@CrubbDaTubb pronounced what??? haha. mad me chuckle. I believe the correct phonetic spelling may be more like Bo wee...although many call him Bough ee
It was a b-side to something or other, but it's also available as an extra track on the CD version of Pin-Ups! Check out the Marc Almond version of this and other Brel songs too...
@glamourennui I totally agree with your comments to @celeste4ish. I love Scott Walker with a passion but Bowie's live Ziggy version is probably the definitive English language version of this song imho. This version sounds uncommitted (actually insipid) in comparison. Everyone! - get off this page and listen to the live Ziggy version now! ;) Imagine being in that audience...
I am a die hard Bowie fan. Have been my whole life,but I have to say that I prefer Scott Walker's version of this. It's,hands down,the best version. Bowie actually is highly influenced by Scott Walker. That's what even got Bowie into any Jacques Brel in the first place.
After hearing Scott's version of this song,Bowie sounds too strained and the passion isn't there. You should all check out Scott Walker's version of My Death.
David tiene un ojo azul y el otro verdoso. Este ultimo cambia de color con la luz y se debe a un hecho acontecido cuando el tenia 14. Un chico en la escuela le enterro un compas en ese ojo. Luego surgio la leyenda de que uno de sus amigos lo golpeo en ese lado de la cabeza para calmarle un ataque de ira, y el golpe le destruyo la retina. Bowie ve borroso de ese lado.
Lo lamento pero te equibocas, tiene ambos ojos del mismo color, lo que ocurre es que tiene una pupila permanentemente dilatada, lo que da el efecto de que tiene el ojo mas oscuro.
En verdad?. Yo lei todo lo que pude sobre el asunto antes de responder, pero nunca he visto a Bowie cara a cara, no podria afirmar con total seguridad lo que dije. Espero conseguir mas informacion al respecto. Saludos.
David Bowie has one fake eye. His one eye was damaged in an accident when he was a kid. Rumours had it that Iggy Pop poked out his eye, but that's not true.
he doesn't have a "fake" eye, one of his pupils is just permamently paralized. he got hit in the eye at school. he can still see through it but his colour perception is disturbed and the injured eye sees everything in muddy brown.
Well, both his eyes are blue :P It's just that the pupil of his left eye is so dilated that the color is messed up. It'd be so cool if his eyes really were different colors though!
Well, yeah, but not in "Life on Mars?" at least. They look blue there. They're both blue. I REALLY wish they were different colors, though. That'd be awesome xD
Most stupid,greedy humans don't seem to realise that death is waiting for them, rich or poor the reaper is waiting for us all, make the most of it, and spare a thought for the animals... they're very important!!!
things mean different things to different people at different times. death is patient. may death be patient with me. this is not a quote from Ecclesiastees in the Holy Bible (forgive my misspelling)
I like the Thin White Duke too, but I like Ziggy Stardust better. Since he was on coke at the Duke period, I can't help the feeling that I can't really trust what the Thin White Duke says, does or even feels. Like it wouldn't be Bowie himself but a mannequin or a robot...just a strange feeling I can't explain. The music was good though. (I want Ziggy back! :( )
The origanal song was done by Scott Walker, who's voice is soft and soothing. Pleasant to listen to. Scott Walker did a lot of songs that were dark and bone chilling.
this song is just great,so hauntingly beautiful and with feeling.what ever bowie does he does great,i dont care if he didnt write it,who ever the origional artist was wouldnt beed any where near as good.
Great song by Brel curtesy of Bowie. Brel is'nt popularly known but he's one of the greatest most original songwriters in history, and I think it's fantastic that Bowie has given his work exposuer by covering it. Hats off to Bowie! "My death waits there between you'r thighs" ? hmmmmmmmmmm
The Song is from the "new" Album:David Bowie 'Live Santa Monica'72'
What a song? What a voice? Not from this planet!
Zitat:Jahrzehntelang war dieser legendäre Konzertmitschnitt von Bowies 1972er Ziggy-Stardust-Nordamerika-Tournee mit den Spiders Of Mars nur als Bootleg erhältlich.Nun kann man sich endlich in sehr guter Klangqualität ein Bild davon machen,welches Denkmal sich Bowie damals vor 3000 Zuschauern im Santa MonicaAuditorium zu Los Angeles geschaffen hat.Ein Klassiker der Popgeschischte!
