Added: 5 years ago
From: salubrius
Views: 20,913
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (252)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • EDGE EDGE EDGE ALL THE TIME

  • THE EDGE WIN

  • i vote both because their both completely different

  • Kurt Cobain and The Edge shouldn't be on here. And slash wins it easily.

  • dsdgh

  • well remember that jimmy page was in the biggest band in the world at one point. stairway to heaven is one the best songs ever to be played. And almost every album had more than one good song that everyone knows.

  • @mjaquez323

    Just because he was in one of the biggest bands in the world doesn't make him good. Ringo was in the beatles (an even bigger band) but he wasnt technically good. And he was really unoriginal, and he ripped off the intro to stairway.

  • Yngwie Malmsteen vs Kurt Cobain!?!?! Are you kidding?!?

  • stevie is the best of all times pure it.

  • wmg rendering another video useless. thanks wmg!

  • since when The Edge and Kurt Cobain are guitar legends?? o.O

  • because they have acomplished to be guitarrists that change music both of them

  • jeff beck is as good as anyone

  • No audio? Fucking lame.

  • PAGE 1

    EDGE 2

  • JIMMY PAGE NR 1 ALWAYS AMEN.

  • page

    EDGE

    slash

    the edge is my favorite guitarist of all time but i cant give him the edge over page even though u2 is my favorite band

  • SRV is by far the most talented and he is amazing at improvising, Page is awesome and he is a guitar god. Slash's licks are getting old and Kurt Cobain was a master at singing/songwriting, but never really shined on lead guitar. Just an opinion

  • jimmy beats all of them...end of story..he and hendrix are the best..gods..

  • page sloppy, Stevie not sloppy

  • @drewsky80 yes but jimmy is a riff master, he created stevie. jimmy is the daddy of stevie

  • mm good point.

  • kurt cobain? are you kidding?

  • Page will always be the best.

  • The Edge beats Slashs

  • are u stupid edge is good but he wouldnt stand a chance against slash thats stupid

  • hello !?

    guitar playing isn't a form of duel

  • Page wins the first match and Slash the second and Malmsteen the third, but this is my top 3 of the video.

    1.Page

    2.SRV

    3.Slash

  • page and srv are very cole

    i would go with page because he has done more styls

    but vaughn is really really realy sick

  • SRV

    Edge

    Yingwee (spelling? but seriously yingwee vs powerchords is not exactly fair)

  • kurt and jimmy win it fuck the rest

  • srv beats jimmy page but it was close they both have their unmatchable improv moments but stevie's were pure emotion(jimmy was also emotional but not as much)

  • There are two guitar solos in the history of rock that will NEVER be equaled. "Stairway to Heaven" and "We Will Rock You." Page and May closed the door electric soloing and to this day, no one has topped them.

  • Jimmy beats Stevie,Slash beats the Edge,Yngwie beats Kurt

  • i agree

  • Edge beats Slash

  • strait up

  • SRV beat Jimmy Page.

  • FUCK NO

  • The edge :) is the best cause he make 1 guitar sounds like 3 guitars and he copy nobody and don't uses scales.

    But i like slash to

  • Of course he uses scales... Are you a drummer, you sound like one?

  • Yeah because he uses loads of delay effects. Remove them and hes just an average player. I thinks hes way overated, he made the sound that sold billions of album but he has no feelings to me

  • The Edge doesn't often do big solos, but his sound is really amazing, he has a real "trademark" and in that sense is the best guitarrist ever, because he innovates and creates some parts and patterns nobody else ever did.

  • Where's Brian May in all this?

  • My personal list:

    1. Hendrix

    2. Page

    3. May

    4. Gilmour

    5. Jonny Greenwood

  • identical to mine,

  • Nice :)

  • ITS ANGUS YOUNG HE IS THE BEST THEY ALL SUCK SO SHUT UP ANGUS YOUNG ACDC IS THE BEST.But hey thats an opinion but stop fighting PLEASE its all opinions ....WHO CARES

  • Slash wins all.. Rest are a bunch of fucking loosers.. Kurt cobain takes 2nd ..

  • jimmy page kicks more ass than chuck norris vs. mr. t in an ass kicking contest

  • kurt cobain was a shit guitarist

  • not true

  • no page, no slash and as someone already said, slash's licks are getting old

  • stevie ray WIN!! :))) next Jimmi page :p next Egde next slash :) and others are too wek for me :)

  • my pick is for SRV..... that man sold his soul to play like that..

