Added: 3 years ago
From: shara696
Views: 299,225
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (370)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Veronicas wrote the music and the text of that song and later on sold it to TATU... But was theirs at first...

  • the veronicas wrote this song fpr t.a.t.u ?

  • i like the veronicas version better, but thats just my opinion i like both

  • They actually wrote the song but it got sold to tatu

  • Don't get me wrong, I like The Veronicas, and this version of the song...but I believe t.A.T.u did the better job.

  • sorry, tatu powns this :I

  • They...no.

    tatu did it better.

  • The two versions are way different.

    ._.

    I mean, i like both of them, but I think t.A.t.U makes better songs.

    I don't like the way they ended this song though.

    =3=;;

  • isn't this t.A.T.u. song?

  • COVER Beeeeep tey took it

  • @TeamRocketGrunt69

    yeah but The Veronicas wrote it :P

  • Lena Katina and Yulia Volkova <3!!!!!

    I love t.A.T.u. <3!!!!!

    Im glad the veronicas didnt do this song on their cd instead though. XD! It sounds better done by t.A.T.u

  • T.A.T.U is like way better BUT kutos to the veronicas 4 writing such an awesome song

  • @XxOMGiTzZmExX the tatu version is higher.. that's why everybody loves it.. i like this one, too though

  • I like the veronica's Better. But, the t.A.T.u version is great as well. <3 t.A.T.u and The Veronicas! ^^

  • I love the veronicas but I love the original better because tatu puts more emotion into it and it's the love the 2 of them have. <3 The Veronicas & Tatu

  • I personally like t.A.T.u.'s version way better; but this one is good too. ^_^

  • nothin gets to the veronicas:) i think its much better than tatu..<3

    i love jess

  • ti's rocky ;)

  • Both versions are great :)

  • The veronicas wrote this song for t.a.t.u years ago and did a cover version of it. The veronicas talk about it in an interview

  • t.a.t.u sing it with feelings and more pation =\

    but this is ok

    I love this song

  • Tatu's better. -_-'

  • ??? tatu did the original version?

    but the veronicas wrote the song

  • @Tsukawaki7Nana they didn't wrote this song.tatu sang this song many years ago..

  • @KathyJuicyFruit Yes, they sang the song first a while ago, but it's true that the veronica's wrote it, but they wrote it for tatu and later did a cover of it.

  • @TeamRocketGrunt69

    Sììì

  • i like this one aswell.

  • Both tATu and the Veronicas are great artists. Their versions of this song is great. Stop the bitching. Seriously....

    If your soo insistant about it why don't you ask for both bands to do a cover together. Problem solved..

  • I like t.A.T.u's version better

  • oh my FUCKING god! shut. the .FUCK. up! no one cares! just listen to the damn song or go to another video. was it really usefull to have this all out comment war?!! shut the fuck up.

  • Ok. The Verconicas wrote this. Tatu sang this as well. Both versions are the best. So don't keep arguing who wrote it.

  • the veronicas wrote this but tatu's voices are better. it just sounds better cuz tatus voices are higher.

    but tatus version is a lil different with the lyrics

  • the veronicas do NOT wrote this, t.A.t.U sang it first, this is a cover version.

  • I raelly like this song and i also like this version played by the Veronicas and the version that it's played by Tatu nice job for uploading this song i really like it

  • THE SHURES VERSION IS BETTER THAN BOTH OF THEM D:

    Rawr... stick that in your pipe and smoke it :]

  • i hella like this version too. its hella good. i love the veronicas and tatu.

  • GUYS, STOP SAYING SO & SO IS BETTER.

    The Veronicas wrote it, t.a.T.u covered it, The Veronicas heard their version and kindly let them release it.

    Get your facts right.

  • @fortunethecookie actually t.A.T.u did the original version then the veronicas covered it

  • @SunshineOnCrazyRed19 Actually The Veronicas wrote this, but for t.A.T.u

  • veronicas are better so get over it!

  • Don't delete it...just pay no attention to stupid comments

  • I like the TATU version better, but this one is okkkkay i guess

  • I like both the TATU version and this version...

  • @K1llScreen  me too

  • yea tatu definately wrote this.....these guys did ok, but my fav version will always b tatus.

  • tatu did not write the sogn the veronicas wrote the song and then tatu nbought the song off them

  • @tbgwb thats wrong actually the pussy cat dolls made it for tatu then veronicas bought it off them ur very wrong

  • @Fatalityman721

    ...you just made my day.

