Melanie Amaro - Judges' Houses Performance - THE X FACTOR 2011

[asoicnarf]

FREAKIN AMAZING !!! love u Melanie !!!

[mariedante20]

Talenteddddd...

[bugalper]

she is a copycat she will never be successful in the future voice is not enough she may be back in the stage with beyoncé

[JanekValgepea]

Is it actually live? It cant be performed so well with that small music technic which is on the floor... I watched sometime german x factor and they sang on a boat, so perfectly and the sound was actually like a studio sound.. So they are singing live, but while tv, they put a recorded version?

[Babyyboyy6915]

Shit ill carry her

[preitaly]

wowa wuewa there is a vitality and sweetness in her voice which i never heard from anyone, if you compare it to the show u can say she did really bad there from what i ve seen

[healthhavencom]

By the end, even the birds are chirping.

[Macdivers1]

Thatsss Right!!! Rip! Rip! Contest Over! Melanie wins right here. What a voice! No other even comes close to the vocal performance she gives. After the show ended Melanie was on Kelly Ripas show and admitted that Simon elimated her as a pulblicity stunt. Shame on him and he's a total tool for doing it. Bottom line is that she won as he knew she would.

[bestindabiz17]

Is it just me or does simon look like a pimp?

[ictph3]

i knew from the first time she sang she would win....nobody can beat that!

[pinkodz]

tu es la meilleure ma chère melani!!!

[poopsack6]

@lles2 i 100% agree! i still dont know how chris made it so far with such weak vocals.

[devmanification]

@poopsack6 Lyrically he has a sincere style. I wouldn't say weak, but Melanie is much stronger. Chris has a sincere style about him and that's one of the things he's got going for him. You can hear the inspiration in his vocals.

[lles2]

still cant get enough of this video, chris rene had nothing on this girl,even marcus sings better than chris

[healthhavencom]

Great boobs.

Did she sing something?

[onedayautumn]

Simon give me some of that pepsi ! :3

[rivershoman1]

Her judge house audition was beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee...etc...­....eeeeeeeeeeeee yep still going eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee I can't stop eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeee I need a break eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee bathroom break eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­ee cigaret time eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeee getting a beer eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeYOND AMAZING!!! I saw everyone's judge auditions but NOBODY can't compare to Miss Melanie Amaro!!!

[islesofhapiness]

@rivershoman1 wat a talent........absolutely magnificent!!!!



[TengisKing]

she gave her the look!!! the look that say i'ma kill u if...

[niekles1]

a chance to impress? she did the best auditions what are you talking about? He knew someone like chris rene would beat her if melanie didnt have somewhat of a story.

[CataPoblete05]

she walks like a boy :P

[rivershoman1]

@Outcast better than Drew?!? Are you serious?!?... Melanie is waaaaay better than Drew... What's wrong with you? Clean you ears like I keep saying to Chris Rene Fans, just saying lol!!

[balotelli456]

3:52 BOOB ON THE LEFT

[balotelli456]

3:09 DAMN BOOBS

[melthecoolmoose]

....what an ugly house simon has.....

[yronline]

so amazing

[treasured3]

She tore that song up!! Awesome!!!

[OiaGrace2010]

now what the hell could

simon not like about her performance, even if she was in her comfort zone; if the performance present was good enough why judge her for other things? I loved how she sang that song.

[cresselia67]

one of her best performances=]

[jojey18]

Omg she's amaziiiing!!!!!!

[MultiMele1]

Just Beautiful Melanie!!! Just beautiful! ;D xx <3

[jasonphilly]

it blows my mind that this is a live vocal.. sounds more like an HD studio recording. her voice is legit perfect

[1andonlikb]

she killed it ( n a good way)!!

[maximilianmamacho]

She is amazing!!

[roryyooooo]

SLAYED

[cindieb]

drew who?

[outcastedz]

HOW did she won, Drew Ryniewicz is MUCH better.

[MultiMele1]

@outcastedz Umm? Have u heard Melanie Properly?? Shes 100% Better than Drew!!! o_O

[MaddieSW]

omfg i fucking loveeee thiiissss!! weird how he sent her back home, but also great that he got her back and she won! :D

[CathrineRJ]

Om my God, her song gives me chiilllllsss, wonder how that is possible..?

[Lenee76]

@niekles1 of course, he listend to her, he decided it will be 5 million bucks well spent (she will bring him much more..) but he didnt want to take any chances so he came up with a story that will move the public and get the voters to feel for her and like her. Simon, knows very well how to make money...:)

btw. she deserved to win anyway, great voice.

