Tokio Hotel- Automatic-Coca-Cola Live-MTV The Summer Song (Roma, Italy) -Bill Kaulitz-Humanoid

[BillKichliebedich]

He isn't lip-syncing ! The person who made the video put the music over the original! Because you can barely hear the drums and when they sing live the drums are heard perfectly !

[Horsiedudette]

i'm pretty sure the person who made this video just put the original song overtop the video....

[Complicated065]

I was there *-*

[ZESTYWONDERLAND]

In Italy..Live Singing is NOT ALLOWED on LIVE TV!

They have to use playback because of censorship!

If you watch TOKIO HOTEL TV you will see how much it bother's the boys to not SING LIVE! They have to do these kinda gigs in places Like Italy for the fans to see them. Any NON LIVE TV shows in Italy........or other censored countries ar 1000% Tokio Hotel & their talent is beyond amazing!

[Pulina1998]

you know it is playback ? XD i love th ... you go to poland <3

[Galigatio]

I really really love TH, but this looks so fake :( i'm sorry

[FreiaOo]

I love bill's outfit in this preformance! so awesome :33

[PatrickD248]

he isnt singing hes lipsinking

[Estephania94]

xd tokio hotel come to peru

[crimsonrafael]

why the video and audio is in bad quality?

[SakuraxPwnsxAll]

awh i love Bill's bad dancing

[viggost375]

yup, definitely lip-syncing.

[KaulitzTwins2010]

Is it me or is this really blurry?

[ArizBillTH]

@KaulitzTwins2010 it is lol

[Ashleyzxx]

Right now, I don't care if he lip-synced, The way he was singing in the beginning looked like he actually was PISSED. : S

But other than that, Still hott. ; D

[taekwondogrl006]

@Ashleyzxx you're right...he did look pissed! Lol but I love this band anyway, no matter what <3

[mollySUiCiDEx]

quanto mi manca questo giorno ç___ç

[seraichigo]

Bill is lip-syncing here.He goes lower live when it's Automatic.

[TheMidoriAkita]

I love how Bill has a different hairstyle every time I see a video of him xD

[swifty4eva96]

bill we all know wat an angelic voice u have......but y u lip syncing???? anyway i Love Tokio Hotel!!!

[fatalhazardous]

he 's the best although he's lip sync . i dun want him 2 get hurt . :)

[therandomboy500]

Living Rock Legends!!!!

[kiaramelaanih]

I♥tokiohotel

[teakwondogirlz123]

I L.O.V.E THEM!! so much!! even if it is a playback!! they're still cool!!! LOVE THEM Especially Tom <3 !!

and Bill ^_^

ICH LIEBE DICH TOM und Bill!!!

Pls. come here in the philippines!!

TOKIO HOTEL ROCKS!!!!!!!

[luvspuff13]

@teakwondogirlz123 amen to that! :D

[lovemykaila]

GOLF PANTS ! <3

xD

[xkimiiii]

Love this song (L)

[pianofreak14]

poor bill, he must have had a bad voice day that day :(

they would only have playback if they really had to, so...!

love u my schweet Bill <3

[giusod76]

addio musica è stato bello averti potuto ascotare ora ho la certezza che non esisti più

[JokerMyWorstPart]

un grande

[joanna01051]

yes is real love in you sweet bill:X...luv u:X

[shayniitA]

i love bill y tu voz tmbien!!!!!!!!!!!

[blueice900]

love this song!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3 you bill

[xstuupidloveex]

Yeah, playback, but i love it *-*

[yohannHilton]

Playback

[blueice900]

love this song. my top 10!!!!!! <3 you bill

[Arukaaaaa]

is incredible,

he's voyce in the studio as the same in live :o

[TomminAnnettina]

Io c' ero!!!!!! ♥

[helleeno]

he moves kinda like michael jackson wtf

[BillKichliebedich]

Bill is singing Automatic , but this music is not here !

