one thing that kind of annoys me about pink floyd videos sometimes is that they have all these stupid effects for half of it and i jsut want to see the band
what kind of organ is that? it deosnt look like a farfisa compact duo that Rick used to play this. So may be it is a Hammond m-100 that used in the studio version...
@MrCkufu juz play around wit the notes. have patience n you'l find the progression. try not to rely on tabs. makes you a better guitarist when u learn it by ear
did you noticed that around minute 4:38 rogers screams something like "one more!!" and they keep playing a little longer?? poor david you can tell he was tired jaja
With Rick now sadly gone, I will never see them live again in my lifetime. They have been with me since I bought Relics in 1972......I now have to live out my life with the recordings that exist and the odd gems that turn up from time to time like this. @luisanas, thanks for posting. May be one day I will see them again on the other side.....if there is another side ;)
for those who said that they cant stand The Devision Bell:
a true fan of should be able to listen to any album, any song put out by that band. i love each floyd album because it is so uniquely different to the others. The Devision Bell is very minimalist and peacefull, A Momentary Lapse Of Reason was all about showing Waters what Gilmour, Mason & Wright could do without him, so it is very emotionaly charged.
some people are wayy to dismissive of post Waters Floyd. it frustrates me......
i mean purely in saying that whatever people say, momentary lapse of reason and the division bell do sound like floyd albums to me and that is why i like both albums.
some people with disagree about that of course, but thats their opinion on the records
Does anyone remember where this was recorded? It was a festival, featuring also the soft machine, it's a beautiful day, and more. I had it on VHS but I lost it...
I haven't seen this version before-- the more versions/recordings of this song I can find the better!! The Live at Pompeii recording of it has got to be my favorite; maybe my favorite song of all time. Echoes is up there, too.
Every time i hear that shit i can't stop shouting "oooooooo ooooohohohohohooooohohohooo oooooooo aoaooaooooaoaooo aaa aaaah heee haaa o oh ooooooo" That's AWESOME
How can anyone hate the division bell. Of course you are entitled to your own opinion. I think all music recorded was awesome by Pink Floyd. If any dislikes.....you should dislike music of today's generation.
agreed wm7888 todays music has no soul or flare. Its always the same shit, never will there be another soulfull band such as floyd, not with the way music today is heading.
@XDiverseUniverseX - thats total crap. Pop music has always been lame no matter what generation. Pink Floyd was not a pop band in the 70s. Its the people that choose to do something different that have a real impact. It still holds true today. There are many talented artists today its just that the music and media industry are doing a better job at shoving banal pop music down your throat then they were 30 years ago. If you believe all music is shit today then your not looking hard enough.
@clehneis Even if this musical generation did have soul they'd sell out to those big record labels and they would shape them into something that makes good money. Green day for example, look at the change there, they used to be awesome now they're all dark black hair emo lookin people, jus coz thats whats hot.
Big record companies have shaped bands since the beatles explosion. They are just getting better at marketing because of the technology advances that we've seen over the years. They can make someone who has very little talent sound amazing in the recording studio. Thats why you see the explosion of crap artists now. Thats not to say that there are real talented people playing music today. There are a lot you just need to learn how to filter out the crap.
@wm7888 - Because its not the real pink floyd. It was the combination of Waters and Gilmour as front men that made the band so interesting. Now its just like soft core porn or something. Gilmour so focused on his tone than actually making some interesting sounding music. It doesn't do it for me. Pop music has always been banal no matter what generation its been in. It 's the people that choose to do something different that have a real impact and it still holds true today.
Hate Division Bell? It's much more in line with the Pink Floyd sound than The Wall, Final Cut or Momentary Lapse of Reason. And for that reason I enjoy it more.
@bryanswagerty - No it wasn't. Division Bell was what David Gilmour wanted Pink Floyd to be. Its crap. It was the combination of Waters twisted lyrics and Gilmours awesome tone and playing that made pink floyd who they were.
It was a festival sometime around '70/'71 in Holland that featured Jefferson Airplane and Carlos Santana. The footage of this show is available on the concert video "Stamping Ground."
i agree with you , it is amazing but on the other hand when you make more and more money the ego is growing with you or is awaken and then division bell rings and everybody has its own free will to go and create more beauty or else whether
is more magic in this piece or that one is up to you to discover. All i want to say to You that we have to be thankful for P.Floyd and these genetic circumstances that brought these people together so we can indulge their music be happy and creative
bueno para mi esta cancion esta a toda madre ma cae la vida es un platillo de secretos vivan la banda este grupo cambio mi forma de ver la musica ampliaron mis conocimientos en horabuena para syd barret y para todos ....
rick wright is on heaven .we love you man .we miss you .this really brings me to tears i dont know how to express myself all the words his creations meant to the world and to me.now he is in heaven playing this beautiful music .
The constant symbol crashing is so loud and am surprized you don't complain about that. What I can hear of Gilmore sounds like a bass vocal. The drummer used way too much symbol that you can barely hear the other instruments. I just look at it as an experiment that didn't turn out the best they could have done, so move on to what works.
Pink floyd's Saucer Full of Secrets, I was commenting on what I hear at my end, that the recording was not clear and I thought it was possible the compression for YouTube made it sound bad, and the symbols were too loud for my taste for this song. Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands, since 1968.
