Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (35)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is fucking insane. Imagine Schubert lived till he was 58.

    This fucking guy killed it.

  • better than drugs

  • Music to cleanse the soul by.......

  • dit is zo vreselijk mooi, zo prachtig om naar te luisteren, t werkt door tot in je ziel!

  • This piece is just incredible. A great performance of one of Schubert's masterworks.

  • i'm studying it with my friend, i'm a conductor, he is an organist, and i've decided to take the second part only to decide on the sustained pedal

  • i'm studying it with my friend, i'm a conductor, he is an organist, and i've decided to take the second part only to decide on the sustained pedal

  • this is the best performance for this piece.... it's amazing

  • @aurore891 i agree with you, this is the best performance

  • I'm learning this piece! It's soooo beautiful! This is the recording my piano teacher likes the most. Thanks for the upload!

  • Great interpretation, but I'm quite surprised by the numerous mixing mistakes, with such different background (ambiance) between whay seems to be the rehearsalsand the final. Listen to 0:44-0:47, 1:10-1:15, and 1:38-1:40 for example. Unless this is totally hazardous compression effects...

  • Comment removed

  • I've been trying to fond this piece for a long time...now that i found it, it's time to sit and relax with a beautiful and quiet piece.

  • WOW EFFING WOW this is great music!

  • So much more delicate than Britten and Richter - beautiful nonetheless!

  • Two masters at work, love it!

  • Simply perfect!

  • Schubert le plus grand musicien.. qu'une putain de maladie nous a enlevé.

  • Perfectly delicate and spiritual.

  • I simly adore its melancholic(μελαγχολικό)theme!­!!

  • What a wonderfully descriptive adjective - brooding - you use to convey the mood of the first theme. I think this is one of the most beautiful themes ever written.

  • thank you for this post

  • Perahia and Lupu are great pianists for the Schubert repertoire but I still feel like the Gilels are a bit more balanced.

  • You know, it's kind of funny: there is an innate tendency to fall in love with the first performance one listens to; somehow it becomes the standard by which others are judged. Yet, there are surprising ways in which "first loves" can be surpassed. That's how I feel about the Gilels, as compared to Badura-Skoda and partner (the first duo I heard).

  • I agree. For example: by the time I was introduced to Lipatti, I had already collected quite the library of piano recordings and now they are mostly useless since Lipatti bests them all, by a long shot.

  • Perhaps young death has a way of immortalizing great artists; but there's no denying the sheer genius of Lipatti. I meant to qualify my original post: to tell you the truth, I didn't even care much for the piece (Schubert's Fantasia) at all, when first listening to a recording (Badura-Skoda). Then the Gilels' performance changed my sentiment: there's no question that the WAY something is performed makes all the difference in the world.

  • To continue with another example: I used to hate Chopin's Nocturne #17 (in g) -- until listening to a recording by Ivan Moravec.

  • @JLFAN2009 You're so right! I find this with almost everything I listen to. I've been trying really hard, lately, to surpass it, as you say. However, especially with Schubert and Beethoven, only a couple of things remain my 'favourites' even if they were the first recording I heard; notably, the Cleveland Quartet with Yo-Yo Ma playing Schubert's string Quintet in C major is still my number one favourite.

  • @JLFAN2009 This performance is glorious, lovely, great... I'm stil in favour of the Gilels playing the Fantasy...

  • @dirkjdejong Another good one I found on YouTube is a live concert performance of two pianists: Imogen Cooper and Paul Lewis.

  • 3:05 awesome moment

  • Thank you so much for this post....

    There isn't a more heartwarming performance of this great musical piece!!!

  • You're welcome.

    I love how brooding the opening theme is.

  • @teunfaber Heartwarming? Haha. Morel like heartbreaking. :P

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more