Added: 3 years ago
From: AikaPelottava
Views: 14,518
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (200)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • And where is At The Gates?

  • no amon amarth??!! NO FUCKING AMON AMARTH??!!!!O.o

  • whats wrong with you where is Dark Tranquillity one of the best bands of melodic death metal PLS KILL YOURSELF... you put Sonic Syndicate and forget Kalmah ok... now im shure you are comercial with the bands

  • @gargueda01 I agree with you. WHERE IS DARK TRANQUILLITY!?

  • NO WINTERSUN? ARE YOU FUCKIN KIDDING ME? 

  • Mors Principium Est is amazing :)

  • 1. Sonic Syndicate sucks balls. They are a Emo Pop Boyband and dont deserve the designation "Metal" or "Melodic Death Metal". They are just popular because they have emo haircuts and a girl in the band (who just can play 2 notes on the bass). Listen to the new album and especially the shiity song "Turn It Up". Its sounds like David Guetta. .....really. Totally fag band....

  • How dare you put children of faggots and not put Kalmah probably the best Melodic death metal band ever and whats that Homo Sonic syndicate 7# ?? id rather listen to slipknot on them btw the only 3 descent bands are Arch enemy - mors pricium - Diablo

  • @Melodeathatic

    Agree......Sonic Syndicate is gay.

  • WHERE THE FUCK IS AT THE GATES?

  • NO KALMAH!!!! MPE SHOULD AT LEAST BE IN THE TOP 3. just my 2 cents. And i think norther should replace COB. AND DT and KALMAH should be a coin flip to determine who should be ranked number one.

  • dawn of solace is so so so so so much better than before the dawn

  • dang.... you seem to like a lot of more industrial stuff :S

    I only like a couple of the bands you mentioned and I think you posted some of their not-so-good songs.

  • WHERE THE FUCK IS DARK TRANQUILLITY?!?!

  • COB is the best band in the world \m/

  • no

  • you sir, have a very wide definition of MDM.

  • Bloody great list. Loved the Eternal Tears of Sorrow and Amorphis add. And Before the Dawn - Totally agree!. They have always been a very under rated bands imo.

    I have a melodeath solo project, if you get the chance check it out - Heavily influenced by almost every band here!

  • DIABLO ftw

  • nice choices ...... but inflames should be in the 1st place :))

  • I just think that DARK TRANQUILITY should be in this list ! But Nice choices !!!!!!

  • I just think that DARK TRANQUILITY shoul be in this list ! But Nice choices !!!!!!

  • lol is the chick in arch enemy the singer? if so thats fucking hot

  • Amorphis was the best band in that list, purely because they have not focused on the screaming, it gives futher depth to thier songs and lets you concentrate on the melodic part of melodeath - even if it does make them sellouts. In Flames are my personal favourite. But 9/10 on those songs i have on my iPhone anyways :P

  • Omg...i'm so happy to see EToS and Cob! xD

    but...in flames on second place? wtf? -___-

  • Children Of Bodom, In flames, Arch Enemy. my FAV ones off the list. Bodom most of all though. Hail METAL \m/

    oh and fuck Justine Bieber. that is all.

  • Pretty good list. The only personal changes would be that a few of those bands I've never listened to (Which will now change lol) and I probably wouldn't have Children of Bodom or sonic syndicate. You should check out Skyfire and Wintersun. Also, Scar Symmetry was my first melodeath band =) (And a heavy influence on my band)

  • @ScarsOfTheForgotten Thanks. Yeah I have listed to all those bands. Scar Symmetry is great! This list is pretty old so..

  • Whoa, no Dark Tranquillity or Kalmah in a Melodeath video. Wtf?

  • You missed Dark Tranquillity and Amon Amarth. :D Still nice list.

  • Comment removed

  • Amorphis was very good, but there wasnt any screaming :-)

  • @milkylicker99 lol at u :) u put all ur info on the internet, stupid american ;)

  • Insomnuim would be my #1 but great list man

  • u shlud listen 2 dark tranquility....srry

  • u shlud listen 2 drak tranquility....

  • Boy go check Amon Amarth.

  • and #G0D is Metallica!!!!!!!!11

  • it started it off ok but u blew it with the commercial crap at the end. In F and cob r past tense in this genre but its ur opionion. my top 5 are

    1) MPE 2)Tracedawn 3)Early Mercenary 4)Naildown 5)Nightrage.