TBH I'm pretty sure this is a live recording and WYHIWYG ... or rather what they played then and laid down to the limits of a 1970s non-studio recording system.
For a live rendition of a pretty complex piece of prog/psychadelia I rate it highly ;-)
no fucking way i am a loose relation of gilmoors but hendrix was a better guitarist gilmoor is a better band member whereas hendrix was the experience gilmoore is a big part of the floyd but not the only talent at work
Is there any doubt that Gilmour was a better guitarist than Hendrix? Is there any doubt that Gilmour is the best guitarist of all time? When God created the guitar, he created David Gilmour along with it so that the masses can learn from the master. Hendrix was a mediocre student at best.
seconded. I love and admire Gilmour for everything he did, but he surely is not the best guitarist of all time (in terms of technique at least). But I remember a nice quote I read somewhere which sums this discussion up very well: "Gilmour doesn't hit many tunes. But he hits the right ones."
Hendrix, Hendrix, blah blah blah... One of the most over-rated artists of all time. "You might want to rethink...", as if I told the Pope Jesus wasn't all that he's made up to be.
If you had more than three grams of brain, you'd say "wow you're smart", not "wow your smart". Now go back to your trailer, sit on your rent-to-own easy chair, relax, and leave me alone, moron.
Excuse me, but are you saying that David Gilmour has a bad voice? Well if that's the case, take this into consideration. Pink Floyd composed some of the most vocally challenging melodies in rock music. The fact that he is still able to sing songs nowadays that men half his age find difficult at best is a testament to his talent and destroys your point. And that "quacky strat" of his was the primary guitar used on every Floyd album from Atom Heart Mother through The Final Cut.
He does have a nice voice, but what I originally said was that he butchered this particular performance. He sounds great on all the Pompeii videos and he sounds good on many albums. He just sounds like a cat being strangled by a violin in this one.
I said that strats are quacky. They are indeed quacky and twangy, that's one of the attributes Fender aims for, it's sound is desirable for many artists. I for one don't like the sound, and find them to have very little sustain and too much treble.
Anyway,it was never Gilmour who had the huge ego, it was Waters. Roger Waters is my biggest hero, but he is dick. However, in his defense, he knew exactly want he wanted to do when he was in Pink Floyd and when the others had no idea where they should be headed musically and conceptually. So how can you say that David Gilmour was the one with the egomania when it was clearly Waters? Gilmour barely made any decisions in the band. Waters is shouting for another round of the chord progression.
About my different parts of the fretboards comment, I am well aware that both songs are in B minor and that they're share the same octive during the verses, but you're not going to convince me that a memorable portion of Comfortably Numb's final solo is not played an octive higher than that of Money.
it's a little rough and ready, but man the passion and energy! think it's the "stamping ground" film. man, wouldn't you just love to hear this sucker properly remastered? sure there's mistakes, but wright's totally into it, and mason's burning.
Comon anyone can use a slide. Gilmour is another example of simple playing being regarded as epic.
Pink Floyd is indeed about the passion but Gilmour is beyond predictable in his guitar playing technique, what can he honestly do? Play a Blues Scale back and forth and maybe introduce an old Blues lick? Comon! The solos for Money and Comfortably Numb are on the exact same scale just played in a different pace!
I love all of the members of Floyd to death but he really butchers songs sometimes.
It ain't about technique, it about feeling. It all about express emotions and touch people hearts. He can use just one or two licks (like BB King for instance) but he knows how play and touch people... I hang around and see lots of people with amazing skills, playing fast as a bullet, but without touch anyone. What do you prefer? It's matter of choice :-)
Carloteiro, Gimour said that he was better than Hendrix! If you want a rational direction with your life, I'm sure that maybe the idea of Gilmour being ignorant will help you.
jackflashrj, what i felt from his playing was just gurble from his voice and the muddy distortion from the combination of what ever the hell he's put his strat through.
To each his own, but my own is that Gilmour butchered this version.
Well clearly if you are such an enlightened critic, you would have no issues with writing a song with well-crafted lyrics, an interesting melody and a god-inspired guitar solo and posting it on youtube in order to let everyone see if you have any real virtue in critiquing someone of David Gilmour's stature.
Oh, and anyone with a basic education in music could determine that the solos of Comfortably Numb and Money are simply played on different parts of the fretboard as they're both in B minor.
I really don't understand how "passion" justifies how sucky gilmour is. He's just another EGP. (Egotistical Guitar Player/or Extra Gay Player for some).
Well by all means, point out exactly in this video where the sloppiness lays, and then give me an example of your own god-like passion. And have you ever considered the fact that the Floyd played A Saucerful of Secrets as their last song of their shows in the early 70's, and that after almost two hours of playing, wouldn't you give anyone some room for blundering?
Your really upset about somebody critisizing Gilmour.
The last bit of comfortably numb is indeed in the same key different octive, i will agree on that. But the basic spine, if you will, are both in the same spot on the fret board.
You have no idea how simplistic this man really is? I've been playing guitar for 11 years and when i was just fourteen i realized how easy it is to play any form of floyd.
