Added: 2 months ago
From: NostalgiaCriticFan7
Views: 33,496
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (334)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think The Grinch is kinda "meh"... Cat in the Hat is a lot worse, there's not even one likeable character in that movie.

  • I used to adore this movie. But hey, if somethings bad, its bad.

  • @vissova I used to think that, but then I took an arrow in the knee.

  • uhhh i put my pipe down i had hash

  • 2:38 Wow! Now NC scared me.

  • I hate Jim Carrey. He's annoying, over the top, and every performance is like his last.

  • i think its hilarious how the critic rhymed in his review when the grinch movie barely had any rhyming in it at all

  • "Ya know, For kids!!"

  • I love how the Critic made even the review sound Dr. Seuss-ish with the rhyming!

  • the lorax movie was actually good, it annoyed me that taylor swift was it, but zac efron isn't the bad actor that he use to be, after THOSE movies that will never be named, and has actually gotten somewhat good at times, i liked how the movie was had a story inside a story, i love it when those happen.

  • @BlueRise85 Personally I think the flashback should have been the entire movie, take out the stupid love story and just make it about the Lorax and the One-cer.

  • But I thought people loved this movie? Not me really because I hated how they would immediately counter the Grinches villainy with humour ie the scene where he flips out after realising the girl he has a crush on is a shallow bitch.

  • cindy loo-who's song literally made my brother cry...(the bad cry, not the good one.)

  • I never understood why people liked this version. It was way over the top with its juvenile humor and ridiculously stupid jokes.!

  • Comment removed

  • Hahaha, I love how even the clips from different movies rhyme.

  • I don't think The Lorax remake is going to be good either, because of 2 people.............

    Zac Efron and F***ING TAYLOR SWIFT!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!­!!

  • @SmilieChick16 Wait what....They're in it?! wow. that makes it worse. Plus, I never liked the poster and trailer. It looks pretentious and uncreative.

  • @SmilieChick16 it sucked

  • I kinda liked this movie.

  • This movie really is a piece of shit.

  • @killer92173

    It's not so bad, even it's not a big hit.

  • @bluethunder25 Plus who said this Grinch is a Remake? It's not a remake; it's a different adaptation. I don't know how he thinks it's remake, but it's not.

  • @killer92173 i see what you did there

  • @mikayla690 Yeah. I think we all agree that the live action Cat in the Cat movie is worse!! If that movie doesn't make Dr. Seuss roll in his grave, I don't know what will.

  • Oh, man--I eagerly waited 11 months for this flick to come out and... HATED it! From the experience, I knew better than to watch the live-action "Cat in the Hat."

  • I liked it but one time, in middle school 3 of my teachers played this movie and i saw this 3 times in one day ughhhh

  • I've always hated this movie, critic..

    my sisters used to watch this movie every damn day. I finally slid the disc under the entertainment center. No more fuckery :D

  • the script is probably why this review was released a few days late.

  • uh... family video rental... funny

  • I liked this movie when I was little but I still think this review is funny

  • the colors look bright to me

  • When the Grump got an idea, I shat myself at that face.

  • This is one of my new favorite reviews

  • I hate this movie because it gave taylor momsen her big break. Nuff' said

  • The Nostalgia Critic has some impressive rhyming skills!

  • I love this movie, Sorry the NC didn't like it but I grew up watching this every christmas and still watch it when the holidays come around. Some of the acting wasn't great (really didn't like Mayor or Cindy that much) but Jim Carrey was hilarious and did a great job at the Grinch in my opinion. As far as the song goes I like the Faith Hill version 10 times better, the kid can't really sing.

  • This is one of the best Nostalgia Critic review EVER

  • PG rating, that's the MPAA's doing. Did you know Home on the Range also got a PG rating? Kind of ironic since it seemed like it was just geared towards little kids. and it was just for that one line that a cow says about her udder "Yeah their real. Quit starring." It's amazing what you can't get away with in movies now a days. In the 90s Home on the Range would have easily gotten a G rating.

  • I love the movies that you make fun of, but you're really funny and I like you <3 I'm a subscriber :D

  • pause at 2:36

    

  • It's weird because most people hate this movie, not love it.