  • aika pelottavasti tehty hitto nään painajaisii täst vireost=D no eii sillee oot aik oikees mut oisin pistäny scar symmetryn johonki 5 paras joukkoo ja amorphis ei oo melodic death metallii mielestäni=(

  • aika pelottavasti tehty hitto nään painajaisii täst vireost=D no eii sillee oot aik oikees mut oisin pistäny scar symmetryn johonki 5 paras joukkoo

  • Moar Sybreed and Disarmonia Mundi

  • I Agree with the #1 on your List BTD is one of the best out there right now with Black Sun Aeon...

  • He got Kalmah good tops list you can only fit 10 but some can be revamped make another new and CoB is complete mdm I was thinking itd be 1

  • wheres cradle of filth

    

  • @TallicaFan1912 not on any list where they should be

  • @TallicaFan1912 cradle of filth arent a melo death band and they suck...

  • Oh and no Amon Amarth?

  • No Carcass? No At The Gates? No Dark Tranquillity? But good list anyways!

  • @TheZombieRitual Carcass isnt a melo death band -.-

  • @lolatmyaccounts Yes they are. Their later material, i.e. Heartwork and Swansong, is considered Melo Death

  • @lolatmyaccounts their later albums are Melodeath

  • terrible list, No Wintersun, No Kalmah, No Amon Amarth

  • Virgin Black. Paradise Lost. The Absence. Just a few bands that are really good for melodic death metal. Primordial isn't death metal but melodic as fuck

  • Where's Kalmah? At The Gates? Equilibrium? Eluveitie? :[

    Only one I like on your list is Mors Principium Est.

  • Where the hell is The Black Dahlia Murder?

  • Soilwork and Disarmonia Mundi DEFENITELY deserve to be on this list, and darkest hour!!!

  • Soilwork and Disarmonia Mundi deserve to be on this list :(

  • mors principium est ?

    and..wtf..in flames are second

  • Strapping young lad, fuckers theyre Canadian too...not exactly melodic though

  • this ain't no death metal where the fuck is the black dahlia murder go listen to some real bands nigga

  • Your name is KillswitchJohn, all credibilty that you might have about knowing which bands are good or not goes flying out the window with a name like that.

  • nigga. that band had nothing to do with my name and i kinda regret it but still, the death metal i listen to sounds nothing like this

  • @KillswitchJohn

    hahahahah dumbass

    fuck black dahlia murder ... they' mainstream so they dont deserve my respect

    these are MELODIC DEATH METAL dumbshit

  • @KillswitchJohn dude fucking really? BDM is not medolic death metal.....

  • where is at the gates and lamb of god and death?

  • lamb of god and death are death metal

  • Personally feel there are plenty of better bands than all of them, but anyway lol...

    In my opinion, Insomnium, Dark Tranquillity, Wintersun, At The Gates, Kalmah, and Be'lakor are better than all of them... i do like Arch enemy tho :)

  • that band "amorphis" reminded me of h.i.m for some reason

  • i'm glad that you posted a song by sonic syndicate that was actually written back when they made melodeath music. eden fire was a good album =( why'd they have to change

  • where the hell are AT THE GATES, poser?

  • most of these bands aren't even death metal

  • wheres the dark tranquillity bro?

  • lol i used to hear children of bodom & arch enemy all time but then i got tired of screaming so now blink 182 is my favorite band

  • @emericask8xD you went from awesome, to aweful. how dare you?

  • @emericask8xD

    That is kinda gay, you know...

  • Mors Principium est is way too overated...but whats is really concerning is Sonic Syndicate.....I mean, listen to those Clean voices....that's so emo =/

    Mantra, Dandelion, Lessthanot & Forget the Fallen (all from venezuela) and Misty Fate (from colombia) just simply OWN a lot of this "top ten" bands =/

  • wow that before the damn band sucked I'm sorry for your opinion

  • Arch Enemy 4ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • 3:57 anyone think the guy at the front with the really long hair looks like a white snoop dogg?

  • i dont like ur taste, arch enemy, mors sure but other than that not lot of ur bands are actually melodic

  • wheres kalmah? good list but eternal tears of sorrow sucks my balls

  • CAN'T YOU READ???

    IT'S "Top 10 Melodic Death Metal Bands (my own opinion)" IN HIS OPINION YOU RETARD, GODDAMIT!

  • @skaplis yea, he understands that. hes simply asking about a great band. he isnt saying that EVERYONE he listed is garbage.

  • very good bands, dark the suns are fucking amazing, listen them and said me bye

  • This is a really mainstream list you need to search for some more unknown bands, try Sybreed - The Next Day Will Never Come. :D New Scar symmetry album out aswell.