Gilmour may have way more years experience than I. But, if the qoute from Gilmour "I'm better than Hendrix" rings a bell, then you'd understand why he's such an egotistical prick
Where's that quote from? When I Google it, I only get this video. I'd also like to use this opportunity to diss both you and Cesgord on account of grammar.
ok, I went to wikiquote and typed in his name and found the quote. You must be kind of thick. Have you ever seen the interview sections of Live at Pompeii? Well if you have, you'd have noticed that during the entire time, the Floyd were making fun of each other and of themselves. That quote and the other two from the Pompeii interviews are ment to be jokes. He didn't literally mean that he was better than Jimi Hendrix. It was a completely sarcastic remark.
pfff the best thing about gilmour is the simple way he plays and the extremely feel he put in each simple easy predictable notes and keys he plays...now you Britania, go on! compose a single song or just a solo with all the scales you learnded in your apatethic 12 years playing guitar...I'm sure you will have not success...pff 12 years playing guitar and you think you can talk about Gilmour the way you do...the only egocentric man here is you! you really suck man!
Success means nothing to me actually. Is it egotistical to critisize? If it be, then you are indeed a hypocrit for critisizing me. Critisism is just one of the endoresments the first amendment gives anybody. It is a heathly thing to have ones opinion, but you, you have absolutly no rational direction or purpose toward what I'm talking about. Feal free to join in the aguement when you can type more than one sentence defending Gilmour and not bashing me.
man you simple sucks! tatas alll ou don't have the knowledge to talk abou t pink floyd ou're a looser ou play the geetars... good! but you sucks man you're not gilmour...you'll never be..I've beeen paying guitar alla my life..not 12 year you sucker,....you're sucker! shut thata fuck up!!!....wake up man!!! shut thta fuck up!!!
Again, all you are pegging is me. It's no longer about Gilmour. Please calm down, it's absolutely pointless and immachure to use such volgarity in this sort of arguement. If you will please retype that last comment, becuase I understand less than half of that. But what ever your the one that's getting upset. I don't have enough knowledge to speak of Pink Floyd, well you obviously don't have enough knowledge to defend Pink Floyd. Again, your not making any sense, your talking about me not Gilmour
Apparently you don't have enough knowledge to speak of the Floyd because you have yet to respond to me on my point that A Saucerful of Secrets was used as a finale.
okay Mr. B miner... "Finally" whatever. It's a good tune. So your saying Waters with the Percussion role is more egostistical than the guitarist whom said he was better than Hendrix? I know all about roger waters, he's a brutal song writer and he took the band in his own direction, upset at the government,father died in Black Friday ,etc. Back on the actual subject. Gilmour is egotistical aswell as roger Gimour butchered this particular performance with his banshee voice and quacky Strat.
Es hermoso, hasta puedo ver el túnel que lleva al cielo. Les dejo la secuencia de acordes para que practiquen en sus casas XD. ACabo de encender mi Yamaha a todo volumen con sonido "Hammond"...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
LoL, did you see Dave's vocals?
Ahhahha..
I think Rick Wright is the most talented person in the group there. Because:
- Dave was a child as you see, he was newest and newbiest.
- Roger didn't have a musical talent, Syd was according his bass.
- Nick was the "normal"(?) man. I mean he said that: "I wish I would be a racer". I think he was just doing his job, kicking the drums, I don't believe that he gave something to the group.
Awesome... forever awesome. Haha wow... This does a great job at focusing in on all of them, which is a pretty important thing. Haaha what was Roger yelling at 4:30 or so? Either way, they seemed to be having lots and lots of fun... Haha, I can't stop laughing. Good to see them happy.
I think backthen musicians just were out there to make music, not to please the Label execs as they have to today. That's why a band like PF wouldn't make it today. Everything is made for under 5 minutes formats.
But all that aside, we are very fortunate that times were different and a band like Pink Floyd came to be.
You are so right. They actually wrote their own music - didn't have a bunch of song writers etc. writing songs for them to sing like they do today. It is like a sausage machine nowadays. No real talent. There are bands like Foo Fighters, Velvet Relover et al who do their own writing, but generally it is
They have to release a Saucerful of Secrets Immersion set!!!
lnormann2410 2 weeks ago
one thing that kind of annoys me about pink floyd videos sometimes is that they have all these stupid effects for half of it and i jsut want to see the band
angelfang 8 months ago in playlist Pink Floyd
Omg it's so sad music is so shit now ,( this times were so colorful !
diegosandvrs 9 months ago
asi es...indiscutible !!!! pero suena mal....
claudiazepam 11 months ago
asi es...indiscutible !!!!
claudiazepam 11 months ago
The Massed Gadgets of Hercules This is Genuin they can just sit down play whats in there mind and sell it. i Love it
hahahaha1188 1 year ago
MOST EPICEST!!! SONG WOOOOOOOO
salchiwebo 1 year ago
what kind of organ is that? it deosnt look like a farfisa compact duo that Rick used to play this. So may be it is a Hammond m-100 that used in the studio version...
mikedeliv 1 year ago
How the band found this chord progression, I do not know, but I wonder...
MrCkufu 1 year ago
@MrCkufu juz play around wit the notes. have patience n you'l find the progression. try not to rely on tabs. makes you a better guitarist when u learn it by ear
slayerkills1 1 year ago
did you noticed that around minute 4:38 rogers screams something like "one more!!" and they keep playing a little longer?? poor david you can tell he was tired jaja
adriancol87 1 year ago
beautiful ,made me cry. i love floyd.is this particular performance available on a dvd or vhs somewhere?