  • ISsn't B flat on the D string for Violins and C for Violas

  • Tatu's is BETTER!!!

  • @JeweledCrimson i agree!!!

  • Comment removed

  • better than tATu's

  • t.a.t.u version is better, but i like this and t.a.t.u wrote this

  • the veronicas wrote this song not tatu!

  • wait who sung it first?

  • @32ROCKERCHICK32

    The Veronicas

  • @32ROCKERCHICK32 the veronicas wrote it but tatu bought it from them

  • @quietshylilangel errr... no way... tatu was way before veronicas whut u talkin about?

  • @32ROCKERCHICK32 the veronicas, but they let tatu use it as well.

  • I like t.a.t.u's a bit better. This is good too but idk I kinda like the other one a bit better :D

  • veronicas wrote it and the veronicas are better so get over it

  • @trot123456 I won't say they sung it better, (so i won't start up anything) but I'm like the biggest fan of The Veronicas. <3 but, wait, didn't tatu break up?

  • Comment removed

  • i love this song. they wrote this song and sold it to tatu?

    the veronicas have talent

  • @trot123456 no they didn't right it, the veronicas did a cover on this song, they did very good though.

  • both versions are amazing but I love this one better <3 i actually think they have a stronger harmony

  • @TiltedHalo1996 finally, someone who compliments both.

  • I personally prefer Tatu's version of this song, but I like this too.

  • I love it so much:D this is my first listenin', but I love it right now... Sorry if its dont correct at all...:)

  • if u listen to it together it sounds so cool. u have a nice tone going on

  • Tatu's version is much better because it goes a little faster as well side with it as they also have the Russian accent that makes it sounds much better and they have a more bright and clear voice.

  • i like t.A.T.u's version better but this is ok

  • "All About Us" is the first single released from Russian band t.A.T.u.'s second English studio album, Dangerous and Moving, and Russian album, Lyudi Invalidy.

    Originally written by The Veronicas, the song became another big hit for the group in the UK, peaking at #8 on the chart, two and a half years after the group first hit the #1 spot with their single "All the Things She Said".

    straight from wiki so seems like this is technically the original

  • They actually wrote the song, so I don't think there's anything wrong with singing their own song? :) right

  • They actually wrote the song so I don't think that there's anything wrong with singing their own song? :)

  • i love this song...i think u did nice work...i love the hearts in the background...<3

  • i love both versions!

  • OH FOR FUCKS SAKE!

    I'd say this is more of The Veronicas song than t.A.T.u's

    1) Lisa & Jess co-wrote this song. t.A.T.u didn't help in the writing process at all. They don't write any of their songs.

    2) We don't know when the Veronicas recorded this demo do we? They could have recorded it before the officially became the Veronicas; before 04.

    Just because t.A.T.u sung it first doesn't mean it's theres.

    Jeez

    t.A.T.u. & Veronicas fan <3

  • i like the tatu verson better cuz it portays more emotions than this and they sing like they mean it and tatu is way better verison

  • @1alex110 Not to offend non-straight people, but it's more emotional because it's about the two girls. plus it's so much higher.

  • people,it doesn't matter which version is better!all that matters is that this is an amazing!

  • The Veronicas sing it better.

  • yeah i like this version a little better than TATU's

  • TATUs version is better but this one is really good too...

  • a bit boring, tatu made it better :D

  • they wrote it!!

  • ya.... I agree. this is a kool song, but id perfer tatu's version. they cant just copy their song! geez! LONG LIVE TATU!!

  • The veronicas wrote All about us. It's their song from the beginning :)

  • mother fin tatu copying slutty bitches

  • I like t.A.T.u version better

  • i prefer tatu's version. dont know the deep voices just dont seem right...

  • tatu does this way better! im sorry just the truth!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • oh yeah? you should keep your mouth shut and look in wikipedia dumbass

  • Comment removed

  • they are both good. tATu has more hamony but the veronicas have more depth . Its hard to compare them but they are both good. I would have to say i like tATu's version better because I heard that one first lol.

  • Je préfère LARGEMENT la vraie version, celle de tatu

  • tatu's version is way better

  • This is a good song honestly but I think the t.A.T.u. version is much better. I say that because the veronicas version is just plain boring and very plain in general. And that is my own opinion so don't randomly start bitching at me about how idiotic and haterish I am. xD I honestly like some songs that the veronicas sing but them singing THIS song makes me want to hurl, sadly. ~

  • I agree

  • t.A.Tu sings it better WAY better...

  • totally agree

  • tatu way better i love the veronicas but them this song no

  • they breathe too much

  • veronicas and tatu are different I just cant compare them.