The original is a song by french chansonnier Jacques Brel called "La Mort" which, I think, he wrote during the late fifties or early sixties. It's absolutely worthwhile checking out the original, which is quite different from Bowie's version but no less haunting. Brel, by the way, died exactly 30 years ago from lung cancer at the relatively young age of 49, which makes the lyrics even more meaningful.
I've never really actually looked at this songs lyrics. David Bowie is one artist whose songs (even if he didn't write it) actually mean something, but are aided as well by his ability to really tell a story.
Oh, this is so weird. I had a dream David Bowie died last night and his spirit came to me, to thank me for defending him after some girl in my school called him a fag, I got in huge trouble for calling her a cunt.
It's just weird that I came across this song today.
Bowies voice was phenomenal, he had an unbelievable ability to sing to perfection. This song outlines his amazing talent. The version on the ziggy final london concert with the backing of mike garson etc. is fantastic any sense of normality..
Does anyone have any footage of the Spiders after Bowie and Ronno left. My pals Dave and Pete joined the band and recorded an album at Trident Studios with them but broke up soon after !
It comes from the Portuguese word 'Teggua' meaning 'pink hair' and an Arabic symbol 'sardoz' referring to the giant full moon. It translates literally to 'big pink hair and moon face'.
i like the scott walker version better.
migled9 3 weeks ago
OK, what version is this version from? Jesus Christ, does someone have the MP3 of this version?
ivorytower99 1 month ago
Listen to Scot Walker's vesion of this great song . I find it rly interresting too ! Maybe a bit more passionate ;')
SuperFrankenChrist 3 months ago
Nice IM beep in the beginning! :P
invisibleidiot 6 months ago in playlist David Bowie playlist
not heard this in years still as good now a classic track
bedsitsongbird33 6 months ago
recorded at santa monica in 72
DANTECHPFN 8 months ago
i wish i could like the song description ...
falco1118327 9 months ago
Makes me want a cigarette and a quiet place to comtemplate this song<3
GaxlTheGr8 9 months ago
DB actually has 2 different color eyes, epic!
Goingbeach 11 months ago 2
@Goingbeach
David bowies eyes are the same colour but one pupil is permantly dilated. due to an accident as a child
dfg297lpopdirk 10 months ago
@dfg297lpopdirk yeah you're right it was while fighting when he was 15
romdju 10 months ago
mate, we all know who wrote it ..Zzzz. Yr not some kinda sage. Bowie covered several Jacques Brel songs over the years
latinaloveruk 11 months ago
This song was written by the great jacques brel... fyi
theropodia 1 year ago 3
It would be nice to hear Bowie do a cover of a Peter Hammill song, he is one of the few singers who could bring it off.
unomeimeno 1 year ago
This is off the Santa Monica bootleg
madtraprecords 1 year ago
i've missed one genie il m'a trompé c'était mon cousin gilles Barbier
63virgini 1 year ago
This will be my funeral song.
KathleenAlexisxx 1 year ago 4
this song could be released today, he was and is an artist, his music will never grow old. rock on ziggy you aladin sane
brianpatrick58 1 year ago
a bible truth? ha ha ha
TheYazoo321 1 year ago
Beautiful rendition of this song! His voice is haunting...fantastic pictures, too!
theultimateotaku 1 year ago
j'adore i love this to much so great
edwigederer 1 year ago
waouhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh l'histoire de ce disque et dans ma memoire
diablesssssss 1 year ago
They actually played this song at Bowie's (pronounced Boo-aye) funeral.
CrubbDaTubb 1 year ago
@CrubbDaTubb Errr... what? Bowie's funeral?
sally0sally 1 year ago
@sally0sally Yes, in 1986, this was the song they played
CrubbDaTubb 1 year ago
@CrubbDaTubb I still don't get it. Bowie had a funeral, but he didn't die?
sally0sally 1 year ago
@CrubbDaTubb pronounced what??? haha. mad me chuckle. I believe the correct phonetic spelling may be more like Bo wee...although many call him Bough ee
vonsterflick 1 year ago
where can I get this studio recording of the song?? which album/bside?
gringolazlo 1 year ago
@gringolazlo
It was a b-side to something or other, but it's also available as an extra track on the CD version of Pin-Ups! Check out the Marc Almond version of this and other Brel songs too...
