Added: 2 years ago
From: lyricful101
Views: 77,717
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (365)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • as much as I loved Chris singing this, Lea is the better one for this song.

  • lea is way better

  • Chris is more of a Glinda, Lea nails elphaba:)

  • lea all the way! but i love chris too!

  • I like Lea but I think Chris sing it better.<3 Sorry.

  • nooo nooo noooo i love Lea she sings it best....my opinion she's the best singer on glee. Sorry. :)

  • lea is better <3

  • Comment removed

  • LEA sings better just my opinion

  • lea is way better she has better range and shes a girl this is a girl song not a boy song and chris high uglly girly voice sucks sorry to say but lea is waaaaaaaaaaaaaay better than chris

  • on some songs she kinda sqeaks and its a lil annoying,but she is still a great singer :)

  • lea sings better like 1% better

  • I like Chris Coulfer better

  • i luv them both, but i like them together

  • Let's agree that Lea's voice is Beer. It's an acquired taste, you either love it or hate it. Plus, once you start it you can't stop it. (Oh and Chris sings it better <3)

  • I love her voice! I definitely think Lea sings it better.

  • 15 likes and i promise!!!! i will sing this infront of my school

  • lea

  • both Lea and Chris are AMAZING!!!!!!!!!.

  • lea... <3

  • lea

  • LEA whoooooo love her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Lea sings it the best she is freaking amazing :)

  • i love her voice its amazing <3

    but she isn't really known as a singer mainley an actress :(

  • Chris sings it better - I don't like the way Lea sings this song in particular - she's amazing usually, though, don't get me wrong :)

  • Chris sings it better!

    

  • Natasha.

  • @tyshe101 Who's Natasha?

  • Lea. All. The. FREAKIN. Way. <3

  • lea !! : )

  • i think chris is awsome but lea is better

  • LEA!

  • Lea Michele <3

  • !!!!!!! POWER!!!!!! lol awesome! although the Curt version is more in my range (alto 1 or 2) o.o

  • rachel, i hate your guts. rachel ruins everything. i cant't even listen to this song without going on a murderous rampage.

  • lea u r amazing i love u so much and kurt is aman ....well this song made for awoman so ......

  • RACHEL!!!!!! sorry but Rachel hits the higher notes A LOT better and not just because she is a girl it just comes more natural than Kurt.

  • I think Kurt souds better cuz I know the story of the episode where they sang this song. Kurt's life is much more like the lyrics of this song than Rachel's. But. Both of them are really goooooooooooooooood! I love Glee!!

  • Rachel!

    

  • rachel

    

  • Rachel!!!!

  • I prefere Lea's version :P

  • omg glee made this song sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooo much better!

    GLEEK FOREVER!!!

  • Comment removed

  • rachel is better but she a girl and girls are better singers but kurt isn´t verry good

    xxxxxxxxx from holland

    (my english is verry bad)

  • @lovegleeQuinn

    Kurt is a countertenor! He's the best singer on the show! I don't hate Rachel's version but Kurt just sings girl songs better, and girls aren't always better. There are tons of guys who are a whole bunch better than a lot of other girls...

  • Kurt's version isn't on the same planet as Lea's version.

  • @Nimron12 Yes Kurt's is amazing too but i'm just saying that her version was amazing that's all!?

  • Kurt was definitely better !!

  • this was in a book when someone died and almost cried during this song -.-"

  • I think chris did better... less breathy....but lea's voice is AMAZING too!! both of them did awesome I LOVE GLEE!!!!!!!

  • I think that Chris did better than Lea, but her version is still amazing.

  • Comment removed

  • I love it!!!!!!! i mean Lea and Chris were amazing but Lea's version??!! speachless :O:D!!!

  • @Emmaa14xoxo Kurt's too !

  • 6 people are not defying gravity

  • @MrsJulilicious 7 now

  • lea M.

