Added: 4 years ago
From: alpet07
Views: 29,801
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (146)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Your voice gives me goosebumps. I love it :)

  • well done!

  • I love your voice, but where is the guitar? the guitar during this song is the most crucial part.

  • Gives me goosebumps, her voice is gorgeous!

  • nice

  • check out my guitar cover for this song. Pretty good in my humble opinion

  • Very talented, no doubt. It's more than ok, it's really good!

    Having said that, to be constructive, it could do with some more 'pain'. As it is now, it's just a sad song, but in fact, it is a painful text.

    Hang in there!

  • I never followed the words until you sang it. i was 21 when "Dark side of the moon" came out, but I was filled w/ Cat Stevens, JT , Crosby, stills, N and Y, America at that time, so i didn't get into them as . I was a part time stoner, "Pink Floyds" were full timers, tokin away. Those were the days. I like you version just as well, heartfelt and left me moved and inspired.

  • Love it.

  • nicely done............after 47 yrs of life i am indeed still swimming in a fishbowl......i have run over the same old ground, and yes, found the same old fears............

  • What a warm voice, reminds me a bit of Eva Cassidy. Nice cover. Hopelly you do more PF covers . Would be awesome

  • YES IT'S OKKEY, sorry for late but I found your vid after a long time, it's simple, like you, and you have a beautiful voice, very pleasing to hear. sorry for my English is not so good. Greets from Italy.

  • nice - and the songs great as well !

  • Beatuiful version of one of my favourite songs. I'm hooked.

  • Everybody thinks he can sing these days

  • Very nice cover! Your voice is so sweet! Congrats!

  • Very nice cover! Your voice is so sweet! Congrats!

  • Very nice cover! Your voice is so sweet! Congrats!

  • me gusto =D !!!!!!!!!!

  • great tone and melodic voice accompiant with your guitar. very Blue Nightingale vocals..... Nicely done...Robert

  • You have a beautiful voice

    And you are very pretty

  • i love listening to these covers and i do it...alot...and every once in awhile i get that one person that just totally shocks me and gives me a performance that i dont expect and this time you were that person!!...Great song...great voice....well done!!...only thing is i wish you had done the whole song...=)

  • Very sweet voice... should have a great future. If you're not in a band yet you darn well should be. :)

    

  • wow *-* thats beautiful :*

  • was nice but you turned it into a gospel, sry its good but you changed the message in the song its great but not to my liking

  • amazing deff not what i expected tho

  • are u single?? ^^

  • Awesome. not what I expected

    

  • please be my girlfriend.. 

  • awesome voice

  • If i could sing like you i would never put my guitar down, ever. Great job.

  • Very nice interpretation, very relaxing, beautiful voice and beautiful face , I´m going to suscribe :)

  • Awesome!

  • WoW, i really enjoyed this version!

    David Gilmour and others would be Proud!!

    Good job!

    S. Kuppens xD

  • Very good. I like how you made this song your own instead of just mimicking the original artists. This is one of my all time favorite songs and you just made it a little bit better. Thank you :) Keep up the awesome work. You have talent!

  • Beautiful! 

  • Oh Yesssss! love this, I have every Floyd album.

  • @MITCHWILD - Hi again Mitch :-)

    I'm glad you like it - thank you!

    I was just teaching myself to play the guitar then so I had to look lots at the music. :-)

    Take care,

    ♫ Hollyxx ♫

  • Wow... Beautiful voice... : )

  • @JuniorANDThays

    Thank you very much. *blushes*.

    ♫ Hollyxx ♫

  • WOW REALLY BEAUTIFUL VOICE PRETTY WOMAN

  • @bu6bo4

    You are very kind. :-)

    ♫ Hollyxx ♫

  • very pretty

  • @pinkfloyd458

    Thank you for your kind comment.

    ♫ Hollyxx ♫

  • i love......marry me!!!

  • Great vocal,

  • @owenmpk - Thank you very much :-)

    ♫ Hollyxx ♫

  • nice cover, pretty voice....pretty face!

  • Thumb up!

  • The key to hapiness is to singer for your own soul, making this the way to link you with the hero inside you... Good job alpet07!

  • Very good job. You have made your own way on singing. You did your vesion. This is fantastic!