DaddyHarvey 1 year ago
morbid song
sallyfieldrequired 1 year ago
may21 2011.....
Lea71777 1 year ago
@Lea71777 what about it?
sallyfieldrequired 1 year ago
@glamourennui I totally agree with your comments to @celeste4ish. I love Scott Walker with a passion but Bowie's live Ziggy version is probably the definitive English language version of this song imho. This version sounds uncommitted (actually insipid) in comparison. Everyone! - get off this page and listen to the live Ziggy version now! ;) Imagine being in that audience...
ClubUrbanLondon 1 year ago
gewoonweg knap - een eeuwig recent onderwerp
puyneers 1 year ago
excellent version but Scott Walker's version is undoubtedly better more powerful
zigzagwanderer0 1 year ago
what album is this from
anthonysalamanders 1 year ago
the song my computer randomly picked to wakre me up today and without a doubt i can say bowie was better than sex.
FoxGreyhound 1 year ago 2
@FoxGreyhound I don't believe yuo have ever had sex, maybe been buggered.
CrubbDaTubb 1 year ago
I am a die hard Bowie fan. Have been my whole life,but I have to say that I prefer Scott Walker's version of this. It's,hands down,the best version. Bowie actually is highly influenced by Scott Walker. That's what even got Bowie into any Jacques Brel in the first place.
After hearing Scott's version of this song,Bowie sounds too strained and the passion isn't there. You should all check out Scott Walker's version of My Death.
celeste4ish 1 year ago
bowie's masterful interpretation of brel's gut-wrenchingly beautiful song. thank you for posting this :)
tigerfishgirl 1 year ago 2
this is really quite amazing.
ezalbelleinad 1 year ago
It's a great song and a great Man i love him and all his songs^^
ShannenDoherty1971 1 year ago
bowie is alive and well - he's been hiding behind my couch with jesus. thank GOD i found him!
gloiven 2 years ago 5
Actually I think Bowie's version is better that Brel's original. (no offence to Brel!)
kaligula11 2 years ago 2
Bulat Okudhava you should hear for that song.
bogbron 2 years ago
David Bowie was one of the great artists of the Twentieth-Century!
HeathenLoveGod 2 years ago 7
Thank god we have David Bowie!!! This is one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard!!! :D
miha03aj 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
Do you remember, OUR President Nixon, or YOUR Beth of Death, creepy pig Brits?
Do you remember dropping your loads along the roads, away from Jerusalem, 1187?
Do you remember, Salah twisted your TITS, to keep you TWITS biting BITS,to swing out SHIT, to blow past the SHIITES, in Teheran, to take CHINA.
You hold those TWO, or you fail, in Jerusalem, since JEWS ARE FROM ETHIOPIA, Queen Israeli-Blue-UK.
Iman and pig overproduce Nixon's surveillance, to PROFITEER at U.S. RIOT, royal-geek Thebans!
bobgnote1 2 years ago
the first time i heard this song from the last ziggy show in 74,,i was hooked.
i play it al the time on my guitar,,one of my favs although its a jaques brel song. i think bowie did a great cover.
ABOYINSANE 2 years ago
yes it is a great song; new to me, but I really like it!
YoSoyZuri 2 years ago
David tiene un ojo azul y el otro verdoso. Este ultimo cambia de color con la luz y se debe a un hecho acontecido cuando el tenia 14. Un chico en la escuela le enterro un compas en ese ojo. Luego surgio la leyenda de que uno de sus amigos lo golpeo en ese lado de la cabeza para calmarle un ataque de ira, y el golpe le destruyo la retina. Bowie ve borroso de ese lado.
IsabelDhampir82 2 years ago
Lo lamento pero te equibocas, tiene ambos ojos del mismo color, lo que ocurre es que tiene una pupila permanentemente dilatada, lo que da el efecto de que tiene el ojo mas oscuro.
AthosJosue 2 years ago
En verdad?. Yo lei todo lo que pude sobre el asunto antes de responder, pero nunca he visto a Bowie cara a cara, no podria afirmar con total seguridad lo que dije. Espero conseguir mas informacion al respecto. Saludos.
