@kellyclarksonismygd I actually enjoy Kelly, and not once said that I didn't like her, while you have stated that you don't like Beyonce. MY comments are retarded? When according to you, saying that I don't know what Kelly fans think about Beyonce's originality makes me have something against the video(which, again, I never said <_<), again, you try to switch the roles in this argument
@SuperPianogirl123 Ugh, my personal preference is irrelevant to this commetory. I will say that i recently purchased 4 and enjoy a lot of the songs. Which is something that you cannot say about any of Kelly's albums which puts your reply in ridicule. Also, makes me unbiased oppose to you. Furthermore, I do not "hate" Beyonce, I do not know her. I like Christina's music. Your comments are truly retarded. If you have anything to against my video say so, my opinion stands.
@BrenTheGorgeous And Beyonce IS a better vocalist than Kelly, better technique, More dynamics, Far more control, if you don't believe me: /watch?v=jaN2TbWMvuw
@BrenTheGorgeous There is not one moment when Beyonce screamed, for anything other than exclamations. Beyonce's belting is fine until after F#5, and her Head Voice goes up to E6(D6 live). Kelly has far more power and ease on G5 and G#5, but she is closer to screaming than Beyonce
@SuperPianogirl123 You're so ignorant. A chose Byonce best notes, and Kelly's OK notes. And even with that difference you can see that Kelly reaches notes above the D5 with far more ease and control. If you watch or listen to any F5 or F#5 belt in the studio album "4" you will know that she is in fact screaming to reach those notes. If you think otherwise, you're delusional.
@kellyclarksonismygd I'm an idiot for saying that Beyonce is better. I get that Kelly is your favorite, I like Kelly too, but Beyonce is a better vocalist all together
@SuperPianogirl123 No .. No .. Beyonce is not. Beyonce is DEPENDANT on screaming to hit notes in her range.There is no such thing as a nice belt by Beyonce eb5, by then she is shouting and her headvoice cuts off at c#6,this exclamation crap is garbage. Beyonce may have nice lows and middle belts. But her high notes are a mess, screaming is not even mixed (so she can't have healthy mix), it's bad technique and makes singers not dependant on screaming better singers.Kelly wins
this video should be revamped.. kelly has tons of sustained no strain F5's few months ago.. and that will left beyonce's c#5 is the only note she has on kelly.. lol
@carshe209 Haha, I would revamp this but I got so many haters out of this concept, i don't know if I can go through that again. I'm generally not one to make hate videos. And I don't like beyonce, so no matter how unbiased I seem it will still have an effect on the video.
BYEonce. Kelly on every belt. Fuller, more solid sound. I will only give F5 to Beyonce and this because I'm on a good day LMAO. Beyonce has an amazing low register (which Kelly lacks) and there it ends. She is nothing special in the rest registers. Kelly's beltings are fuller, sustained better and she doesn't have to add that annoying ass vibrato in every note. They both did ok in head voice. Still... belting wise... Kelly >>> Beyonce.
@damskooo since when have the grammy's been credible? there have been so many artists that haven't gotten grammys because the grammy's are voted by out of touch old farts. the fact that the beatles, unanimously hailed as the best EVER, only has like 4 grammys. queen, the who, led zeppelin, buddy holly are just the some of the true legends of music to have never won a grammy. but i guess that means bey is better right?
KELLY,KELLY,KELLY in my opinion is better, i think she can go high with more facility, I can hear her notes more clear, but Beyonce is really good too, but I prefer Kelly
@musicguy713 I have to disagree. Kelly never uses her head voice but when sh does go up ther, sh can compete with Beyonce's. It's not like they're rough. It's amazing to me how kelly has only reach up there once on so many notes and they can still compete with people who use it, and hit those notes all the time. The lows: When you reach the F3 they are pretty much equal. High belts all I can give Beyonce is the C#5 and the F5 but that's just my opinion and I do respect yours btw.