  • Lea's version gives me chills. She's supposed to play Elphaba in Wicked in a couple of years.  She was clearly born for this role. :)

  • lea sings better like i am jealous of her voice but kurt did good i guess

  • I personally think that Chris Colfer did a better job that Lea, but I still think her voice is incredible. (:

  • chris' is soo much better cause it folws better and i like him more so im bias

  • lea sings it way better

  • I love both lea is amazing but so is chris

  • CHRIS ( KURT) <3 !!!!

  • it's an amazing performance but i still prefering Kurt's version

  • @enagtiney: Yeah, but she (and Idina Menzel) can't really do anything about that. They were born with squeaky voices, and no matter how many voice lessons they take to "tame" their shrill sound, they will still sound essentially the same. And it's NOT Idina Menzel who's the Queen of Squeaky Voices -- it's the legendary Aretha Franklin, who ironically sounds like the one who idolizes her, American Idol "Donald Duck on steroids"-voiced Fantasia Barrino.

  • @enagtiney: You got it wrong; it's the other way around. It's Idina Menzel who sounds like Minnie Mouse, while it's Lea Michelle who sounds like Alvin the chipmunk. Either way, they're both annoyingly squeaky...

  • @enagtiney: I'd say her voice is an "acquired taste." Those who have gotten familiar with it, inasmuch as it sounds like a chipmunk's or Minnie Mouse's, and have gotten to like her personality don't mind it. I personally like her, too.

  • @joshgardell I like her aswell

  • Sorry, but Lea Michelle sounds like MINNIE MOUSE. Her voice is too squeaky. And it just keeps getting worse on Glee, where she sounds like MINNIE MOUSE ON STEROIDS competing with the Queen of Squeaky Voices Idina Menzel, who in turn sounds like Alvin from ALVIN & THE CHIPMUNKS.

  • Neither Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth do!! :D

  • 6 people have no emortions. Why is there even a dislike botton? lyy racheal

  • @aeris44 Thank you.

  • Lea

  • this version gives me the chills.

    but in a good way <3

  • i Love Chris Colfer.. But It LEA All the way.!!!<3

  • Chris was a hell of a lot better, as his character gives it meaning. To the bitch-tastic "Rachel", it's just another solo.

  • @CamilleMorinozuka please all the characters are bitch-tastic, Kurt being one of the biggest divas, why else would they provide a scene b/w him and rachel hugging it out? Then theres that Santana, just wanna slap her but i wanna hug Naya for her talent. I hate the characters but i luv the actors.

  • @aeris44 True about Kurt, and yeah, I really want to slap Santana. The actors are all great, but their characters need some improvement. Especially that bitch rachel.

  • @CamilleMorinozuka Yeah, Rachel just needs to stop being so abrasive, but the others just need to be better people haha

  • Lea Michele sings it alloottt better than chris.....if chris hit the high note in the episode he could have totally bin closer than he is now

  • lea (Rachel) sings it better by farrrr ... x

  • I think they both sing in a great way, but I'm just more used to Lea's version.

  • she really did sing it better. i love the way she sings!!

  • I wish I could sing like that :(

  • rachel sang it bettter

  • lea michelle (rachel) sang it better than chris (kurt)

  • I think the biggest problem is that Lea sounds so much like Idina. She can't help it, and it works most of the time, but I think that Kurt has a more original feel.

  • Chris's version was so much more smooth. Lea's voice is beautiful, but I truly love Chris's soothing voice.

  • i love kurt's version. he has an amazing voice. like. wow.

    but i do think that lea's voice is better for this particular song. she's just the better traditional singer. i still like kurt's character tho. and his facial expressions. they are the freaking cutest

  • this isnt the last series of glee it is starting in febuary in england.

  • @xthelinsx interesting comment seeing as glee's ratings are up from last year AND they've already renewed it for a third season...

  • pwned.

  • @xthelinsx Dude, stop dissing Kurt. Kurt is a lovely boy with tallent, and this is not the last season of Glee.

