Re: Top 10 Favourite Uneven Bars Workers Gymnastics Montage

[anthony66363]

4 stars Short Video

[gymnasticsloverxoxo]

I like your choices! May I ask do you not like Korbut on bars?

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

@gymnasticsloverxoxo no I like her i just prefer others

[FallenRose101]

I'm happy to see Beth Tweddle as number one. She's such an interesting bar worker, isn't she? And she's only getting better as time goes on.

[b1warwick]

I like your favourites! Very nice. BTW is that a twisting Comaneci dismount from Steffi Kraker?

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

@b1warwick yes, it's named after Kraker

[RhiannonMR]

This montage is great. You can really see the changes to the gymnastics and the apparatus in it. The skills seen are unique and I enjoyed that very much. The music worked for me. I liked it. I'm not real enthused with American gymnastics these days or maybe it's the COP. It's all starting to look cookie cutter and not in a good way.

[lauraITT]

Those skills are class - it's a pity a lot of them are not allowed any more !

[Missbottlenose]

Love your no. 7 choice. Lin Li is so graceful.

[gymnist2009]

U fuckinq spick

[gymnist2009]

@soccerchic1097 y wont u stfu and go suck on. A dickvrllyn u dont need to comment about every1 so stfu

[horseluvr999]

Woop Woop Beth Tweddle! Shes the best :) good choices.

[saai]

i really like the vid and the list, only 1 im missing is Olga Korbut but that is what i my opinion

[heeymi]

I like so much this montage and the gymnasts that you chose. However, I think that Vera Caslavska or Olga Korbut have to be on it, specially Vera, but it's my opinion. Thanks for all the montages that you make, they are amazing!. and I like the music too, I don't LOVE Nightwish, but I like it, and I DO love Sonata Arctica and the song that they perform together, beauty and the best, i think. thanks again! (Sorry for the bad writing, I write with the little English I learned)

[heeymi]

I like so much this montage and the gymnasts that you chose. However, I think that Vera Caslavska or Olga Korbut have to be on it, specially Vera, but it's my opinion. Thanks for all the montages that you make, they are amazing!. and I like the music too, I don't LOVE Nightwish, but I like it, and I DO love Sonata Arctica and the song that they perform together, beauty and the best, i think. thanks again! (Sorry for the bad writing, I write with the little English I learned)

[jrlassiter]

Julie Mcnamara gets my vote.

[gymnist2009]

i think they should take this off because the dont have nastia or hexin wich is sad \

\

[Soccerchic1097]

@gymnist2009 WOW. U R STUPID. hexin isnt ever her name! its he kexin! smart one! and nastia was elegant, but she ALWAYS had sloppy form and bent her legs past the low bar, look 4 it and youll c it! and he kexin ended in a dead hang and muscled up to the kip so sorry but u r an idiot

[MaebySurelyBarely]

Yay! Fellow Kuroda fan!

[TheLevel4gymnast]

You should have put Nastia Liukin in this because she is better than all of these people

[ThomasTheGymnast]

YES BETH TWEDDLE, WOOOOOOOOOOOH!

[spgrey]

luv kim gwang suk. i was sooo happy when i saw her on here as number 2!!!!!! don't reply this is my dads account

[huntasoup]

Great montage, thank you!

[volleyballgurly15]

i think Nastia and He Hexin definitly need to be in this! They are both World and Olympic medaliats on this event so they deff deserve a spot!

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Yes but using that criteria, Mary Lou Retton is an olympic medalist and there's no way she's coming anywhere near this list

[volleyballgurly15]

yes but both Nastia and He Hexin are good on this event. VERY good. I don't think Mary Lou was that great on this event.

[Soccerchic1097]

@volleyballgurly15 i dont know if you noticed...but that was a sarcastic comment...and so is this one.

[volleyballgurly15]

@Soccerchic1097 what comment? i have no clue what your even talking about...?