RockDreams1000 1 year ago
where is this one from again?
TEMPmichaelhansen 1 year ago
@TEMPmichaelhansen
Holland Pop Festival in Rotterdam
axelhesse 1 year ago
Doesn't this song have a name? And words? I swear it was on Saucerful of Secrets Album, but now I'm not sure.
LeeWhite999 1 year ago
Nick's out of his head here and could probably have played the whole thing in his sleep. They are all epic.
BigGunsBates 1 year ago
PINK Anderson & FLOYD Council.
zeppelin6572 1 year ago 2
With Rick now sadly gone, I will never see them live again in my lifetime. They have been with me since I bought Relics in 1972......I now have to live out my life with the recordings that exist and the odd gems that turn up from time to time like this. @luisanas, thanks for posting. May be one day I will see them again on the other side.....if there is another side ;)
HarryAardvark 1 year ago 2
THE GREATEST SOUND EVER CREATED THE GREATEST SONG THE GREATEST LIVE SHOWS ,,ALL BELONGS TO PINK FLOYD
deansusky 1 year ago 5
wow mason
maiaiberia 1 year ago
OMG...... its fuck´n amazing
floyd best band everrrrrrrrrrr!!
ozkrfuckers 1 year ago
THIS IS MY FAVORITE VERSION : EPIC and GLORIOUS ,
PINK FLOYD IS THE SOUNDTRACK OF MY LIFE...
FeloMateo 1 year ago
i change my opinion, this is better than ummagumma, and better than pompeii.. too bad the recording is awful.
denarikan 1 year ago
This esoteric performance was recorded live at Kralingen/Holland in 1970. Wish
I was there !
BrettMayaAllisonTory 1 year ago 2
@BrettMayaAllisonTory
thanks.. i reckon it was amazing..
denarikan 1 year ago
Amazing that it has been over 40 years and they still rock. This music and this band were ahead of their time. No question about that.
adamsv1000 1 year ago 2
great version... different but just as good as the ummagummma version. does anyone know where and when this was recorded?
denarikan 1 year ago
good version but pompeii is my favorite
ledzeppelinnnnnn 1 year ago 3
...OMG
LastZweetDrug 1 year ago
Mason rules
SELFsufficiently 1 year ago
pink floyd es mi grupo favorito y este video no se que tiene pero me encanta!!
marklrd 1 year ago
Wow!
0bananaskin0 1 year ago
THAT WAS AWESOME!!
GCMPJLRMYLIFE 1 year ago
for those who said that they cant stand The Devision Bell:
a true fan of should be able to listen to any album, any song put out by that band. i love each floyd album because it is so uniquely different to the others. The Devision Bell is very minimalist and peacefull, A Momentary Lapse Of Reason was all about showing Waters what Gilmour, Mason & Wright could do without him, so it is very emotionaly charged.
some people are wayy to dismissive of post Waters Floyd. it frustrates me......
seantheman121 1 year ago 3
@seantheman121
Wright's contributiton to the momentary lapse of reason was very minimal... me thinks..
denarikan 1 year ago
well he was brought in after the album was finished recording, but it still involves the same principle
seantheman121 1 year ago
@seantheman121 I agree with you 100%
Foodylox 1 year ago
@seantheman121 you cant just love all if their music because its floyd but because you appreciate it on its own not the fact that pink floyd made it
sixssixtsixc 1 year ago
i mean purely in saying that whatever people say, momentary lapse of reason and the division bell do sound like floyd albums to me and that is why i like both albums.
some people with disagree about that of course, but thats their opinion on the records
seantheman121 1 year ago
what a treasure, thanz for posting...
janmadytay 1 year ago
Does anyone remember where this was recorded? It was a festival, featuring also the soft machine, it's a beautiful day, and more. I had it on VHS but I lost it...
Antisthenes1 1 year ago
thats a great video to one of my favorite music pieces,,but the sound quality is aweful..thnx anywayz
Mohannad22886 2 years ago
I think the quality is quite good when you take the year under the consideration.
Arturdg1bk 2 years ago
Ummagumma album version of this
extraordinary simphony is to me the most
elaborate performance of the Floyd. But
this dark sided and desperate Kralingen
recording has always been one of my favs
BrettMayaAllisonTory 2 years ago
I haven't seen this version before-- the more versions/recordings of this song I can find the better!! The Live at Pompeii recording of it has got to be my favorite; maybe my favorite song of all time. Echoes is up there, too.
thx01138 2 years ago
Every time i hear that shit i can't stop shouting "oooooooo ooooohohohohohooooohohohooo oooooooo aoaooaooooaoaooo aaa aaaah heee haaa o oh ooooooo" That's AWESOME
trojanlol 2 years ago 6
Yes, those vocals get down to my soul...
lucho663 2 years ago
wow if only we never had the X-Factor today maybe music would still be as good as this
Greig1424 2 years ago
What a trip........
1982HAIG 2 years ago
How can anyone hate the division bell. Of course you are entitled to your own opinion. I think all music recorded was awesome by Pink Floyd. If any dislikes.....you should dislike music of today's generation.
wm7888 2 years ago
agreed wm7888 todays music has no soul or flare. Its always the same shit, never will there be another soulfull band such as floyd, not with the way music today is heading.
