Added: 2 months ago
From: OfficialBirdy
Views: 244,552
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (359)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love this song.

  • The singer is flat out amazing. What a voice! So many levels of nuance and depth for an individual so young.

  • I like this version way better!

  • this bitch is fabulous.

    

  • I heard Phoenix's version last year and thought it was ok, however I'm a fan of Birdy's soft style of music and I love this!

  • I prefer Phoenix but she has a beautiful voice.

  • She sounds much older in this. I'm sorry, but I prefer the original.

  • Phoenix makes 22 account and dislike this , good tried .

  • @xmainhu what a loser

  • Comment removed

  • I like your songs but this not iam sorry

  • Phoenix > her.

  • I,m Almost cry she singss beautiful!lovei ;d

  • I've seen many comments on how she's not a big artist because she does covers. First of all, her voice is amazing, and even more, it has intensity, power, a combination not that easy to find. Second of all, she should be admired for making covers of great songs. It brings music that may have been forgotten by the newer generations back to life. I'm 21, and I made contact with the originals through Birdy.

  • @cris69415 That's true for me too. I'm 21 and I've never heard of the group Phoenix

  • This and Phoenix's version are spectacular! 

  • i'm really sure that this version is better than the original by phoenix... birdy you are incredible

  • best way to spend an afternoon - listening to this beautiful song while watching Birdy's beautiful flawless face.

  • tord of the wombats brought me here...

  • wolfgang amadeus birdy

  • Beautiful voice

  • I usually listen to deathcore, metal and screamo, but I seriously LOVE birdy <3.

  • ohmygosh she's so pretty... and she sings amazingly?... WOW! <3

  • #areyouserriousbro

    

  • I like the sound of this, but i'll think the original is better :3

  • This is such a great cover of 1901 by Phoenix. Awesome.

  • Seriously after hearing Skinny Love, and now this...I'm a fan...This girl can freaking SING for a 15 year old. She puts Justin Bieber to shame. Too bad she may never see the same notoriety as that kid. She will outsing Justin Bieber ANYDAY...hands down...15 years old folks...I'm a fan of Birdy *hands down* and I usually listen to Hip Hop.

  • @dlofiasco Isn't it good she won't be notorious? It's too bad she may never see the same fame as Justin.

  • I never knew 1901 could sound like this. This is beautiful.

  • she did such a great cover. 

  • she's beatiful, your voice too

  • no credit to original composer?

  • Awww , she's beautiful :') and i love her voice..

  • I clicked like before even hearing the vocals.I already know I'll love anything she sings! Is this girl amazing,or what??

  • such a beautiful voice omg!

  • The original 1901 of Phoenix is, in my opinion, hard to cover. So I don't think she made the right choice to cover this song, and that's why I don't like her version, it's a weak extract of the original.

  • I like Birdy's records, i'm not sure about 1901, it's not my cup of tea, but she does a great job of it, with all the other songs on the album, there is something for everyone to listen to, she has changed them to her outlook on music, which is really great, such a powerful voice and her piano playing is just wonderful, watch this space when she gets her guitar out and starts playing!

  • i forgo my porn for this

  • i forgo my porn for this

  • amazing

    

  • She's simply AMAZING.

    I love her voice, her pure soul, her being young and happy. She's magic.

  • @LadyBeesKook i agree she is amazing.

  • She sounds very much above her years. Gosh

  • this is what covering should be.. she brings something completely different to this song and it sounds awesome

  • I swear we are soul sisters... honest to God.

  • this is a complete change to the original version, prefer this version sososo much more

  • Amazing voice,...can't wait for her future albums!!!

  • she is real, not a girl who does the things her manager or parents tell her like JB. :)

  • I LOVE IT!!

    

  • @hitcherred7

    stop comparing it to the original. although the lyrics are the same, it is an entirely different experience...and an amazing one i might add.

  • can't beat the original, Phoenix is just amazing

  • Marry me!! Great Track!

  • Adele's student! :)

  • which font is used for ''Birdy'' ?

  • i think i like her cover better :)

  • i loooooove it

  • Drum kit sucks, at least admit it's not your song in the title. Gonna keep seeding your album so people can torrent it for free, don't deserve your fame, write your own songs that where talent is.

  • @nkennyish Maybe if you knew more about Birdy and came out of your "I'm too good for covers" attitude, you would realize she does write her own music. Nice try though.

  • @lakenbaconnn3 Yeah, I know that, but she's most famous for a singing show in which she sang other peoples music and for singing great songs like Skinny Love, a Bon Iver song, incase you didn't know. I'm not saying she is bad, just selfish.