IsabelDhampir82 2 years ago
David Bowie has one fake eye. His one eye was damaged in an accident when he was a kid. Rumours had it that Iggy Pop poked out his eye, but that's not true.
queenofpeace1 2 years ago
he doesn't have a "fake" eye, one of his pupils is just permamently paralized. he got hit in the eye at school. he can still see through it but his colour perception is disturbed and the injured eye sees everything in muddy brown.
Muxxyy 2 years ago 5
It's not fake; it's just been changed with surgery.
SekaiNoMu 2 years ago
this is a Jacques Brel song. Bowie is coveringit...
tattypatty 2 years ago
"I think he has the most beautiful blue eyes,"
(in description)
You mean eye :P
(sorry had to)
callums91 2 years ago
Well, both his eyes are blue :P It's just that the pupil of his left eye is so dilated that the color is messed up. It'd be so cool if his eyes really were different colors though!
SekaiNoMu 2 years ago 3
The big pupil eye has always looked brown to me.
MissMael 2 years ago
Well, yeah, but not in "Life on Mars?" at least. They look blue there. They're both blue. I REALLY wish they were different colors, though. That'd be awesome xD
SekaiNoMu 2 years ago 2
me 2
DomiFrique 2 years ago
anyone knows where to find the my death
's original version (JB's version)??
it's amazing youtube doesn't have it.
hkbaby1985 2 years ago
Bowie is a true genius at work with music and acting. i thank you for another David Bowie video i can add to my favorites. :DD Rated 5/5
DanielleLovesKyle1 2 years ago 3
"But whatever lies behind the door
there is nothing much to do...
angel or devil, I don't care
for in front of that door...
there is you."
Ah, this guy breaks my heart.
With every line of every of his songs.
alma1980sommerregen 2 years ago 49
@alma1980sommerregen this is jacque brel's song.. xD
DanBlabbers 1 year ago
@alma1980sommerregen Jacque brel's a good song writer ;)
DanBlabbers 1 year ago
@alma1980sommerregen but he didn't write it, jacques brel did
DanBlabbers 1 year ago
@alma1980sommerregen
I love these lines aswell, and ofcourse DB, but these lines were written by Jacques Brell. Since it's his song
SHBlacky 1 year ago
@alma1980sommerregen Jacques Brel wrote this song
DanBlabbers 5 months ago
@alma1980sommerregen
Beautiful and haunting and GENIUS.
sherieva 2 months ago
gorgeous - like eveything he does.
sianegallozzi 2 years ago 6
David Bowie - the best!
TheCinemaization 2 years ago 7
Most stupid,greedy humans don't seem to realise that death is waiting for them, rich or poor the reaper is waiting for us all, make the most of it, and spare a thought for the animals... they're very important!!!
garybh2112 2 years ago 32
amazing, ever and ever!
atondl 2 years ago 8
just amazing
LadyStardust577 2 years ago 5
this is from his live at santa monica album right??
holyunderwear92 2 years ago 2
yeah it is.
harrisongsrule 2 years ago
Where have you taken all the pictures? I've rummaged through many internet sites,but a picture as good as the 1:48 one, I hardly found it! well done.
Bowie: a genius.
electricqueenstage 2 years ago
Comment removed
holyunderwear92 2 years ago
bonne chanson, je ne connaissais pas, c'est superbe
carlotta8 2 years ago
THIS IS AMAZING!
Disaster3T 2 years ago
ohhh Ziggy Stardust come back to us!
donno54 2 years ago 5
OHMYGOSH! i love this video! these pictures are gorgeous! and 5:08! wow i love the garb. i love bowie. soooo much! :D thanks SO MUCH for this video!
funkateer854 2 years ago
Comment removed
miha03aj 2 years ago
AAAAHHH HAHAAHAHHAHAA
Shusssshssssh 2 years ago
things mean different things to different people at different times. death is patient. may death be patient with me. this is not a quote from Ecclesiastees in the Holy Bible (forgive my misspelling)
h
justkevy 3 years ago 2
i agree.this one is just awesome.
but i like more the character of the Thin White Duke,because i just love station to station and the berlin trilogy
valesomma92 3 years ago
I like the Thin White Duke too, but I like Ziggy Stardust better. Since he was on coke at the Duke period, I can't help the feeling that I can't really trust what the Thin White Duke says, does or even feels. Like it wouldn't be Bowie himself but a mannequin or a robot...just a strange feeling I can't explain. The music was good though. (I want Ziggy back! :( )
AijaP 2 years ago
is it true bowie has an album on youtube called the wittle man? ive heard it and i reckon its him, and its good really good.
