Added: 1 year ago
From: mglova09
Views: 35,144
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (114)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • its okay,but just okay,mabe if u in a club sippin crown,all sweaty n fucked up,but to really appreciate, NO!!!should have left it alone,IT'S A CLASSIC!!!

  • Not a fan of this. The vocals are fine. The arrangement is terrible. Some songs should NEVER be remade.

  • this version is garbage. i'm just being honest.

  • There are some songs that are best left alone, unless you perform them close to the original. This is one of those songs!!!!! I may like Usher and Robin Thicke.......but this version is SICK!!! and I am not speaking positive!!

  • I actually don't have a problem with making the song uptempo. Dance music can be sexy and sensual too. My issue is that if they were going to go in that direction, it should have been done in a deep house style (Osunlade, Harley & Muscle, Jay Denes, ANY of those guys would have done this song justice) or even 2-step garage (think Craig David or early MJ Cole). But in its current state, there's too much of a disconnect between the mood of the song and the instrumentation.

  • POINT BLANK.. THIS SONG IS FUCKIN WHACK.. THEY DETROYED A CLASSIC. YOU CANT MAKE BABIES TO THIS SHIT

  • WTF....FOR REAL...FOR REAL...I CANT BELIEVE THEY DID THIS SHIT...WOWZERZ...THIS IS LIKE THE NATIONAL SEXIII ANTHEM....AND YALL.... F...U...C...K...E...D****IT UP...FOR REAL.....DONT GET ME WRNG I LIKE THEM BOTH...BUT CERTAIN SHIT U DONT FUCK WIT..AND THIS IS ONE OF THEM...SHAME SHAME ROBIN & USHER...STILL LUV YALL THO..

  • Classic example of how to ruin a fantastic song by coming up with a totally unnecessary, crap and tasteless remake.

  • are you taking the fuckking piss !!!!!!!! this is not pill music wtf how u mash up the music so????? end of ..real tlk ..

  • These lads are good singers yes but this is damn criminal. Someone should protest this to the nth degree...THIS IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WRONG!!!!

  • Sitting and pondering why would they get Usher and Robyn Thicke to disrespect "The Secret Garden"...They are both outstanding vocalists (I love you Usher and Robyn) but some things just dont need a remake and this is one.....Im sorry but i say "Sho u WRONG!" Please return "Secret Garden" back to its sensual and sexy format....Start over and let Usher and Robyn do a remake on the same level as the original ....now that would be right on :-) ..... One Love

  • THIS SUCKS

  • luxo......

  • Is it just me or does it feel like ''Rape'' insted of ''LOVE''!!!! My skin is crawling!! I love Robin Thicke but this is horrible!!

  • Urgh, cant listen. Totally lost the point of the original song.

  • Not feeling it at all! They needed to keep it slow!

  • woulda sounded better if robin sang it alone without all the poppy dance crap beat

  • WHAT DA FUCK IS THIS!!!!??? I love, love, love the ORIGINAL version & respect Usher & Robin but c'mon wat da fuck!! son.....u all ruin this CLASSIC!! SERIOUSLY!!

  • Usher made the song awful.

  • I don't know what the fuck everyone is talking about this version is hot.

  • @TheWolfchi ...HOT YU RASS!!! THIS A FUCKRY!

  • Usher and Robin Thicke both don lost they mind next time do this song with Tyrese, Avant, Robin Thicke, Usher, Ginuwine, and Tank

  • oh hell no WTF is this shit............GARBAGE! learn how to leave shit alone!

  • The fuck is this shit??! This could have been amazing but it's...just....not...right.

  • What the hell?!!!!!!

  • NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The classic is THE only one that stands! Usher and Robin I'm VERY disappointed!

  • beautifull song great barry white kirk wallun no existing next song whyyyyyy?

  • They took all of the romance out and added Techno?????? I agree they should have left it alone or did a remake along the lines of the original

  • @kingofsparta2010 this isn't techno it's called breakbeats

  • i think these 2 artists are pretty good... but wtf?? they raped the song by putting that uptempo beat underneath it... this is one of the best slow songs ever.. it would be alot better if they kept it slow!!! i wonder if Quincy Jones like this ...

  • Both of them should write a letter to Quincy and apologize for this disgraceful mix.

  • WTH?????

    

  • NO SIR, THEY SHOULD HAVE LEFT IT ALONE.....

  • Omg ew! Highly disgusted with this. They shouldn't left this song alone. >:(

  • They took the soothing and love out of this song. I am highly disappointed in this song because I know the artists singing this can do better. It sounds like a club and f^^^k type of song and it also took all of the personality of this song.

  • WTF!!! Don't get me wrong, I think both these guys are talented...but WTF is this? It would be cool if they kept it a slow jam.

