@mmistry5 Nope, this is actually Noel's production. Noel said Liam asked him to take everything out and just leave the acoustic guitar, and that was the final version.
On reflection I think I prefer the album version :) don't get me wrong, I really like this version too, I just think the album version is so perfectly understated, it really captures Liam's feelings. I'm going to get thumbs down for this I know, but that's just my opinion!
Jesus Christ! They managed to rip-off two beatles songs in just one. The guitar is definitely I should have known better, and the bass sounds like the one in Rain; almost identical, except a slight key change. lol oh well, as Picasso said, "good artists borrow, great artists steal".
Love the Album version of this but this is much better, why was this not released as the single? The Baseline & Guitar reminds me of The Beatles - Rain!!!
@offspring13691369 Oh man :D. Oasis copying so much, you wont believe it :D. Listen to Waiting for the Rapture and listen to "five to one" by the doors :D for example. or listen to put yer money wheres yer mouth is and roadhouse blues by the doors, too Oooor listen to cigarettes and alcohol:D. And so on :D.
yes really good but i bet this was on the album,, and than the acoustic was then realeas, than the acoustic will be better,,, so they are both really good
this is good why wasn't this realised the whole is to clean in sound to me. don't get wrong i like the album but the demos seem to make the songs really come to life.
I FUCKIN' LOVE THE GUITAR SOLO!
MegaBanana51 4 months ago
one of the few demos that is better than the original song
santas20 5 months ago 4
Comment removed
mmistry5 8 months ago
I guess u can say this is Beady Eyes version of the song, b4 noel got his hands on it
mmistry5 8 months ago
@mmistry5 Nope, this is actually Noel's production. Noel said Liam asked him to take everything out and just leave the acoustic guitar, and that was the final version.
FreezerBurn1704 4 months ago
this is great! :D
2nile2 8 months ago
On reflection I think I prefer the album version :) don't get me wrong, I really like this version too, I just think the album version is so perfectly understated, it really captures Liam's feelings. I'm going to get thumbs down for this I know, but that's just my opinion!
BohemianArcade 9 months ago 2
better!!!!!!!! :D
jimmyzgames 9 months ago
Jesus Christ! They managed to rip-off two beatles songs in just one. The guitar is definitely I should have known better, and the bass sounds like the one in Rain; almost identical, except a slight key change. lol oh well, as Picasso said, "good artists borrow, great artists steal".
avsky123 11 months ago
kto, do cholery, głosuje tu na NIE?
who the hell rates this song RED?!
fcionsz 11 months ago
it's just like 'i should have known better'. great tune!
MLR13 11 months ago
great version - nice and raw
11mikaela1 11 months ago
it has got everything i miss in the album version - the long intro, the long ending, the harmonica...
Phyllocran 1 year ago 3
@Phyllocran that harmonica intro id from the beatles song 'i should have known better' ;)
MultiLiamryan 1 year ago 3
Live performance not a demo, either way, amazing!!!
BodaciousWickerman 1 year ago
Im pretty sure this is a live performance, not a demo
Christaphunk92 1 year ago
WOW!!! Should have been on the album as a hidden track. Thats amazing. Not dissing the album version though,its still class.
bonoman1982 1 year ago
The album version is about a million times better, this sounds muddled and confused and the guitars drown out the melody. I guess Oasis agree.
LowleyUK 1 year ago
@LowleyUK I'm not from Oasis, but I do agree with you.
Kozaack 1 year ago
cejudo
TheChum1981 1 year ago
whatever liam touches turns to gold
louismccourt 1 year ago 2
@Gyphia I think Taxman also
birdy47 1 year ago
the album version is shit compared to this!! Why didnt they release this one??
oldmangimpsuit 1 year ago
The harmonica sounds alot like "I Should've Known Better" by the Beatles. But, yes, I think this version is better than the album version too.