  • Yeah I have to indeed with that, I will make a new list soon with my music taste today.

  • I think your list is perfect those are all good bands. :D Did you ever listen to Disarmonia Mundi or Insomnium?

  • Thanx! Yes I listen to them :)

  • Okay, sorry do burst AikaPeilottava bubble and everyone else that thought that this was a good Melodic Death Metal band list. Sonic Syndicate...ehh not Death Metal nad I can't list them all that I thought (my opinion) that wasn't Death Metal. Hasn't anyone heard of Death, kind of pioneers in this feild. How could they not have been in the list....ahh I forgot, this list is made by 11 year old. Other bands like Sadus, Obituary

  • Maybe you should think before you write

    milkylicker99...if this is a Melodic Death Metal list how could Death be in the list then. And the bands in this list are/or were Melodic Death Metal. And I'm 19 years old so fuck you.

  • I will agree that COB is definitely Melodic Death Metal and they are one of my favorites.

    I lived i Orlando and kind of grew up with the Death Metal genre and especially the band Death from when they formed. They might not be considered Melodic Death Metal now, but they sure were in the mid -90's.

    However though ,your list sucks (in my opinion). ..and mr cocky: I'm 19 years old so fuck you...maybe you should think outside the box....but then again it might be hard for someone that young.

  • Okay, but there's more bands in this list that's definitely Melodic Death Metal..Okay I didn't know that. Well, if that's your opinion I have to accept it.

  • @milkylicker99 19? You're acting like you've seen it all buddy. Calm down. It's only a video.

  • @milkylicker99 Death is the greatest band ever to be!

  • Because the list is MELODIC death metal, not DEATH METAL. Big difference even though they sound simmilar (In the name not the music). Basically it's deathmetal with lyrics you can understand wtf they are saying.

  • Ok where the Fuck is Dark Tranquillity,At The Gates,and Amon Amarth!!!

  • only for the weak is the best song of melodic death metal on the world men!

  • This is a really shitty list and half of these bands aren't even melodic death metal, i mean really..

  • I think list is made by a finnish guy. there are more finnish bands at the list than there must be. how can't dark tranquillity or at the gates be at the list whilst before the dawn or sonic syndicate are there.

  • Nice list. My #1 Melodic Death Metal band is Disarmonia Mundi! (:

  • Wow! Awesome list! :)

  • Pretty sure all of these songs are at least in my top 50 =P Good job

  • You have very good taste here. Not that big of a fan of Children of Bodom as I used to and never really liked Sonic Syndicate but good list non the less!

  • Ou, thank you so much! :) My music taste has changed since I made this list, so I should delete this and make a new video I think.

  • I think you should keep it, you can make a better one though, but I would keep this one up. It's your choice

  • Ok, then I keep it.

  • who's the girl in sonic syndicate? she's pretty cute

  • Before the Dawn and In Flames fucking rules.

  • ARCH FUCKING ENEMY! Everyone out there, look up Nemesis and listen to the WHOLE SONG. The best is at the end and is incredible.

  • 1,6,10 are the best.

  • Scar Symmetry is the pinnacle of the genre in my opinion

  • who is neaera ? ;)

  • Great Amorphis, even if they arent death metal, but what about Equilibrium, they are great !!

  • Nice List 5* for your opinion, Amorphis isn't Melodic Death and never was tho. Here is mine for this week 1. At the Gates 2. Carcass 3. Dark Tranquility 4.Kalmah 5. Exhumation (Greece) 6. Quo Vadis (Technical Melodic Death) 7. Arsis (Technical Melodic Death) 8. Omnium Gatherun 9. Burden of Grief 10. Disarmonia Mundi
  • Thanks! Okay..

  • does it matter

  • Obviously

  • Amorphis is closer to mellow death then carcass is lol, though your list is good, carcass doesnt belong up there at all

  • Heartwork is one of the best melodic death albums INM. And Carcass has enough good melodic Death to be in the list

  • lol @ fail vid

    lol @ fail description too, you're missing dozens of bands like Quo Vadis, Carcass, Eternal Tears of Sorrow, Imperanon, Descend Into Nothingness, Incarnia, Disamornia Mundi, Archons and so much fucking more.

    Also, Wintersun, Norther, COB, Soilwork and Sonic Syndicate are all overrated.

  • well, lol @ you! Eternal Tears of Sorrow is inluding in my list so maybe you should stfu before you write. Yeah, but the list isn't correct for me anymore, because my musical taste has changed since I made it.

  • i forgot you're opinion is the same as everyone else's...

