Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (205)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I reported this video as SPAM -- for being marked as "Earth Song Official Music Video"

    Why do people have to lie? -- and use trickery to get people to click on their video? Desperate for attention -- that's why.

  • This girl could be the next celion dion

  • not bad! I like it. not too far from the original but i like michael version better. not a bad effort though. gud work

  • At the beginning it sounded like a commercial

  • Nisha was invited to perform with Michael in London during first few shows.

  • zum weinen

    

  • ONLY MICHAEL JACKSON CAN SING IT!!!!!!!

  • she's good

  • Fotze dein Maul iss Scheiße zum Kotzten Fick dich und verunstalte nicht so ein guten song

  • @MrMissBales Bist du eigentlich noch ganz knusper? Jemand der sowas schreibt hat doch nicht mehr alle Zellen im Kopf !!

  • WTF !

    it's NOT Michael Jackson !

    Micahel Jackson Is Better !

  • I like the Pictures... VERY GREAT !!! But Michael's Song-Version is much better...

  • You know this is Michaels little apprentice dont ya?

    TY Nisha for speaking up 4 michael after his death. I'm so sick of the "MJ fascinated with boys" BS trying to suggest he only encouraged boys he invited all children no matter race or disabilty etc.

    I'm glad some people speak up for him TY.

  • nooo HD.

    michael is better

  • ich finds ja schon doof dass deutsche nicht die wahl haben, für gute Quali nichts extra zu zahlen, wofür hat man denn ne flatrate? (Antwort net wirklich nötig)

  • echt gut , fast so gut wie michael jackson

  • Ein wunderschöner Song und ein sehr schönes Video

  • she sounds nice this is like a female mj shes awesome

  • jedem seine Chance , sie singt es gut....

  • Para celebrar el Día de la Tierra este 22 de Abril. In honor our planet Earth, work for our home called Earth. I enjoy this version also like Micheal Jackson.

  • K First off, she was discovered by MJ's manager, worked with MJ, and got to do a version of this song. Second, MJ obvs saw her talent, and knew she would be able to express the songs message in the same way he did. I personally think she did him proud with this song! She did an amazing job, and should be proud to have accomplished this, and to have been able to work MJ.

  • Fans, we all know that it 's very difficult to sing MJ's songs beautifully because no one can get close to MJ indeed. The Earth Song carries such noble message to preserve the earth and the singer's voice must be very powerful to convince the listeners . Nisha Kataria has a beautiful voice and I deeply appreciate her courage to sing this song out to the world. This is not an easy task and she knows that everybody will compare her work with MJ. MJ is the best. Kataria is also good.

  • Great job Nisha!! Be proud of what you have acommplished. Michael is very proud of you!!!

  • come on. Everyone who likes michael jackson shouldn't listen to this crap

  • I don´t like it when people cover songs from other singers!! That´s not fair...and for me it doesn´t care if the song is better than the other one or not!!!

    MJ was an amazing artist...he sang his songs with his heart and with L.O.V.E <3 Nobody can sing this song with sooo much feelings like Michael because he REALLY thougt and felt so what the song is about!!!

  • I LOVE THAT´S SONG

  • Wow ! you got a wonderful voice ! :) keep it up ! but stilll MJ'S VERSION IS BETTER :)

  • najjjjjjjjjjjjaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  • yeah i hate covers of michaels songs most of them are soooo bad michaels version is better but i have to say thats the best cover of this song

  • I WISH MJ was still alive to see how many veiws he got =D

  • souless piece of self-prpaganda and earning $ from a deceased-star,

    Bad sining in general.... however, message appreciated, we sld love our earth.

  • what a lovely voice~~~! she was discovered by MJ~? what an honor!

  • But WHO CARES guys ? She is great. She doesn't claim to own this song or anything. Please, omg. Her voice is incredible.

  • tzzz Michael Jackson singt beser

    ;(

  • naja es is ok für eine frau aber

    MJ is geiler

  • i have lookt every where but i can´t find the REAL song i only found remixs and covers WTF?!

  • This is realy great! Whaat dont u guys understand about someone else doing the song? Is it bad for someone to cover a song? No one could do it like MJ obvs but still give her crredit!

  • I think her voice is still good. Obviouslly its can't be changed with MJ, but it brings this song a little bit differences :x

  • i like it, but i like the Original Better. 

  • I love it... The video is beautiful, and her voice is sooo nice... ♥

    Keep singing, Nisha! :D ♥

  • Beautiful.

  • Her voice is really amazing and unique but i think without Michael she will sing shit. This song is.. i can't say how amazing she is but Nishas' songs this is commercial shit.

  • Her voice is freaking awesome!!! I cant stop listening to this song!!

  • good on you nisha your really good

  • chill , she was one of MJ's artist.