  • for me, it's between Slash and Malmsteen

  • jimmy slash and yngwie

  • jimmy page, slash, and malmsteen ftw

  • 1 slash, 2 kurt cobain, 3 page,4 yngwie etc etc. love guns n' roses, love nirvana!!! woot woot!!!

  • jimmy page , slash and kurt

  • there's only one god guitar player:

    James Marshall "Jimi" Hendrix

  • you mean two

    Mr. Eddie Van Halen has definetly reached Guitar God status

  • Kurt cobain beats them all!!

  • there are two gods here jimmy page(the real guitar god he is better than jimi hendrix)

    and the god of chords yngwie malmsteen

    match one:jimmy page

    match two:slash

    match three:yngwie malmsteen

    ( and how the hell did kurt cobain join in that competition he is no good lead guitarist)

  • i was about to say the same thing about Kurt Cobain.. Like is that really a challege?

    Page, Vaughn, slash and yngwie are definitely gods. Hendrix is a Duh..

  • thank you kurt cobain is nothing compared to them all i dont no how ppl think hes good all he does is power cords and when i solos there not the good at all

  • I think Kurt's more about raw emotion rather than skill but w/e

  • i pick

    jimmy paige over SRV

    kurt over yngwie

    slash over the edge

  • in my opinion, none of them are really "guitar gods". Page comes close, but i cant really tell his playing from a lot of others, although he is great

  • jimmy slash and yngwie kurts good aswell

  • Page is great at soloing and all that stuff, slash totally sucks ass and shouldn't be here, cobain is alright but not that great cuz he's more of a songwriter, SRV is def on of the top greatest blues players, Edge may not be a crazy awesome player but his ideas, uniqueness, and originality earns him his identity in music today, Yngwie is too much about technicality and not enough emotion.

  • 1 slash,2 page,3 kurt,4 yngwie,5 steve, edge

    slash is the beast

    page is a god

    kurt .. you konw

    yngwie I like him but is bouring

    steve I don't like him

    and edge I like u2 but the other are beter tham you

  • listen 2 kurt cobain 2 years and u'll get enought from him

  • Puede que The Edge no sea tan rapido para tocar (bueno...nunca lo ha querido hacer asi que no lo sabemos realmente), pero lo que lo ha llevado a convertirse en una leyenda de la guitarra es el estilo impecabel que ha desarrollado con el paso de los años, un estilo que muchos quisieran tocar, un estilo que no se basa en quien toca mas notas por segunto, es un estilo unico e incomparable.

    Grandes guitarristas todos estos.

  • cobain is a great songwriter but not a good guitar player

  • 1st kurt cobain and slash 2nd page 3rd the rest

  • page slash and cobain

  • PAGE ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!

  • where's kirk hammet? O.o

  • sucking at guitar somewhere else =]

  • SRV Cobain and Slash

  • yeah but Cobain is dead so wat can he do with a guitar

  • who cares about everyone else JIMMY PAGE WINS EVERYONE!!!!

  • page,slash,Cobain

  • cobain and page own all

  • page, slash and yngwie

  • This is to whoever said Cobain could write better than any on this list-Cobain stole riffs from famous songs made it sound grunge then changed the lyrics. Watch people are gonna thumbs down my face off just cause they disagree

  • who said kurt beats malmsteen are mistaken..

    this is not song writing or singing this is playin guitar and no one beats malmsteen at playin

  • kurt wins kuuurtttttttttt

    kurt kurt kurt kurt kurt kurt fffffoooooooooorrrrrrrreeeeeee­evvvvvveeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrr r.i.p

  • NOBODY BEATS SRV...NOBODY!

  • THANK GOD, some one else here knows whats up, SRV is the best

  • SRV has a different style... but everyone knows hes the most talented of the bunch...

  • Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page Jimmy Page

  • i agree.

  • Cobain is a greatest artist...Page&Slash are d greatest guitarists in this vid....

  • Page vs SRV: Hard choice, but I choose Page.

    Slash vs The Edge: Really easy choice,

    Slash wins!

    Yngwie vs Cobain: Easy choice, Yngwie wins.

  • TE FALTO SWEET CHILD O MINE

  • Here kurt would say he aint a guitar player. In song writing, he owns everyone here in the list.

  • Jimmy Page vs Slash= UNDEFINED!!! Yngwie, not my style...

  • Malmsteen OWN ALL THE WAY

  • In song writing, kurt owns yngwie

  • kurt isnt even a guitar player compared to Yngwie

  • kurt isnt one of th best its not comparable...now if it was SONGWRITING yngiw ewouldnt evn b up here but its not kurt gets slaughtered by yngwie

  • Jimmy Page

  • Slash se chinga a Edge,Yngwie Malmsteen se chinga a Kurt. SRV se coje a todos.