[crazygfish]

This is almost like a music video~! Amazing~!!

[ratvinc1]

After seeing this, go to Jeniffer Hudson at MJ memorial, singing the same song, then tell me who should've sung at MJ's memorial.

[Bkg581]

@ratvinc1 I went and listened to Jennifer Hudson singing this song. Melanie did it so much better ! Sorry, but I never did know what anyone thought was special about Jennifer Hudson.

[ukeinfused]

this was astoundingly great - yes, she killed it!

[maa053]

Everyone shulda known cuz dat performance wuz the bomb she killed it

[prettymom04]

Simon sent her home so that he can have 5 girls instead of 4 smart move simon!but im glad melanie won!!

[ifluvinguiswrong]

She gave that!

[Worldclassbeauty]

I was so mad when he sent her home! And the sad thing is you know she was not in on this sick joke. You could tell through the live shows and her stage presence she was heartbroken and she lost her confidence. But she still sang her heart out and won it all. So glad she won! You go Melanie!

[Ilovecassi100]

Simon falls over as if to say. Game over, this girl is in a different league. Songs like this and her audition song listen on the radio are just amazingggg! We need her to come out with some big belting songs like that. I think this girl is actually very under rated, she's better than what she showed on some of those live show performances. She did some holding back, but when she had to pull out a performance to save her, she got er done.

[gotosjaa]

Wow, wow and WOW!

[girlz4lives]

she killed that performance...who would send her home after that..simon.....imagine what would have happened if he didnt come back to get her..wow...u won girl!!!!!YYYEEEAAHHHH

[lifeline1702]

I LOVE HER !!!! ..and i can't beleive after THAT performance he cut her out !!! how could anyone think about it even !!!! .... So glad she WOOOOONNNNN

[damackofemall]

I LOVED YOU SINCE DAY 1...YOU HAVE SO MUCH LOVEEEEEEE

[antoine1984]

glad*

[antoine1984]

so gald she won it all. her voice is amazing

[linux2216]

I can't wait until her album comes out. Hearing this girl sing transforms my soul.

[joeypackloveskh]

Me sent her home bc he wanted rachel n her

[davidtoddsingleton]

All of these shows are scripted that way...on purpose to appeal to the audience's sympathy; thereby making them tune in more.

[egondupurity]

simon cowel sent her home to torment us ..& make d show's ratings go up by bringing her back!!!cunningly staged drama ..the girl was better than all the first 30 put together..she sings micheal jackson's songs with meaning & heart & u get d message of her songs & goose bumps all over as u listen to her sing..it is not just her fabulous voice and calm and collected stage presence like a pro...she sings confidence like someone that has been singing professionally 4 19 years at d age of 19...

[egondupurity]

for me the whole show was over once I heard Melanie Amaro sing...she won me over at her first audition

[georgiabunny89]

I could not believe Simon sent her home nd she came the winner!!!!!

[maxie6330]

What is with the rip rip rip? Did he do that because he knew right away she won the show? It makes no sense that he sent her home.... Don't get it unless it was a no brainer win and Simon did it just to drag the dramatics of the show out

[therealPRINCESSNAT]

She was my favorite, I was so glad she won!!

[mi2sredroses]

Simon sent her home so that he would have a reason to get her back & have 5 girls instead of 4. Outsmarted the other judges. Anyway he is the boss & could do anything he wants. Melanie was my pick on the finale & happy that she won as the 1st XF USA Winner!

[andartarius]

she has a great voice but i just dont see star potential in her... i dont know i guess well see

[RmNaNtCbScRrn]

@andartarius close your eyes and listen to her voice, now imagine that sounding from your stereo.. of course she has it!

[RickJames1811]

61 People are haters for not liking this awesome performance.

[selenagomezroxmesox1]

she wonn, yayyy

[bellabelieber98]

Personally, I would rather sing in front of a huge crowd on stage than just to simon.

[RarturoAlevano]

Melanie es la mejor por eso gano bravoooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooo

[FlorentinoLoco]

Simon did it on purpose. He sent her home so that he could bring her back because he knew she would win. Its all about drama

[imjenjoseph]

@FlorentinoLoco so.... was sending home Jazzlyn for the drama as well?