XDiverseUniverseX 2 years ago
@XDiverseUniverseX - thats total crap. Pop music has always been lame no matter what generation. Pink Floyd was not a pop band in the 70s. Its the people that choose to do something different that have a real impact. It still holds true today. There are many talented artists today its just that the music and media industry are doing a better job at shoving banal pop music down your throat then they were 30 years ago. If you believe all music is shit today then your not looking hard enough.
clehneis 2 years ago 2
@clehneis Even if this musical generation did have soul they'd sell out to those big record labels and they would shape them into something that makes good money. Green day for example, look at the change there, they used to be awesome now they're all dark black hair emo lookin people, jus coz thats whats hot.
XDiverseUniverseX 2 years ago
Big record companies have shaped bands since the beatles explosion. They are just getting better at marketing because of the technology advances that we've seen over the years. They can make someone who has very little talent sound amazing in the recording studio. Thats why you see the explosion of crap artists now. Thats not to say that there are real talented people playing music today. There are a lot you just need to learn how to filter out the crap.
clehneis 2 years ago
DB's music is good, but i can't stand the lyrics and David Gilmours singing on it.
superdude13666 2 years ago
@wm7888 - Because its not the real pink floyd. It was the combination of Waters and Gilmour as front men that made the band so interesting. Now its just like soft core porn or something. Gilmour so focused on his tone than actually making some interesting sounding music. It doesn't do it for me. Pop music has always been banal no matter what generation its been in. It 's the people that choose to do something different that have a real impact and it still holds true today.
clehneis 2 years ago
Hate Division Bell? It's much more in line with the Pink Floyd sound than The Wall, Final Cut or Momentary Lapse of Reason. And for that reason I enjoy it more.
bryanswagerty 2 years ago
@bryanswagerty - No it wasn't. Division Bell was what David Gilmour wanted Pink Floyd to be. Its crap. It was the combination of Waters twisted lyrics and Gilmours awesome tone and playing that made pink floyd who they were.
clehneis 2 years ago
it was in Kralingen pop festival, Netherlands
antoineguguen 2 years ago
This is insane beauty.
This beauty is insane.
Godspeed Pink Floyd...
Rabidsenses 2 years ago 3
where was this?
mightyzeppelin 2 years ago
Wish I had A Doanut
Hysteriabelle70 2 years ago
This is the most Powerful song in history!!!
thanks for uploading!
flosyd 2 years ago 3
I think Nick Mason could have been the one who first used timpani mallets on a drum set.
HaydenFromHell 2 years ago 3
He's realy creative.
tie32101 2 years ago
a few jazz drummers in the 50s used them
VUnit258 2 years ago
Comment removed
qbc176 2 years ago
i want mason's stache
j0rdanb0yle 2 years ago
omg waters with short hair ???? o_O
heuilleman 2 years ago
AH AH AH
Lioanimals1977 2 years ago
but division bell was way later than this
TheXPatient 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thats blasephy. division bell didnt have ROGER OR SYD! Division Bell is the worst album! Come onnnn it came out in 1994! THIS IS WAYYYY BETTERRRR!!!!
humplik07 2 years ago
SORRY! I completely misread that. I thought you wrote BETTER instead of LATER...
humplik07 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HHAHA its cool I hate division bell too. just read more carefully haha
TheXPatient 2 years ago
Looks a lot better than the last one, which someone said it was a studio version.
Does anyone remember the album with a large head on it. I thought it was Relics, but the one on web site "PF" was different picture.
lois228gmail 2 years ago
the one with the heads is division bell
TheXPatient 2 years ago
Relics had a mask sort of thing on the cover of the reissue.
littledite 2 years ago
Love Rogers hair here! :D
J0nnan 2 years ago
Wonderful from the beginning!
mobydikp 2 years ago
looks like my dad
poluza9 2 years ago
this song is wonderful and i think it's quite underrated..
andreapf1989 2 years ago 10
because studio version is bad
only seldom gilmour singing part good
limunan 2 years ago 2
What are these floating pyramids, part of the show? Does anyone know where this footage was shot? I love it anyhow!
PEEBLIES 3 years ago
It was a festival sometime around '70/'71 in Holland that featured Jefferson Airplane and Carlos Santana. The footage of this show is available on the concert video "Stamping Ground."
Y2KV 2 years ago 2
This is truly amazing to see. To me this is the time where Pink Floyd was at its best musically speaking. Before all of the drama began. I love it
shtty17 3 years ago 6
i agree with you , it is amazing but on the other hand when you make more and more money the ego is growing with you or is awaken and then division bell rings and everybody has its own free will to go and create more beauty or else whether
is more magic in this piece or that one is up to you to discover. All i want to say to You that we have to be thankful for P.Floyd and these genetic circumstances that brought these people together so we can indulge their music be happy and creative
Kozanecke 2 years ago
bueno para mi esta cancion esta a toda madre ma cae la vida es un platillo de secretos vivan la banda este grupo cambio mi forma de ver la musica ampliaron mis conocimientos en horabuena para syd barret y para todos ....
bobfloyd20 3 years ago 3
Rick i miss you say hello to Syd
mazinger95350 3 years ago 38
say hello for me too...
tammerlane25 3 years ago 2
Taking everything into account, lyrics, albums, music, arrangements, I'd put Pink Floyd as the greatest band of all time.
