@11cutiepop, Rose freaked out a lot during her first season as well. As did Martha, I think both Martha and Donna would have gotten better at traveling with the Doctor if the continued for longer then they did. All the companions (even what I have seen from the older series) are freak out-ish when they first start traveling with the doctor but slowly grow into their own. Rose was too shallow for me.
@ThePalominoUnicorn, Thank you so much. And I do try to have some sort of storyline, sometimes it works, sometimes its more interesting that way, and sometimes it doesn't work too well. But glad you liked it. And Donna was so different then normal companions, so think thats what I liked about her so much. <3
@Lunarsundance, Oh...phew. I was beginning to think I was the only one who didn't care for Rose, well me and my friend-he HATES Rose, I mean over the top.
@smallorangerainbow, Well, I've always though that the best couples always came from being best friends first. I am biased though, because I can't stand (which is putting it lightly) Rose. In my own opinion, I really did like Nine/Rose-they had chemistry and made a lot of sense, but Ten/Rose (again in my opinion) not so much.
But, as long as you got some enjoyment from the video then I'm happy. Really why I make videos in the first place. <3
@smallorangerainbow, Oh I know. I respect your opinions. And I'm glad you liked the video. Was one of my firsts. Think it was my third or fourth attempt at a video, so was nervous it wouldn't be too great. XD
I love this video. I always thought Donna was better for himt han Rose...there was something about her that made me just not like her to be honest...she was amazing with nine but ten/donna is how it should have been
@Stacio1901, Thank you so much, happy you enjoyed the video. And yes, there was just something about Rose that I despised. Though I agree with you Rose and Nine was fantastic, but Ten and Rose...ehhh... Definitely love Donna/Ten. Love Stories aside, Donna was just really good for the doctor, it's sad that she had to "die".
Yes, I agree with you. I believe the doctor refused to let Donna die even though she preferred death was because he loved her and he couldn't stand the thought of her dying because he wasn't strong enough to protect the Earth on his own. In the end he let Donna down and he had a hard time coping with that.
Yes, that is something else to consider, but in a weird sense that might almost make the doctor seem selfish to his own weakness and feelings. And I've never imagined the Doctor to be selfish. But yeah, it's definitely something to consider...might turn into a good debate too. XD
There are certain things that shouldn't be touched. There are certain things that are valued over life. Those things should be respected just like others' wishes. People don't have a right to choose what is best for someone else.
I agree with you one hundred percent. And If I had been in Donna's place I probably would have chose death over becoming a person I didn't like. Then again, how can she miss the doctor or who she had been if she doesn't remember ever doing any of those things or being better then she was? I was a little surprised the Doctor did what he did, because I find it immorally wrong, and the Doctor always seemed the type to do the right thing.
Of course, I think they kept her alive, in some way, just in case they did want to bring her back for a episode or two. But sticking with characters, from the Doctors perspective, he did love her, in a platonic sense, and that kind of love is VERY strong, and I'm speculating, but perhaps the Doctor couldn't abide by his wishes because he didn't want her to die die, and maybe couldn't live with himself if he had done what she asked and allowed her to die.
She was different. To strip away all those adventures, all those good memories, it was to take away a piece of her personality. He restored her to the miserable person she was before he met her again and that just wasn't fair. I liked how Donna was cool headed and she was more willing to ridicule the doctor than others. She was able to tell him when he went too far. Who's going to do that now? No one was there to say that when he tampered with her brain.
If Donna would have preferred death with knowledge over living life as a shadow of her former self, the doctor should have accepted that. He took more than memories from her. He took experience. He took her newly gained confidence. Donna used to be so insecure. She hid behind layers of sarcasm. Although she still loves to play games and use sarcasm she finally came to understand that she was important and could make a difference. She became less rude and more open minded. She changed.
I agree with you guys! Rose did get a fairytale ending. Although, I was actually happy with it. No matter how he might appear, he's a copy not the original. I was ecstatic when I found out Donna would get the real doctor. Of course then he erased her memories and she lost all character development which made me really angry. She told the doctor not to do it. He had no right to touch her mind without permission.
I'm doctor/rose shipped and I think this was amazing doctor/donna might now be my second ship well done I read the dr who mag and it had the results for the best compaiun contest in it. 1st rose tyler 2nd donna noble 3rd martha jones 4th captain jack harkness remember this is not my opinion I would have put jack 3rd not martha 5 stars Amazing!!!!
Oh thank you so much! I am glad you enjoyed this video.
N I've got 2 say, I always thought Martha was a good companion, intelligence and compassion wise. Though in my own opinion, Donna is the best. Was there for him, like a true friend. Really I think all of them, even Micky, were just awesome companions.
