Added: 5 years ago
From: KiltedScribe
Views: 18,968
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (121)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 'Mrs Hardbroom' est beaucoup meilleure et surtout plus jolie que 'Severus Snape'

  • Might I say that throughout the Worst Witch series Hardbroom has never been caught, she's always been invisible or the enemies were too afraid of attracting her attention (maybe except during the uninvited bit, but she was freed first cuz she was considered the most powerful)

  • This would of been a great video if it had been made properly. Ms. Hardbroom kicks Snape ass, cuz she is fierce.

    Hardbroom scares her students too, but not with a quiet voice.

  • *-* I love you Kate Duchene and Alan Rickman!!!!!

    Miss Hardbroom & Profesor Snape *o*

  • Hardbroom HB always! Luv the worst witch follow it always Soz to my BFF whod go 4 snape :( hard broom was always best.

  • Yeah, as characters only, I can't pick. As strict, dark, potions teacher, no one can be HB for me. HB held that place with me first. And of course, most who were into Harry Potter first (or only Harry Potter for that matter) are going to pick Snape.

  • @Syvelocin Snape can do so much more than HB, though. I`ve watched worst witch first, then got onto harry potter later. But, i assure you that Snape could do everything HB could do, and more. He could kill her with but a short incantation, and a flick of the wand.

  • @brentlion What you have there is pure speculation. They're both very advanced compared to the people around them, and the universes are different so you can actually never be sure unless they were in the same universe. As well, that has nothing to do with the character's likeability. Lots of wizards can kill, it's just a spell. That wouldn't impress me at all.

  • @Syvelocin Nah, it isn`t speculation. Snape is very accomplished in the dark arts. He can put the imperius curse on her, which would put her under his control, while he can also do most spells without uttering a single word....could kill her with but a few words and a flick of the wand, could put the full body bind curse on her, ect, before she knew what hit her. A lot of the spells on worst witch are too lengthy to make much of a difference.

  • @Syvelocin Have you even read all of the Harry Potter books? If not, you should.....they`re all available online, in pdf format. And yes, while lots of wizards can probably kill, i`ve never seen Miss HardBroom use a spell like that. Do they even have a killing curse, or a full-body bind curse? Or a curse that would allow you to hold a person in mid-air, hanging by the ankles? Or a spell that could cause great pain over your entire body, ect?

  • @brentlion I can't recall HB ever using an incantation. If yes, not much.

    Yes, I've read and seen every single bit of Harry Potter material available. I do think there would be such spells, but as The Worst Witch is more oriented for a younger audience, I doubt they'd show it. And again, my favouritism of HB is in her personality. I couldn't give a damn who could kill the other, and it's really difficult to judge anyway. Dumbledore is more powerful than Snape but I like Snape over Dumbledore.

  • @Syvelocin Harry Potter isn`t really geared towards any audience in particular. HB is cool, and, as for Dumbledore and snape....i tend to favor the decent ones a bit more....

  • @brentlion You're missing one big thing. Snape can't do anything without his wand. HB can zap her enemies into oblivion with bare hands. Now that's something.

  • @ScarredSycomore Actually....snape CAN do things without their wands. ALL wizards and wizards in Harry Potter`s world can, but it cannot always be so easily controlled. But still....they can do amazing things. I`m sure you`ve seen what Harry did to his cousin without meaning to, or his Aunt Marge? Have you heard what the kid Tom Marvolo Riddle did?

  • @brentlion Of course they can, but it's unstable and most of the time, they cannot control it. In the Worst Witch, any magic user can do impresive magic without wands. It always miffed me that Harry is as good as dead without his wand, and when it gets broken, he goes into mourning. Come on, that was just a tool...The wandless magic HP wizards and witches doesn't impress me at all. It's unfocused and too rare to be of any practical use.

  • @brentlion you're only half right, snape for instance can't fly without a wand and wizards don't seem to be able to apparate without them either but it is true that random uncontrolled experiments can be performed

  • @pantstelly93 Actually, wizards have apparated without any wands visible. And, broomsticks?

  • @brentlion ANd she can dispel a severe blizzard by SINGING! How cool is that?

  • @ScarredSycomore Actually quite boring/corney.

  • @brentlion That's your opinion. The Harry Potter universe told us preciously little about weather changing, and the snippets we got were only about indoor weather regulation. Girls in Worst Witch can make it rain, snow or hail. The problem arises when you have to control the elements you've summoned. That's the lesson of Worst Witch: you're toying with enormous power and it's only up to you to control it. Harry Potter has you straining to turn matchsticks into needles.

  • @ScarredSycomore In worst witch...you have the foster`s effect, however, which can make some spells go VERY wrong. In Harry Potter`s universe, things are more complicated.....more, believeable.

  • @brentlion The Foster's Effect can make almost any spell go wrong, and there are different kinds of the Foster's Effect. There's the Double variety: two parties casting the same spell on each other at the same time: the effect is such that the spells multiply and grow at exponential rate. There's also the Ordinary Foster's Effect (Misgone Magic) that happens when there have been too many spells cast in a small area or one after another.