[flooox93]

Playback.. But Love this song

[ashisasa633]

r they on playback??? it sounds like it.. but i luv them to death:)

[rapsberrymoon]

LOVE . <3333

[tokiohotellover1221]

and i travel around just tew see there concerts yupp itz true :)

[tokiohotellover1221]

i was on the secound row

i screamed alot that i could speak for a day

oh gosh im so addicted to them buh i was there i love going to there concerts alot

lch liebe dich bill und tom

[th259]

zu geil um wahr zu sein *___*

[A1L2E31]

ajaja !Un artista se reconoce por ser original en el escenario...

Y hacer mimica no es ser original ...

No se puede decir que son los mejores...

Pero tienen buena musica !!

[cutiechipmunk123]

Iove the main singer what is his name

[himeno19]

bill kaulitz^^

[amanda999555]

Bill Kaulitz

[Wellgoodgrief07]

Bill Kaulitz

[xxxkacyjoxxx]

@cutiechipmunk123 Bill Kaulitz hunn:)

[LuluLithiummm]

WHERES HIS HAIR GONE???!!!

[applecake111]

New message from TH official website- NRJ AWARDS 2010: SUPPORT TOKIO HOTEL! There are only a few days left to cast your vote in the huge NRJ voting! Support Bill, Tom, Gustav & Georg now and make them champion in the category BEST INTERNATIONAL ACT! Head over to the NRJ page right now and show your love for the guys. >Ready, Set, VOTE!! Visit my profile page for the direct voting link XD

[TheKyoXI]

tokio hotel

¡¡¡lo maximo!!!

[IngaZork]

BILL IS GAY!!

[QueenPoptart325]

i thought i was gonna burp but then i threw up :D

[IngaZork]

Omg xD lol

[vanesa1410ful]

vos lo seras zorra de mierda no molestes a mi bill entendiste ? o te las vas a ver con todas las tokitas . y vas a ver como te dejamos entendiste?

[IngaZork]

I dont speek mongolisch?

[tokiohotelluvr909]

OMG!!!! i love T_H there like the best in the whole world and well i speak german so i think that they should do more songs in english like zoom into me they were thinking about not making it into english so yea i think more songz in english

[A1L2E31]

Sucks !!

Tienen buen sonido.. pero estan haciendo mimìca y eso apesta!!

[vanesa1410ful]

vos sos el que apesta imbecil y ellos son los mejores

[missyag94]

BILL (L)

[LucyValentina]

hmmm..I think is not live..I'm a TH fan..but they must it to sing live..whatever...at mtv day they sing live and is really good..

sorry for my English T_T

[vanesa1410ful]

en serio tu ingles apesta te recomiendo que entres a clases de ingles xq das pena

[killer71094]

he's not gay he just dresses like that

[dranzersfv]

anyone else thinks that he is lip-syncing?

he holds the mic so close to hide it, and the song sounds exactly like the cd version.

im fine with lip-syncing, but dam.

[amanda999555]

I think he is lip-syncing !

It sounds identical like the studio version

[x0xTHLover4Lifex0x]

@dranzersfv Yeah, I think they do playback for all the performances down for tv shows and interviews and stuff and only perform live if its an awards show, tour, or radio interview :) And I think its because they don't have the time to do a sound check first.

[Ashleyzxx]

@x0xTHLover4Lifex0x That, I'll agree on. ^.^

It could also be their managers too that decide this. : )

[emes810]

@dranzersfv Definately think hes' lip syncin. plus ive heard what he sounds like on live and the quality is pretty different. its practically impossible for any singer to sound the same on record and live. TH is a lot about the show and entertainment so... i guess the fans dont mind too much. oh and Bills been lip syncin for years.

[AFIafflictiion]

@dranzersfv hes not lip syncing.

lol it's play back.

thats why it sounds exactly like the xD.

i've seen them live a TON of times, bill sounds different live [better]

you can tell he doesnt lip sync though Dx

[xforeverfadingx]

@dranzersfv As much as I hate to say it, I don't think he's lip-syncing, I think they're using Autotune...which is worse in my book, but whatever. x.x He used to sing entirely live, though, when he did Schrei and Zimmer 483 and Scream.

