Added: 5 years ago
From: clash78
Views: 728,070
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (947)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • THE CLASH IS MY LIFE!!

  • I LOVE YOUTUBE!

  • I honestly never really liked this song that much, but I must say this live version is a lot better than the studio recording

  • @iwantcompletecontrol agreed it sounds much better live

  • Its sad... Music media cares more about what lady gaga is doing or Justin Beiber then Joe ever did. They should be honoring today to remember a true legend! Joe Public!

  • Norway

    

  • @benjibobable

    we are with you!

  • I AM WITH YOU ON THAT ONE march into downing st with a ghetto blaster and take our country back.RIP JOE

  • easily the best band ever, from craddle to grave i'm a clasher

  • The people of the world need to unite and declare war on the international banking cartels who have raped our countries, received trillions in taxpayer bailouts and are now asking us to pay more taxes to them and receive less. We need to stand up and take what is ours from the ruling elite and the rothchilds and the 13 families controlling the world. We are the 99%. Police everywhere there will be a winner of this revolution and it's likely to be the 99%

  • THIS SONG MAKES ME WANT TO PUNCH A TREE AND HUG IT AT THE SAME TIME WHILE TYPING A COMMENT IN CAPITAL LETTERS WITH NO PROPER PUNCTUATION WHATSOEVER

  • @Ramonajunie3 haha! i love that

  • @Ramonajunie3 In which you have success. Hoorah!

  • @mrwells111 huzzah.

  • Happy birthday Joe!!!!<3<3<3

  • great

  • Joe Strummer is my god :)

  • TROLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL­OLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL­OLOLOLOLOLOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL­LLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLLL­LLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLOLOLOLOLOLOL­OLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLL

  • English civil war....think it happened last week!!! great vid.

  • La rivolta dei ghetti, disgraziati ed emarginati di Londra dicono "BASTA " !!!!!!!!!!!! Quando verrà' il nostro momento ?????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Joe Strummer is a Saint in MY church :)

    I'm actually Muslim but nevertheless...:)

  • @benjibobable ... more riots... im up for it!

  • R.I.P Joe )= we miss u nd will always love u <33

  • Norwegian flag in backround :)

    R.I.P JOE!!!! WE LOVE YOU!!

  • Its like coming home.

  • greatest bands.....I loved it so much

  • I fuckin loved Give em Enough Rope ... so hang me.

  • harrow!

  • The world of music is alot worse off with the loss of Joe Strummer .

  • 26 people dont like punk =/

  • this is my song when I'm marching off to an exam :D

  • I have wondered for 20+ Fin years..........what the hey are they saying in this song besides Johnny come marchin' home?

  • @Bigscho69 horrow

  • @Bigscho69 lyricsfreak  . com/c/clash/english+civil+war_­20031933.html

  • I love the stench of rebellion. No mater who's carcass it seeps out of.

  • paul simonon is hot

  • one of their FINEST!

  • The Clash! Punk Rock! Forever!

  • Arriba The Clash chicas! xD

  • Never compare stupid American band Green day to Clash, they are uncomperable you noobs.

  • Fucking amazing!

  • CUT THE SHIT and listen to the bloody music... This is The CLASH so show some damned respect!!!

    Long live the music.......... Rock on....!!!

  • If I only had a time machine...

  • @sharpayRK take me with you

  • R.I.P joe strummer you will be missed....you was a god in punk

  • this is brilliant so much goddamn energy!!!

  • @jimjimtrains Joe Strummer is the best rock´n´roller ever....maybe....right now I just can´t think of anyone else.

  • @ClubViking63 ya me neither... i have people saying you should try listen to other musci I do like but none ever compares to this!

  • I adore them

  • this is why the clash are my favorite band

  • At 1:23 you can see Joe Strummer is facing away from the mic for his line.

  • I noticed something funny, at 2:01Mick is at the left to Paul and Joe, but then the cut right after that Mick is seen right to the right of Joe.

  • Still at the stage of clubs and fists

    A well known face got beaten to bits."

    Still true today.

  • What's with the Green Day bashing all the time? They're still an awesome live band, I just wished I was alive when the Clash were around =L

  • WOW

  • ok guys, every freakin punk video i watch there is an arguement about what is punk and what is not...lets just setle it. the clash are the greatest punk band of all time...is green day punk? no. were they punk at one time? yes. just accept the fact they were punk but can never come close to the clash and let it go..