  • @brentlion It also tends to occur when an already enchanted object is magicked again: the underling spell clashes with the top one.

  • @brentlion One more thing. In the Worst Witch universum, transfiguration spells are simple magic - first year witches can do them. Imagine what HB could do.

  • @ScarredSycomore It shouldnt be so simple, though. Transfiguration is not simple magic. That just takes the fun out of it. Besides, the Harry Potter students can still do a lot more.....without the need of lengthy spells.

  • @brentlion Depends on a kind of transfiguration. In legends, turning into animals is widespread and common, so it makes sense that these spells are simple. It is much more difficult to transfigure into something specific, and Worst Witch rightly notes that conjuring objects is much more advanced. I think Worst Witch has better magic system, because we actually got to know how it works: it was explained thoroughly. In HP, it's guesswork: we don't even know how Untransfiguration works.

  • @ScarredSycomore Actually, transfiguration was notoriously difficult in legends. Where do you think Rowlings got it from? But, some transfiguration is simple in Harry Potter, just as conjuring is more difficult. Actually, i don`t think you understand Harry Potter`s magic system, which is why you think it isn`t better. But, it is not something she just thought of out of the top of her head. I`ll prove my points, in a message.

  • @brentlion think of the physics of transfiguration though; you are converting the molecular structure of one substance into that of another, if you think of it that way it does sound a great deal more difficult. the same goes for conjuring and vanishing as well, for you're changing not only the structure but the state of matter (if you think of it as i do as transfiguring solid objects into molecules of air and vice versa), the one thing i was never sure of though was the switching spell...

  • @pantstelly93 ...where does the switched object go? if anywhere or does switching simply mean transfiguring

  • @pantstelly93 Switching spells are like the sub-division of transfiguration spells. But, on the difficult meter, most switching spells are rather low on the totem pole.....they are taught to first years. Changing your nose to a plant, or something, is a form of a switching spell.

  • @brentlion it's true the longest spell in the hp universe is 2 words long, with the exception the 3 word incantation used by malfoy in hp6 film to fix the vanishing cabinet but i don't count the spells invented for the films

  • snape. thts it. just snape. srry.

  • Id like to read your fanfiction :)

  • Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape Snape WINS!!!!!!!!!!

  • Love this!

  • I so wish I could just swagger on into a room and close the blinds by will v_v lmao! Snape's the only reason I'd ever join Slytherin xD

  • Hardbroom :D :D :D

  • I seen both harry potter and the worst witch... if the worst witch would've had better special effects and the writters would've add a bit more flavor to the worst witch it would had kick harry potters ass all over.... Oh and Miss Hardbroom is much better then Snape. Harry Potter is all about the special effects.

  • @sunnysideup703 are you serious? all about the special effects? Have you even read the books before saying something so lame? Harry Potter is all about the people, the love, the friendship, the adventures, the magic, the pain, the mystery, the suspense.. you don't know anything about Harry Potter if you think it's all about the special effects..

  • @sunnysideup703 The Worst Witch began in like 1999? or something where special effects at The Worst Witch's level was the best of it's time, if The Worst Witch had been something new and only now been made into a show, it's effects would have been phenomenal.

  • could you please tell me which song is the last one??

  • Ms. hardbroom for the original Worst Witch movie pwns all u.u

  • SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE SNAPE!!!!

  • Much as I have the utmost respect for Severus, both as a person coming from the kind of background and childhood he did, and as an astounding wizard to do what he did for so many years, I have to say Constance wins this for me every time. She's just... well, she's HB. Hard to the bone. Goodness knows what she lived through when she was under Hecketty's spell-casting fingers, but even though she is a powerful, natural witch it's given her the power to control herself. Severus uses cunning. x

  • undoubtedly, Hardbroom is the best Witch all the times. Snape is amazing too but Miss Hardbroom is most powerful.

  • I think Snape is scarier. I'd sooner have detention with Hardbroom than Snape. But I think Hardbroom gives the impression that she is more powerful. It was never denied that Snape was talented, but he was never singled out as an exceptionally powerful wizard; whereas The Worst Witch series constantly reminds us of how much more powerful Hardbroom is than the other witches. I say HARDBROOM!

  • There is such a thing as wandless magic in HP. And what does a wand matter in potion making, anyway? It's all about skill and instinct, which Severus has in abundance.

  • i love them both but i think hardbroom would win b/c she dosent need a wand to cast spells and snape cant do ship without his wand exept look really hot but i dont think miss hardbroom would fall for that she is to stiff.

  • HB is so fantastic love kate duchene.

    However, i think snape is also a good character, cant they just share the title??

  • hardbroom!

  • omg i am so in love with both of them !!!

  • hehehe... i agree that somebody should make something with snape and hardbroom in the same place... that'd be quite amusing.... maybe i'll have a go! ;D

  • Hardbroom forever! But Snape is wonderfull character too... And I love them above

  • Severus Snape ROCKS!!!!!

  • nice

  • Miss Hardbroom is the best!

  • Oh HB, you were there from the beginning. But Snape has a more developed character, and backstory. But HB kicks general ass on all fronts. It's a tough one.