  • CAN SOME 1 PLZ TELL ME WHAT IS HAPPENING.

  • what the fuck is this i hate hollywood for this mistake what is goin on out here with these people ...and where the fuck was quincy jones when this happen and how much did he sale out for this time,what tupac said about him is starting to look true,..,.

  • WTF?? This is terrible!!!! Why mess with a classic? Coke learned their lesson with messing with a classic. Why ruin the ultimate slow jam??

  • i just like teven campbell little part the rest is wack pls stop mixing good music

  • Um...it started good until 0.38 seconds. O_o

  • Leave perfection alone. You have lost the very romance of the song. Stick with what you do and leave this to the originators. Its missing the class as well as what was given to it by Al B, El Debarge, James Ingram and of course the very silky Barry White.

  • @dvs1ne This has disheartened me. I can't believe they have literally tampered with the masses of great production. Shiz-Nic! This definitely wasn't the goose that laid the golden egg, and if Mr. Quincy Jones okayed this shit, then shame on him too; he'd need some Q-tips from now on. This was the best song and now everytime the original plays, i'll probably think of this stupidity. #F***ERY@It'sFINEST!!!

  • Leave perfection alone. You have lost the very romance of the song. Stick with what you do and leave this to the originators.

  • OH HELL NO. NO NO NO NOO NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! THIS IS A DISASTER. WHO TOLD THEM TO REMAKE THIS SONG. THEN THEY HAVE THE NERVE TO TURN IT IN TO A DAMN POP SONG. OH LORD, WHAT IS THIS WORLD COMING TO? THIS IS JUST A DOWNRIGHT MESS. I'M DONE

  • IS THIS A JOKE WITH THE MUSIC??????? WTF?

  • THIS IS TRASH!! Robin Thick and Usher have nice voices. However, this version and their voices do not match this song. The original version was sexy, sultry, romantic, perfect harmony of very different voices of James Ingram, El DeBarge, Al B Sure, Barry White. The mood was set. This was the perfect song and Quincy Jones was brilliant in bringing all of those unique voices together. A techno version of this song is just wrong on so many levels.....

  • @mariewilder I know that's right. This was the best love making music ever and now we have been straight f**** with this non-sense!

  • @MsYvetteCorbett: True. True.:)

  • must people dont like but i think its fine different because they know nobody can remake this classic the way quincy did so they did this song their way and I like it, the beat is catchy but yes they can do another remix with other rnb neosoul artists

  • why did they make it fast....ughh leave it to todays singers to mess up a good song.. they should left it slow.. it would have been aight... just aight...aight... not good not great but aight... smh thats like when they remade Cherell and Alexander Oneal Saturday love #EPICFAIL

  • Dis shit iz WHACK Y Y Y Y Y Y did they eff up a great song. Somebody should be shot. iI had 2 PAUSE it cause I couldn't even write this comment with my hands covering my ears. Damn Shame....gotta go now havin a heart attack

  • This is the Ultimate Disrespect! If it ain't broken, don't try to fix it. My ears are bleeding. #Wtf! I hope this disgrace wasn't released, please tell me they were playing around in the studio. It's not like it sounds all that bad; they just ruined the mood and feeling for the context of the song. Who the fuck is making Michael. Jackson noises in this song? OMG! I am so pissed. They need to get sued for destroying a classic. This is straight fuckery!!!

  • @MsYvetteCorbett: Agreed.

  • pure garbage

  • Sacrilège !!! Quelle horreur !

  • honestly the vocals here are amazing but of course that should be obvious because they're both great artists in their own right but I definitely could have done without the remixed beat. Maybe some subtle changes to not make it an imitation but still close enough that it doesn't take away from the classic R&B flavor and sound that the original version has

  • my ears are bleeding

  • I think Usher and Robin Thicke did there thing. people are just haters. I think they did the song justice. They are bringing back a hit record for the past and making it relevant again. And a lot of young people are starting to listen to old school jams. If you can revamp a old school joint from 20 plus years ago and make it where young people are into it tell me you wouldnt do it.. Stop HATING

  • @Taylor11152007 One thing I've learned in music is that people tend to get stuck in the past, or believe things should never evolve, or are quick to reject anything that's "out of the norm" (to them). It's like there's some unwritten law somewhere saying that if someone thinks a song is good, then no one should ever be free to redo or remix the song as they wish. This kind of close-mindedness affects dj's & producers who love being unique, trying new things and creatively experimenting.

  • @Taylor11152007 By the way; Jermaine Dupri did discuss how and why he created this production and briefly mentioned the fact that the original creator of the song "accepted & embraced" the record in addition to voluntarily agreeing to put it on an upcoming album. So, I guess... as long as they are happy with it and that it came out well done, that's all that truly matters. 