[Dogwithnolife]

@dranzersfv no the dude just put it on mute and played the cd one

[ForbiddenRose22]

@dranzersfv yes, theyre lipsinging... i ,3 tokio hotel but i dont like that hes lipsinging

[ZESTYWONDERLAND]

@dranzersfv IT's the Venue(MTV Italy) only allows playback & not Real Live.....it's their from of censorship.

Bill & The Guys HATE doing gigs like that! However, certain countries & venues will not allow real LIVE show.......so they have to do it for the fans.

[MinningAround]

@dranzersfv I don't think he lip syncs. All singers hold the mic close, so close that it is usually touching the lips. They do perform with a backing track at times though. Rarely it seems, there is a mystery instrument in the mix and it isn't being played by anyone.

[RawnsSecretSister]

@dranzersfv Well sometimes it's not the bands choice if the lip sync just saying...

[bannanna215]

@dranzersfv I think it's because he wasn't ready to sing automatic live at the time.

[andy147LarisakoSs]

@dranzersfv well actually he is singing!! because i was thre and it was real!! but this videos is not real..! the sound HERE is back up not on stage!! :) love you TK!!!!

[bboywilsen]

i love tokio hotel before. please change back tokio hotel., back to your original hairstyles and tokio hotel tv.

[DjHottieeWasabi]

i love TH, but I just HATE bills new style here!!!!!! Bill, please change, NOW!

[vVkaPewVv]

Fuck up your coMMents...!!! BILL IS NOT GAY....!!!

HE JUST LOOK LIKE A GURL ^_^ how sweet...

and I like the hairdoo

[spartaner0815]

is the singer a girl or just gay?

[TomKaulitzXParamoreX]

@spartaner0815 it a guy n no he is not gay

[kataxtitis]

fuck off idiot

[marildaJB]

sou super fam delis

adooooooooooooooooooooooooooro

[MsBoterkoek]

Tokio hotel is so f*cking Awesome <3

[br34kth3ch41ns]

LMFAO, why is everyone freaking out cos this is a playback?

alot of performers that day did it was well.

[br34kth3ch41ns]

those are some tight pants, gustav. ;D

[flowergardengal]

I think maybe someone did put a sound clip in because i just watched on another posting singing automatic and it was live and they sounded great and he can hit the high notes they are great live i hope to see them in concert

loving tokio hotel in kentucky :)

[ginna86]

sounds like someone put the song to the clip as u cant even hear the fans only at the start and end

[ryceskate]

Okay, I do like these guys, but this is a lipsync. Whes he hits the high notes, he can't do that robotic voice alter himself. And the song has two guitar parts. Tom can't play both parts at once without it being a playback. I don't like watching these guys live on stage, or any of their videos. Majority of them I've noticed were playbacks.

[br34kth3ch41ns]

@ryceskate they do that for most awards shows and public appearances, but not their own concerts. and everyone does it in musicvideos, :l

[internetlover100]

丰 All TH fans go to Musiqtone's website and vote for 'Automatic' as "Video of the Year" in "The Count". Voting ends January 15th at midnight! Vote 50 times each day. Simply go to Musiqtone . com, scroll over "Music" then click on "The Count". Happy Voting! 丰

[Holly2743]

playback !?!?!?

[TheGothstar2]

he's not actually singing live??? is he??? i believe its a playback and that he 's actually lipsynching!!! its obvious!

[tinkerrbella345]

@TheGothstar2 WAT HE LIP SINGS....NOO FREAKN WAYYY

[TheGothstar2]

@tinkerrbella345 listn well he's not singing live!!

[subforsubbbb]

i dont like  tokio hotel but i really luv da song!!

[bozu213]

fukc thoes guy arnt even tired

they are playing the show kick back

[jonasloverist]

i mean he never lip sing!

[LoTmS17]

it's lip sync

[jonasloverist]

no!

[Aprilyoung]

i believe he can sing well its just that maybe if hell sing humanoid tracks continously it will strain his voice:) remember that he got an operaxon

[mrdong2007]

bunch of quermos!!!!