  • ich wünschte ich hätte so ne stimme und könnte so singen aber noch besser is michael ! :D

  • Michale is always the best

  • Michael Jackson is the one has the right to sing this song.You are nothing without this song from Michael Jackson

  • Unglaublich schönes Video ... DANKE ... sehr gut gesungen ... PRIMA Nisha ... ich brauche nun deine Tour-Daten ... Lächel !

  • nice :)

  • nice and beautiful video ......

  • beautiful

  • it is execellent just like yours is michael............

  • This young lady is very pretty and smart; she also has a beautiful voice, but not every voice is for every song. I think this is more of a homeage for Michael from Nisha..she certainly doesn't sing his song with feeling and compassion like Michael did, but this is a nice gesture though. It's nice that she's paying tribute to Michael and keeping his memory alive.

  • bleah ..

  • she fucking killed this song..noone should sing it but Michael!

  • no talent here :D

  • no talent here :D

  • shes great not better than michael ones, but she dont need to be better, i like her version too :-)

  • Comment removed

  • How it can be, that MJFans are sometimes so unfair?You´re right: No one will sing like Michael! MJ was the best and always will!His music,dance&lovely heart makes him unforgettable!And nobody will take his place,NEVER Because he is the King of Pop FOREVER!Nisha likes this song and sang it!Whats wrong?She sang it wonderful! I think it was a heavy job to do it because its a high level!In my opinion she managed this job very good!I wish you good luck&that your wishes come true!God bless you,Nisha

  • @TTWFulda09 -- What's wrong is she lied by calling her video The Official Video. It's not okay to mislead people just so they click on your link.

  • The video is awesome.But the talent factory is really limited..

  • Ficou legal, MAIS O MICHAEL CANTANDO É MELHOR!

  • dose anyone know were the this is it eartg song video is??/ with the little girl in it??I LIKE THAT ONE AND I CNAT FIND IT :-(

  • vERY GUD VOCALS BUT UM I THINk SHE SHOULD WRITE HER OWN SONGS,ccause um it dosnt make me sad this just makes me think how retarded she sounds singing someone leses SONG!when mj sings i give more thought and feeling into it :-P

  • she is so bad and now she thinks she can become famous wih this song to and replace M.J. WELL HE IS NOT GOING TO BE REPLACE!

  • @adriangarza45 why are u so mean? shes just paying tribute to MJ

  • Did you ever stop to notice that your version sucks?

    Ahha ahaha hahaha.. OOOOOO.. AHAHAHAH..OOO.oooo

    Did you every stop to notice that you just killed his best song?

    what about all the verses you just ruined? What about Mj's rep?

    what about all the things that you said you? did you ever stop to notice that it wasn't your song?

  • @XFace3t5 you are right!

  • Thank you!

    +1

  • She has got beautiful voice, but Michael had the best voice ( ;

  • No one can top Micheal on this, but she does a great job and this is a beautiful video.

  • this is mjs song so of course mj is a whole lot better, shes good bcuz hello mj taught her thiNgs of course shes good the king of pop showed her a lot of techniques, mj did great teaching her!

    miss you mj

  • this is nice but it gives me goosebums on the body when mj is singing it....this one doesnt have the same affect

  • mmmm i dont like it

  • Nice voice, but i don' t think it's better than MJ's)

  • Dyke

  • does anyone know if she actually lived with Michael etc? x

    she has an amazing voice! and shes so pretty! x

  • stop it.thats not NICE! Nisha is a BEAUTIFUL singer,with a voice like an angel.She did it because she loves the song!why put her down for it.I dont like that!-Me

  • Come on, it's Michael's song. Why covering it? There can't be a better version, I'm sorry.

  • it was prly a way of showing her appreciation of MJ, after his passing. Thas wat i think.

    but i do agree that there will never be a better version than Michael's.

  • Well, this is shit compared to Michael's..

  • she is ok actually...its nice...but wen Michael sang it...it had more emotions...

    I'm not saying hers is bad...but compare to the origional..its no where near~~

  • @aV2eA well michael saw something special in her and even helped her sing this song so....

  • @aV2eA This girl lived with Michael I'm sure he gave her the Okay and he discovered her

  • @aV2eA 'If only the best birds would sing the forests would be silent'. I can sing this song, too! (i do, but in the bathroom;) She is a great singer, wonderful, charming person. Michael have seen her talent, taught, promoted her. Her voice can 'guide' you, turn inside out. Very few sing like that (i.e. Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, check 'O Re Piya') Enjoy, enjoy, enjoy <3

  • Original is always the best but what she did is better than other people who covered the song

  • Michael Kocham Cię ale Nisha nawet ok, To Ty z niej chciałeś zrobić gwiazdę, na pewno nią będzie! :-)

  • Michael Kocham Cię

  • Congratulations!! not much people can sing this song--- NO ONE LIKE MICHAEL---MICHAEL 4 EVER--- (I.L.U. MIKE J.)..