i know some of yall bitches aint comparing these two vocally kelly wins only after the f#5 note in belting thats it kelly clarkson couldnt sing love on to or i'd rather go blin like beyonce if we are talking about who's the better vocalist even kelly would say beyonce c'mon i know some of yallstill iol fans an love kelly but don't get shit twisted fa real
@DOMINIW5 Well, who wants to immitate another artist? Who wants to reproduce what others do? You're right. Kelly couldn't copy Beyonce in a million years. But you know why? Because Kelly is original enough to come up with her own composition. Also, Beyonce could never, in a million years reproduce what Kelly does during Since U Been Gone or the emotions she exhales when she sings Because Of You. But that's a good thing, they're both very different. Get your act together.
@DOMINIW5 lmfao.. i don't think so.. bitch.. beyonce's songs like halo, and listen murdered by amateur singers in the philippines.. jonalyn viray, nina, rachel ann go.. and the best is floprice pempengco's version on glee.. she even covered halo in acapella.. not saying that they did BETTER, but they actually sang those songs in the same key, technique and everything but noit ORGINAL of course.. but it only shows how easy beyonces songs to be sang by amateurs hahaha..
I love both, beyonce is one of my favorites artist in the world and kelly is a GREAT singer i think this battle is for beyonce and kelly TRUE voices of our generation !!
beyonce mixes to the extent that it is about to become head voice, her '1 + 1' performance backstage off-mic was really weak. even the C5s in 'halo' is super weak. it only sounds strong because the mic is heavily-EQed. true i dont like beyonce, but lets be real here. if you wanna compare kellyC's belts (with acoustic mic) with beyonce (overly-EQed/condenser mic + echo machine) belts, you know kellyC wins. there is no such thing as a perfect singing technique in pop btw...
@GCassa94 kelly is chest dominant.. beyonce is heady.. thats why her upper register is airy breathy thin.. even her mid belts are airy breathy -----------------------> __/ a sit for you :)
the perfect mix does not mean a head-dominant form of belting with the help of a condenser mic to make your sound powerful. of course its easy to maintain pitch with a SUPER head-dominant form of belting. hear '1 + 1' backstage, it was really weak coz she sings soft... #justsaying
@carshe209 No, she's not heady, her mix is perfect...and "thin"? Please...you better stop it....you don't like Bee? Ok, but her technique is amazingly perfect..that's the truth.
Beyonce's technique is something else, I'll give her that. She definately has that over Kelly. But she has nothing on Kelly's voice, regardless of that. And that's a fact. And actually, just to let you know, Kelly can mix just as well and consistantly as Beyonce if she chooses to actually. She's displayed that more than Donald Trump has displayed his stupidity (and that's a lot) Kelly's tone, control, and range are far out of Beyonce's league, althoguh Beyonce's pretty good too xD
@GCassa94 You really think the G5s and G#5s showcased here are proof of Beyonce's amazingly perfect technique and perfect mixing ? Hmm...That's weird.
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow 'her 1+1 performance backstage off-mic was really weak' that's one of the most fucked up delusional things i've ever read from youtube. she was singing without a mic, projecting her notes in a room
actually, i do know what im talkling about. her belts are HEAVILY MIXED throughout her register. and you can see that she was going to her fullest. her projection is really not that great, like kellyC, the sound is also very covered up. :/ no offence to you, coz your like an awesome friend! :)
ikr! as much as i dislike bey, i dont think i will ever make a vocal battle vid concerning her. coz i dont like her, why would i want her in my channel lol! :P
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow OMG. This is exactly how I flt about her. I literally CANNOT stand her. But after the Beehives went after Kelly I had to prove my point. On thing is for sure though. I will not bother with her any longer.