[horizonlancer]

quit hatin cuz you cant sing or even get a gf fucktard

[CristianaSpinu]

I know that Bill sing very well.I love very much TH and I don't want to say bad things about them:(

But I think this is playback..it sounds to perfect.If it's true....I will be very disapointed because Bill has a beautiful voice and his voice was made for singing live:(:(

I will always love TH!!!!!!!!<3<3

I'm sorry if I didn't write well the words..I'm from Romania:):)

[KenzieLynnLovesLife]

omng i luv his hair in this vid

[Bellepepper92]

LIP SYNCHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheGothstar2]

@Bellepepper92 ... i hate to say this cuz i'm really a great fan ... but i agree wiz U!!! i dnt think he's singing live!

[Ninismegis]

Bills röv!:D

[distoyedyou]

why is so hard to people belive that Bill sing so well ?? On dvd he sing live and is most perfect !!! Bill not use playback ¬¬

[tmh1717]

@distoyedyou probably cuz they think he cant look that cool and sing so perfect at the same time ha

[hikarutagamy]

uummm playdizk

ezkuchen bien lq segunda voz del fondo de la cancion y si miran la acustica no hay segunda vo0oz

es identika a la del cd

la verdad q aora zi ze pazar0on

=(

[DurchDenMonsun4e]

C'ero anche io! FANTASTICIIIII! Comunque ragazzi, non è in playback, questo è stato trasmesso in TV, e in TV non fanno sentire le voci live..prendono le canzoni dal computer e le coordinano col video..in realtà loro hanno cantato veramente.

[mollySUiCiDEx]

è veroooo! non stavano cantando in playback!

[TokioHotelGirl96]

io c'eroooo k kasinooo sn trp braviiiii *-*

[delfhii]

Playback :'(

[drummersuicide]

no duh its playback...

but you need to realize that EVERY ARTIST uses playback sometimes...

i mean ya they could have done it live but whatever! just be glad theyre on MTV

[graziana123]

nn so proprio coosa dire per esprimere tutto il mio naffetto e l'amore per i tokio hotel

[ahon01]

aw mamw

[xxAnCafePowaxx]

Sa va.On sait tous ce que c'est du Playback.--'

[andrea57024]

yeah its playback because this isnot a concert (just publicitty i think ) their album humanoid d been recently public so the shouldn't play it in mtv !

[KristinaMWA]

I LOVE BILL KAULITZ BEST SONG EVER

[rockislife1000]

i love this song..

but they didn't sing it live

:'(

[michellesnake123]

Playback

[presiozazexy]

:o soo cool nais tokitha(to)

[Ashluv085]

Woah woah woah woah woah. this is so a play back.lol. cause there is no way he can hit the REAL exactly like that! it sounds animated and everything. Now if he can props to him! but seriously. can some one put the reaaalll version!!!! and he's so friigggeeennn hot!!!! even though he kinda loooks like a girl but hes a hot bou.:)

[madelares]

play back

[Hanielo]

PLAYBACK!

[ravenhawk6910]

playback.

[xXGeisterfahrerXx]

this is my favorvite song

[dickandsmithh]

I think that its just awsome that they sound pretty much just like the album.

[TechnoGirly1996]

Ich liebe euch TOKIO HOTEL ich bin der größte fan von euch fahre zu jedem einzelen Konzert egal in welchen land ich war auf jedem Konzert von euch ich liebe euch ich kann ohne eure musik nicht leben ich habe alle CDs von euch und überall in meinen zimmer hängen Poster von euch ich liebe euch

[StoryxDead]

I love ...

[ikbengeenkoe]

i am just a smart man trying to convince some of their fans, realy wtf... they dont look cool at all, and their songs suck so.

[rocknalternative]

the singer always has a cool hairstyle all the time although he changes it a bunch and theyre songs are good because they have meaning

[Vettorziiinh]

Playback !