  • That was some TRASH!! This version was like translating from another language. It lost it's original meaning....the concept. You are not supposed to pop, lock, and drop it on this song. The words don't even go with this fast beat. Ugh!! Now, I'm going to look at the real version.

  • @nvunvme1

    amen

  • @nvunvme1 Hell yeah!!! We need to petition this shit!

  • I think I just vomited inside of my own mouth (apologies for how graphic that sounds). This was pure garbage.... EPIC FAIL! -------

  • this shit Is wack wtf!!!

  • SILK's version was MUCH better..... still cant touch the original, but definitely better than this one!!!!!!

  • WTF, OVER?????? They trashed a true classic!!!!!! This is a slap in the face of a Master!!!! No wonder it didnt hit the airwaves!!!!!! DAYUM, GINA!!!!!!!

  • they just fucked a classic up !!

  • mouth wide open!! No they didn't!! No they didnt!!

  • nothing beats the original.. i agree they should have left this one alone

  • this sucks pretty bad.... really bad.... its wreched. Who would do this and think it sounds good? #missmewiththisbullshit

  • SO mad at this! :( :( :(

  • Very nice remix, entire cd is excellent. You have to appreciation the talents of Quincy Jones to understand the Bossa. He's not trying to say anyone sings it better just adding the new hot artists to his old music with a musical twist of jazz, house music hip hop, etc.. I love the remix, he's a muscial genius. We are in 2011 time for change and need a way to bring R&B back. It's been suffering for some years. This is fun, you can dance or ride to.

  • I think it's a good cut~~

  • Na Na.......this is horrible....None of these niggas couldnt even touch Al B. Barry and El. HELLL NAWWWWWWWWW!!!

  • why the fuck would you turn this classic into a pop song.. very sexy beginning but still, you shouldve left the original record alone. IF YOU WERE GONNA MAKE A REMIX, YOU SHOULDA PUT R.KELLY. GINUWINE, AVANT, AND DONELL JONES ON THIS SHIT.... IM JUS SAYIN

  • @davemelodyghf yea it starts off sexy then it fucks up

  • @davemelodyghf i'm, with you it shouda been Trey ,Tyrese and chris brown and raheem Devaughn

  • @davemelodyghf WORD.

  • ummm no, should have left it alone #yeahman

  • the cd version sould way better

  • i heard this in las vegas & i had to buy the cd fo this song so worth it! & i love the old song one too

  • i heard this in las vegas & i had to but the cd fo this song so worth it! & i love the old song one too

  • -__- Trey Songz was supposed to be on this.!!

  • Not what I was Expecting...Not Hating It...but this suppose to be a Love song...turning into a humping club song isn't the worst thing I ever heard but Classic should remain Classic's

  • WTF!! BootyMIX on a Quincy Jones Classic!!! HELL NAW! Shame on all of them! They all have what it takes to BLOW the Record to #1 on top of all the charts. How DEGRADING! Poor use of everyone's talent. Usher, Robin etc, if this is how you gonna pay tribute to classic records, don't do it. Just remember that one day another artist will come along and Deface YOUR HIT record! You all are too talented to be putting out this kind of garbage! VERY DISAPPOINTED!!!!

  • i dont know if i want to make love or dance lol.

  • I just want to know where you people are getting these alternate versions of the songs from the album.

  • @beversane Quincy Jones came out with an album with these artist remxing classics

  • nooo they should have used tevin more and where were the other men in the song...why the hell is it a club beat?

  • this version is cool, it didnt need to be sped up though

  • robin thicke's songs r so intimate i like it

  • yea i loooove this song

  • dang dis video is epic man REVIVED EPICNESS!!!!

  • lllllllllllllllooooooooooooooo­oovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeee­eeee this..

  • I Luv this song so much, they did a good callaboration.......

  • it would probably be nicer if that fast pace beat wasn't on the song.

  • this is ok but not a song you can "make love" to. the orignal is still better.

  • i really like this...of course i love the orignal but i feel they did a good job.

  • Sexy!

  • Respect to the original ofcours but this sound nice ... very nice ...

  • what the damn! omg... smh.. omg... jermaine dupri.. omg.

  • AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL!!! THEY SALE ANY THING TO THIS GENERATION, AND THESE KIDS LIKE THIS SHIT!! QUINCY..U NEED KNOCKED UP SIDE UR HEAD. THIS IS BULLSHIT.

  • @hehblk this was remixed by jermaine dupri fool. what yuh knockin quincy for dumbass?

  • They sound nice. I'd rather hear the Barry White original myself.

  • I heard Tevin Campbell sing this on 2:36.....but wow sound nice but I prefer the original version

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more