CaptainRockNRoll 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
2 Chords - 1 Universe
MultiTyrannosaurus 1 year ago
amo el solo de guitarra en el final
cross741852 1 year ago
Love the Album version of this but this is much better, why was this not released as the single? The Baseline & Guitar reminds me of The Beatles - Rain!!!
davekm43 1 year ago
Great version... anytime I pick up a guitar I end up playing this song! ( Most likely.. thats because their the only chords I can play ha... )
Derekgarlandmusic 1 year ago
geeeeeeeenious !
LtoTheSLukas 1 year ago
IsGreat, Louder than the final version, but anyway i think, boths versions are good...
TianCrash 1 year ago
wow the beggining just like I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN BETTER - the beatles. exactly the same, check it
offspring13691369 1 year ago
@offspring13691369 Oh man :D. Oasis copying so much, you wont believe it :D. Listen to Waiting for the Rapture and listen to "five to one" by the doors :D for example. or listen to put yer money wheres yer mouth is and roadhouse blues by the doors, too Oooor listen to cigarettes and alcohol:D. And so on :D.
LtoTheSLukas 1 year ago
@LtoTheSLukas
dave790 1 year ago
es increible lo que se puede hacer con dos acordes oasis es la mejor banda desde nirvana !!
carlitox3956 1 year ago
the bass line has been stolen from the rain and the harmonica/intro bit sounds too much like i should have known better
marky918 1 year ago
te AMO LIAM LO MAS BELLO K VIIII X DEOOSSS¡¡
27Flox 1 year ago
Where Can I find this version?
jonniemoz 1 year ago
Thank God we have them both (album and this)
TheRoseMarch 1 year ago
this is better than the album version.....a lot better....amazing stuff :)
bobbybansal 1 year ago
this sounds really clustered tbh and the bassline is from rain not tommorow never knows..
PedrosProductions 1 year ago
fookin' love the bass!
ther901 1 year ago
Sounds so good...as the other version
aeroalien 1 year ago
wow.this is a lot better than the original.
MrXxiii 2 years ago 3
this song reminds me of someone... i think she might even know who she is
jmoss69 2 years ago
Bass line is straight off "tomorrow never knows" which doesn't work well for this anyway cos it's too busy for the song.
posthumous5 2 years ago
The start: iiiiii shoulda know better with a girl like you! ha
jcollins32 2 years ago
they need a new masterplan for 2000-2008, and have this on there haha
jigglypuff1994 2 years ago
it sounds a bit like and your bird can sing by the beatles
manualfie112 2 years ago 3
this is sooooo much better than the original.......i didnt think that would be possible!!!!
TheTala44 2 years ago 2
in places the bass line sounds a bit like the beatles taxman
pcmiddleton123 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
pcmiddleton123 2 years ago
i think this is slightly better thn the acoustic one..
Oasisaremylife1 2 years ago
no queda caorde a la letra, ni la bateria se adopta a la cancion, no me gusto, pero como rareza esta buena
gosecamaleon 2 years ago
Some parts a bit like I am the resurrection ...
JTlat 2 years ago
that bassline was used in (Probably) All In The Mind
Slackerhouse 2 years ago
at the start i was expecting to hear, i shouldve known better with a girl like you..
tomelaide 2 years ago 3
Ha ha
TheWallOfSound1990 2 years ago
Let the rain come as they run and hide their head.......
bentheled 2 years ago 3
yea the problem with this demo is that the instruments drown out Liam
taekneek 2 years ago
Well it is a demo, a finished song would be mixed better.
w390024 2 years ago
yes really good but i bet this was on the album,, and than the acoustic was then realeas, than the acoustic will be better,,, so they are both really good
ukhouseRJ 2 years ago
i do like this version more! it sounds way better 2 me.
callmegene 2 years ago 2
de ???
Waitforme88 2 years ago
this is really good!" but i like the album version, more simple
MissBFan1 2 years ago 3
sounds like and you bird can sing mixed with i should have know better
PICHICHI90 2 years ago 6
spot on
Beatles39 2 years ago
this is good why wasn't this realised the whole is to clean in sound to me. don't get wrong i like the album but the demos seem to make the songs really come to life.