Carlisle3Leeds1 3 years ago 105
@Carlisle3Leeds1 . No argument from me.....my all time number 1 with Led Zep at number 2 and Yes at number 3.
HarryAardvark 1 year ago
@HarryAardvark
all those bands rule
TEMPmichaelhansen 1 year ago
Gran músico que deja una gran contribución a la música. Seguramente se fue tranquilo y satisfecho. RIP.
ehsorcia 3 years ago
rick wright is on heaven .we love you man .we miss you .this really brings me to tears i dont know how to express myself all the words his creations meant to the world and to me.now he is in heaven playing this beautiful music .
bengativo6 3 years ago 6
Man , they are fucking cool
giorgos4life 3 years ago 3
Rick Wright, no te olvidaremos (1943-2008)
galmier18 3 years ago 4
R I P Rick
In our heart you are immortal
Please..say hallo..syd in heaven
absinther666 3 years ago 2
hahahaha, i love how waters says "One more" in the video, so that they go through it once more
Nathantok7 3 years ago
One of my favorites. But Gilmour never really hit this vocal, from the 3 or 4 I've heard...
Anyone know of a band that could pull off this song now?
assfuckhole 3 years ago
Try the live at pompeii version. I rather like that one.
oddtunes 3 years ago
The constant symbol crashing is so loud and am surprized you don't complain about that. What I can hear of Gilmore sounds like a bass vocal. The drummer used way too much symbol that you can barely hear the other instruments. I just look at it as an experiment that didn't turn out the best they could have done, so move on to what works.
lois228gmail 3 years ago
Your claim is very uncertain, please define your strange feeling more precisely but on the other website!
Dodkar 3 years ago
Pink floyd's Saucer Full of Secrets, I was commenting on what I hear at my end, that the recording was not clear and I thought it was possible the compression for YouTube made it sound bad, and the symbols were too loud for my taste for this song. Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands, since 1968.
lois228gmail 3 years ago
TBH I'm pretty sure this is a live recording and WYHIWYG ... or rather what they played then and laid down to the limits of a 1970s non-studio recording system.
For a live rendition of a pretty complex piece of prog/psychadelia I rate it highly ;-)
Farweasel 3 years ago 2
this inducts me to floyd
thelastcupofsorrow 3 years ago
thy do a much better version in 1971
smouch..net/lol
great song
justiniscoolohyea 3 years ago
This is my new favorite version of this song. Is there a bootleg this is on?
BrokenChair88 3 years ago
Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".
BrokenChair88 3 years ago
great song but needs more sound, i like this version
abisail 3 years ago
no fucking way i am a loose relation of gilmoors but hendrix was a better guitarist gilmoor is a better band member whereas hendrix was the experience gilmoore is a big part of the floyd but not the only talent at work
nutcase315 3 years ago
Some loose relation... you can't even spell his name correctly.
heretic1488 3 years ago
Is there any doubt that Gilmour was a better guitarist than Hendrix? Is there any doubt that Gilmour is the best guitarist of all time? When God created the guitar, he created David Gilmour along with it so that the masses can learn from the master. Hendrix was a mediocre student at best.
GiantAias 3 years ago
dude...i'm a huge gilmour fan but you might want to rethink what u just said.
it aint possible. Hendrix was from another planet. And his legacy is just 4 years of music..
LoneDerangerer 3 years ago
seconded. I love and admire Gilmour for everything he did, but he surely is not the best guitarist of all time (in terms of technique at least). But I remember a nice quote I read somewhere which sums this discussion up very well: "Gilmour doesn't hit many tunes. But he hits the right ones."
ClassicManiac 3 years ago 4
Hendrix, Hendrix, blah blah blah... One of the most over-rated artists of all time. "You might want to rethink...", as if I told the Pope Jesus wasn't all that he's made up to be.
GiantAias 3 years ago
so what if hendrix was over rated, he was fucking good! dont you think theres a reason
he's over rated?
hendrixqwe 3 years ago
hendrixqwe, you're so dumb I don't even know how to reply to your comment.
GiantAias 3 years ago
wow your smart
hendrixqwe 3 years ago
If you had more than three grams of brain, you'd say "wow you're smart", not "wow your smart". Now go back to your trailer, sit on your rent-to-own easy chair, relax, and leave me alone, moron.
GiantAias 3 years ago
You did it! You replyd to his coment! I knew you could do it.
BrokenChair88 3 years ago
no good sound in this video
alimite 3 years ago
Excuse me, but are you saying that David Gilmour has a bad voice? Well if that's the case, take this into consideration. Pink Floyd composed some of the most vocally challenging melodies in rock music. The fact that he is still able to sing songs nowadays that men half his age find difficult at best is a testament to his talent and destroys your point. And that "quacky strat" of his was the primary guitar used on every Floyd album from Atom Heart Mother through The Final Cut.
heretic1488 3 years ago 2
He does have a nice voice, but what I originally said was that he butchered this particular performance. He sounds great on all the Pompeii videos and he sounds good on many albums. He just sounds like a cat being strangled by a violin in this one.
I said that strats are quacky. They are indeed quacky and twangy, that's one of the attributes Fender aims for, it's sound is desirable for many artists. I for one don't like the sound, and find them to have very little sustain and too much treble.
