- A wonderful thought, but the drugs f---'d up a lot of that beautiful sentiment.
redmaj1 1 year ago
Well so did , poltics, our own colonialism, Alcohalism , lies and our young laying dead in Vietnam , Peace , Love and Dove's are still something to shoot for against our lower natures, many doctors , lawyers, teachers smoked pot back then or tried it most grew up to have families and careers which pokes your constipated opinion just where it belongs.right it the kaboos!! have a cocktail cheer up, let us enjoy a fucking song ok?
rakeuiff 1 year ago
Oh man memories this brings. Magical time for better or worse.
redmaj1 1 year ago 2
Where can I buy this video? I live in the UK.
Shielmor 1 year ago
what video?
bbdowns124 1 year ago
It is a shame we are so self centered that we cannot feel the paranoid oppression of our brothers and sisters accross the sea . Facisum is alive and well . In the form of some religions . Can we say Islam ? Shiites want to dominate Shia and vice a versa . Homeland Security was maybe set up to thwart these kind of threats . God Bless .... Joe Kolaski III U.S.A.F.
bboice02 1 year ago
@ bboice02: Homeland Security was set up by your very own government to keep tYOU silent, blaming terrorism. Look what Bush did: how many cicilians and good soldiers have been killed in Iraq, in a war that has been started by Bush with LIES??? It is disgusting.
And yes, fascism is alive, even in my own country (Holland). We gotta raise our candles higher brother!!! Love, Sam
samopdrift 1 year ago
What the fuck are you doing man , this song is about Peace not anger. As long as you have anger and resentment Peace will struggle to the forefront . Put the past behind and move forward.
Shielmor 1 year ago
Some people from the 60's have changed their minds. Timothy Leary said he was wrong before he died.
Peace is always good to hope for at any cost.
cindysk8er 2 years ago
i wonder what kind of songs she would write today about Homeland Insecurity and paranoid oppression
Syntarro 2 years ago
aww flashback LOL i remember the hippies in brooklyn blasting this song. i was in first grade in private school uniform lol hippies scared me back then lol
Syntarro 2 years ago
Cindy Lauper was in high school she bopping when this was written. I also like Cindy.
n2uid01 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cindy Lauper did this song, it was way better
thatbamadude 2 years ago
I heard this on an amorphous androginous album and thought this girl can sing
bandofhorses4 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song,
Ratkar 2 years ago
What a voice and it's so fantastic emotional. Let's sing together!
marinar1000 2 years ago 4
thanks it s beautiful
atavistos 2 years ago 3
This is the song that started it all for me as a fan of Melanie! I saw her live in concert way back in March 1974! It was an enchanting time in my life that I shall never forget! She held us all captivated with her presence on the stage at Valley Forge Music Faire in Pennsylvania that year! What magical memories!
Titan752 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I wrote in my 1979 graduation book,God help us when the 60,s generation takes power.Its so sad that the good people that really believe in what they want to accomplish, do not look at what their actions will accomplish.You will bring down the middle class.Raise up the Upper class,give the politicians more power over you and you will be more poor than you where,less freedom and poorer.Please wake up and look at what you are doing to your selves
philchemi 2 years ago
Abby Hoffmans spinning in his grave looking at how the peace generation sold out
Syntarro 2 years ago
Before Stevie Nicks and Heart there was this Lady! Her voice is unbelievable. I have NEVER heard another woman Howl like she does in this song. Probably could be re released now and still be a hit. Will they ever write em like this again?
imsneeky 2 years ago 4
Don't think so! Modern youth don't have a social conscience nor the balls to voice their beliefs. It's all about getting what you can out of life and FUCK your neighbour and fellow man. But like all cycles it will return, the social conscience I mean.
Davo66 2 years ago 4
Great song and Melanie is a wonderful artist/vocalist, but the Edwin Hawkins Singers (usually ignored) really did a fantastic job backing her on this track.
kristov29 2 years ago 6
My favorite song by melanie
BENSMOVIEWORLD 2 years ago
So raise the candles high, like we did 40 years ago. thanks Chrissy and,, Melanie with the great Edwin ( Oh Happy Day ) Hawkins singers
budelke 2 years ago 2
Just love it!! and always has, it's Melanie at her best!!!
fengfipe 2 years ago 2
Outstanding.....I'm old now, but remember 1969, 1970 like it was yesterday.....Melanie never got the recognition she deserved. Maybe someday she will....Thanks!!!
steve52jema 2 years ago 7
she gets the recognition she deserves with every view on you tube,as more people are exposed to her,perhaps they will pass this artst from friend to friend as was done in her emergance.and oh yeah the song is fabulous.
holmsatlarge 2 years ago 3
This song gives me goosebumps every time I hear it, even way after Woodstock she has that wonderful voice and musical talent.
sr633 2 years ago 24
@sr633 She was really feeling it huh dog? That's why I came here gives me GB's too.
Cantrememberjack 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hippies are lazy and stink, what we need is one dictator !
that dictator would be me.