[PhenixJoe]

@MunchTheSilivasFan On behalf of whatever American screwed you over, I'd like to apologize. I have to agree that their artistry is lacking on the uneven bars, but certainly they deserve a spot in ONE of your "top tens." I respect your choices and agree with them, but your bias is painfully obvious. Sorry that you're so jaded =/.

[EdGringo78]

@MunchTheSilivasFan LOL!!!

[AlexCorralMexico]

@MunchTheSilivasFan LOL THAT WAS A GREAT REPLY!

[frankjunior25]

@MunchTheSilivasFan than you should change the name of this montage to----- no suggestions...

[tedsler]

@MunchTheSilivasFan I like the mix of 'old' and new gymnasts :) And obviously I love you put Beth Tweddle in the top spot, she is AMAZING!!! :)

[cherylannemason]

@volleyballgurly15 Comes to that, Nadia was a fairly dominant bars worker in her time, so were Olga and Elena Muchkina. This seems to me a fairly good mix of some obvious, some less so and with Tweddle, a promising newer talent.

[tedsler]

@volleyballgurly15 As the comment box underneath the video says "MY favourite bar workers. Not 'the bar workers that everyone else likes'." The people made it to this video because the creator liked them, not because they won this or that competition...

[volleyballgurly15]

@tedsler okay thats fine, i understand that these are her favorites. But if she dosent want to hear other peoples oppions/ input then she should have just disabled the comments on this video. Obvously when people watch this there going to want to voice there oppion as well. I never told her she had to change the video & put my favorites in..i'm just saying who I think are good bar workers..nothing wrong with that!

[tedsler]

@volleyballgurly15 Fair enough that everyone is entitled to their own opinion but when the list is so subjective and not based on whether or not the gymnast has medalled in Worlds and/or Olympics then why use that as a reason and say they deserve a spot on (still) her/his own favourite list..? If the maker had made a list saying 'the best bar workers in the world' and not taken medallists into account i would agree with you. but this list is still not about medals.

[volleyballgurly15]

@tedsler Your right, maybe I shouldn't have brought medals into this. I guess what I was trying 2 say is my oppion which is that He Hexin & Nastia Liukin are amazing on bars & would deffinitly be on my favortites list. Then again I never said she had 2 change his/her list so it fits my likeing.I just said who I would I like. Just stated my oppion. Thats fine if nobody agrees or cares!Lol Again if this person really didnt want 2 hear others thoughts then they should have just disabled the comment

[missmouse35]

well nadia was amazing, but not anything to get worked up about on bars, nastia is amazing as well, but she just doesnt hav the originality that beth tweddle and the others in the montage have. He Kexin wasnt known too well until after this montage was made. and to anyone who thinks Shawn is the best, u r clearly confused, her DISMOUNT is amazing, but its her worst event and shes very generic.

I love this montage! Could someone plz tell me how to get video for montages and just video in general

[nogymnast87]

i really like this montage.

your choices were great.

and who cares you guys if nastia or shawn or he kexin isnt on here?

if you think they should be in the top ten, go make your own montage.

and the music was fine with it too. (:

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

thank you :)

[Elemarth]

I love this song, too, but it so doesn't fit! Yup, some aren't so common. Very nice.

[nimh21]

haha i think you are the dumbass. Shawn really? wow i think you need a lesson in gymnastics. shawn didnt do the hardest skills and her style isnt too pretty.

[TwisterFlipp95]

a lot of people like kim gwank suk, daniela, and sveta, but al the others are very interesting!

i love how your not like me&everyone else who insist on nastia being el best :D

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Thanks, most people seem to think it's a crime not to like her

[Hasoginy]

@MunchTheSilivasFan: ya, and I don't understand why they like her so much, either. No offense to Nastia's fans, this is personal opinion.

[flopsyandcottontail]

Great montage!

I love beth tweddle she deserves first place :)

well done

x

[gymshiv]

okay, i agree about Nastia but he kexin and yang yilin both have dreadful dead hangs and Shawn is absolutely appaling on bars.