  • what a beautiful voice

  • her voice is really good.

  • NOT NOT!!! NOT NISHA KATARIA!

    Michael i love :**

  • il y a ke michael ki peu chanté ce genr de chanson persson d'otr

  • love EARTH SONG !! great voice NISHA !!! Diana-Maria / Berlin

  • Nice video...

  • gottdammnnn fuckin good ass jobb

  • I Think She Did MJ Proud ! , If Only He Was Here Too Watch :(

    R.I.P Gone But Not Forgotten King Of Pop x

  • MJ loved her.  the biggest star in the universe wanted to make nisha a star. i love MJ

  • It's alright... so dull though

  • I like her voice, but she shouldn't try to imitate MJ, no one can do this. She should write her own songs. But Michael was right, she has truly talent.

  • Ich verstehe das einfach nicht. wie kann sich ein künstler anmaßen einen so wertvollen song nachzumachen?

    Dieses Lied verkörpert den Hilfeschrei unserer Natur und nur MJ ist fähig die ganze Verzweiflung der Menschheit so widerzugeben. Sie hat aus einen wundervollen Lied eine gewöhnliche Ballade gemacht. Für mich hat dies keinen künstlerischen Wert mehr. es macht mich traurig, dass sie das nicht verstanden hat.

    Und dann nimmt sie sogar Mariah Carey's Hero. Auch nicht Akzeptabel.

  • Sie hat ihn nicht nachgemacht es ist einfach nur ihre eigene Version! KEINER wird dieses Lied so gut hinkriegen wie Michael, es ist eben SEIN Lied. Dennoch ist Nishas Version in ihrer eigenen Art einfach wundervoll! Ausserdem hat sie ja ihr eigenes Lied jetzt rausgebracht! Guckt doch mal danach in iTunes. Es heisst "Breathe"

  • Honestly this sucks. I feel no emotions. This is a complex song that needs the perfect mixture of dispair, anger and a tinge of hope. When she sings it, its not even faintly sad.

  • She's got an amazing voice, but nobody beats MJ in this-actually, nobody beats him at all. But can't she sing her own songs, and not other people's?

  • Michael sings better.

    But Nisha`s voice is amazing , too!

  • I TOTALLY AGREE WITH Locke2020  and 4everMJ09 !!!!!!

  • Very nice voice ;)

  • This sounds horrible to me. I can't hear anyone sing this song but MJ, i'm sorry. It sound so fake, no emotions, like she's just trying so hard.. NO, NO, NO..she needs to sing her own song. Maybe I'll like her voice if she sing something of her own. Sorry,..i am not buying into this.

  • I Love <3

  • Its still great~ but at 1.27 the wailing part and at 3.17 the bridge are examples y MJ songs are so difficult to sing.

  • Amazing voice, Nisha! You're quite fortunate to be the last to be at Neverland before the police did it an awful disservice. I hate the police corruption--it makes me sick to my stomach, but at least you had the chance to know Michael and develop this amazing talent!

    I'm sure he would be very proud of you! <3

    Keep up the good work!

  • WOW O.o

  • lol my teacher is her cousin

  • WOW What a GREAT tribute to the the man I loved and miss constantly!!! You have a GREAT voice and you are so blessed that MJ trained you and that you lived at Neverland with him what a blessing

  • nice voice :)

  • سبحان الله عز و جل

  • She has a nice voice, this song wasn't a good one for her to sing , when someones sings Michael's song no one could ever compare to him..

  • Totally agree with kissey. Nobody can sing MJ song~ Becos Mj put so much emotions into a song... gd singer might match up his notes but no one can do it to the right emotion like MJ.

  • You can't compare of course but , She DOES have a  very very lovely voice!

    She will go far!

  • michael discovered her and this just goes to show how well he could pick talent. she is AMAZING!!! she really did well with song.

  • shes not trying to replace mike her and michael were good friends they call her the lost girl of neverland cuz she was the last girl and kid to be neverland before they raided it and took over police.

  • :OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • Her voice is so amazing : )

    No one can replace Michael Jackson but she is not trying to : )

    Michael I love u and miss u so much and Nisha you have an amazing talent,you are so lucky.

  • Michael said she has a ANGELvoice..;)

  • her voice is great, but i dont like her accent.

  • michael is much better than her she should sing her own songs not only copy songs like hero or earth song thats not good....but i didnt like her much she has a funny voice :D

  • I'm sorry to have to say this: There is NO way she should be singing this song. She's not even on the same planet as MJ in terms of talent and ability.

