I have a question if i may. Hajj Hassanain RajabAli says that Shaytan is composed of fire and the angels are composed of light. He also says that Shaytan is a JIn (composed of fire) He then quotes:
وقلنا للملائكة إسجدو لأدم فسجدوا إلا إبليس أبا وستكبر وكان من الكافرين
So Allah asks the angels to prostrate to Adam, he didn't ask the jins to prostrate. And Shaytan did not prostrate to Adam. Does that not mean that Shaytan is an angel as Allah only asked the
Do you doubt that God can create what ever he wants. Do you think to make a man infallilible is hard to him. Do you think that is to much for him. Look around my friend, God has created harder thinks then that.
Salamon alaikom brother, where did you get this idea that human beings can not be infailible and they make mistakes? haven't you read in Quran that the Shaitan (Satan) himself admits that he can not trick the "mokhlesin" (sincere ones)? haven't you read in the Quran that Allah says about our prophet (pbuh) that he doesn't talk of his own desires but only what god inspires to him? there are many other verses that has the same logic.
@gharib4ever first of all if u read any shia theology books they will tell u infallibilty isnt that the person cannot sin its that they choose not to why do u think thats impossible? that is a christian ideology that man is sinful and its his nature to be sinful if there wasnt origanal sin there would be no christianity we can make a desicion to commit sin or not thats rubbish that we are sinful and cannot help it
What you are talking abt is something different. The Christians believe that mankind are born sinful, which is not true and not what I am trying to say.
You might know about the Hadith where on the day of Judgment, People will go to Adam (AS) and say, You are the father of mankind, intercede for us to Allah and He will say not I have commited sin, I can not intercede. And so will other prophets except Mohammad(pbuh).
Do you think that Imams are greater than the prophets?
He's not bad, but he isn't very sharp in his insight! He also makes translation mistakes. He should always read the verse in Arabic then read the translation right away before he tries his own very weak translations! I think he still has time to become better so we should encourage him.
angles to prostrate? Because that will then contradict what he said about angels being infallible right?
gaydaontheradar 8 months ago
Masha Allah. Great presentation.
I have a question if i may. Hajj Hassanain RajabAli says that Shaytan is composed of fire and the angels are composed of light. He also says that Shaytan is a JIn (composed of fire) He then quotes:
وقلنا للملائكة إسجدو لأدم فسجدوا إلا إبليس أبا وستكبر وكان من الكافرين
So Allah asks the angels to prostrate to Adam, he didn't ask the jins to prostrate. And Shaytan did not prostrate to Adam. Does that not mean that Shaytan is an angel as Allah only asked the
gaydaontheradar 8 months ago
Wonderful, Masha Allah! I am new to the Shi'a path and have been a convert to Islam for over 5 years. Thank you, jezekAllah khayr.
SeventhHeaven5655 1 year ago
Quran is a fake!
Quran say Adam was created from clay.
but Adam come from the Hebrew word Adama (soil/dirt)
perrik7 1 year ago
@perrik7 wow really? what is clay made of? dirt or soil!!!! i cannot believe u just made that silly statement
zulfiqar501 1 year ago
@zulfiqar501 So why don't they call him Clawi?
perrik7 1 year ago
@perrik7
Where do you get clay from?
What happens when rock wheathers?
Don't be ignorant.
Have you even read the Quran from the first page to the last?
Have you read the Arabic and the deep understanding of it?
Common, wake up!
gharib4ever 1 year ago
Mashallah, may god keep and bless you...
MrPeaceMessenger 2 years ago
@gharib4ever
Salam o aleikum brother.
Think what you are saying.
Do you doubt that God can create what ever he wants. Do you think to make a man infallilible is hard to him. Do you think that is to much for him. Look around my friend, God has created harder thinks then that.
Think about it,
Salam o aleikum
tmt04020 2 years ago 7
Also to gharib4ever:
Salamon alaikom brother, where did you get this idea that human beings can not be infailible and they make mistakes? haven't you read in Quran that the Shaitan (Satan) himself admits that he can not trick the "mokhlesin" (sincere ones)? haven't you read in the Quran that Allah says about our prophet (pbuh) that he doesn't talk of his own desires but only what god inspires to him? there are many other verses that has the same logic.
Vassalamo alaikom WR WB
MrPeaceMessenger 2 years ago
Astaghfirullah el Azeem,
Human beings are not infallilible. They do make mistakes, including the prophets and the Imams. Imams were normal human being.
And Allah knows the best.
gharib4ever 2 years ago
@gharib4ever first of all if u read any shia theology books they will tell u infallibilty isnt that the person cannot sin its that they choose not to why do u think thats impossible? that is a christian ideology that man is sinful and its his nature to be sinful if there wasnt origanal sin there would be no christianity we can make a desicion to commit sin or not thats rubbish that we are sinful and cannot help it
zulfiqar501 1 year ago
@zulfiqar501
What you are talking abt is something different. The Christians believe that mankind are born sinful, which is not true and not what I am trying to say.
You might know about the Hadith where on the day of Judgment, People will go to Adam (AS) and say, You are the father of mankind, intercede for us to Allah and He will say not I have commited sin, I can not intercede. And so will other prophets except Mohammad(pbuh).
Do you think that Imams are greater than the prophets?
gharib4ever 1 year ago
He's not bad, but he isn't very sharp in his insight! He also makes translation mistakes. He should always read the verse in Arabic then read the translation right away before he tries his own very weak translations! I think he still has time to become better so we should encourage him.
Thanks for the video.
Daz20s 2 years ago
Translation mistakes is a serious accusation. Please use specific examples of the weak translations.
If you are so inclined perhaps you can post a video response and show us how to eloquently deliver an Islamic message. Peace.
hammadhaider 2 years ago
@Daz20s lets avoid the mistakes this speaker makes, and learn from him..he truly is great
AhlulBaytfan12 2 years ago 3
did it fulfil?
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
SuhaanALLAH.
QambarAH 2 years ago
is this at the ihow??
angelna0858 2 years ago
yes
ShababAlMehdi 2 years ago
@ShababAlMehdi Imams are not Infallible
nokia5095007 1 year ago
@nokia5095007 Please listen to the lecture and from there if you are not convinced than please ask your questions
ShababAlMehdi 1 year ago
@ShababAlMehdi Thanks
nokia5095007 1 year ago