  • I luv the veronicas and this version of the song but I think the tatu version is better, idk y

  • I like both versions cuz the veronicas and tatu sings very good but i think that tatu version is a little more good that veronica's version. AND PPL IF U DON'T LIKE THIS SONG WELL DON'T WRITE BAD COMMENTS ABOUT IT, AND THAT'S ALL!!!!!!!!!!* WHO CARES ABOUT WHO WRITE THE SONG, JUST LISTENED AND ENJOY IT, THAT'S ALL!!!!!!!!!

  • aww ilove this song and i love the veronicas i love tatu too...

    i think tatu is great but the veronicas too

  • The level of retardation in the comments for this video stopped being funny a while ago, now it's just pathetic.

  • you know what i don't get it's not their song and the original is better because it's original and i like this version too, but it's completely t.A.T.u 's SONG!!!!

  • Actually it was theirs first

  • DanieyRouge they wrote it for t.A.T.u they have every single right 2 do a cover

  • I love how you can hear their accent when they sing this :)

  • I like both of the versions of this song. and whether you like which version of the song better has nothing to do with how hard the artists life was. And its true, The Veronicas wrote the song but the music director of the music company they worked for BMHG (I think) gave it to T.A.T.U. I have nothing against neither group

  • Ashley: and this is a shame i cant stand listening to this annoying song god i like the REAL one MADE by TATU not THESE bitches/sluts

  • Ashley: OK 1- you guys are fucking retarded

    2- cant you hear how they sound like whiney little bitches/sluts

    3- TATU keeps it real they dont sing songs other ppls wrote them they sing their own.

    4- you guys are stupid fucking sluts/bitches like the fuckers that sound like whiney bitches/sluts

  • u need to CALM DOWN!

    if u hate the song so much then the solution is very simple don't listen to it! &leave some space in the comment section for ppl who actually like the song

    it drives me crazy when ppl go into vids they dont like &start writing a bunch of shit, why dont u just go watch videos u actually enjoy

    oh and u dont have any right to say the veronica's dont know pain or rejection, EVERYONE knows pain and reject just 'cuz TATU r bi dont mean they r the only ppl in the world who suffered

  • OK if u don't like this version well don't listened, and that's ALL, BITCH!!!!!*

  • i like this one sooooo much better. besides the veronicas wrote it for Tatu

  • no they didn't you idiot!

  • . This is bull. Think long and hard. Stop with the when's and the hows because you have to think of the life they had to make the song. the veronicas had fun and luxury and guys that'll barely use them. look at lena and yuilia, they are hot and bi and they must have been used lots.

  • okay im not saying your wrong i dont know who is but... YOU dont know every bodies life! sry, but it could go either way... like i said u don't know the life of everyone...maybe it`s not about fans but wat happened through out their lives? maybe. ur right maybe ur wrong...u dont know wat they go or WENT through :) neither do i

  • Shawna: AND the veeronicas do not understand the MEANING of the song. Obviously, veronicas did not have to worry about rejection from people. Tatu can understand because they were rejected by many because of how they were bi and russia is a very religious place and so yeah. How can the veronicas write a song when they don't know shit of the pain to say that they'must and when they seriously didn't go through shit to write such song

  • wtf are you talking about o.o how do you know the veronicas have never felt pain? are you stupid? everyone feels pain. don't go judging people when you know nothing about them! thats fucking shallow.

  • Ashley: ok these sluts didnt write this. u fuckers are messed if u think they did. the veronicas wasnt even together when this was wrote and made.

  • Yeah maybe they didnt write it but they sang it! Everyone does it! And this is there own song cuz they did there own version of it! So Up Yours!

  • tATUs version is better

  • Alright everyone who claims the Veronicas wrote 'All About Us'. They didn't.

    t.A.T.u was formed in 1999 and released their single 'All About Us' in the August of 2005.

    The Veronicas was formed in 2004 and NEVER RELEASED 'All About Us' on any album. Check the track listings for 'The Secret Life Of...' This is clearly an unreleased cover done FAR after t.A.T.u created it.

    I've been a fan of t.A.T.u for years and the Veronicas barely became popular not long ago.

  • Ew.

    I love the Veronicas and all but they should stick to doing THEIR own original songs.

    t.A.T.u rocked this out. It's THEIR song and their's for a reason. I respect this version but t.A.T.u's is the best.

  • The Veronicas wrote this song for t.A.T.u

  • I like t.A.T.u's verison better but it was originally written by The Veronicas.