[LarissaLoves]

Gustaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaav *-*

[tigercubb7]

i love this song so much! i recorded my own version of it and i would love to know what all you TH fans out there think about it! its on my channel =D

[PLNataliaDK]

Why dident they show him sing this song on Tv??? :(

[dreamzxoxo]

guys stfu about the play back.

obviously its not the REAL live video.

you can tell .

so stfu .

i love billlll <3

[ucca100]

god...what is your problem if they make playback?seriously now...if you don`t like them..then why do you listen to them?at least they sing something...that is really god...so don`t you loke them don`t criticize them ....mad people:O:O

many people are very stupid:O...

god..!

love them:X:X

forever:P

[ucca100]

they are so cool:X...

and..what`s the problem if they make playback?

this people is so stupd...god!

at least they sing..what`s your problem?

if you don`t like them..then why do you listen to them and then criticize them..:-w.../:)...stupid people

[tomek0408]

PlayBackPlayBackPlayBackPlayBa­ckPlayBackPlayBackPlayBackPlay­BackPlayBackPlayBackPlayBackPl­ayBackPlayBack

PlayBackPlayBackPlayBackPlayBa­ckPlayBackPlayBackPlayBackPlay­BackPlayBackPlayBackPlayBackPl­ayBack

[ikbengeenkoe]

polio hotel!!!!

guys... seriously... what the f**k

go get a live and don't listen to this shit.

the singer is gay/lesbo. i think bil means gay in usa. fuck all tokio hotel songs. they suck too. dont spam me, bcous you are angry I am just telling facts. well 1 thing left to say. FAGS

[Susukeyup5555555]

@ikbengeenkoe - If you think their gay here's a hint. DON'T LISTEN TO THEM! Stupid ass...

[HeliKaaayy]

Oh my goodness.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE THEM, STOP FUCKING LISTENING TO THEIR SONGS & STOP LOOKING AT THEIR VIDEOS.

seriously.

[TheMadsling1]

same goes with jobros. everyone says they are fags but they get 1000x more pussy than you will ever get. they can just snap their fingers and 10k girls line up.

[BillKaulitzLuvMyHart]

I belive that Coca cola put the song over the performance

[Bizarrehotel108]

i love tokio hotel they rock they r 1 of the best bands in the entire world

[tigercubb7]

I love tokio's single automatic so much i recorded my own version and made a vid with pictures of me and the guys =) I would love to know what you think about it! Its on my page

[m0nxXx3kaulitz]

te amo bill

[terelovegirlTH]

esta claro k ahi bill hace playback x lo k sea pero lo hace !!!

I'm speaking spanish

sorry xD

[pumkinpie5]

ok heres the thing. i live in america tokio hotel is my fav band and has been forever!! their goin on tour in 2010 in europe,russia ya know places like that!!! i was so mad when i found out!!!

[carmenmadcas]

Rammstien Is Better Than This :) Trust Me No PlayBack In Rammstien TH=PlayBack

[elllsee]

rammstein and tokio hotel have completely different styles, it's stupid to compare them.

tool.

[kleyssen]

AwEsoMe -!!!!!!!!!!!

KOMO sIEMpre MArkaNDO la DIfeReNCia

[thehopeneverdie]

ой,Билл что у тя с волосами? да.меняется так меняется..

[Deine93]

Playback isn't Bill's choice... I'm Italian and I know (unfortunately) that italian' s music programs are ALWAYS like this!

Playback, playback and playback!!

Il playback in Italia è una cosa ormai quotidiana, tutti i nostri programmi musicali utilizzano il playback... sarà anche per la qualità audio migliore, ma secondo me così non è più musica!

[marika66tk]

i've heard them live it's almost the same! Bill is really great singer! And his hair!! Now he looks the best in his whole career!!!

[ichliebeBill4leben94]

he is still a good performer . play back or not his voice is beautiful but it ia impossible to sing at every single one of httem with your voice alon. u can destroy . u cant just wake up in the moring everyday with a beautiful voice all the time ...I LOVE U BILL!!

[GlobalSounds101]

Tokio Hotel has been nominated for the THIRD year in a row! PLEASE SUPPORT THIS BAND VOTE for tokio hotel as "Best Band" at the Europe music awards! go to my channel for the link or tokiohotelamericadotcom for more info VOTING ENDS NOVEMBER 1, 2009 this is NOT a spam! SUPPORT THE ARTS VOTE FOR TOKIO HOTEL! plz support them even if you're not a fan! WE NEED FANS ALL OVER THE WORLD TO DO THIS!