  • SLASH PAGE AND KURT

  • 1. slash

    2. paige

    3. edge

  • Bad music choices for Edge, just listen to solos from "The Fly", "Bullet the Blue Sky", "Mysterious Ways" and so on live and you'll know what I'm talking about.

    Edge is outstanding and my favorite guitar player along with Slash. Everyone mentions Page... Page is history and vey over rated.

    Tom Morello is missing here cause he's also great and Kurt Cobain? Did he actually played the guitar?

  • Page, Slash(was that even a question?), and although I LOVE nirvana, Yngwie Malmsteen is one of the best guitarists of all time. btw, they definitely didn't choose malmsteen's best, watching Yngwie play Evil Eye and Far Beyond the Sun changed my life.

  • hmm... page.. unfortantly i LOVEEEE SRV he is one of my fav but ive loved LZ for a lot longer.. then slash .. hands down... then hmm cobain.. love nirvana

  • Jimi Page..(aunqe dificil)SLASH!!!AND...KURT!

  • Jimmy,Slash, and Kurt

  • Jimmy Page couldn't ever play the blues like SRV (nobody could) but is still an overall better guitarist. Slash and Yngwie

  • u spelled Stevie Ray "Vaughan" wrong...

    anyway, jimmy page, slash(DUUUUHH) and Kurt Cobain win.

    i really like SRV, and if he was against Kurt Cobain he would win by far. overall page wins.

  • 1-.Jimmy PAge

    2-.Jimmy PAge

    3-.Jimmy Page

    4-.Slash

    5-.Kurt Cobain

  • this is in my opion so if u don't agree thats ok just don't fucking get made or anything

    1. SLASH

    2. PAGE

    3. um i don't know lets see here i think Kurt

  • 1.Page - because I love LZ and Stevie was great, but no band-plyer.

    2.That decision is hardly to do, but one influenced me more: Slash.

    3.Kurt Cobain.

  • vaughn slash and cobain

  • the first one is a good matchup its a hard descision but im gonna have to go with jimi not just for his solos but for his all around guitar skills, the second one is a little unfair for the edge because slash is a monster. and for the third one, well i guess all i have to say is kurt cobain sucks at guitar lol

  • Slash and Jimmy Page FTW

  • SRV.....struck down before his time...he kicked ass

  • the ege suck hiry dick

  • page,slash,and yngwie...

  • Jimmy Page Beats Vaughn, Slash beats The Edge, I like the sound of Kurt more so im going with Kurt

  • it would be ignorant to compare those guitarists together, but SRV kicks everyones ass. Slash is a sellout

  • the edgesucks!!!

  • Slash sux!!!!!!!!!!!! Page won over everyone i am sorry but, if u think slash one you r retarted!!!

  • your retarded no one in the world even svr can say slash sucks what are you stupid?

  • The edge???? lol

    Jimmy Page, Slash and Ynwgie!

  • Mr. L.G. thinks that jimmy page is very homosexual gay but he play the guitar almost like a monkey like god!!!!!!!!!

  • jimmy page without thinking

    Slash is beast and kills U2 even if he's drunk

    kurt wins just because the other guy stole EVh's technique

  • Jimmy won. So did Slash, and I think a lot of people will say no , you idiot but i think Kurt Cobain wins. =) P.S Slash, is my fave guitarist.

  • page barely beats stevie but page is the best on here

  • Page beats SRV(by a little) slash beats the edge and malmsteen beats kurt cobain by alot. lets mix it up thoe how about page vs slash the edge vs kurt cobain and SRV vs yngwie.

  • maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­lmsteen oooooooooooverall

  • Jimmy page over SRV

    Slash over the edge

    Yngwie Malmsteen over kurt cobain

    OVERALL: Jimmy page

  • page vs stv umm, i think page is much more deep (debatable), dont really listen to u2 or gn'r but i still think slash focuses more on his guitar work, finally...yngwie malsteen vs kurt "emo master" cobain, where you on druga or something, i wont even explain why ym owns him it should be a world wide known fact...cheezits crust...

  • don't be an asshole.All the guys unless Kurt plays kinded of rock blues style but Kurt plays grunge. Try to understand that!!!!