  • bat credit card

  • Almost everyone I know loves this film, critic, open your ears

    at least we all know what christmas humour is,

    and for giving this film a negative review

    I hate you... hate, hate, hate,

    hate, hate, hate...

    double-hate... LOATHE ENTIRELY!!!

  • Comment removed

  • In my opinion the grinch is a good movie.

  • He needs to do the Cat In the Hat 2004

  • critic this movie came out in late 2000. i thought u said it had to come out before 2000 cuz thats ur cutoff date

  • 1:35 I might liked that film

  • @benkenobi2011 Um, I hated "Hakuna Matata," too. If no one agrees with you, don't get all butthurt. Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Now, try to understand that, moron.

  • Comment removed

  • Ok I knew that Confused matthew was an moron. However I thought their was hope for you, but I guess the sad truth is... You and Confused Idiot... Are MISERABLE HEARTLESS BUSTARDS. Ok I admit that you have some good taste in disney movies, but you still got issues, and sadly their is no hope for Confused Matthew. Except for 3 or 4 movies. it seems Confused Dumass hates everything he watches. Did his parents drop him on his head at a young age?

  • @benkenobi2011 What? If this is an insult, it's a pretty bad one. He can have his opinion and you can have yours, but he can't be a miserable heartless "bustard" for having one, but it can't be right or wrong. And he doesn't hate everything he watches, the point of his reviews is he's suppose to be CRITICAL of them so he chooses movies he can critique badly. Anyway, according to you his opinion is wrong therefore you are immediately thrown into the fire with the rest of the stupid internet.

  • @benkenobi2011 Hey look, some prick who thinks his opinions matter and nobody elses does, please read "Ahmed176E"'s comment.

  • I actually liked this movie despite its flaws, but its always great to see a new review. And the beginning is so damn clever haha. I love the Critic.

  • "I must stop Christmas from sucking! But how?"

    Sounds like a job for Santa Christ.

  • I hate it, yet I love it.

    Guilty Pleasure I guess. 

  • The movie sucked. We watched it in school and I swear half of us would rather be doing homework.

  • @choclateitsallgood For me, it was Elf. -shudders- And I DID do homework.

  • This was an EXTREMELY pointless remake. I completely agree with the Critic on this movie.

  • Is this movie bad? Yes. Is it unentertaining? Not necessarily

  • I don't blame Nostalgia Chick; I like Nightcrawler, too.

    By the way, what's the matter with blue?

  • I grew up watching this movie and it's still my go to christmas movie.

  • The reason that the Grinch is so crazy in this one is because he has gone completely insane from being alone so long. The only company he has is Max, so he entertains himself with these crazy stunts!

  • Carey's role in this movie? ANNOYING?!! Not half as nnoying as this review!

  • a critical review that's written in rhyme?! Save it for the kid's books, man.

  • @cabbitsd you sir are a nitwit.

  • @johnhamilton08 Nitwit as that may or may not be, it's my opinion and I am entitled to it as much as I stand by it. (I believe that my nitwittedness or lack thereof is also a matter of opinion, and I shall reserve judgement upon yourself until such time as I get to know you better.)

  • @cabbitsd I said that because you didn't get why the critic did it in rhyme. He did it to change it up. I never said you were not entitled to your opinion. But you're not giving your opinion you're just attacking him.

  • @johnhamilton08 Oh... Forgive me, I thought I made it very clear that it was that he chose to do this review in rhyme which was the big thing that I personally found annoying about this review. It might not even have been so bad if his cadences seemed so... forced... even the movie in question only used rhyme a few select times, so to spoof that is an attack on Dr. Seuss, who is, among other things, NOT in question.

  • @cabbitsd But it's original source material did and he was paying respect to that. Also you try to write an entire review in rhymes.

  • @johnhamilton08 I don't think you're paying attention to me... I just got through saying that the source material isn't in question here. What is in question, at least in this conversation... to ME...  is the review. All I'm saying is that it would be much better TO ME if it wasn't in rhyme because I PERSONALLY find it annoying. The cadences sound forced in places.

    Furthermore, I wouldn't review this movie in rhyme because I'd probably find it annoying.

  • ABOUT DAMN TIME HE DID THIS MOVIE!!

  • hilarious

    

  • Oh my gosh the beginning is so freaking clever. I love it! :) Tee hee

  • Comment removed

  • nostalgia critic sucks

  • Comment removed

  • props 4 making your trolling rhyme XD

  • I like how he rymes the whole time

  • 'Think' and 'big' do not rhyme together!