I like his older ones 2, like Romana, Sarah Jane, ...gosh its been awhile since I've seen the old version. But there were a lot of good ones there.
She was left with a man who looks exactly the same, has the same memories, acts exactly how he acted when he and Rose first met (and who she fell in love with), loves her, is part human who will grow old and can die with her(something the other Doctor can't do), and in the deleted scene was given something to make a TARDIS, so "it's Rose and the Doctor traveling the universe the way it was meant to be."
If that's not a fairytale ending for this day and age, I don't know what is.
Its alright.. buhh donna didnt love the doctor and he didnt love her.. not in that way anyway. You can tell.. and anywayz.. rtd said its not a love story.. it would be a better vid if you replaced donna with martha i think.. cuz she loved him..
But if you want the reality aspect of my video, here it is: From personal experience n from a lot of the couples I'm friends with that have been married for over 40 yrs. All said they had been best friends for several yrs before they started dating. So just 'cause Doctor/Donna don't love each other in that way, you can't ignore the possibility that somethin more could have happened if they continued travelin together.
rose is my favorite donna seems to freak out to much
11cutiepop 11 months ago
@11cutiepop, Rose freaked out a lot during her first season as well. As did Martha, I think both Martha and Donna would have gotten better at traveling with the Doctor if the continued for longer then they did. All the companions (even what I have seen from the older series) are freak out-ish when they first start traveling with the doctor but slowly grow into their own. Rose was too shallow for me.
XxLeschaxX 10 months ago
Great video, glad to see a storyline for once. I like Donna, she's my third fav companion (after Rose and Amy).
ThePalominoUnicorn 1 year ago
@ThePalominoUnicorn, Thank you so much. And I do try to have some sort of storyline, sometimes it works, sometimes its more interesting that way, and sometimes it doesn't work too well. But glad you liked it. And Donna was so different then normal companions, so think thats what I liked about her so much. <3
XxLeschaxX 1 year ago
Don't worry I really don't care for Rose either!! Great Video though :) And Donna did have a very very sad goodbye
Lunarsundance 1 year ago
@Lunarsundance, Oh...phew. I was beginning to think I was the only one who didn't care for Rose, well me and my friend-he HATES Rose, I mean over the top.
Thanks. Glad you liked it.
XxLeschaxX 1 year ago
welcome....and you are never the only rose disliker i know like 5
Lunarsundance 1 year ago
@Lunarsundance, That's good to hear. XD
XxLeschaxX 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Don't worry I really don't care for Rose either!! Great Video though :) And Donna did have a very very sad goodbye
Lunarsundance 1 year ago
Comment removed
Lunarsundance 1 year ago
the only thing is that he & donna were simply BEST friends...
he & rose were in love...
good video though!
smallorangerainbow 1 year ago
@smallorangerainbow, Well, I've always though that the best couples always came from being best friends first. I am biased though, because I can't stand (which is putting it lightly) Rose. In my own opinion, I really did like Nine/Rose-they had chemistry and made a lot of sense, but Ten/Rose (again in my opinion) not so much.
But, as long as you got some enjoyment from the video then I'm happy. Really why I make videos in the first place. <3
XxLeschaxX 1 year ago
@XxLeschaxX i loved the video, i was just sayin'
:)
smallorangerainbow 1 year ago
@smallorangerainbow, Oh I know. I respect your opinions. And I'm glad you liked the video. Was one of my firsts. Think it was my third or fourth attempt at a video, so was nervous it wouldn't be too great. XD
XxLeschaxX 1 year ago
@XxLeschaxX Yay!
smallorangerainbow 1 year ago
I love this video. I always thought Donna was better for himt han Rose...there was something about her that made me just not like her to be honest...she was amazing with nine but ten/donna is how it should have been
xxoxx
Stacio1901 2 years ago 8
@Stacio1901, Thank you so much, happy you enjoyed the video. And yes, there was just something about Rose that I despised. Though I agree with you Rose and Nine was fantastic, but Ten and Rose...ehhh... Definitely love Donna/Ten. Love Stories aside, Donna was just really good for the doctor, it's sad that she had to "die".
XxLeschaxX 1 year ago
Yes, I agree with you. I believe the doctor refused to let Donna die even though she preferred death was because he loved her and he couldn't stand the thought of her dying because he wasn't strong enough to protect the Earth on his own. In the end he let Donna down and he had a hard time coping with that.
Diclonana 2 years ago 8
Yes, that is something else to consider, but in a weird sense that might almost make the doctor seem selfish to his own weakness and feelings. And I've never imagined the Doctor to be selfish. But yeah, it's definitely something to consider...might turn into a good debate too. XD
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
There are certain things that shouldn't be touched. There are certain things that are valued over life. Those things should be respected just like others' wishes. People don't have a right to choose what is best for someone else.