im one of many lambs who prefer christina over beyonce. literally 'because of you' LOL! im getting addicted into kellyC's music again after like 2-3 years lol! :P
Kelly has more ease with her higher notes and can sustain notes past E5 longer than Bey (I think) , but I think that's due to having a naturally higher voice than Bey. I think they're pretty equal :)
I love Kelly's resonance and she doesn't stress notes like she use to, but in this video she lacks versatility in the note when she hits it she does the same thing, Beyonce's has the ability to make her notes have different characteristics which adds to her versatile singing
@STRATEKOOL15 There was no d6 there ._. that was a c#6 and a bb5.. g#2 to c#6 .. still no d and e. Not held infact not even touched,probably an error in the video. Who cares I am moving on
@BeyonceLuvr93 What's more, I don't see Whitneys fans going around saying that she has notes in her range that are not actually in her range. Beyonce g#2 - c6, case closed.Kelly has a far bigger,far less restricted and way more comfortable head register then Beyonce could ever have.
@BeyonceLuvr93 No I haven't and that is because Whitney cannot hit d6's just like your girl cannot hold d6's properly and requires autotuning.It's a fact that your girl has no control about c6,think what you want.You are clearly deluded, Do you even know what an exclamation is? Find me an example of Beyonce properly hitting and holding a d6 or e6 effortlessly with vibrato? You can't it does not exist, she has very little control in her head register.
@BeyonceLuvr93 I will be sure to report you to every youtube member I know. Including my friends, my combined subscribers (650) and release hell on you for making that thread on ATRl.
Kelly's songwriting abilities >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BEYONDSH!TS Lying career.. And don't bring kelly's weight to this argument.. coz we all know that Adele slays all :D Without promo.. slaying beyondsh(i)t effortlessly.
THE ONLY GOOD THING BEYONCE IS GOOD AT IS STEALING OTHER PEOPLE'S SONGS IDEAS, CREDITS, HARD EARNED WORK.. and the list goes on... PFFT LOL she can't even sell out 100k seats.. did you see that photoshopped booklet of her I Am Sasha Fierce World Tour? LOL.. so desperate to make it look like she sells out stadiums.. Poor beyonce.. she won't be a legend. coz nothing she does is special nor unique.
And what the fk? Second Coming of Michael Jackson? Gurl, don't get me started. She's not even on Madonna's level yet. Beyonce doesn't work hard.. She just have a good marketing team. LMAO....
Beyonce is such a try hard, buying all these awards for her.. Millenium Award? PFTTTTTTTTTTTT. HOW MUCH DID SHE BUY THAT FOR? 4 FLOPS SO HARD.. I should call it 4CLOSURE. LMAO.
@spidey678 honey.. quit copying my posts on other videos..they might think that i'm you.. which is not.. coz your channel is full of hate on mariah.. sorry! im a lamb.. bitch! stop using kelly..
KELLY WINS.. GURL BEYONCE IS A FAKE ASS BITCH WHO CANT EVEN SURVIVE A DECENT CONCERT WITHOUT INFECTING THE STAGE WITH HER BOOTY.. SHE SHAKES HER BOOTY AND SHE CALLS IT DANCING.. SHE CAN'T SING FOR HER LIFE.. SHE NEEDS AMPLIFIERS AND ECHOES TO MAKE HER SOUND MORE POWERFUL THAN SHE IS.
@BeyonceLuvr93 and funny how eevry stan of beyonce bash kelly's intonation calling it shitty.. keep in mind that kelly's genre is pop/rock the rise and fall of her voice and super controlled transitions is not necessary.. but it doesnt mean she can't!! coz there were songs like LIES, and her cover of ''I KNOW YOU WON'T'' has great projection, shifting and overall great intonation.. so the claims on her shitty intonation FAIL!
@BeyonceLuvr93 I have watched roseland and i'm sorely disappointed that there was that much playback involved, I understand it was for DVD purposes somewhat but I wouldn't waste my money buying that. If i wanted to hear a bunch of playback I would just go listen to "4" Also her love on top performance at the VMA's is pre-recorded play.