  • @jverlander35 you tell em dude nobody more punk than clash

  • my favorite live performance ever.

  • god save the clash

  • Oh my god! I LOVE them!

    I was born way too late :'(

  • Great song: but punk is fukin dead : )

  • ala ovo prsti

  • There are lots of things to be grateful for in life. We all have our own private joys. I will always be happy that I got to see The Clash four times (all with Topper at drums).

  • Actually, I think you'll find that it was the "Give 'em enough rope tour" . The album was released in November 1978 and I remember seeing them at the Music Machine in Camden. That must have been very late 78 or early '79 because I remember getting the album the day it was released, when I was at Uni in Leeds.

  • VloggingToNoOne, The Footage is from the Sort It Out Tour Oct-Dec 78. You can date it by the flag backdrop that was used on this tour. I saw them at Middlesbrough Town Hall on 17/11/78 on the very same tour.

  • it's a shame that punk is only alive on the internet..... it sucks

  • This is a wonderful song, which I've said before. Quintessially English, based on English values, which alas, are fast fading. As Blitzkriegpunk said earlier, The Clash encompassed all that was good about the punk movement, the raw excitement is evident in every Clash performance. I always remember Joe Strummer as he was then, not like he would be now. We are punks forever. GB

  • 2:01-2:21 nearly put me in tears

  • no band has ever or will ever come close

    Joe, Mick, Paul and Topper are Gods.

  • Vlogging to No One: This looks like 1978 or 1979 based on hair style and playing style.

  • @carrite yeah but we loved the music more than anything punk rock.

  • does anyone know what year this is from?

  • my generation have definately missed out from the greatest period in music.

  • To all of us old punks who there and remember those times when we were the kids the clash always were and always will be truly loved because they were ours and nobody elses.........................­..........

  • They produced more energy in that sheer two-and-a-half minutes than the sun did in its entire existence. Blows my mind.

  • hey, i love this stuff, we dont have stuff like this now, i love ALL punk that isnt shit like green day or blick 182

  • STILL the only band that matters

  • i love the clash because of their music, but even more, i love how they give it 400% everytime

  • when john comes marching home....

  • such passion!

  • there's a reason the fucking media polyglot monster doesnt put bands like this on tour anymore - its not an accident. JUSTIN BEAVER FUCKER is on top, because this is a fucking matriarchy we're living under, given to us by a narcosis squad of old corporate farts. Joe Strummer said rock music was there to remind you life was worth living. There is a lot of the new generation that's trying to play instruments on a stage, so SOMEONE should succeed. They still need a kick in the nuts, though.

  • @SoundtrackBand

    so so negative, bands are out there, giving a 100% every show, you just need to look harder. i've no idea why every music page you go on you see someone spouting off about that little publess canadian or yank, whatever he is, im not even gonna mention his name.... but that doesnt help matters much at all.... even by me typing about him now..... wish we could go on to a groups video and not have to read about that groomed puppets name !! its easil ignored u know !!!!

  • ORWELL -- ANIMAL FARM

  • long live wokingham skins

  • Wow man, such an high quality!

  • 25 people are fucking retarded!

  • Wow... quality

  • can somone tell me why it is a big norwigen flag in backround?

  • @5ebb theyre playing in Norway perhaps

  • The Clash are so perfect and passionate ... I love them!

  • they look wierd and they look like there in fast motion

  • Every now and then- you think punk is dead or way to commercial- but these guys pioneered and lived it! So miss the CLASH!

  • Classic Joe! Billie Joe of Green Day is indeed a Rip Off!

  • @nickashworth100 u think billie joe is copying joe strummer hahahahahahhahahahahahahahahah­a

  • @nickashworth100 Billie Joe Armstrong is nothing like him, Billie is his own thing, he is another great punk rock muscian

  • @nickashworth100 Billy joe armstrong wishes he was this fucking cool.

  • @nickashworth100 Why is everyone hating on Green Day?

    Im 16 and LOVE the clash, and lets face it, most kids today don't even know who they are.

    Instead of saying how much Billie Joe is a rip off,how about saying he's keeping the clash legacy going and getting younger people into this kind of music.

  • You really got it! You are 16 and wiser than most 50 year old guys!