[natalienat518]

@gymshiv not really, i think only he kexin have this problem because yang yilin is taller than he kexin

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Sorry, you just told me that Shawn Johnson should be in a favourite 10 bar workers montage, and then accuse me of having terrible taste? Oh the irony

[banis87]

Kim Gwang Suk = best bar worker ever!!!

amazing powerful routine

I LOVE IT!!

[jaymibugs]

nastia should be on here

[ShawnJohnson8808]

nastia, he kexin?!?!?!?!!?

[itstheapocalypse]

That Korbut Flip at 0:56 is fantastic.

[kras118]

love your montages-- keep them coming!

[and now i'm thinking about my own top 10 lol]

[davies375]

very very happy that Tweddle is on top!!!!!

[bunnierabbits]

@davies375 of course she is on top. munchthesilivasfan is from the uk.

[dancerr707]

i difeinetely agree, beth tweddles the best on bars (:

[KorbutFan]

For the people complaining I think you've misread the title. It's not the best ever bar workers, but the makers favourite.

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Thankyou very much for noticing. This is my favourite recent comment :)

[filatovafan]

This is a joke right - a all time top 10 that doesn't include Nadia Comaneci - yet has the shocking poor formed Seffi Kraker?

Doesn't Nastia get a look in either?

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

I am amused that you mock me for putting in Kraker, who doesnt really have bad form, then asking me why Nastia is not in it. She, after all, has amazing form.

[theghastlypirate]

Nadia doesn't compare with the girls in this video. When Nadia got her perfect 10, the skills were simple compared to the ones now.

[rippedfur]

You lost me with your top pick, she wasn't an innovater

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

No she only has a release move named after her

[Richifaye]

My Top Three Bar workers are:

1st: He Kexin

2nd: Lin Jie

3rd: Yang Yilin

Yes, they all go to Chinese Women.

[goldenthroat86]

No disrespect intended, but I don't think Any of these are before 1992. Surely the uneven bars and female gymnasts existed before then. The first perfect 10 score EVER in the olympics...1976 Nadia on the uneven bars.

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Why is everyone under the impression that because Nadia scored 10 I have to think she's wonderful? And Ma Yanhong was the 1984 olympic champion, Daniela Silivas the 1988 olympic champion and Steffi Kraker was around from 1976 to 1981

[smartabarn]

what about nastia liukin, Nadia and He kexin?

[jumpinggymnast5]

did u forget that nadia was the first person in the history of the sport to score a perfect ten and it was on bars!!! and nastia liukin is incredible on bars too!

[1robertos00]

sorry... no Nadia????

[michelleyuk1989]

For China,I love Li ya,He kexin and Bi wenjing,Bi wenjing is better~

[xllamasrhawtx]

I love love love your music choices. THey're interesting and really go well with the gymnasts, unlike the songs most people who make montages use. Keep it up you're amazing!

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Thank you :D

[Fussims]

I love Kim, Lin Li, Mo and Khorkina!

Really good montage ;)

[mistybabe5489]

i like your list. Lin Li was so underappreciated

[lky1010]

Ma Yanhong is good.!!!!!~~but both are my love!~i want to ask that what's name of the background music?~it's so great!!

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

music is Over the Hills and Far Away by Nightwish

[zrcsoccer5]

omg steffi kracker is amazing

never heard of her be4

[caramelcreamsauce]

Only one thing: I would put Kexin/Yilin on it.

Great montage! Beth is my fave too!

[Mergoose]

I can't belive Nastia is not on this list.

[FlippinTitan2010]

YAY SILIVAS!

[nixelin27]

beth tweddle is such a great choice!

[ChildofPluto]

Great music choice!

[sassyfloridian]

Good selection, but you missed Li Li and Lu Li, Elvire Teza... Steffi Kracker's performance was sort of flashy back in the day, but her moves are way unpolished, alright, but it's your selection anyway... good work!