[Violetz1ify]

@FlorentinoLoco and it is also because x factor can also get more views

[LiizMariie27]

i love u melanie

[jolyn329]

And to hunk think he wrote her off for Tia Tolliver and Simone Battle!!! Thank God he came to his senses and brought her back. Cos...SHE WON!!!!!!! YAYAYAYAYAY. So very happy for her. She changed my life. I absolutely love, love, love her. Can't wait to see what she does next. God is good.

[Neisha05100]

I Don't See How Simon Can Send Her Home After That Performance. SMH But He Brung Her Back & Guess Who Won. Yay !!!

[mcneal78]

@Neisha05100 It was destiny! God and Simon Cowell brought her back for a reason! And we found out why!

[whitesoxfanforsure]

AMAZING!!!

[waterman19612001]

He talks about her being in her comfort zone the whole time, but the mentors CHOSE the songs for the contestants to sing.

[030SG]

NOBODY deserved to win it more than Melanie. She was light years ahead of her competition and probably soon to be one of the greats. She was basically the only reason why I was glued to this show week by week. I feel like I know her personally now. And she´s also a VERY beautiful woman. Whoever ends up marrying her, is the luckiest person in the World.

[JGDOLLARD]

At least Simon realized his mistake when he sent Melanie home and then went to get her back! Good for you, Simon....take notes, Nicole.

[JGDOLLARD]

Melanie, you deserve to win the X Factor crown!  You are amazing!

[yronline]

@JGDOLLARD She won! :)

[malykaellison]

i can't believe simon sent her home! good thing he brought her back!

[mpms04]

Yey!!!! SHE WON!!

[Allyspups01]

Wonderful.

[Sexxyllove012]

Shes So Beautiful In and Out thank god she won! we need someone like her! <3

[mi2sredroses]

I was shocked when Simon did not pick her to be on the live show. She has a powerful voice.  I'm glad she won the first XF competition in the USA just like Leona Lewis in England.

[heavenbound0306]

Thank God Simon seen the light!!! I can't believe he sent her home after this performance, but so very thankful that he realized that he did make a mistake and brought her back. She was my pick from start to finish and so delighted she won, because she deserved it. Melanie your Gods gift and he would be so proud!

[FloBustos715]

This,



[renatadezso]

A man who created a show like this, cant be stupid, but an incredible showman. He sent her home to give her more supporter. I am happy she won, she deserve all good, she have shown all the time how grate personality she has. And how incredible voice!!! In the same time Simon had a risky and clever move to send her home and call back. Grate team! Congratulation.

[ashvan3211]

CHRIS RENE ALL THE WAY!!!!

[22paita]

she has great voice! and she sounds like a sweet person! good she won!:)

[mynameiswhatever]

How could he have sent her home after this performance? I'm beginning to think the people who believe he staged sending her home for drama might be at least somewhat right. It's beyond stupid for that guy at the end to think she can't be contemporary because of the song choice they made for her--especially considering the older songs they chose for the contestants who Simon DID let through to the live shows. Maybe this was staged after all. Who knows. If it was, clearly she wasn't in on it.

[Estas01]

Her voice is great, but not her style.

[PrettyBossMook]

SHE WON !!!!!! LOVE HERRRR <3

[ginaalicea]

Cant wait till her cd comes out

[mrsDtrix1]

her and rachel crow were great singers.

[tomboyattitude96]

I'm glad Simon brought her back, she DESERVED the win! I'm definitely getting all the CD's she has<3

[MrTweety3]

Im so glad Melanie won her voice is beautiful and I get chills when she sings I'm proud of you melanie can't wait for the cd

[claufraga]

She deserves it!!! So much talent, what a voice, God bless you! Althoug Josh and Chris also deserve it, because they are amazing too, wonderfull singers and performes, but she is awsome! Congratulatios to this edition of X-factor USA!

[justwantlife]

well done Melanie,honey you are a shining star.

Bring It, arohanui to all, and to all a good night.

Merry Christmas people :-)

[thegeneral182]

@justwantlife 2meke

[liamk994]

Watching this back I can definitely hear the accent coming through a little bit

[thegeneral182]

@liamk994 and what!!!

[liamk994]

@thegeneral182 And I definitely didn't hear it before.

[cotessproductions1]

SHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE WWWWWWWWWWONNNNNN GOOD !

[maysville854]

You won!

[alekadanielle11]

MELANIE WON CONGRATZ MEL :)

[lolam1001]

VOTE FOR HER!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[greeneyes1718]

bad song choice



[unclesam21]

oh and his lean forward was "here we go" and mark my words, she will take MJ back to number one for a few weeks soon with this song. little homey will be up there too.