  • @nkennyish But she is writing her own music? She's using their lyrics, yes, but she's changed the music to suit /her/ style. That's what covers are for. Not only that, but she's a young teenager. Give her some slack, honestly. And she /has/ written an original song called Without a Word which was also featured in TVD. She's famous, because she's good. She's taken good music and made it better. And I can /guarantee/ you that she bought the rights to use the lyrics.

  • @kaanchXkeXguriyaan i agreed with what you were saying until you said "made it better". none of her covers compare to the original. they're good, yeah, but as a teenager who likes a song, she probably has no idea what these artists went through to write emotional songs.

  • @mermaidblushxo i dont want to discredit your statement but i would just like to add that being a teenager, doesn't meant you "have no idea" about the emotions. yes they might not know what the artist was feeling at that exact moment but I'm sure some can relate or at least understand

  • @xlauraxgrajales i didn't say she had no idea because she was a teenager. i said she PROBABLY has no idea because the original artists are a lot older than her and probably went through a lot more than she has. i think she has a good voice but i'd like to see her write her own songs. 

  • @kaanchXkeXguriyaan made it better??, clearly debatable....do you really think she makes these songs?....nah she is told to sing a cover which is made by some random geezer on a computer

  • @kaanchXkeXguriyaan I know that Shelter and Skinny love was in TVD, but which episode was Without a Word in?

  • @nkennyish don't really see the selfish part.. She is a young teen who has a great talent trying to make name. And in my opinion see does deserve al the attention, because she is one of those exceptional singers with a voice which touches you. Though you probably don't have the guts to admit that her voice does such a thing to you..

  • it's similar enough where one can compare this version to the original, yet differs enough that it's a brand new experience. i'm in awe. <3

  • ok taylor swift now you got competition !

  • finally a real young musician is getting credit for real talent

  • This is probably my favourite Phoenix song, and it's probably my favourite Birdy song. Love and adore both versions. <3

  • Lovely.

  • she. is. fucking. amazing.

  • can i have her hair, clothes, and voice. please. thank you.

  • ...and then you heard she's only 15...

  • Adele? Dude, where are you talking about ?! Birdy = the new Adele

  • she is 15!! O.o

  • Comment removed

  • CHAPEAU!!!

    

  • Who was justin bieber again?????

  • @sunburst2000 thanks for reminding me of that name, yet again..

  • This is too pretty.

    Seriously.

  • Damn, birdy.

  • Thank god for Vampire Diaries. I know you all think it's lame but I would never have found this artist without it. I love her so much! She is so talented and I am addicted to her bluesy and carefree style voice! She is soooooooo good! I wish her album was available in the US already because this girl is my new favorite singer now

  • @kaylap1410 lol That's where I heard Birdy too! :) Thank goodness indeed.

  • Amazing!! Love that she loves Phoenix too!! I'll be everything you ask and more.....

  • this song has been in my head since last week! its really beautiful. Thank god Ive foud Birdy! and thanks to harry styles too actually! Shes simply special.

  • I think that this song will be on

    "The Vampire Diaries"

    because sixteenth episode of TVD is called 1911 :)

    It's similar :D

    After Skinny Love and Shelter I would like that ;)

    I

  • holy cowness, simply beautiful  <3

  • wouah!!!

  • Just Beautiful...Miley cyrus aint got nothing on her =]

  • Love your voice

  • The original is my favourite but this is an awesome take on the song :D

  • Love the Phoenix version and love this!

  • so i'm pretty sure i have a girl crush on her. :c

  • A nice, calm version of the Phoenix'es song, but I think I prefer the energy found in the original. Still, she has a nice voice, that actually makes the song a little bit different.

  • @dantey01 yeah the synthesizers really do something for me in the Phoenix original

  • Comment removed

  • Birdy is a great singer. All of her songs are amazing.

  • @1ElectroDan who are you to say that? You're just a kid if you say things like that

  • @1ElectroDan You're retarded.

  • @OmfgNot Uh... I'm sorry that your mom drank before she had you, you stupid fuck-stick.

  • @1ElectroDan You really can't just leave a normal, human, decent comment? Always need to call each other in different ways. I ask you a question. Can you be normal or peaceful at least a single time in your life? Nice song...

  • @1ElectroDan

    What ..your mad !

    You actually chose Miley Cyrus to compare to BIRDY! what the hell is wrong with you?

  • @1ElectroDan What was the point of that comment

  • reading these comments i feel like some people dont know this is a PHOENIX song.

    PHX > Birdy

  • Its good!

  • not her best song...

  • So is this song not out to buy on Itunes yet?

  • @Roryluvsdean Not in the U.S.