  • A lovely version of an incredible song. You sing it so beatifully, it's a shame it isn't a longer song.

  • great performance!

    

  • I think you do a good job on this one:)

  • Holy jesus an angelical voice good job ! =)

    A kiss from brazil =)

  • As a die hard Pink Floyd purist, I have a bit of trouble liking this... but I like you, so it's all good. :D

  • i love you :o

  • You have a very pretty voice. Good guitar playing.

    I'm looking for critique for my version of this song, if you wouldn't mind.

    Thank you!

  • beautifully done!

  • i wanna see her do AC/DC "big balls"

  • absolutely atrocious...... no just kidding it was good nice job i sing and play to im thinking of putting some of my songs on you tube.

  • Great voice!

  • Is the capo there to compensate the key of your voice, Take it off if otherwise, you seem to play a G chord awkwardly, are you a classical musician?.

  • Beautiful :)

  • very good i like

  • loose the cappo. the song is too dark for it.

  • Great voice, you are a talent, no denying that. You lack any conviction or interest in this song and do it no justice.... Sorry.

  • i nearly fell in love while listening to your sweet melody of gentle singing :) your talent is limitless & i'm left wandering, why don't ya go on Idol? I'd vote for you :) great stuff :D

  • it's wierd sung by a woman ha, david sings special for anyone tho, you make it sound a bit country

  • Sembra una messa. Non mi piace, ma non vuol dire che non sei brava. T consiglio di non cantare però i Pink Floyd.

  • this is great

  • your voice gave me goose bumps!! oh and please ignore these morons and their stupid comments, they only criticise coz they don't have talent!

  • you raped it dude ..

  • Buana voz rubia te felicito, pasate por el mio a ver q te parece!

  • moving, entrancing , sublime

  • I like your beautifull voice... (:

  • awesome and so original !!!

    6/5 :-)

  • My favorite song, never get tired of hearing it. Nice rendition.

  • How I wish you would make the song longer. haha i like your short cover though.

  • What a beautiful voice for a beautiful girl. Loved it!

  • Thankyou very much - you are very kind :)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • nice job me 2 i wish

    have a nice time

    take care

  • Thankyou very much for your kind comment :)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • Very nice, love your voice and your picking. Keep up the good work.

  • Thankyou for your lovely compliment - you are very kind :)

    Best Wishes

    Hollyxx

  • pretty voice! good!

  • Thankyou very much :)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • Comment removed

  • sorry...that should have read related to Kathy.

    Ooops!

  • Hi :)

    Do you mean Kathy Kirby?....no, I don't think so :)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • Yes, I did mean Kathy Kirby. Sorry I typed in a rush cos I was going out. You have a great resemblance to her. She had a wonderful voice and a sweet nature. You have both and you look a lot like she did when she was young. Tragically she became the centre of much manipulation. You are i think and hope, too smart to let that happen but I wish you every success in your future.

  • You are not realted to Kathy are you?

  • Very good in a feminine sort of way.

  • awsome

  • wunderschön! liebe Grüsse Gitte

  • Very nice. Indeed!

  • Nice vocal

  • Many thanksfor your comment Chris - I am happy that you like it :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • wow that was stunning...it brought on tears for me:}

    check out my version=]

  • Thank you very much hockeyrocker - you are very kind :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • Lovely Voice and nice cover...love to hear more!!

  • Many thanks muller - I'm glad you like it :-)

    I have 60 something more videos on here, but I'm afraid I don't think I did another Pink Floyd cover ........yet :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • Do you have any from coldplay....love "yellow"...great song

    Muller

  • Nice rendition. I have watched almost all the covers of this classic on Youtube. Your voice has a country music tang to it, which makes the difference in this cover. You are very cute too! Keep truckin'!

  • Hiya joselourenco :-)

    Thankyou very much for your great comment :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

  • Besides you singing this great! WOOOOW!!! you are F I N E !

  • Haha! Thankyou pinkfloydmamo, you are VERY kind *blushes*

    Best Wishes

    Hollyxx

  • Holy potato, you're totally awesome! Your voice is full of emotions, and I like your version even more than the original :)

  • Hiya Miunni :-)

    Wow! Thank you so much for your amazing comment. I am really happy that you enjoyed my version of this great song!