  • each battle: jimmy page, slash and Also Kurt Cobain cause' he play simple combinations of power chords and the riffs that he make whit his guitar insipire people and freedom the spirit of youth.finally most of the people feel more entusiastic with Nirvana's power music than a solo of a great guitarrist

  • haha id perfer a good solo over nirvana anyday

  • match 1 is a tie with a very so slight edge to page edge vs slash slash takes edge out the 3rd match Yngwie is 1 1000 times the player kurt is end of story kurt is a average guitar player Yngwie is not yngwie offers up things on guitar that none of the players on this list too so he wins against Kurt I like Kurt but he doesn't belong here in this group of guitar players because each and everyone of them are better then him

  • kurt is good and everything but he really didnt do much with his playing. he played simple combinations of power chords and the occasional little cool sounding riff. the others are much better but i do respect kurt (rip)

  • jimmy page slash kurt cobain

  • yngwie looks like a pornstar at 4:45. page and slash are my personal faves, but there all good

  • Jimmy Page, Slash, Yngwie Malmsteen.

  • No need for confrontation of guitarists, because every of them has a unique style. And I think nobody should decide what guitarits are better than the other. But, if you ask me personally I would choose for myself Yngwie Malmsteen !

  • everybody says that kurt cobain is an awsome guitarist, but i dont really think so, i mean yeah he made some good stuff but he cant solo for shit

  • It´s a really really a nonsense to decide who is the best guitarist,because they work in different musical stiles and bands.Everybody is the best for their band,everybody has something different and unique,but don´t ask me to choose between Edge and Slash for example, because I will always choose both two!

  • pfft 1st place Jimmy and Stevie tie, 2nd place Slash, 3rd place Kurt, 4th place Yngwie then the other queer of U2 sucks

  • asharp12, Kurt doesnt suck, his chops might not be up to par with the rest of em', but he was an innovator, and further more, vuaghn and hendrix win, hands down

  • Definitely Jimmy Page but you should use the solo from whole lotta love.

  • The Edge really beats Slash. Edge is very different from the rest of the guitarrists, he always tries to avoid the solos and the blues scales, I love his sound.

  • for me its vaughan,slash,malmsteen and my favourite one is slash.Slash rocks.

  • vaughan, slash, malstemm.

    What's the song at 3:50? (slash)

  • estranged by guns n roses

  • its acually november rain

  • Jimmy Page, Slash, and Cobain

  • Jimi Hendrix is the very best though

  • HAHAHAAHAHAHAH EDGE COMPARED WITH SLASH

    I HAVNT HERD A DECENT SOLO FROM EDGE HE SHOULDNT EVEN BE IN THE LIST KIRK VS SLASH MAKES SENSE THOUGH

    AND OVER THAT SMELLS LIKE TEEN SPIRIT IS WAT ?? A 7 note solo or 14

    AND YNGUA PLAYS WAT 24 NOTES/SEC IN BLACK STAR hhahahahahahahahahahahaa

  • Jimmy Page anyday over Stevie Ray Vaughn (but he's good too) and Slash over the Edge plus i go Kurt Cobain over that other guy

  • kurt cobain sucks ASS at guitar..yngwie (even though im sick and tired of him) can shred cobain away....could* i should say

  • Jimmy Page without a doubt! Only you should've used Since I've Been Loving You.

  • Stevie ray is just too good

    I mean Jimmy page;s solo is timeless

    but in sheer blues power and feel

    Stevie ray slays anyone

    Slash is just pure geetar butter I love it

    And then...I gotta go with CObain

    MAlmsteen cracks me up

  • Angys won, he is the Greatest !

  • Yngwie is God!

  • page is the best of all time.

  • vaughan, slash, and malmsteen(only cus i fuckin hate nirvana, should have replaced kurt cobain with paul gilbert, so it would be shred guitar vs. shred guitar)

  • If this was based on originality the Edge wins hands down

  • the second guitar riff was a bad example

  • Well..

    First Match: Jimmy Page, Because SRV isn't that good here..

    Second Match: Slash, because he's way better then the edge..

    Third Match: Yngwie Malmsteen, because Kurt Cobain is an overrated piece of shit! I'm so happy that he isn't alive!

  • You are a real warm human being. I guess prison does that to a guy.

  • I never been in prison.. What the fuck are you talking about?!

  • I'm sorry. My mistake. I just thought that someone who is glad that a rock star is dead is so cold and callous that he must have spent a significant period of his life in a prison environment.

  • Shut the fuck up! I don't like Kurt.. He is far from being a rocker! He is just some stupid low life who couldn't deal with a little bit of problems.. He sucks when it comes to guitar! I'm not cold..