  • Amazing. Never thought a songs meaning could change too me. Just by someone else singing it. Thanks Phoenix and thanks Birdy your voice is so timeless

  • shes got a lovely voice but i dont think this song works, original is much better

  • ♥ Great voice and her text is all about real life and feelings ♥

  • Birdy i just thought i let you no that your music is very apealing to many ,It is extremly calming like Adele .Oh yea you have a new fan from the US:)

  • she looks+sounds like an angel<3.

  • I love you so much, when I listen your song I smile. It's amazing. Your song very help my when I am sad. Thank you <3

  • Wow, I just listened this song and I felt alive.

  • She's the only musician from my generation that I admire. Truly admire. Beautiful voice and so unique.

  • This picture is so beautiful, i love it. The music is also cool, ofcourse haha

  • Birdy and Phoenix? makes sense. lol

  • shes 15 ... shes beautiful and so is her voice and songs.. she has her own personality.. take THAT Justin Bieber...

  • I think we are gonna hear more of here.

  • thankk god a teen that sings real songs and not overrated mainstream shit

  • hoi

  • Amazing voice, but my question how does a teen know anything of Phoenix?

  • @Wisconsin222 cause they're not exactly minor threat? they're actually fairly well known and well represented on radio in europe.

  • @MrChavman I guess. I mean when I was in high school I only knew about them because of the Cadillac commercial featuring this song, then their album for this song came out like a month or two after.

  • @Wisconsin222 Uh, a lot of people are familiar with Phoenix. They aren't some super exclusive band.

  • @queefstorm I know but in high school I mainly listened to T-Pain and Black Eyed Peas because most high schoolers that's all they know.

  • She has an amazing voice.

  • she's 15... this. is talent.

    kudos to her!

  • PHOENIX! ♥

  • Jasmine van den Bogaerde......aka Birdy .......is the name of the next big thing in the music industry.....

  • it is coming out on my birthday

  • I'd rather listen to an awesome cover than a shitty original.

    Love this. <3

  • MASHALLAH' MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU. I pray for u love 100000000 years and do nicer music

  • Only 63000 views? U kiddin me. . I bet I heard this around trillion times. If u think so give a hell yeah. .

  • iTunes really needs to get her whole album up in the USA store. I dont have any euros in iTunes.

  • She's Amazing ! Her voice ... just .. WOW

  • wow she must be amazing sitting and listening to her live playing piano

  • omg, her voice.. her voice is PERFECT! AMAZING!

  • her voice is amazing to say she is what 15? she is such an inspiration just shows you can do whatever you put your mind to!

  • I wanted to hate her for not being original but FUCK i absolutely love this cover! She is amazing! she has really turned this song to her own! so much for me hating her!

  • Look at most teen signers, now compare...just try and leave a stupid comment now.

  • singing she can do well but makin' her own song a problem it is

    -YODA

  • I love the fact that she's only like 15 or so, it gives me a little hope

  • She's gonna go big time

  • I've just discovered her and I think she has got a wonderful voice. Incredible.

  • birdy is gewoon goed :)

  • My Favorite song of 2009, One of my Favorite songs of All time, being sung by a 15 year old girl............ I LOVE IT!. Beautiful

  • Hi, My name is Jorge, you probably dont care about that, im 15 years old and Im a music producer, also I really enjoy Birdy´s songs, so I made my own version of this song, I hope you like it, and please if you like it, please thumbs up, so everybody can see it! THANK YOU!

    /watch?v=cmLrT9a3VPE

  • I like it, but more importantly

    Maybe finally the stupid people who always thought it was Fallen Fallen Fallen... can shut up, as the cover More clearly says FOLD it.

  • Woaaaah! Birdy i love you're voice!!!!!!!

  • aaaw birdy you're amazing ♥

    u re very different from all the other singers... I realllyy love your voice ♥♥

    Keeep it up !

  • omg omg i love her! absolutely brilliant.

  • Ten people don't know what to say.

  • Please do this live.

  • aww shes so pretty :)

    nice cover !

  • No snowflake button? :(

  • guys give her a break, she's trying to get through GCSEs first, I'm sure she'll write some songs later

  • it's really calm and slow i like it! go on like this birdy :)

  • the most amazing voice covering the most amazing band.... best christmas ever!

  • this girl is amazing!

  • isn't this song originally sang by Phoenix ?

  • @dreamcatcher7268 You're right

    

  • i adore this girl. So young so amazing

  • the amount of criticism she is recieving is riduculous, she's 15 and she can sing like that - utterly amazing, everyone is just jealous of her.

  • เพราะมาก ><!!

  • i think people just need to understand that birdy's mostly a singer, and she's just working on her songwriter-ness. she IS only 15, anyway.

  • Birdy should cover Sophia by Nerina Pallot