Damn! I really want to read this, but I'm depressed because on Amazon, and any other site, it's ridiculously overpriced- not even kidding, the cheapest used copy was like $900! I really want to read this, but I cannot find any copies! As an obsessive phantom phan, I am crazed and panicking. No one can help me! There are no copies ANYWHERE!
How about you give it a chance..listen to the coney Island waltz and Till I hear you sing..they are amazing..and you think it has lost its magic, I have seen it 5 times in NYC and trust me it has not. 8 times a week thousands of people see it, and feel the magic of the music of the night and leave the theatre beaming or with a tear in thier eye.Or when the overture starts, people still feel that warmth and triumpth, so give it a chance...then critisize. Wicked was ripped apart before it opened
No they aren't. In fact, they are pretty low quality. same as 1000 different musical tehatre's song all aroung the world. Wouldn't recognize it if I hear it with others at once.
Phans unite against the sequel and voice your opinions! The sequel may go ahead but the fans do not have to be silent. Follow LoveShouldDie on Twitter and/or sign up to the brand new Love Should Die fan page on Facebook!
all you guys are wrong... its gonna be the same actors from the first one, its gonna be based on the book "the phantom of Manhattan" and its gonna be a different story and different songs!!
like I know people like things playing close to the book but if you all love erik so much you should be happy he didn't die when I heard he died as I watched the movie I though it was coming but I was so happy he didn't
sure... that captivated my attention, i have to say. it sounds like a very-well written phanfiction, but i'm afraid it'll never make it big. the fact that the story ends where it did gives our imaginations a place to wander without a landing. it's the perfect ending and noone should ever officially change it.
I agree that the first one is a wonderful peice of musical theatre. but wouldn't you like to see what would happen after? I'm not saying it'll make it big either, and if it doesn't, well, then we still have the wondeful original to watch. But I for one, am very excited.
I just bought the book but I think that making a sequel is the worst idea imaginable. It ruins the whole story. I love the 2004 version of Phantom but the only thing wrong with it is that Erik doesn't die. He dies in the original book and I think that's the most beautiful part of it. It says that Erik can't live without Christine's love. He made his choice at the end of ALW version to let Christine go and making it go on destroys everything Erik stands for.
Is this supposed to be funny? The way the guy reads makes him sound sarcastic. The fact that the story sounds like bad fanfic smut doesn't help any. And you know that at the end of the original book Erik dies, right?
do they have this at Barns & Noble?
Orochimaruswife1 8 months ago
do they have this at Barns & Noble
Orochimaruswife1 8 months ago
That was actually pretty hilarious.
hurd98 1 year ago
Damn! I really want to read this, but I'm depressed because on Amazon, and any other site, it's ridiculously overpriced- not even kidding, the cheapest used copy was like $900! I really want to read this, but I cannot find any copies! As an obsessive phantom phan, I am crazed and panicking. No one can help me! There are no copies ANYWHERE!
TheAngelintheShadows 1 year ago
It's actually really good. I mean REALLY, esically considering it's based off the 04 movie.
TPOTCD 1 year ago
I totally agree with you.
laurefin87 1 year ago
meg shoots and kills christine
garrychelsea 1 year ago
Naw, you've gotta be kidding
NightShadeslayer 1 year ago
@NightShadeslayer its true meg points a gun at christine and it goes off and christine dies and the phantom is left with gustave who is his son
garrychelsea 1 year ago
Oh wow, but why would she do that? And Raoul?
NightShadeslayer 1 year ago
can i just say THIS BOOK WAS AWESOME
phanphan1 1 year ago
How about you give it a chance..listen to the coney Island waltz and Till I hear you sing..they are amazing..and you think it has lost its magic, I have seen it 5 times in NYC and trust me it has not. 8 times a week thousands of people see it, and feel the magic of the music of the night and leave the theatre beaming or with a tear in thier eye.Or when the overture starts, people still feel that warmth and triumpth, so give it a chance...then critisize. Wicked was ripped apart before it opened
Broadwaybum2 2 years ago
No they aren't. In fact, they are pretty low quality. same as 1000 different musical tehatre's song all aroung the world. Wouldn't recognize it if I hear it with others at once.
laurefin87 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Phans unite against the sequel and voice your opinions! The sequel may go ahead but the fans do not have to be silent. Follow LoveShouldDie on Twitter and/or sign up to the brand new Love Should Die fan page on Facebook!