  • shes really good but she should sing her own songs no one on earth is better than michael and everybody will compare it with him

  • Michael Jackson discovered Nisha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    she's the only girl to have been invited to live in neverland by the king himself!!!!!!!! what an honor!

    i love MJ and i love Nisha

  • i think it's wrong to cover his song , cause people will not see her talent they will only compare it with MJ version including me lol

    she's talented and i hope to see another songs written by her

  • ASH GOOD BUT NO ONE GET THE PLACE OF MJ

  • I dont think anyone could ever sing as well as Micheal. Shes really good, but I dont think shes putting alot of emotion into this song, well not as much as MJ does. I'd say her voice is good, but kinda average.

  • YES you write there no one get the place of MJ

  • Michael Jackson has good taste!

    We love you Michael!!!!

  • Apparently, she was his prodigy and they were recording together. She was going to be his opening act for the This Is It tour.

  • good

    but not compare to michael jackson...

    michael jackson is the king forever and ever

  • man, she really has so much potential to make good music. but this new-agey back ground music not only drowns her out, but makes the overall song just sound like crap. she needs to get together with some real musicians instead of just singing over some pre recorded track.

  • i think if nisha uses and showcases her vocal prowess to its fullest highest potential, we'd be wowed. michael jackson was wowed when she belted out a whitney houston song. THAT SAYS A LOT.

    i like her sound though. old school and natural.

  • Like it....much better than the disco remix version!

  • I like it

  • Michael Jackson discovered her!!!!

    hes a smart guy! shes wonderful

  • It's not that it's bad...it's that she's not Michael Jackson. And when Michael sang the song, he sang it with passion, there's no feeling in this AT ALL.

  • she actually does have a very nice voice, if you listen to it....

  • what was she thinking. this's awful.

    I've read that Michael was her mentor and was supposed to introduce her to the media but i agree with previous comments, she sounds only average to me.

  • Michael Jackson sing better.

  • agree.. Michael put so much heart and soul in that song, no one can replicate that ever..I wish her good luck, Michael Blessed her..

  • Excellent!> soeren - schnabel . de

  • michael´s still much better

  • nice voice.

    but she don't look so old as she is. (23)

  • This is very good. Nisha is really a beautiful lady and a great singer.

    But Michaels Earth Song is so unique. You can't reach that level of emotion in a song.

  • Her Voice is very Nice

    But the Orginal One is Much better

  • Maybe Michael liked her voice, but I think NOBODY should try to reach his amazing talent and NOBODY should cover his songs because he was so great, unreachable. She kills it. In her voice is just too less of the... aggression and emotion that Michael showed in his version. Maybe she'll make it with some new songs, maybe she won't But I can't see the talent that Michael saw in her.

    Well, maybe Michael disagreed with me, but anyhow.

  • mj like her voice thats y mj called her and stay n neverland 4 a while

  • I try but I don't hear an extraordinary voice. I'm trying really hard too lol, cause my boy Mike loved it. but her voice is good, just good. Nowhere near Great.

  • This version totally lacks SOUL!!! It's just singing with a big attitude (like "see what a GREAT voice I have" *hugh*). I don't like it at all.....

  • Hey but she did good, dont slam her, besides noone can sing like Michael, so i think this is a good version, Michael had a good ear, wanting her to sing with him, besides she lived at Neverland for two months, Michael believed she had talent

  • i agree, you have great vocals but this version lacks the feeling and intensity that made Michael's such a hit and moved the listeners. Even the other song you did, hero was vocally great but again, no feeling.

  • What made this Michael Jackson song a big hit was the feeling he put into it. At times he was almost in tears and then we feel his anger.

    This version, however, has no such feeling. It just feels numb and therefore the message of the song is unable to be heard by the listener.

    Another point, if you want to make it big, make some NEW songs. Think of the Britney Spears debut (Baby One More Time)!!!

  • Ok, I've listened to a few of her songs and I hear a nice voice but it's too commercial. jmho.

  • Michael is untouchable vocally, but there's something about this chick's voice that gives me chills...and for all those dissing this girl, understand that she has actually had the blessing of knowing King Michael Jackson....just saying

  • Great voice, Michael Jackson knew better, that's why he was mentoring her. Too bad they couldn't tour together, as he had planned. I wish her good luck in her career. A MJ fan from Phoenix AZ

  • I think she did a beautiful job I love her voice. Michael will be proud, no question.

  • michale jackson sing its way better but she has a amazing voice and i like it! and she sing it with feeling out of this ahhhh uhhh that here so she died in the next second !!!!!!!!!!!! hhihi well i like her

  • I am sure Michael would forgive her - but sorry its not worth to listen: bad arrangement and a voice with no feeling.

  • michael was better but stil good

  • WoW

  • nicht schlecht ...... aber Michael hat es mit viel mehr gefühl gesungen !!!!!!!

  • @Lindy384 Da hast du Recht nur das Nisha von Michael Jackson endeckt wurde

  • Michael was the best ever miss u :(