09mrPNJ 2 years ago
i should have known better
ive always thought that this is the closest oasis ever came to sounding like the beatles any one agree also go let it out
noelwannabe 2 years ago 4
bloody hell this is brilliant
andyrangersoasis 2 years ago 42
@andyrangersoasis Bloody
iShTaRaHiMsA 1 year ago
mejor k la original
sometry 2 years ago
on my life this sounds better than the single version?
jimmykinski 2 years ago 2
Yes. It does.
JPChabert 2 years ago
I didn't know liam could play the guitar
conombnm 2 years ago
he also knows how to play keyboards
gabittooasiis 2 years ago
Comment removed
89cheapmonday 2 years ago
great!!!
zimmidd 2 years ago
Love this version. Sounds like it could fit on Don't Believe The Truth hadn't it been previously released... B)
helterskelter1980 2 years ago
sounds like I Should Have Known Better...
viomartyr 2 years ago 2
kind of does viomartyr at least the harmoinica work in the beginning mirrors lennon's at lteast a bit
slider41 2 years ago
I think it's supposed to lol. The bassline is like one of Macca's as well. I'm thinking of Taxman...
kapnzach 2 years ago
it is
MaDFuRiT86 2 years ago
it's better the album's version..
xiwi01 2 years ago 38
like the album version better. Is that a harmonica I hear?; I don't like it.
tkslan00 2 years ago
better than the album vertion
desasterz 2 years ago 2
nope shit really is bad
ruined noels chillin in the park
deebabygirl369 3 years ago
Comment removed
Billster3345 2 years ago
ace
supersonicspringy 3 years ago
Superb version, really adds something different. Had this version played at my wedding, everyone was going mental to it. Superb song
psj3809 2 years ago 3
do you have this?? could you send me a copy? I'm trying to get this version for my wedding in Cyprus!!!!!! Pleeeeeeease???
k3826m 2 years ago
Comment removed
Billster3345 2 years ago
it's on the dvd equivelant of the songbird single
Billster3345 2 years ago
this a mint version love the bass shit fuckin hot!!
supersonicspringy 3 years ago
i prefer this one it sounds like something out of a hard days nite top or what
grundy901 3 years ago
Good version, liams voice is better in the latest version though in my opinion
julianbarry 3 years ago
So much better than the album version, they should've kept it like this.
PerhapsMaybe 3 years ago
very nice version the harmonica intrpois identical i should have known better by the beatles
mutttha 3 years ago
*__*
JeyPcrazy 3 years ago
sooo awesome...=)
wasp714 3 years ago
so much better than the actual version
teddyboysmith2 3 years ago 2
The jacket Liam wears in the video looks like something Bowie might have worn.
Does anyone know where you can find this demos? Is there a good bootleg CD?
anwiyayoukhanna 3 years ago
b side to the song bird single
smcauley600 3 years ago
the intro of demo version was just like i should have know you better by the beatles
yenrald 3 years ago 3
The one in the album is more to the lyrics, but this one kicks-ass!!
JosephGallagher 3 years ago
the lyrics are exactly the same mate.
lsdarcy 3 years ago
I maeant that the album version (Sort of acoustic) goes more accordingly to the lyrics. It keeps the meaning/feeling of them
JosephGallagher 3 years ago
only got it on the dvd version anyone know where i can download this?
dannytanti7 3 years ago
Get a YouTube-MP3 converter, they're everywhere. I use DVDsoft's
JosephGallagher 3 years ago
how do u download that coverter mate? is there a certain website you use?
bigdaveupload1980 3 years ago
That is the page itself, DVDsoft dot blah blah blah
JosephGallagher 3 years ago
Wow...amazing!
capukkione 3 years ago 3
this is so much better than the album version.
redsoxbsball3338 3 years ago
This song is amazing...fucking great...someone could tell me where can i find it?Cheers!
Lessio4 4 years ago 3
its on songbird dvd single
1001polly 3 years ago
thank you very much!
Lessio4 3 years ago
Great! Perfect!
Oasis, Love!
blueberrybg 4 years ago
como no
chivas!!! chivas!!!
Liambich 4 years ago
@Liambich wtf.?
doorsforce 1 year ago
esas voces porque no concuerdan!!
betoliam 4 years ago