  • pfff... Sonic Syndicate and Before the Dawn is not melodic deathmetal it's faggotry.

  • lol. Screw you.

  • Diabloo!!

  • what about quo vadis

  • isnt a melodic death metal band supposed to have clean vocals?

    just wondering...

  • i thought so too. But there are many Top "melodic death metal" list, with bands which dont have clean vocals. :S

    Sonic Syndicate =D

  • Not intended originally but emos came and now we can't have nice things :<

  • where the heck is dark tranquility

  • no offence to the band but eternal tears of sarrow sounds like the name of a goth or emo band

  • wheres kalmah!!

  • DARK TRANQUILLITY?????.... SUCK!!

  • Faggot

  • Scar Symmetry FTW!!!!

  • No it isn't. The Gossow albums are overrated when compared with their older stuff.

  • ffs you guys, its a fucking opinion, its not for you to decide what song someone else likes better

  • Actually the biggest problem here is the choice of songs. I mean, Nemesis instead of Pilgrim? Only For the Weak instead of Moonshield? House of Sleep instead of Black Winter Day? No fuckin way.

  • nun of those bands are death metal lern your shit

  • Yes, it's called melodic death metal. Fuck's sake.

  • without Cradle of filth, Dimmu borgir? I thank you Arch Enemy-great!!!!!! Sonic Syndicate, Before the Dawn??? What is?! emo?! :) This is only my opinion.

  • Cradle of Filth and Dimmu Borgir are not melodic death metal ffs! No they're not emo.

  • Ok. :)

  • Without Insomnium? You're suck.

  • No Insomnium I see.....

  • You cant call yourself a real melodeath fan with those songs, even your #1 is metalcore

  • Nope, my #1 isn't metalcore, it's Melodic Death Metal.

  • arch enemy is mdm, but children of bodom arent same with eternal tears of sorrow and amorphis. there are a lot of mistakes in your txt

  • wheres kalmah!!!!!!

  • Before the Dawn <3

    Kyllä oot jonku ikivanhan biisin kaivanu :D Laulaako tossa Lars vai onko joku muu?

  • indeed <3 joo, se on varmasti joku muu koska Lars ei oli bändissä silloin :D

  • i know Sonic Syndicate are a new band

    but there so dam good !

    there on the top of my list

    thx for the video

  • SCAR SYMMETRY FTW

  • WTF. The poster made NO mention of Dark Tranquillity.... lol no mention of the band that pretty much started melodeath?

  • fucking amazing

  • Arch Enemy arent Melodic Death Metal.

    They are metal. lol

  • I think Sonic Syndicate is very unique among other melo-death bands. It's no surprise that they're on Nuclear Blast.

  • There you have a point.

  • Children of Bodom ei kyllä miellä itseään MDM-bändiksi.. enkä kyllä itsekään. Tai amorphis - house of sleep, ei ole MDM:ää.. Sen sijaan Missä Soilwork? Pain Confessor? :D

  • Lapintaika - Okei. Nojoo kyllä mä tiedän että se house of sleep biisi ei oo MDM, mutta itseään se bändi on mun mieles MDM. No he eivät jäi mukana, mutta mun musiikkimaku on muuttanut mielensäni sen jälkeen kun tämä lista on tehnyt. ;)

  • in flames children of bodom and the black dahlia murder

  • my best Melodeath band is Dark Age from Germany

    they are guuuuuuud

    check out there songs

    also my profile's

  • Kiitti :)

  • Kiva lista, Soilwork ja Skyfire jäi jonnekki :p

  • i think in flames and children of bodom is the best

  • That song from Amorphis that you have isn't MDM.

    Isn't even metal...

  • Pff, Amorphis is a MDM band so..but that song is a bit calmer than other songs they have..

  • nice list mate :)

    Saw CoB live last June! OMG KICK ARSE XD

  • children of bodom i think are the most talented.

  • one of the greatest melodeath bands missing, Dark Tranquility...but ye it's his opinion

  • agreed

  • Thanx!

  • i wouldnt really call arch enemy melodic death metal, but they are very good

  • Okay, but I think they are melodic death metal.

  • i agree :)

    one of my favs

  • Arch Enemy does MDM and Thrash.

  • nice list!

    (In Flames #1 imo lol)

    but also for all you watching this look up these two bands also...

    Anterior (a bit metalcore also)

    Naildown

    some good melodic death metal not too many people have heard

  • could you list the names of the songs

  • Now I've listed the song names.

  • well amorphis is (in my opinion) Melodeath/Folk/progressive metal.

    Children of bodom, MPE and Arch enemy where the best.