    Best Wishes

    Hollyxx

  • Nice voice...but why did you put a capo???? It isn't necessary

  • Hi NEWPAGE :-)

    Still learning - teaching myself :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

    Happy New Year!

  • Thanks,BTW the chords are G C D A- Enjoy it(try to do them without the capo ^^)

  • Hey! Nice voice... And record without capo, it's better. Greetings from Brazil :D

  • Hi royryun from Brazil :-)

    Thanks for the advice! :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

    Happy New Year!

  • holly cow what a nice voice....kip on rockin baby...from philippines...:)

  • Hiya lilibethcepeda from the philippines :-)

    Thankyou very much ~ you are very kind!

    Happy New Year

    Hollyxx

  • really? please redo this one. please?

  • Hi nobodyspecial4u :-)

    Whyyyyyyy???

    Hollyxx

  • ease up a bit!

    You look so uptight.

  • LOL! Sorry about that standardbearer :-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

    Happy New Year!

  • play that for a guy and hes yours

  • Hi f1uf1uf :-)

    Haha! I may try that sometime ;-)

    Take Care

    Hollyxx

    Happy New Year!

  • Hello Holly,

    This one, I never ear it before.

    But your voice still a such good feeling in my ears.

    Miles stars ******************************­*

    Catherine♥

  • I think "Pink Floyd" would be "GREEN " with envy...if they heard this!

    (I know...I know...that joke really sucks!)

    Holly baby...you're the greatest!

  • Hi Pete - how's you?

    hahaha! :-D - you see, I laughed, so it can't be that bad :-)

    Thanks very much for your brill comment!

    Bye for now

    Hollyxx

  • Hi! Im from argentina, i've seen many of your covers and they are all great!

    SON BUENISIMOS!!!

    Keep on singing!!!

  • Hello whitechocolatemoka from Argentina :-)

    Thankyou very much for browsing my videos.

    I am very happy that you are enjoying my songs and I am very grateful for your support :-)

    Best Wishes

    Holly from the UK xx

  • Holly, your voice is beautifully wonderful and you have a natural gift.If you ever get to try out a song by October Project, titled

    "Return To Me" I would truly love to hear you sing it if you decide too.

    Thank You

    InTune27

    Thank You

  • Hi InTune27 :-)

    Thankyou very much for your amazing comment.

    I will have a listen to "Return To Me" :-)

    Take care

    Hollyxx

  • Awesome! :)

  • Many thanks Jilllapraik :-)

    Take care

    Hollyxx

  • Beautiful. Every interpretation you do is uniquely yours and better than the original. You bring tears to my eyes. I love that you keep your English accent rather than sounding American like every other English person who sings, lol. You are a true artist, someone who has found their calling in life. Music will fulfill you and you can move millions of people with your heartfealt and passionate performances.And you are sweetly beautiful too. Please make music your life. Have you been signed yet?

  • Hello again Ph... :-)

    Thankyou so much for another wonderful and very flattering comment.

    I am very happy that you are enjoying my music. It gives me confidence when I know that people like my music :-)

    Take care

    Hollyxx

  • ok i gotta give you 5/5 stars your so great its not the one that i am used to hearing but its better the way your voice flows with the music i love it please do more like this ttyl your friend,  Doug

  • Hi again Doug :-)

    Thankyou very much for your nice comment and also for the lovely stars - I really appreciate you watching my vids :-)

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • thats really good. you really made it your own, not just playing it how pink floyd did it. v good.

    i cant really see, but thats a kinda strange way to play G chord. how are you playing it?

  • Hiya BBKatsu :-)

    Thanks very much for your great comment!

    I'm not sure how to describe how I was playing - lol

    I'm not that good a guitarist as I am teaching myself with each new song. I just play to accompany my singing really.

    Thanks again

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • lol. thats kinda the opposite to me. i just sing to accompany my guitasr playing :P

    im ok at singing. i can sing this song well but other ones im not that good.

  • wow its weird it was really unlike the original, but I loved it! :] 5/5

  • Thankyou very much Curtis - I am really happy that you liked my version :-)

    Take care

    Hollyx

    ps Thankyou for the lovely stars too :-)

  • Hi Holly, sorry not my favourite song but YOU do sing it very well.