  • @kohsamuimannen haha thanks(:

  • @AshleyRox14

    I don't think Billie Joe and Green Day are keeping the Clash legacy going at all. Green Day is a Pop-Punk band, which has grown to be a much different genre that doesn't really share the same foundation as classic punk such as this.

    I think the hate comes from Billie Joe acting like he's the same as this, but it's clear he can't hold a candle to it. Unfortunately, most kids these days are missing out because they don't really know what real punk is or who The Clash really were.

  • @LNA3igD Of course Green Day and The Clash aren't similar in their music style. Everyone was saying Billie Joe is copying Joe Strummer and what not. What I meant was that Green Day will do Clash songs, and talk about them alot of the time. And for kids who have never heard of The Clash, they'll probably be like, oh hey, lets go check them out.

    That's what I meant by getting younger people into it.

  • @AshleyRox14 I can see what your saying, but the main issue here (in these comments) isn't what Billie Joe might be saying about The Clash but what he does and how he acts like something he's not.

  • @LNA3igD I agree with AshleyRox14. I'm 17 and Green Day got me into punk and by citing one of their influences as the Clash they got me to delve into old fashioned english punk, which I now love and I recently bought one of the Clash's albums. In the later years Green Day have really changed their tone into a more pop-punk sound but their older stuff is excellent.

  • @nickashworth100 well, he learned from the best!!

  • @nickashworth100 no-one can ever replace Joe Strummer RIP

    

  • Is that the Norwegian flag?

  • Sa wthem 2x in the early 80's at Bonds in NYC and Asbury Park NJ

  • If England were for Englishmen again......sigh

  • its such a shame that good old punk rock has been replaced by dizzy rascal and his tribe of music hating rappers.

    We need good intelligent punk bands again to wake up the masses put into slumber by the bling bling 'culture' of shite.

  • @rushkagon Well said son, RIP Joe. Dizzee Die Soon Shit Head

  • @rushkagon we still have bands like the levellers though

  • @rushkagon can I recommend you listen to Bad Religion? The lead singer has a phd...and they're incredible. Punk is NOT dead.

  • THE PUNKS iS NOT DEAD

  • Wow, absolutely classic Brit hard

    Pistols cover this?

  • 23 assholes who don't like it? what a shit are thinking about?

  • One of my favorite bands 

  • this is from rude boy best film ever...better than rolling stones movies

  • I'm only 34 and couldn't be there, so I'm so sad. because I'm sure that the Clash is the best ever was in world's music.

    I hope you are in the better world now.

    Russia loves the Clash.

  • The Clash were one of the best of the first wave of the English punk bands. R.I.P Joe Strummer. All their albums up to London Calling are classics.

  • @ManFromMelbourne magnificent seven strummer favorite album

    not one lump of shit on the triple gem - experiencing and venturing out. all good even cut the crop has TWO GOOD SONGS on it.

  • this is real punk not green day shit!!!

  • LONG LIVE THE CLASH THEY ARE MY LIFE :)

  • Ok, lets get this shit sorted out once and for all, THIS song and others like sweet chariot and MANY other songs (that for some reason people think are irish ) were ENGLISH Protestant interpretations of the changes that where occurring during the ENGLISH Reformation (I.E THE LEVERS THE SHAKERS etc...), Which were the taken up by the ENGLISH settlers who then created what is now known as the US which is fair enough. But what gets me is when OTHERS get away by stealing what is not theirs.TRUTH

  • the enemy never slew ya, johnny i hardly knew ye

  • Il saggio non deve obbedire alle leggi, ma vivere da uomo libero.

  • @sympathyfortheblues yes well said, i agree

  • immortal !!!

  • aguante The Clash, siempre lo voy a escuchar desde mi corazón!

    Desde Argentina!

  • Pity those who don't get it. Ditto so many Clash anthems.

  • haha micks jump at the end was perfect

  • Best music of clash!

  • its genius to re-use original music but enough said

  • what's the original name for that "hurrah, hurrah" tune?

  • @winggoddess Johnny I Hardly Knew Ya.

  • @jcdixon97 i listened to that song, but it wasn't the right one. the right one was "when johnny comes marching home."

  • @winggoddess Yeah 'when johnny comes marching home' is an american version the melody taken from the earlier song 'Johnny I hardly knew ya'. So either one I suppose. This is one of the coolest melody's ever written.