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
he does sound bad in this one
SimMaster 3 years ago
Anyway,it was never Gilmour who had the huge ego, it was Waters. Roger Waters is my biggest hero, but he is dick. However, in his defense, he knew exactly want he wanted to do when he was in Pink Floyd and when the others had no idea where they should be headed musically and conceptually. So how can you say that David Gilmour was the one with the egomania when it was clearly Waters? Gilmour barely made any decisions in the band. Waters is shouting for another round of the chord progression.
heretic1488 3 years ago
About my different parts of the fretboards comment, I am well aware that both songs are in B minor and that they're share the same octive during the verses, but you're not going to convince me that a memorable portion of Comfortably Numb's final solo is not played an octive higher than that of Money.
heretic1488 3 years ago
para mi esta es la mejor version de saucerful pink floyd en vivo es un agasajo
ebalsuriel 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't hate this
gabyroxs109 3 years ago
bengativo6 you are very ignorant
gabyroxs109 3 years ago
Gilmour kinda butchered it :(
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
it's a little rough and ready, but man the passion and energy! think it's the "stamping ground" film. man, wouldn't you just love to hear this sucker properly remastered? sure there's mistakes, but wright's totally into it, and mason's burning.
- thewordofgord
thewordofgord 3 years ago
Comon anyone can use a slide. Gilmour is another example of simple playing being regarded as epic.
Pink Floyd is indeed about the passion but Gilmour is beyond predictable in his guitar playing technique, what can he honestly do? Play a Blues Scale back and forth and maybe introduce an old Blues lick? Comon! The solos for Money and Comfortably Numb are on the exact same scale just played in a different pace!
I love all of the members of Floyd to death but he really butchers songs sometimes.
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
You are an ignorant.
Carloteiro 3 years ago
It ain't about technique, it about feeling. It all about express emotions and touch people hearts. He can use just one or two licks (like BB King for instance) but he knows how play and touch people... I hang around and see lots of people with amazing skills, playing fast as a bullet, but without touch anyone. What do you prefer? It's matter of choice :-)
jackflashrj 3 years ago
Carloteiro, Gimour said that he was better than Hendrix! If you want a rational direction with your life, I'm sure that maybe the idea of Gilmour being ignorant will help you.
jackflashrj, what i felt from his playing was just gurble from his voice and the muddy distortion from the combination of what ever the hell he's put his strat through.
To each his own, but my own is that Gilmour butchered this version.
Some things never change ;)
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
Well clearly if you are such an enlightened critic, you would have no issues with writing a song with well-crafted lyrics, an interesting melody and a god-inspired guitar solo and posting it on youtube in order to let everyone see if you have any real virtue in critiquing someone of David Gilmour's stature.
Oh, and anyone with a basic education in music could determine that the solos of Comfortably Numb and Money are simply played on different parts of the fretboard as they're both in B minor.
heretic1488 3 years ago
same part of the fretboard actually. same key same octive. :)
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
I really don't understand how "passion" justifies how sucky gilmour is. He's just another EGP. (Egotistical Guitar Player/or Extra Gay Player for some).
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
I mean... Since when does "passion" justify a sloppy performance?
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
Well by all means, point out exactly in this video where the sloppiness lays, and then give me an example of your own god-like passion. And have you ever considered the fact that the Floyd played A Saucerful of Secrets as their last song of their shows in the early 70's, and that after almost two hours of playing, wouldn't you give anyone some room for blundering?
heretic1488 3 years ago
Your really upset about somebody critisizing Gilmour.
The last bit of comfortably numb is indeed in the same key different octive, i will agree on that. But the basic spine, if you will, are both in the same spot on the fret board.
You have no idea how simplistic this man really is? I've been playing guitar for 11 years and when i was just fourteen i realized how easy it is to play any form of floyd.
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
Gilmour may have way more years experience than I. But, if the qoute from Gilmour "I'm better than Hendrix" rings a bell, then you'd understand why he's such an egotistical prick
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
Where's that quote from? When I Google it, I only get this video. I'd also like to use this opportunity to diss both you and Cesgord on account of grammar.
AlbertMondback 3 years ago
wikiqoute
type David Gilmour
3rd qoute states:
"Jimi Hendrix isn't as good as me!"
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
ok, I went to wikiquote and typed in his name and found the quote. You must be kind of thick. Have you ever seen the interview sections of Live at Pompeii? Well if you have, you'd have noticed that during the entire time, the Floyd were making fun of each other and of themselves. That quote and the other two from the Pompeii interviews are ment to be jokes. He didn't literally mean that he was better than Jimi Hendrix. It was a completely sarcastic remark.
heretic1488 3 years ago
Not only that, but the Interviews in Live At Pompeii were staged.
AlbertMondback 3 years ago
Sounds good to me.
In that case I'll admit that I misjudged him.
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
Fuck you.
aDeSe18 3 years ago 2
pfff the best thing about gilmour is the simple way he plays and the extremely feel he put in each simple easy predictable notes and keys he plays...now you Britania, go on! compose a single song or just a solo with all the scales you learnded in your apatethic 12 years playing guitar...I'm sure you will have not success...pff 12 years playing guitar and you think you can talk about Gilmour the way you do...the only egocentric man here is you! you really suck man!
cesgord 3 years ago
Success means nothing to me actually. Is it egotistical to critisize? If it be, then you are indeed a hypocrit for critisizing me. Critisism is just one of the endoresments the first amendment gives anybody. It is a heathly thing to have ones opinion, but you, you have absolutly no rational direction or purpose toward what I'm talking about. Feal free to join in the aguement when you can type more than one sentence defending Gilmour and not bashing me.