lukenewland 3 years ago
The origanal song was done by Scott Walker, who's voice is soft and soothing. Pleasant to listen to. Scott Walker did a lot of songs that were dark and bone chilling.
cjlynn777 3 years ago
the original song was by jacques brel and what a performer he was, his version is on utube
ssounessz 3 years ago
Oh, woops. Hehe... Thanks anyways... Scott Walker's version was the first and only other one I had heard of...
cjlynn777 2 years ago
this song is just great,so hauntingly beautiful and with feeling.what ever bowie does he does great,i dont care if he didnt write it,who ever the origional artist was wouldnt beed any where near as good.
jones47star66 3 years ago
3rd photo sort of looks like Sid Vicious from the Sex Pistols
jerkwang69 3 years ago
I LOVE this song!!
TheLovelyCreature 3 years ago
beautiful song never heard it before. i love u david bowie!
enderflea 3 years ago
I want this song played at my funeral. Bowie is a Genius and was so far ahead of his time.
B1N4RYGH0ST 3 years ago
god he was beautiful...
LetsBurnGoats 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it WAS written by him.
sweetmarypie 3 years ago
Oh please!!!! STOP!!! Cringe
MISTRA77 3 years ago
Lovely song- never heard b4- much appreciated~
JennyJayWhite 3 years ago
A Beautiful Song , written by the Unforgettable Jacques Brel, sung by an exquisite Artiste.. forever ..David Bowie
maria1024 3 years ago
awesome .. Bowie's Ziggy was like a new Messiah for music
donno54 3 years ago
他长得真美。
wsyanjun 3 years ago
Is he crying ?
kikoololmdr 3 years ago 2
Ziggy for ever in my heart !!!
Ko7kO9TofAI 3 years ago
I just wish that on rarest one they didn't have the part about getting the acoustic numbers done because David Bowie's voice was going.
KnightoftheValor 3 years ago
Oh thank you so much for posting this,
this is such a beautiful song,
I adore David's voice and he really is so beautiful here.
This has given me another excuse to watch my Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust dvd again.
Sammit2 3 years ago
Great song by Brel curtesy of Bowie. Brel is'nt popularly known but he's one of the greatest most original songwriters in history, and I think it's fantastic that Bowie has given his work exposuer by covering it. Hats off to Bowie! "My death waits there between you'r thighs" ? hmmmmmmmmmm
Skulldini 3 years ago
The Song is from the "new" Album:David Bowie 'Live Santa Monica'72'
What a song? What a voice? Not from this planet!
Zitat:Jahrzehntelang war dieser legendäre Konzertmitschnitt von Bowies 1972er Ziggy-Stardust-Nordamerika-Tournee mit den Spiders Of Mars nur als Bootleg erhältlich.Nun kann man sich endlich in sehr guter Klangqualität ein Bild davon machen,welches Denkmal sich Bowie damals vor 3000 Zuschauern im Santa MonicaAuditorium zu Los Angeles geschaffen hat.Ein Klassiker der Popgeschischte!
model2270 3 years ago
The original is a song by french chansonnier Jacques Brel called "La Mort" which, I think, he wrote during the late fifties or early sixties. It's absolutely worthwhile checking out the original, which is quite different from Bowie's version but no less haunting. Brel, by the way, died exactly 30 years ago from lung cancer at the relatively young age of 49, which makes the lyrics even more meaningful.
qbriq 3 years ago
who wrote this exquisite song? (the person who posted this video/song mentions that bowie didn't write the lyrics for the song...)
Rusalka156 3 years ago
This version can be found with a vocal presentation in Rarest One Bowie.
I do not know where it originally comes from, though.
Great song, btw :)
TWD66 3 years ago
What album is it from?
KnightoftheValor 3 years ago
I've never really actually looked at this songs lyrics. David Bowie is one artist whose songs (even if he didn't write it) actually mean something, but are aided as well by his ability to really tell a story.
KnightoftheValor 3 years ago 3
The song sends a shiver down your spine. Brilliant.