  • Lol, I disagree with the critic on this movie, I think Jim Carry was perfect. I thought the cartoon was crap since I was a kid. I love the critic to death, but 2:36 is going to give me nightmares. I'll be asleep and his face smiling that evil grin will pop up in my mind and I'll lose my will to live ^_^

  • @TheWinterWaterSong the cartoon is supposed to be simple and for kids, and the grinch himself is supposed to be gritty, hot-tempered, but also subtle and stealthy. what made the cartoon great was Boris Carloff (the Frankenstein-monster) as the voice of the grinch and being the narrator. Jim Carrey however, made the grinch into the complete opposite althoug it's funny at times, but i hated how loud his home is since the grinch is supposed to hate loud noises.

  • I like how the last words in this clip was "Y'know, for kids :D" I never get tired of that.

  • Now that i have seen 'How the Grinch stole Christmas' i enjoy this review more and more (:

  • Agreed 100%

  • I officially hate the nostalgia critic now! Lol that Is one of my favorite Christmas movies! The only problems I can find with it is the song that Cindy sings is pointless nd I hate the fact that they tried to make up there own Seuss words :P lol

  • I remember when it came out in VHS I would watch it every day when I came back from school in 1st grade. This movie is probably tied with Scarface for most watched movie of my life

  • "the Whos are more creepy!"

    Well, what do you expect them to look like in real-life when in the books and the animated version they look like humanoid half monkey-half weasel-mutans? And on top of that, most of them in the animated version walked around naked and were covered in fur and had tails!

  • @Creaturelover18

    I think you were seeing a different movie

  • @starwarsnerd100 no seriously, look at the animated version. okay not all the whos go naked, most of them wear clothes. but those who don't are clearly covered in fur.

  • and now for something completely different. pie.

  • Well you have to admit that the Grinch was a better commercial success than the Cat in the Hat was.

  • @EMaster2006 :D

  • I know this movie is not good at all, and I totally get where NC is coming from, but...I still watch it every year. I think it's hilarious. "Guilty pleasures..."

  • His expressions are hilarious~

  • PERFECT. CUT.

  • i thought it was fine but definatly overrated

  • the live action had some funny lines, to be honest.

  • I barely remember watching the whole film, but I do remember the grinch scaring me.

  • Is there a law to how much mugging a person can do?

  • I respect NC's opinion of this movie, but I actually liked this version. It was funny at times and it's one of my favorite holiday movies. If you wanna see something bad, try the Mike Myer's version of Cat in the Hat.

  • i used to be a ...... wait this joke is getting old.

    but what is never old is this guy, this guy rock, forever and ever to infinity and beyond

  • Randy Newman! 5:19

  • This movie blows like a hooker with shame

    and Jim carrey's acting is incredibly lame.

  • this movie funking blows

  • Not to be rude or anything to nostalgia critic, but stinker as it may be, I think the live action remake of The Grinch wasn't that bad. It made me laugh a lot

  • @SmilieChick16 At least this wasn't the movie based off a Dr Seuss book that was totally shitty (Cat in the Hat 2003)

  • @SmilieChick16 Meh, I thought it was OK. Not bad mind you, just OK. XS

  • @SmilieChick16 We fans respect his opinion as he respects ours. Don't forget, this is the guy who doesn't like "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" from The Lion King or Pixar's Cars.

  • @SmilieChick16 You're right, it wasn't that bad...it was worse.

  • @SmilieChick16 Don't ever be afraid to share your opinion. Nobody can say that you're wrong cause it's how you personally feel. I love this movie and I watch it every christmas. ANd I actually didn't find this review funny at all for that matter--rhyming was annoying.

  • @adamtherock2008 Thanks sir, ^_^ I appreciate that someone cares about my opinion. I know the rhyming was annoying, but that was the point to parody the rhyming bit from the original and new grinch movie.

  • So what if Nostalgia Chick likes Nightcrawler, I do to

  • made it to 4 minutes. really annoying with the constant rhyming

  • This review is hilarious, I love his rhyme's timing, the faces jim carey makes in this movie are funnier than the guy from the shining!

  • I used to be scared of the Grinch's face

  • @MrCheesehed1000 But then I took an arrow to the knee.