[audrisrozelle]

This has to be one of my favorite songs by Michael Jackson! I listen to this on repeat!!

[sweetie2913]

I want her sing this song finale.

[Nerdymigetfreak]

simon looks exactly like his wax figure in this video

[Skymaster2u]

Only Simon knows why she was sent home after this performance.. If this was a bad performance then it must have been angels that went through.. This is pure talent and thumps up simon for admitting you were wrong for once and taking immediate action.. Melanie for the win

[xDdarryDx62]

VOTE FOR MELANIE!!!!!!!!! PLEASE :'(

[loopyallie1]

I want her to sing this song in the Final. <3

[melly6newsuan]

god bless her i hope she win

[Swedified]

mmmmm her voice is like a drug! I hope, hope, hope, hope she wins!

[bustindlite]

This girl makes singing look so easy, I even end up thinking I can sing too until strangers tell me to shut up! She's great!

[PettoHelterSkelter]

the voice within..

[winterbaby126]

I bet Michael himself would love her performance:)

[felaipechev]

OMG THIS PERFORMANCE WAS ONE OF HER BEST :O

[suddenlink3]

Good luck Melanie. The world needs a voice like yours to be an inspiration for being true to yourself! You are amazing, and the only people saying anything negative about you are just in awe of your talent and in denial because you and your voice are the definition of greatness! Stay humble, and you will achieve so much success and personal satisfaction from your God given gift!!!! Go girl!!!

[taylan007m]

it seems like she wrote this song...R.I.P. MICHAEL JACKSON..

[davidbranagan]

WOW WOW WOW PLEASE VOTE

[24LakerGirl]

Wow, she blew this out of the water. Gooo Melanie!

[Kakabuarque]

loveee it, love melanie!

[dubbersubber]

she reminds me of mariah carey and beyonce, her voice is so crisp and powerful SHE DESERVES TO WIN THIS THING!!!!!

[unabuna8]

thumbs up if you think see will win !

next beyonce...

[ROHFan1996]

@unabuna8 she aint gonna be no next beyonce shes gonna keep on serving god!

[maxit9]

she has alot of michael jackson covers :)

[trinigirl43]

Estas01.... I guess you're skinny and gorgeous huh? Give me a break! Such a superficial comment.

[maxvain]

Simon needs to fire that guy who was speaking at the end of this video lol

[nspgize]

As we approach the finish line, I urge all you Melanie Amaro fans to let your votes do the talking. I am sure you will agree that she has been the most consistent performer throughout this entire competition. Some will try to convince you that she does not deserve to win, but we know better, because no one else in this competition deserves it more. So let's silence them once and for all, by giving Melanie Amaro what she needs most at this time to emerge victorious; and that is our VOTES

[Dramawitsvu17]

@nspgize She is awesome!!!

[trendy5174]

give it up to you 

[ontheair91]

IN ALLLLL SERIOUSNESS, SHE REMINDS ME OF MARIAH CAREY FROM THE 1990'S LIKE 1993, 94, 95. AND ON. THIS GIRL IS JUST ASTONISHING. HER VOICE IS ON POINT!!! DAMN!!

DO YOU GUYS REMEMBER BACK THEN. BUT MELANIE IS BETTER AND PUTS A TWIST ON IT!!!

[Estas01]

Her voice is amazing, I voted for her, but she looks awful without make up. Her body is not in the best shape either.

[imsayn77]

How the HELL did Simon send her home with this performance.

[NJLinardos]

@imsayn77 It was a hoax so that it wouldn't be so obvious if she won..because it's obvious that she stands out more than everyone else..and has throughout the entire season

[1andonlikb]

i so want her to win!!

[TheVrrrrr]

she isn´t amazing... SHE IS THE BEST..

[BRUCEBRUCE33BAD]

i voted my ass off for her tonight

[KeepTryingHomie]

her rack is amazing!

[carpman98]

@KeepTryingHomie That's the only comment you can make ?? How old are you, 12 ?

[GlitterGift]

Can't believe he sent her home after this. wtf Simon

[fullycomedy1]

54 people are jealous.

[FlyMetotheHoop]

I will literally buy anything she comes out with, whether she sings contemporary or not.

[niekles1]

the note she hit at 2.55 :O she's rly good

[marcomackh]

Is this a ballad

[jurkfilms]

just chillin' with a pepsi

[innusha16]

jUST AMAZInG.....like no other words to express her talent;)

[tallboyandy23]

This girl gives super Goosebumps!! Love her to bits!