Mika151 2 years ago
First you need a talk radio program in America then you will be the most brillant person in the world!!!
hamshow 2 years ago
maybe he can play the skinbanjo ! :O
Mika151 2 years ago
But Jimi Hendrix could play the guitar, obama can not :O
Mika151 2 years ago
Never has her message been as needed as now. I hope President Obama is listening. Peace to the World. xx
gazrobbo53 3 years ago 3
Obama is black :OO
Mika151 3 years ago
This was a big hit on the big 89WLS radio in Chicago. I bought the 45 at Roseland Music on michigan ave. The record was in a photo sleeve. She was sitting cross legged in her baggy dress playing her 6-string. Long brown beautiful hair, beautiful brown eyes, sweet angelic face&voice. I've been in love with her ever since that day. My beautiful hippy girl you will always have a special place in my heart.
lancechamplain 3 years ago 32
@lancechamplain - Thats Awesome! I bet Melanie read that and felt wonderful knowing that she touched you..
jcsrealty 1 year ago
@lancechamplain
Search 'Any guy' then tell me if she's still your beautiful hippy girl lol
BertHigginbottom 1 year ago
@BertHigginbottom Fuck off dickhead
lancechamplain 1 year ago
@lancechamplain -- Same here... I fell in love with her the second I heard her and saw her. I had quite a few of her vinyl 45s and albums, when I was a kid.
covenstead 1 year ago
This is the song that made me fall in love with Melanie. It's been a journey of more than 40 years; she's still my favorite performer (EVER).
I look forward to the day when she will be her inducted into the Music Hall of Fame. It's long overdue.
keygain 3 years ago 7
melanie is my godmother!!!!!!!!!
mattmoo34 3 years ago
P.S. She's beautiful.
marty6161 3 years ago 4
fabulous I bought this album in 1973 and fell in love with her what a voice
jaycee8101 3 years ago 5
an invocation of happy times.
simonturner73 3 years ago 3
She did some song about having brand new roller skates which was pretty cool but what is really cool about her is that at the Powder Ridge Music Festival in the mountains of Connecticut which was cancelled after 200,000 people had gathered and all bands scheduled to appear were told they would not get payed and were forbidden to perform, she was the only one to defy the ban and played under a tree near the stage. She became the heroine of Powder Ridge.
bwanna23 3 years ago 4
My mother, who recently passed away, always had a hippy vibe about her. I remember the almost Powder Ridge Music Festival, the traffic it caused, and giving out bottles of pop to the "hippies" that were coming through the area. I think I was 10 and it was the coolest thing coming to CT. I only wish I could have seen her.
marty6161 3 years ago 4
great story.
jennahazeispro 3 years ago
what is another good song by this artist?
toecutterr6 3 years ago
try "brand new key" or "look what they've done to my song, Ma"
toyzntheattic 3 years ago 3
her best moment was the woodstock recording. search " Melanie Safka woodstock "
I love u all, brothers and sisters of the light
DatSchnitzl 3 years ago
only 2000 people listen to this woodstock video of melanie! Shame on u all! ;O)
listen its greater than great.
DatSchnitzl 3 years ago
Wow.
I was born in the 90s and even I love this!
=D
SKANKxADDiCTiON 3 years ago 3
懐かしい。ちょうど学生の頃だった
miwakiibo 3 years ago 2
gonna look 4 this on itunes
mirandazar 3 years ago 2
With this song, I fell in love with Melanie and her music back in 1970. She remains my favorite female performer.
keygain 3 years ago 3
By far the best version of this song I've ever heard. I didn't realize there even was an extended version. Love it! I've always been a big Melanie fan, and this confirms it! Thanks for sharing this with us!
fleamaller 3 years ago 3
an uplifting & soothing song, thanx for posting :)
jjjay69 3 years ago 4
The bass playing is f***ing awsome, Holy S**t I can listen to this all day long.
Vik66tor 3 years ago 3
agreed,, a fine hippy chick no doubt,,and this is a monster bass run ! i fell in love with her when i was 10 and 1st heard this song
stevebeagle 3 years ago 2
Was this originally a Christian Worship song, made into a successful Protest song of the 60's? That's what I was told anyway.
ozcobblepot218 3 years ago 4
Just checked all music guide. She wrote this song herself.
Chris
Chrissie644 3 years ago
Thanx. Then she was ahead of her time, unless she's a Christian herself.
ozcobblepot218 3 years ago
marcante
toncinho 3 years ago 2
linda musica e letra, se harmonizam e deixam a gente viajar nos anos dourados
toncinho 3 years ago 2
I've never heard the extended version before. Thanks for posting it. I've always liked this song. She had a beautiful voice and was a beautiful girl as well. Her music is no long available. I can not find it anywhere on the market, so Thanks!
MistieBlues 3 years ago 2
I haven"t heard this song ever since I was this young little shy kid. This was one of the all-time Peace Ballards of that era ROCK-ON !!
frankhattere 3 years ago 2
Just great
natasaal 4 years ago 3
I have this version on an old cassette tape of "The Super Hit of the 70's".
But the sound on this one is so much better!
kramcool 4 years ago 2
Thank you for perfect sound.
heinerle59 4 years ago 4