  • @shroudedlight777 I knew someon who made make arrow in the knee jokes, then he took a knee in the balls...

  • @MrCheesehed1000 Me too.

  • Try not to laugh while the critic is making that face at 2:36

  • I loved thise movie whane i was 3 now thate i see it it just blows.

  • I found this episode great but not very funny.

  • As much as I like the nostalgia critic, I think he's being a little judgemental assuming the Lorax is going to suck, in a way so sentimental. I mean, no one knows what's going to happen, and no matter what does, people will still be flappin' their gums on how much they hate it, they won't give it a chance in hell, no matter how they make it.

  • @robertsfunny1995

    the lorax IS going to suck

  • @Harleyquinn191 How do you know, that it will blow?

  • @Harleyquinn191 you just like to make uneccesary judgements don't you?

  • How would shoes effect how he feels about something? Obviously he's never worn heels. That kind of never-ending annoying pain would turn anyone into a bitchbag.

  • I never really understood why the Grinch had to sound like Sean Connery.

  • 1:03 That's really a good point. Everyone I asked said "When your shoes hurt you get grumpy".

  • The rhyming... the rhyming... now it's in my head....

  • I love how perfectly he imitates the Grinch's expressions in this reviews opening.

  • ok, i will admit i hate thuis movie, but i kinda like the scene where the Grinch credits Max for removing the red nose, that was pretty funny IMO

  • @ 0:20- 0:28, that's not exactly true. Feelings about this movie have always been quite mixed, with people either loving it or hating it (Like 'Hook'). I liked it, though.

    @ 0:59- 1:06, wearing uncomfortable shoes tends to make people grumpy.

    @ 1:48- 1:52, I was expecting him to say "Whoever said this needs an update deserves to be fired!"

  • Man, I love this movie, I hope the review is at least funny

  • Wait. It seems like he hates Dr. Suess movies. Does he hate horton hears a who?

  • @keggie09 Its just the live action remakes that he dislikes.

  • @keggie09 Correction he hates the remakes he prefers the cartoons but I like both Cartoons and Remakes

  • Anyone else notice the hypocrisy done by this review?

  • 2:36 rape face activated

  • I smiled evilly along with the critic. Who else did? >:D

  • 2:30-2:37 his evil smile is perfect ^_^

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I love this movie to death, but this review is very clever! =)

  • this is really well done.

  • @TheFirstBroBIB Why is this spam? I agree with you, dude!

  • Well, if your shoe's are too tight, then they hurt. Wouldn't that make you less happy! Anyhow, I agree, this movie is crap.

  • Funny how a majority of the comments are as follow:

    "OMG stop disliekin StuFF I liek yOu're a Big fat MeaNIE"

    OR

    "HAhha I haETed thez movee 2 lululsssszzz"

    Instead of:

    "As much of a positive or negative feeling I have for this movie, I respect the NC's opinion and his taste. However I must add that even if his feelings conflict with mine or not, I watch his videos for the sheer hilarity that happens."

  • @ShadoHeart65

    That's reason I watch NC to see is him making jokes about the movies he hates even if it is one I like, for example Rock-a-Doodle.

  • @ShadoHeart65 You sir, have just pwned every troll on this video. Thank you.

  • @ShadoHeart65 Internet kids are retarded, my friend.

  • I like this movie. You can tell Jim Carey tried hard

  • You ended this on the perfect line XD

  • ok, the rhyming was a clever idea, but GOD is it annoying :P

  • I've seen the sets and they were all polyester. Much more interesting was the set behind there...the Bates Motel from "Psycho"! The rhyming is getting on my nerves.

  • i went to the sets where they made the movie and judging by how dark the set is in the film they must have waited for a solar eclipse on a winters night to film the whoville segments

  • Ace Ventura 2 is my favorite Jim Carrey flick

  • I never saw this film for I, like the Critic, think the original is best and doesn't need fixing but hey it's Hollywood, screw original stories, we'll just remake or rip off old stuff, if it aint broke, we'll remake it and make more money

  • that was shit fuck u

  • 1 random note don't fart in a sleeping bag.

  • You know, for kids!!!!!

  • the grinch is the best jim carrey movie but my favorite jim carrey movie but fun with dick and jane is my favorite jim carrey movie