  • snape is far better, shesh any1 with half a brain cell know's that, and it certainly doesn't hurt that alan rickman plays him.

  • HB, she is an earlier love!

  • Harry Potter characters are excellent but I think that the Worst Witch ones are more ''real''.

    So our beloved Ms Hardbroom wins.

  • HB forever

  • Snape is such a rip-off of Ms. Hardbroom.

    And Ms. Hardbroom totally wins by the way.

  • @magegirl8 theyre both great xD altho MIss Hardbroom came first <3 :P..They should get married xD they'd make a great couple..could u imagine them in the same room as one another? :D

  • Can I ask you what music did you use? :)

  • at the end it's The Smiths - How Soon is Now

    I think Snape is the more developed + complex character but still this is hilarious.. they do have their similarities, lol

  • HB is better as she does not need a wand to cast spells

  • great video... but too short :(

    you could use in the hardbroom battle a clip from the worst witch - uninvited, when she battle with the uninvited person , it will be great then a transformation spell

    i think HB will win , because she is more stronger then snape and she cast more spell . i like when miss Harbroom apears from nowwhere she quite scary

    i like both characters but HB is the best in the role of witch, she has a voice adorable hahaha

  • lol... I'm glad I wasnt the only one who noticed how much they are alike lol.

  • From which film is the scene at 0:40 ??

  • harry potter 4 goblet of fire

  • A bit unfair to only use Snape moments from the only Potter movie that was worth the time or money of its audience.

  • HB all the way!!

  • Rather have HB for a teacher seeing as she does have something of a soft side but oooh I looove Alan Rickman!

  • i know shes class but wheres her soft side?

    are you talking about what happened in the millenium bug episode?

  • I would prefer HB for a teacher I'm a huge fan of both these characters. Constance would win hands down though. Even if she has a softer side she's still more powerful.

  • Snape also has a softer side. He just doesn't show it! I really love characters who seem to be evil but also have got a soft side X-3

  • i know she would totally win but wheres her soft side?

    are you talking about what happened in the millenium bug episode?

  • Yup and it's sweet at the end of The Uninvited, when she trys to get Mildred chucked out at the start but fixes it so she can stay at the end.

  • Yeah, that and in a few others where shes actually on the girls' side :)

  • shes so class

  • what other episodes was she on the giurls side apart from the uninvited and the millenium bug?

  • Hardbroom would kick his ass! *cough*

  • i agree constance woul most certainly win shes far stronger

  • Of course she will win!!!

  • defo HB :D xx

  • iv alwas said we need much more snape and hardbroom they would be the best pairing ever, not relationship wise nesserily, even just snape vs hardbroom would be cool

  • OMG WHEN IS THIS COMING OUT

  • i think HB is meaner

  • Yeah!

  • finally!

  • i liked it

  • Oh my god!!! my dream is comming true, i'd would like to read your fan fiction!! this video is really cool!!!

  • Hey, did you ever write the fic to go with this? Or did someone else? I'd love to read it! If someone did.

    xxStellaxx

  • Always thought Snape was a rip off on Hardbroom, so glad to see this.

  • Wow awesome:) Where can I read this fic? I'm really curious.

    L.

  • What was that song at the end?

  • its the charmed theme

  • The theme from Charmed

  • where can I read that xover?

  • I miss worst witch too yeah they would mae a really class evil couple

  • Hardbroom i would like to have as a teacher i miss Worst Witch

  • Both of them are pretty well suited. Given the choice, I'd prefer to have Hardbroom as a teacher. At least she doesn't kill people. One of my favourite clips ever on the Worst Witch is when Hardbroom gets gunged. Has anyone got that clip?

    I reckon HP and WW would make excellent crossover fan fiction. Is it on the Harry Potter fan fiction site? I'd love to read it.

  • heh cool must read send me a copy at smallflame17@yahoo.com please

  • what weak clips i mean snape attacking lockheart what does that have to do with anything

  • Haha that was great

  • Bravo!

  • Hardbroom... vs. Snape, hmm... never really crossed my mind. I wouldn't mind seeing that for real, although if it were a compitition as to who taught more hard core... i think Snape would win. Hardbroom has her moments of being reasonably friendly or easy-going. Hope to see a crossover fanfic with them somewhere.

  • hows the fanfic coming along?

  • oh yes please i would love that fanfic.

  • you know i though a bout this a lot. Just imagine if you had to have both as your teacher. don't suposse your witten a fanfic about them have you i keep looking but no one seens to write one. Also love the charmed music at the end.

  • Yeah, I'd be scared to have both of them. I am actually in the process of writting the fiction to go along with the video. If you'd like I can send it to you once it's done. Glad to hear you liked it!

  • @starlightdreamer i have saw one fanfic of hardbroom and snape its kind of funny if i ever come across it again i will give you it but with me being a regualr fanfic reader i cant remember which is which :P

  • As much as I love Snape, my money would have to be on Hardbroom. Great idea.

  • can you explain this? i don't get who you are comparing snape to?

  • Constance Hardbroom was the deputy headmistress/potions teacher at Cackle's Academy from The Worst Witch series

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more