    Your one point two fan.

  • Hi one point two - don't worry - you can't win 'em all - lol

    TTFN

    Hollyx

  • Hi Holly, I've been listening to you most of my evening :) Although you do capture it in voice, I was kind of confused by the guitar. It sounds different...just a thought. My best!

  • Hi katanphetamine :-)

    Thanks for your nice comment. I'm sorry about the guitar - lol - I am not too good at playing :( I am teaching myself and only really play to accompany my singing :-)

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • sweet .. !

  • Thankyou beatnik....I think :-)

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • Hollyx..you are welcome... i am not a beatnik though :) .. god bless

  • Mesmerizing. Thanks for such a beautiful rendition of one of my favorite songs.

  • Hi MarvinLordOfMars :-)

    I am so pleased you enjoyed my version of this one - you are very kind!

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • Wow, a friend told me about this song and I am like pretty much obsessed with it now. I gotta say I've been checking through the other covers, but I gotta your's is by far the best one I heard. And your voice is just Fantastic. I loved it =)

    Keep up the good work!!

  • Hi ramiazar :~)

    Thankyou so much for your great comment - I really appreciate it!

    You may notice from my other vids that it is not really my normal sort of song, so I am extra pleased that you think it's ok :~D

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • you have such a beautiful soul

  • You are very kind sandu - thankyou :-)

    Take care

    Hollyx

  • nice version.. I remember this when floyd first released it. I play too & appreciate the simplisticy of your version. :)

  • Many thanks kenyachild :-)

    I am pleased that you like my version of this great song!

    Best Wishes

    Hollyx

  • The Original is in my Top Ten ever Songs!!

    Wish you where here sing a song live infront of me!? ;-)

    ATBFTLOC

  • Haha! Pink Floyd are still very popular aren't they!

    Thankyou again for your great comment hagensborg :-)

    ttfn

    Hollyx

  • I guess by "Mermaid", they meant so high-pitched. I'd have to disagree with that. This cover was beatiful and was a wonderful delight to hear.

  • Sorry for my incorrect spelling...heh!

    I meant "Beautiful"

  • Hello SHREDDER :-)

    Thankyou very much for your very kind comment.

    I am so pleased that you enjoyed it. I know it is different to the real song but I like to try to make songs my own, which does attract criticism sometimes - mermaid etc :-)

    Thankyou again

    Best wishes

    Hollyx

  • horrible im sorry for getting red thumbs up but i hate to see pink floyd turns into the mermaid.

  • Hi bengativo6

    Don't worry - I know that my music can't please everyone. You are very much entitled to your own opinion - but please don't change the ratings on other people's lovely comments.

    Hollyxx

    p.s - I don't understand what you mean by 'mermaid'?

  • I requested this song. I'm also a big Pink Floyd fan and I was unsure about the guitar at first. Holly was still learning the guitar and no one can duplicate David Gilmour after a few months of playing. But who can deny that voice? It's absolutely fantastic. And with total sincerity and feeling. No mermaids here my friend. Just one incredible singer.

  • Good voice. Really sweet.

    Try to learn the guitar for this song more.

  • Thanks very much embroidedjeans :-)

    I play to accompany my singing rather than sing to accompany my playing, so I learn as I go along. I know I still have lots to learn :S

    Thanks again

    Take Care

    Hollyx

  • you are an amazing performer i cannot wait to see you perform here in the US :) your music has an old world charm that cannot be copied, or bought, or sold, but can be shared

  • Hi choppermn :-)

    Wow! thankyou so much for your lovely comment!

    You are very very kind!

    Take Care

    Hollyx

  • May you should learn to play guitar better... your voice is beautiful ;P

    Italy

  • I learn my guitar as I go along - sorry about that :(

    Thankyou robott from Italy :)

  • Nice voice. This is a great song and should be sung with emotion...great job!

  • Hi marko :)

    Thankyou for your very kind comment :)

    Hollyx

  • Tía güena, pero qué güena estás y qué bien cantas, mi pinfloi de mi arma.

    Pretty girl, you are a good pretty girl, I like this song, Pink Floyd in my soul.

    From Spain.