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
If you think i suck then be a critic on my videos, not in the middle of this eventuallity.
Thank you
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
man you simple sucks! tatas alll ou don't have the knowledge to talk abou t pink floyd ou're a looser ou play the geetars... good! but you sucks man you're not gilmour...you'll never be..I've beeen paying guitar alla my life..not 12 year you sucker,....you're sucker! shut thata fuck up!!!....wake up man!!! shut thta fuck up!!!
cesgord 3 years ago
Again, all you are pegging is me. It's no longer about Gilmour. Please calm down, it's absolutely pointless and immachure to use such volgarity in this sort of arguement. If you will please retype that last comment, becuase I understand less than half of that. But what ever your the one that's getting upset. I don't have enough knowledge to speak of Pink Floyd, well you obviously don't have enough knowledge to defend Pink Floyd. Again, your not making any sense, your talking about me not Gilmour
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
Apparently you don't have enough knowledge to speak of the Floyd because you have yet to respond to me on my point that A Saucerful of Secrets was used as a finale.
heretic1488 3 years ago
okay Mr. B miner... "Finally" whatever. It's a good tune. So your saying Waters with the Percussion role is more egostistical than the guitarist whom said he was better than Hendrix? I know all about roger waters, he's a brutal song writer and he took the band in his own direction, upset at the government,father died in Black Friday ,etc. Back on the actual subject. Gilmour is egotistical aswell as roger Gimour butchered this particular performance with his banshee voice and quacky Strat.
BritaniaRuleAgain 3 years ago
beszélj magyarul,a hang 1 kicsit
gyenge ,de át jött.
LILALA09 3 years ago
FLOYD POWER!
AlbertMondback 3 years ago 2
a no era las ruinas de pompeya jo pero esta weno el live
fdogrungero07 3 years ago
huh??
bengativo6 3 years ago
amo este tema y el documusical la raja lo vi por vez primera como el 91
fdogrungero07 3 years ago
huuuuuhh??
bengativo6 3 years ago
Es hermoso, hasta puedo ver el túnel que lleva al cielo. Les dejo la secuencia de acordes para que practiquen en sus casas XD. ACabo de encender mi Yamaha a todo volumen con sonido "Hammond"...
Bm, A, E, F#, D, G, A, F#, Bm, G, F#, Em, D, F#
nochonocho 4 years ago
I don´t think so.
Remember Roger Made a good job with that disk...what is it´s name?..amm... oh yes..The Dark Side of The moon...
Rick just plays the keyboards he doesn´t create the music.
ikicm91 4 years ago
actually Rick came up with the keyboard sequence on Us and Them as well as Great Gig In The Sky, one of my favorite tracks on DSOTM.
crackmunch 4 years ago
huh??
bengativo6 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LoL, did you see Dave's vocals?
Ahhahha..
I think Rick Wright is the most talented person in the group there. Because:
- Dave was a child as you see, he was newest and newbiest.
- Roger didn't have a musical talent, Syd was according his bass.
- Nick was the "normal"(?) man. I mean he said that: "I wish I would be a racer". I think he was just doing his job, kicking the drums, I don't believe that he gave something to the group.
All of these makes Rick best member of that era.
mias4691 4 years ago
First Roger, then gilmour... that's it
oilime83 4 years ago 2
you are just saying a bunch of stupid things,,shut the fuck up
you will never in your life sing like
none of this guys even if you had the magic rub lamp.
you are just a stupid fag who just hidding deep inside the closet.
pink floyd is the best band ever.
remember that .
you are just a fagg!!
bengativo6 3 years ago 3
Awesome... forever awesome. Haha wow... This does a great job at focusing in on all of them, which is a pretty important thing. Haaha what was Roger yelling at 4:30 or so? Either way, they seemed to be having lots and lots of fun... Haha, I can't stop laughing. Good to see them happy.
McMunchy 4 years ago
I think he was screaming 'one more'.
budmaster666 4 years ago
NICK MASON, what godly drums!
BluesVeins 4 years ago 5
God damn Syd Berret is a fucking genius
pigsquealler666 4 years ago
"A Saucerful of Secrets" (Roger Waters, Richard Wright, David Gilmour, Nick Mason)
No Barrett...
Quentinmique 4 years ago 8
he is a genious dude.but he does not appear in this video this was made on 1970 .syd was long gone 2 years from the floyd at that time
bengativo6 3 years ago 2
i barely heard it...
Jaunzin 4 years ago
I think backthen musicians just were out there to make music, not to please the Label execs as they have to today. That's why a band like PF wouldn't make it today. Everything is made for under 5 minutes formats.
But all that aside, we are very fortunate that times were different and a band like Pink Floyd came to be.
disndat11 4 years ago 2
The actual song is over ten minutes, this is just a live one
LSDCoatedBrain 4 years ago 2
You are so right. They actually wrote their own music - didn't have a bunch of song writers etc. writing songs for them to sing like they do today. It is like a sausage machine nowadays. No real talent. There are bands like Foo Fighters, Velvet Relover et al who do their own writing, but generally it is