  • No. It wasn't.

    Do you know when each song was released?

    August of 2005, t.A.T.u released 'All About Us'.

    Since all of you are saying that Veronicas did 'All About Us' on their 'The Secret Life Of...', realize: That album was released on October 17, 2005 in Australia. Therefore, making t.A.T.u the creators.

    Thank you.

  • thats not what i'm saying. No it wasn't on "The Secret Life Of..." but they did WRITE it. The Veronicas have been known for writing songs for other people. If you don't believe me go look it up.

  • I don't doubt that the Veronicas write music for other people but I DO doubt that they didn't write this.

    Even if it WAS on 'The Secret Life Of...' album, it was relased 2 months after t.A.T.u released their 'All About Us'.

    The Veronicas aren't even old enough to be respected by t.A.T.u, who has been around longer and wouldn't take music from them. Trust me. They wouldn't resort to them, not with their predicament.

  • yeah ok think what you want but I do have to say your wrong. GO LOOK IT UP.

  • songwriters: Origliasso, Lisa; Steinberg, Billy; Alexander, Josh D.; Origliasso, Jessica

    THEY HELPED. They didn't, by themselves, write it. They helped.

    Plus, they never recorded it to any album, therefore making t.A.T.u the better users of the song.

    They co-writed. They didn't 'write'. Big difference.

  • you were just saying that the veronicas didn't write it... I like the t.A.T.u version way better but i'm not saying anything about making the song or whos better or when the albums came out. The Veronicas don't have this song on any album. I'm just simply saying that The Veronicas wrote the song. With or without help from other people.

  • There's a difference.

    'The Veronicas wrote the song' = those 2 girls wrote it all on their own and got all profit, responsibility, and respect.

    'The Veronicas co-wrote the song' = the 2 girls got 1/2 of the profit, responsibility, and respect.

    See the difference? See where it can be misleading? They didn't get the full respect of good songwriters. THAT's what I was getting at.

    And when the album came out does matter and whose better does too. Shows musical strength.

  • it aint bad, but tatu's original is ALOT better

  • The Original is from The Veronicas. They wrote the Song for tatu.

  • Really? Hmmm, seems I learn somethin new every day.=]

  • No.

    t.A.T.u was the one's who originally wrote the song. the song is about the oppression they suffered because of the apparent lesbian relationship the 2 shared. The Veronicas covered it. t.A.T.u wrote it.

  • mmm i like this version but i am more aficionated to the metal music but i like the veronicas they are really hot but try listening the version from sonic syndicate its more mi style

  • i like the version from t.A.T.u more

    but this one is not bad

  • I like This Song !! (:

  • i like this version better i do like t.a.t.u.s' version but it sounds idk i just like this one better lol Veronicas =<3

  • this is originally from T.a.t.u. isn't it? : P

    well, I think t.a.t.u.'s version is much better.. but this is not bad at all!! This song kicks ass and that's it xD

  • the veronicas wrote this originally.

  • r u serious tatu kills the song!!! V-Rons FTW!

  • I prefer Tatu's version...

  • :| no words.. very ugly xD

  • The Veronicas wrote this song for t.A.T.u

    this version is just a demo.. but its an alright one.. <3 the veronicas

  • Comment removed

  • I love the Veronicas this version was OK

    specially for their voices

    but T.a.T.u's had emotion

  • i agree with wateva ykim0420 sed

  • this one is horrible!!! i LOVE t.A.T.u.'z version!!! its SOOOOOO much better i swear! sorry but i hate this version.. no real emotions, really.... not the same at all.... n i hate the ending the most.. ughh... lol

  • yeah i love the veronicas but

    this song fits better with tatu

  • imagine to hear this song while havin sex...Yeah... not possible with tatu

  • i prefear tatu but i like the veronicas

  • this is t.A.T.u.'s song!! and their version is sooooooooooo much better!!! <3 t.A.T.u.!!

    this one doesnt have the same emotions.. at all!!

  • I agree, I feel more emotion in t.A.T.u's song. This is a good song, but t.A.T.u's will always be the best :D no competition

  • mmm mas hermoso lo canta t.A.T.u y aunque ellas lo aigan escrito pues ni duda a t.A.T.u le salio mejor , aunq hay q admitir q el coro sta chvr ¬¬ el estilo musical q le ponen jejeje

    pero = yo realmnt fan de t.A.T.u

  • ya what she said

  • Tatu is better!

  • t.a.t.u's one is much better

  • This one is better!

  • Comment removed