KnightoftheValor 3 years ago 2
BAMMMMM
hovogliadicommentare 3 years ago 2
Oh, this is so weird. I had a dream David Bowie died last night and his spirit came to me, to thank me for defending him after some girl in my school called him a fag, I got in huge trouble for calling her a cunt.
It's just weird that I came across this song today.
I looooove you David. <3
kioko3737 3 years ago
His sexuality ain't a straight line from A to B that's for sure :P though somehow in going from A to B bowie touches on a shwa.
ninetwelve 3 years ago
This is no doubt one of the best songs interpreted by him, no matter who wrote it.
kosalet 3 years ago 2
one of my favorite bowie songs. so good.
monkmellon 3 years ago 2
Please stay alive David, I can't live without you!
tvc3111083 3 years ago 6
I'm all for the hard rock and heavy metal but I think Bowie is awesome
6manson6luvr6 3 years ago 3
Does anyone know who wrote the original version??
nGrEng 3 years ago
It's a song called "La mort" by belgian singer Jacques Brel
stonecrazy 3 years ago 4
thanks!
nGrEng 3 years ago 2
il etait belge ?
amaurythewarrior 3 years ago
hé oui! Tu pensais quand même pas qu'il était français...;-)
stonecrazy 3 years ago
ben si justement j'en etais persuadé ! ^^
amaurythewarrior 3 years ago
jac brel
mucaju1974 3 years ago 2
No, I don't.
warszawa45 2 years ago
Isn't originally a Bowie-song, but I don't denye that David's is the best version.
lukkiristi 4 years ago
where can I buy the c.d?pleasw,tell me!!!
343777 4 years ago
Bowies voice was phenomenal, he had an unbelievable ability to sing to perfection. This song outlines his amazing talent. The version on the ziggy final london concert with the backing of mike garson etc. is fantastic any sense of normality..
Ruberneck 4 years ago 4
the kind to sing; is from Lou Reed (velvet underground) more speaking then singing ... :)
great Musican BOWIE songs + songs + songs +
jazzymermaid 3 years ago
Does anyone have any footage of the Spiders after Bowie and Ronno left. My pals Dave and Pete joined the band and recorded an album at Trident Studios with them but broke up soon after !
mashamorgan 4 years ago
Awesome beyond belief. David Bowie is the legend that surpasses all reason.
bumholio 4 years ago
anyone wanna send me an mp3 of this?
moraldecay7 4 years ago
One of the best live moments ever in Bowie's carreer...astonishing.
valered68 4 years ago 2
Jaques Brel was an amazing songwriter.
But David Bowie sings this so passionately... it's absolutely unforgettable
All4YouSophia 4 years ago 2
i agree with you!
captainevita 4 years ago
i want this studio song!!my death is one of my fav songs of bowie but i only listened it in the live versions.
blelenah 4 years ago
This is the live santa monica version! easily available-top tune,love on ya!
guitarad 4 years ago
i cannot find this song anywhere.
its not on limewire or iTunes
anyone know where i can get it?
xxx
sophielovesbowie 4 years ago
buy the album! - I dont think David Bowie would like you downloading his music...
beautifulpeople2 4 years ago
i don't think david bowie would give a shit.
he's already rich.
moraldecay7 4 years ago
it's not about the money. Buying an album is like a symbol or something. it feels real good too, I assure you;).
beautifulpeople2 4 years ago 2
yeah but this is a rarity.
i've never seen the album anywhere.
i think it's ok to download the hard to find shit. but i still buy all the albums.
moraldecay7 4 years ago 2
can you help me finding this studio version as i only can find the various live ones thank you
Cyberneticlovers 4 years ago
ABSOLUMENT inouï
carlotta8 4 years ago
can someone tell me the meaning of Ziggy Stardust???
TyJim 4 years ago
It comes from the Portuguese word 'Teggua' meaning 'pink hair' and an Arabic symbol 'sardoz' referring to the giant full moon. It translates literally to 'big pink hair and moon face'.
MNZofPimlico 4 years ago
ok... u made that up
sspiderglasss 4 years ago
wow.
i wish i was retarded.
moraldecay7 4 years ago
verry great.
absolutely smashing :]
freakinghottie 4 years ago
thank you so much!!!
captainevita 4 years ago