Diclonana 2 years ago
I agree with you one hundred percent. And If I had been in Donna's place I probably would have chose death over becoming a person I didn't like. Then again, how can she miss the doctor or who she had been if she doesn't remember ever doing any of those things or being better then she was? I was a little surprised the Doctor did what he did, because I find it immorally wrong, and the Doctor always seemed the type to do the right thing.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
Of course, I think they kept her alive, in some way, just in case they did want to bring her back for a episode or two. But sticking with characters, from the Doctors perspective, he did love her, in a platonic sense, and that kind of love is VERY strong, and I'm speculating, but perhaps the Doctor couldn't abide by his wishes because he didn't want her to die die, and maybe couldn't live with himself if he had done what she asked and allowed her to die.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
her wishes**
(I can't type or spell) XD
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
She was different. To strip away all those adventures, all those good memories, it was to take away a piece of her personality. He restored her to the miserable person she was before he met her again and that just wasn't fair. I liked how Donna was cool headed and she was more willing to ridicule the doctor than others. She was able to tell him when he went too far. Who's going to do that now? No one was there to say that when he tampered with her brain.
Diclonana 2 years ago
If Donna would have preferred death with knowledge over living life as a shadow of her former self, the doctor should have accepted that. He took more than memories from her. He took experience. He took her newly gained confidence. Donna used to be so insecure. She hid behind layers of sarcasm. Although she still loves to play games and use sarcasm she finally came to understand that she was important and could make a difference. She became less rude and more open minded. She changed.
Diclonana 2 years ago
I agree with you guys! Rose did get a fairytale ending. Although, I was actually happy with it. No matter how he might appear, he's a copy not the original. I was ecstatic when I found out Donna would get the real doctor. Of course then he erased her memories and she lost all character development which made me really angry. She told the doctor not to do it. He had no right to touch her mind without permission.
Diclonana 2 years ago
i completely agree with u and grat video
TaysWickedNinja 2 years ago
Thank you so much! Hope you enjoyed the video. ^^
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
i did and ur welcome ^_^
TaysWickedNinja 2 years ago
icewormie 2 years ago
Oh thank you so much! I am glad you enjoyed this video.
N I've got 2 say, I always thought Martha was a good companion, intelligence and compassion wise. Though in my own opinion, Donna is the best. Was there for him, like a true friend. Really I think all of them, even Micky, were just awesome companions.
I like his older ones 2, like Romana, Sarah Jane, ...gosh its been awhile since I've seen the old version. But there were a lot of good ones there.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
Oh i know people always rule out the older ones I still like jamie/james the doctor actully uses his name in tooth and claw
icewormie 2 years ago
Yeah. It's understandable though. I'm sure a lot of people have never seen the old ones.
And he does? I must watch that episode again.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
yeah sir james micrimen of balamory
(cant spell sorry) Oh I dont hate martha I thought she was great but I just like some of the others better
icewormie 2 years ago
Didn't mean to accuse you of hating Martha. Though I know a lot of people who don't like her at all. It always baffled me.
But I understand, I have my favorites, and then the ones I'm not so fond of.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
Thank you for understanding
icewormie 2 years ago
I do have to say that Rose's ending wasn't a fairytale. She didn't get the man she loves she got his filler.
ravenscheer23 2 years ago
You're right.
She was left with a man who looks exactly the same, has the same memories, acts exactly how he acted when he and Rose first met (and who she fell in love with), loves her, is part human who will grow old and can die with her(something the other Doctor can't do), and in the deleted scene was given something to make a TARDIS, so "it's Rose and the Doctor traveling the universe the way it was meant to be."
If that's not a fairytale ending for this day and age, I don't know what is.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
Its alright.. buhh donna didnt love the doctor and he didnt love her.. not in that way anyway. You can tell.. and anywayz.. rtd said its not a love story.. it would be a better vid if you replaced donna with martha i think.. cuz she loved him..
IXIrandomIXIgirlIXI 2 years ago
I'm sorry, this isn't meant to be realistic.
But if you want the reality aspect of my video, here it is: From personal experience n from a lot of the couples I'm friends with that have been married for over 40 yrs. All said they had been best friends for several yrs before they started dating. So just 'cause Doctor/Donna don't love each other in that way, you can't ignore the possibility that somethin more could have happened if they continued travelin together.
Realistic videos are so boring.
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago
It's a fan video, she can make it whatever she wants.
ravenscheer23 2 years ago
love it.
sting20006 2 years ago
Thank You!
XxLeschaxX 2 years ago