  • @Qwinette88 I never said I was dissing Kurt. Btw I'm a girl so yeah I'm just saying that not much people are watching glee now is because the fact that they dont want their kids watching it because Kurt is really gay and parents dont want their kids looking up to that.

  • @xthelinsx but whats wrong with being gay...? shouldn't people be accepting that?

  • @xthelinsx Ahh, well still, its been a very successful show, so.. yeah .-.

  • @xthelinsx -- Are you that much of a loser that you ignore the ratings just to suit your own warped bigoted hatefilled beliefs. Go get a life, and let the rest of us enjoy the show.

  • @SuperContinuum look im just saying what i read in the newspaper and saw on tv okay its people's opinions. plz respect them!

  • @xthelinsx Um, just because they are people's opinions, it doesn't mean you have the right to say 'sissy gay boy', especially for a kid who is the only kid in his school who has the courage to be open about his sexuality, and obviously these opinions are not very much if Glee's ratings are going up and they are having a third season, if anything you should be showing us articals and other info for this, so we don't think it is just BS. IMO, I do not respect their opinions, they are ignorant.

  • @xthelinsx nope, they are signed on for seaon 3 and Rachel is'nt a very deep character.at all. I love Lea Michele and Glee in general, but she can't always be in the spot light and not watching a show because one of the characters is gay is stupid. it's like like saying "i don't watch this show because someone's black on it" or "that person's jewish so never mind watching that". stuff like that has started over 100 wars. not saying u say those things, but just saying. that's a stupid reason. :S

  • @MrKookoobananas okay i never even said any of that shit okay its people's opinions. its called freedom of speech. no one can stop it!

  • @xthelinsx sissy gay boy! how homaphobic can you get

  • @xthelinsx You crap sack.

  • @xthelinsx imm srry but its not the last season if people have problems with the way kurts character is treaten than they can tell the producer and NOT STOP BEING A GLEEK <3

  • @xthelinsx if you hate it so much then why are you watching a video of a song they remade? P.S. You suck!

  • I like Chris version more.

  • Lea - hands down!!! Kurt's is OK, however...she nails this one out of the water...as she does with anything she sings!

  • kurt, kurt, kurt i like her voice but i hate the gasp between words and the gasp-word thing goin on dont get me wrong here, she is AMAZING but kurt (chris) takes it here no one can do everything

  • chris all the wayy baby!!!!! the way she sings it kind a annoys me. like don't get me wrong it's pretty, but theres no wow factor like chris's version (:

  • IIIIII TOTALYYYYYYYYYYYY THINK KURT SINGSS IT WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY BETTER. JUST SAYIN. :) I THINK IT SUITS HIS VOICE BETTER. :D

  • lea is technically brilliant, although i think of late she belts too much...it's not that obvious in this song but she's beginning to do it...

    chris's voice is so PURE. but that will mean he's castrati and i don't think they do that kind of thing these days...no, it's talent (: and i think it contains so much more emotion too.

    yup, chris is better (:

  • Even though both Lea (Rachel) and Chris (Kurt)'s versions were both good, I was clearly blown away by this (Rachel) solo.

  • Chris' version had more meaning behind it because of Kurt's storyline but if you put that aside and focus solely on vocals, Lea sang the song so much better than him. It's especially noticeable in the episode when Kurt starts to sing the song and then you hear Rachel's part because her voice just sounds so sweet and angelic at the beginning.

  • I prefer Lea's version, but Kurt did it so well. I love both of them :)

  • Lea, just simple as that she hits those high notes better

  • @madsis6 well chris IS a boy, so of course shes gonna hit the high notes better(:

  • @ttiffwashere I know, sorta what i'm sayin, nothing he can control just a fact of nature :)

  • lea is a lot better than chris!

  • both are good! Chris has a amazing voice and Lea sings really good!

  • they both sing it wonderfully...it just depends on your preference and the style you like

  • I think Chris, only because he's had more meaning behind it.

