This is a surprisingly different interpretation. An electronic piano and a baritone voice !!! Is this taste of the Hong Kong audience? Once the classic gut string SAN XUAN and ERHU accompanying a high-pitched voice set the standard, any performance deviating from that will sound awkward, in my opinion.
蔡琴幾時又是音樂老師了?怎麼不做下功課就來亂說
shihfeng2011 1 month ago
This is a surprisingly different interpretation. An electronic piano and a baritone voice !!! Is this taste of the Hong Kong audience? Once the classic gut string SAN XUAN and ERHU accompanying a high-pitched voice set the standard, any performance deviating from that will sound awkward, in my opinion.
shean333ful 2 months ago
Her rendition on this song gives me goosebumps!!!! BRAVO.....
benmok7 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
蔡琴,據說是教音樂的老師,唱歌很講究一板一眼,我將她他們列為書院派,唱流行歌就很呆板,不瀟灑,唱不出感情來,所以我不怎麼欣嘗她的歌。再好的歌星歌手都會出錯高段的補得你聽不出來
MrL3513 5 months ago
蔡琴,據說是教音樂的老師,唱歌很講究一板一眼,我將她他們列為書院派,唱流行歌就很呆板,不瀟灑,唱不出感情來,所以我不怎麼欣嘗她的歌。再好的歌星歌手都會高段的補得你聽不出來
MrL3513 5 months ago
蔡琴,據說是教音樂的老師,唱歌很講究一板一眼,我將她他們列為書院派,唱流行歌就很呆板,不瀟灑,唱不出感情來,所以我不怎麼欣嘗她的歌。
MrL3513 5 months ago
我曾經和我太太說笑，蔡琴唱歌像機器 -- 唱歌的機器。這不單因她唱歌很多時都太標準、甚至太過標準，一板一眼的，很難可以聽到她會有甚麼大膽變化驚喜，更且是因她的功力出色，幾乎永不出錯，真是唱歌的機器也。
但想不到她也會有驚喜的時候，只是這種演釋唱法是最難最難的，難怪「唱歌機器」今次都會有出錯了！（一笑）
但我很喜歡她這種出錯，因她終於有了新嘗試，雖然她的唱功實在好得無話說，但總是一板一眼的唱法，有時真會太悶的啊！支持她繼續求變！
fk167 1 year ago 2
這電鋼琴伴奏的彈的真好~~
syf19840803 1 year ago
hey its zhou xuan cover
dan020350 1 year ago