@TheIndustryKiller I would hesitate saying, "How long have you been a doctor" because even though his life isn't over, his career is. This is a finished time; therefore, may I suggest something along the lines of, "How long were you a doctor?" or "When did you work as a doctor?" or "When did you retire/stop working as a doctor?"
The major difference between the simple past and the present perfect is finished v. unfinished time. The action is sometimes irrelevant.
In spoken English, some people ask the question that way: "Where you live?" But that's not grammatically correct. You need the verb "do" to make the question.
That said, if you don't use "do" when speaking, most people won't notice. I do it myself sometimes when I'm not in the classroom and I'm not paying attention to what I say.
you perfect man...
really its very clearly and simple for learn..
I think I watch this lesson some then never forget...
thanks sir..
PASQUA73 3 months ago
thank you!
DoctarRomarIO 7 months ago
@DoctarRomarIO your welcome!
imagine if a chicken said i love u
TheDevilishUndead 3 months ago
I am always confused with tenses which is correct?
It is good that you informed Dina about the incident. or
It is good that you have informed Dina about the incident.
What is the difference in both?
River3ify 8 months ago
you are a good teacher but you needs to improve his handwriting. Thank you for all you interest.
Your classes are really nice.
puntoclave7 1 year ago
your classes are really really nice =D
BlackOutStart 1 year ago
Would you agree, it would've been perhaps easier if the English language had
a different plural for "you" (than "you", of course)
that to have so many "was", "were" "had", "have"?
adorianvlad 1 year ago
Thank you for this video, you helped me a lot!!
Greetings from luxemburg
Finalforce100 1 year ago
Hi.
As an example.
A friend of mine was doctor between the age of 30-50 and now he is 55.
If I wouldnt know when he was doctor how would I ask him?
Like:
"When were you doctor?" or "When have you been doctor?"
I think the first ones right but the present perfect question sounds better to me.
TheIndustryKiller 1 year ago
@TheIndustryKiller - You could say, "How long have you been a doctor?" (present perfect tense) or "When did you become a doctor?"
Those are probably the best choices.
learnamericanenglish 1 year ago
@TheIndustryKiller I would hesitate saying, "How long have you been a doctor" because even though his life isn't over, his career is. This is a finished time; therefore, may I suggest something along the lines of, "How long were you a doctor?" or "When did you work as a doctor?" or "When did you retire/stop working as a doctor?"
The major difference between the simple past and the present perfect is finished v. unfinished time. The action is sometimes irrelevant.
Carolyn4180 1 year ago
great teacher great work great site thanks teacher
rueiro12 1 year ago
he is professional
zaferian 2 years ago
thank you teacher
Bratzo26 2 years ago
nice,,thanks professor
OTONIELBAYS 2 years ago
Hi. So the auxiliary verb "do" is always used to make questions when the main verb is not the verb "to be"?
Why I can't write "Where you live?" instead of "Where do you live?"?
tivrfoa 2 years ago
In spoken English, some people ask the question that way: "Where you live?" But that's not grammatically correct. You need the verb "do" to make the question.
That said, if you don't use "do" when speaking, most people won't notice. I do it myself sometimes when I'm not in the classroom and I'm not paying attention to what I say.
learnamericanenglish 2 years ago
3:20 - When would one use does as oppose to 'do'? Are they both used in the present tense?
MasterThief1324 2 years ago
In the form of a question, use "does" with "he," "she," or "it."
Does he live in the United States?
Answer:
Yes, he does. or No, he doesn't.
Both "do" and "does" are used in the present tense as helping verbs.
learnamericanenglish 2 years ago