[Ropergirl6272]

I agree with Beth! But I think you should have added Amy Chow. She had the most beautiful stalter work!

[HUGSgymnastics247]

Oh my goodness! Back then, the bars were soooo close together!!! MY GOSH!

[isa1285]

Beth is my favourite too!!!!

[jawkneekim]

Ma Yanhong!! Amazing dismount. Great montage. I'm glad you added the old school stuff too. :)

[letsgetsomeshoes11]

Are these 10 favorites in order from 1 being your most favorite or just your 10 favorites in random order?

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

10 to 1 being my favourite. Though 10 - 5 are pretty much very close together.

[pixieofdark]

I think the music works well with the montage

I like nightwish too ;]

<3

[danielcnsilva]

I loved Mayu Kuroda. Did she stop on gymnastics?

[MostepanovaFan]

No, she went to the Beijing Olympics

[gn02257676]

Mo salto and Kim salto are awesome!

But personally I like Li Ya most.

[humbersidehusky]

This montage was made befor the Olympics. He Kexin wasn't on the international radar in March.

[miamivicepastels83]

every one of these gymnasts did something to make my mouth fall open, i love it

[myekay1192]

he kexin and nastia liukin should be there. and actually beth tweddle had a higher start value that kexin and liukin for event finals on bars... [a 7.8 i believe] but she messed up a couple of times, and that put her in forth.

[briaberger]

Bless Severino for making gymnastics beautiful again.

[flipnchick3824]

What about nastia liukin, and he kexin, they should be in there!

[995835]

@flipnchick3824 This is her top ten. She think that her top yen are the best. That is HER OPINION. I also like Nastia Liukin, He Kexin, but mybe she doesn't. So who cares?

[flipnchick3824]

@995835 If you dont care, then why comment?? I was just stating my opinion!!

[flipnchick3824]

@995835 If you don't care, then why comment??? I was just stating my opinion!!

[teagarden8650]

Sorry, but no list is complete without He Kexin. Shame on you!!

[datoucui]

It's a pity that Mukhina is not on this list...The Korbut 360 was amazing!!! I think her uneven bars stands for the highest possible level that could be achieved before FIG put the bars more apart as they are. Anyway, this list is already pretty cool!

[datoucui]

And I personally prefer Li Li to Lu Li...Though I don't know the name of that unique movement she showed at the 92 OG. What a shame she didn't stick her dismount! The same with Kim.

[datoucui]

Another candidate in my find is Dudnik. Well she's not having such a good feeling as others on the bars. But that mount alone is already everything!

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

Yeah, the move she performed is named after her which is cool :). I love them both, but i like lu li more. And Mukhina does rock, she did on all events, not just bars.

[clubtenNT]

dreadfully sorry for Mo huilan

[XLiPsINgiNinDArainex]

why? what happened?

[98764455]

wow Asian did better.

[lenita233]

i love this video *.*

gooooooooooooood job!

i love nightwish too !!!

[rachezee]

Oh yeah and I love Mo too I forgot how much I loved her routine.

[rachezee]

#2 was unbelievable, but I wish you had included Amy Chow. I think she was very overlooked by many. She was one of the few gymnasts who actually worked the low bar.

[daradriel]

number one should be Korbut =P

[isa1285]

Love that beth is your number one favourite!

[smsflippygirl]

#2 is sooo little, but still sooo amazing!!

[SchwarzeWitwe2]

Awesome! And I love Tarja-Nightwish, so don't apologize. :D

For me, my #1 bars and #1 AA is Khorkina.

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

I'm glad you liked it :D. Yeah, Khorkina is great, but i like lots of people :D

[MunchTheSilivasFan]

It's not difficult to be the best british gymnast we've ever had, but yeah. she rocks. Thanks for watching :D

[xplosive08]

COOL MONTAGE...but i wouldn't choose those...

maybe...

i donno...

chelsie memmel,olga korbut,mukina,li ya,mo huilan....only cos of her uber cool skill...i donno...