    In the show and in real life, but Lea sings it better.

    If that makes sense. xD

  • love his song so much!! LEA all the way although i love kris xx :) go LEA x

  • Lea ALL THE WAY! but kurt did awesome too. Gleek for life :-)

  • lea sing this better than chris, she's amazing :D

  • I think Lea is better, but I like it even more when they sing it together.

  • @eeflickflack me too they cant sing the other other persons part well

  • Chris has got the talent for this! WTF is this?! All shes doing is saying the sentences really fast! If i ddnt have the lyrics in front of me, i wouldnt even know what shes saying!

    My chrisy won the battle <3

  • serlylously 4 people didnt like the song terds

  • I think Lea sings it better. But that may be because my voice is more like hers and I like to sing along!

  • I loved Chris's version but Lea's version was just AMAZING. I was like ' wow O.O ' when she was finished. Totally blew me away!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Where'd you get this version? I can't find it on iTunes Store....

  • @timdatoolman83 search "defying gravity lea" in iTunes and it should be the first one that comes up

  • rachel <33 =) she is sooooo breathtaking and sooo amazing

  • I think rachel was too breathy but she was better

  • i luv both of them but if i had to decide i would pick............kurt....his storyline make the sonqq sound so much more inspirational

  • Rachel definetly!! Her voice is a bit stronger xxxx

  • lea sings it better:)

  • Rachel's vocals are jaw dropping... Her voice gives me goosebumps... Totally crushin on her hahaha

  • Kurt is any day better at dis song

  • chris nailed the song WAY better than lea ,

  • I think Lea (Rachel) sang it waaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyy better than Chris (Kurt)

  • @daemonsidiabilo she had a better and longer high f which is very hard to sing  it took my friend and i about a month

  • CHRIS! :] but Lea did uhmazing too!!!!!!!

  • rachel sings it way better

  • CHRIS !!!!

  • i think lea sings it better thoughh ;)

  • i think Lea is cause come on but chris sang it kind of ...... O never mind just really liked the way Lea sang it

  • It's not just about being in tune. Where's the soul? In Chris's version.

  • i <3 leas singing she rocks

  • Chris. No doubt about it. Well, in my opinion at least...(: i ♥ him(:

  • I think lea sings it WAY better. and i say that in a good way.

  • I think lea has more heart

  • Lea does...but i like it w the both of them

  • i like both chris and lea but i think lea sang it better

  • Definitely like the together version. Why choose between them, when together they can have the power of them both?

  • @Kimahri51992 true

  • lea

    

  • I do not watch Glee (yet). But I have been watching Chris Colfer tubes on here--and I am gay. I prefer Lea's rendition because it isn't pitched as high, and she sings it like she is in the part. Chris sings it in his own style, but he pitches much too high and I have excellent hearing.

  • cte video et tré bien mé l v☆t pa cel de kurt<3

  • i hate her but im so much inlove with her voice.... x]<33333333

  • i think they are both just as good but i do love Kurt and he can go higher but lea has more power

  • rachel's is prettier, but kurt did an amazing job because this is an extremely high song!!

    both are beautiful, but I pick rachels because i think its kinda strange that a guy can sing sooo high!!

  • LEA MICHEAL IS AWESOME!!!

  • rachel is the best to sing this besides the real people in wicked

  • i like the music note with head phones lol

  • rachel is definently better

    

  • A luv this song its a shame glee is finished on the telly

  • @MrsBieber307 um they're not done! they're coming back in september with 3 new members!

  • @MrsBieber307 Not for good though just the first season

  • lea michele definately sings it better!

  • I love the song but Kurt sings it better In my opinion.(:

  • i love chris but Lea she just is so good i love this song it's just so beautiful

  • Rachael is brilliant she is probably the second best singer because mesadies is the best ever i think curt nailed this sond and i think he suits this song better than rachael !! Thumbs Up If You Agree!! :)