Necesse est amor mori.
LoveShouldDie 2 years ago
anyone willing to sell a copy cheeply?
whitemountainowl 2 years ago
but it only needs a bit of rekindling for the magic to return
whitemountainowl 2 years ago
hmm....wouldn't the "sequel" be the same play....just possibly different actors/actresses? and maybe cooler?
nintendo1yo1sasuke 2 years ago
No...get it SEQUEL
Broadwaybum2 2 years ago
all you guys are wrong... its gonna be the same actors from the first one, its gonna be based on the book "the phantom of Manhattan" and its gonna be a different story and different songs!!
mauroburca12 2 years ago
IT IS NO THE SAME ACTORS....same chracters different actors...Brightman is not comin back lol
Broadwaybum2 2 years ago
Is it true than Rhydiah from X Factor will be the Phantom in the sequel?
mrssalina 3 years ago
like I know people like things playing close to the book but if you all love erik so much you should be happy he didn't die when I heard he died as I watched the movie I though it was coming but I was so happy he didn't
Befrie08 3 years ago
Is the sequal going to be the same story but different songs or a completley new story.
helloground 3 years ago
apparantly katherine jenkins may be christine, she is like 1 of my fav singers!!
sportyswifty123 3 years ago
sure... that captivated my attention, i have to say. it sounds like a very-well written phanfiction, but i'm afraid it'll never make it big. the fact that the story ends where it did gives our imaginations a place to wander without a landing. it's the perfect ending and noone should ever officially change it.
DarthxErik 3 years ago 9
That is a really good book! you should read it!
CaptainIchabodRainey 3 years ago
I agree that the first one is a wonderful peice of musical theatre. but wouldn't you like to see what would happen after? I'm not saying it'll make it big either, and if it doesn't, well, then we still have the wondeful original to watch. But I for one, am very excited.
AngryMonkeysClub 2 years ago
where can u get the phantom sequal???? SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME!
kgirl101333 3 years ago
Amazon
CaptainIchabodRainey 3 years ago
Andrew Lloyd Webber is making a sequel, but it is to Frederick Forsyth The Phantom of Manhattan.
CelticRose1 3 years ago
I heard the book was horrible, too.
mrshermionesnape 3 years ago 3
Horrible is an understatment! loL
CelticRose1 3 years ago 7
I just bought the book but I think that making a sequel is the worst idea imaginable. It ruins the whole story. I love the 2004 version of Phantom but the only thing wrong with it is that Erik doesn't die. He dies in the original book and I think that's the most beautiful part of it. It says that Erik can't live without Christine's love. He made his choice at the end of ALW version to let Christine go and making it go on destroys everything Erik stands for.
gerardphreak 3 years ago
Is this supposed to be funny? The way the guy reads makes him sound sarcastic. The fact that the story sounds like bad fanfic smut doesn't help any. And you know that at the end of the original book Erik dies, right?
kenwen4 4 years ago
hahahaha i bought the book!!!
Moosemeeseproduction 4 years ago
you bought the book?! were did you get it i must know!
phanphan1 4 years ago
Love it! Can't wait to read the book. I'll probably be all night! -PMA
phantommyangel 4 years ago 2
It is so hard to find people who like the phantom but on the internet it is so easy! can someone say unfair!
22moonlightfan 3 years ago
That awesome Stef! I am so excited to get my copy!
cleogirl87 4 years ago
Love it Stef! This is fantastic
enzomacd 4 years ago
Awesome excerpt!!! Can't wait for the release! On Amazon, of course! Excellent story, Stef! You go girl!
nightsmusic 4 years ago