  • @jcdixon97 oh. when i looked up "johnny i hardly knew ya" in youtube, i only got modern versions with electric guitars and stuff, so i thought it wasn't the right song.

  • @winggoddess dropkick!

  • @winggoddess

    it is called The Battle Hymn of the Republic; it dates back to the War Between the States, and it is an abolitionist song

  • @peterpterodactyl sorry, wrong song!

  • @peterpterodactyl i listened to that song, but it wasn't the right one. the right one was "when johnny comes marching home."

  • the clash the best punk band (for me)

  • I keep coming back to this song

    I love it

    It's so raw and just plain amazing

  • The Clash mititciiii!! English civil war è una delle mie preferite

  • Who else other than Mick Jones could arrange this old chestnut into a rock and roll classic? Strummer took this song into the stratosphere with this performance. "Give 'Em Enough Rope" is so undervalued by Clash fans. I still love the album, warts and all. The live versions of the songs are fantastic. Sandy Pearlman did what he wanted, but the songs were better than he was at the controls.

  • Punks not dead !

  • @MrStanleyTweedle actually dude i hate 2 say this but it did die,it died back in the late 90s,i no its a sad sad tragity

  • @skinheadfred94 not just punk my friend.. music in general died in the late fucking 90s.. JoeS..goodnite sweet prince.

  • Nope. We've got less hair though :D

  • @MrStanleyTweedle In fact music is dead

  • @brikonsejo W R O N G...industry will beat the dust soon just educate the children and expose them to good music - not lady Caca

  • @MrStanleyTweedle

    Not Dead !!! Yep !

  • @MrStanleyTweedle

    Nope, you're right.. I still have my pair of *lace-up* wellies :0)

  • @MrStanleyTweedle

    I think you'll find it is

  • @MrStanleyTweedle yes it is, do you see any music like this coming out today?

  • @bubs7569 There are good bands today but they don't have to touch! Clash, Lurkers, Killjoys, Ramones, Misfits! Those band had the touch, the attitude and style! You don't need to look like punk rocker to be punk rocker! And this is what new bands are! FUCKING WANNABES! True punk was but it still exists! I think there are bands that will keep the flag high but they don't get enough attention becouse of these new fashion punk bands!

  • @MrStanleyTweedle I agree absolutely. not even the crap that garners inexplicable awards and packs concert houses I don't ever want to be in because it's so damned bland can kill it. Punk is immortal.

  • @MrStanleyTweedle SHUT UP, NAME ONE FUCKING MODERN PUNK, ITS FUCKING DEAD, GONE FOREVER!

  • @PBANDSNOW If punk is dead im a fuckin zombie !!!

  • @MrStanleyTweedle what im getting at is that the spirit of punk is alive, but it has no host band... and its dead until that happeneds

  • @PBANDSNOW gone ? certainly. but never forgotten

    there are no bands worthy of even getting near this artform.

  • @goonchistaw maybe when Joe is resurrected!!!!

  • @PBANDSNOW i can't see that happening in reality , but out there there is another

    singer/song writer/flash of lightning/frontman/& force

    waiting to unleash something on us that we lost when joe passed

    as echo+the bunnymen said

    "bring on the new messiah, wherever he may roam".......

  • @goonchistaw Hey, im 15 with a band, if i play my cards right that messiah could be meself!

  • @PBANDSNOW i only have 3 words for you

    "GO FOR IT" !!!

    what a cool age to be listening to this band ,they blew me away everytime they played manchester or near to mcr when i was 15. best of luck to ya...

  • @PBANDSNOW Good luck mate - only thing is - to approach Strummer you got to be true to yourself, to the people and NEVER compromise for the sake of a few bucks

  • @calligh So ur saying I should be like Joe, or Kurt Cobain, and not Johnny Rotten

  • @PBANDSNOW Johnny Rotten's now doing ads for butter in the UK. Nuff said.

  • @MrStanleyTweedle punk is not dead, just hangover ;)

  • songs: line of our people, may the brave live forever.....amen

  • I'm so glad I inherited a punk love from my mother.

  • energy RUSH xD fuckin' love it!

  • If there were more Clash fans in the US then this country wouldn't be in such a fucking mess! Can you imagine a hundred million people with bullshit detectors keen enough to call out the hypocrisy that's everywhere today?

  • top!!

  • Bellissima!

  • it's better than studio version xD UP THE CLASH