@BeyonceLuvr93 there were times, like 2 or 3 times or maybe 5 times in beyonce's entire career that she hold those notes, not so long.. while kelly from 2002-2011 hits and sustained those notes..almost every night on her concerts..yes some are strained.. but i can still count on my fingers how many times she strained.. and its understandable for someone who doesnt ever lip synch! and for someone without enough vocal rest.. and it wasnt sounded like gutiral screaming.. so its ok..
@BeyonceLuvr93 yes beyonce has good e5's.. but kelly has great eB5-g#5, untouchable compare to any other singers of her generation a fact. that has proof.. she can easily access those notes.. vigorously, sustained and she can hit those notes numerous times in chest dominant way.. without getting to much thin.. or getting it in a very head driven way i.e. beyonce, leona, and on past 3 years kelly has improved her BB4-D5.. before beyonce can kill kelly in midbelts but now! SHE CAN'T!
@BeyonceLuvr93 kelly's genre is pop rock, melisma is not necessary.. she's more of a upperbelter, grunts,growls and riffs..can easily access upper register without holding back and usually sustained! fyi, there was kelly's songs that has great melisma, BOY (acapella) up to the mountain, cleopatra, and studio version of hazel eyes.. and songs that she sang wth Tony Bennet.. beyonce has good melisma (her genre is more of rhytim and blues) if she hasnt have that then she's shittier than rihanna
@BeyonceLuvr93 whole world knows that note was lipped, anyway lipped or not.. that g5 from bleachyonce seems like it was just a cough, sneeze coming from kelly.. and no beyonce's resonance relied on echo/reverb/delay machine and enhancements giving it layers of sound.. very breathy airy.. and its a well known fact that yonka's belts above eb5 was thin!! and talking about runs.. kelly can hold ANY NOTE.. from fifth octave.. while yonka just barely touches notes above e5..
@BeyonceLuvr93 Ugh, it's a known fact that the sugamama was lipped and so was Billboard's Run The World performance, but then again. You're a very delusional stan. Btw, moron, stop calling a quality by the plural. there's no such thing as "melismas". Melisma is a quality of a belt, not an outmost technique. God, stop copying what others write and think it's right. "Her voice and belts are juice more resonant and warm in general" LMAO. Cooking class now huh?
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
@BeyonceLuvr93 Beyonce's head voice is terrible, It needs autotuning after c6 if she attempts to hold it and by e6 is simply exclamations. I am sorry but she has no control at all.Where she hold a resonant d6 with full vibrato for at least 1 second and then an e6 then it can be considered part of her range but if she has all this control like you say she does then why can't she hold a high d or e? Please exclaim..oops i meant EXPLAIN*
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
Head Voice: Beyonce, but then again Kelly seldoms uses it.
Beyonce takes the lower register and gives a good fight up to F#5. Anything above that is Kelly's domain (I give F5, AND F#5 to Kelly, even though these are Bey's money notes). Beyonce has the better head register...but I wish Kelly would use hers more (but her stylings do not call for it) Overall Kelly basically ran over Bey over in this video.
@kellyclarksonismygd well, i dont want to be the guy who pisses everyone off by over-voicing my opinions. so, i'm just gonna say they're both great artists, both have incredible voices, and I think at the end of the day, it all comes down to genre preference. If you're more into rock pop, its gonna be kelly, if ur more into urban, it's gonna be beyonce. BUT, I do wanna say that it was a great video and I enjoyed the quality of it! :)
@carshe209 Well, my policy has always been the same. If you don't give a fair chance to both opponents, even yourself don't believe that your favorite can beat their opponent. So, it has been always my goal to show the best in show for everybody being compared. Besides, i'm fully confident of Kelly's abilities. I don't need to cheat to make my point. However, in the same sense that I can make these fair, I can also make them biased.
@jordangossman1 lmfao, grammy means nothing.. nowadays the credibility was already fucked up how many grammy's has taylor swift and lady gaga has? ..mariah only had 5 in 2 DECADES.. yet shes the greatest singer on this planet! hahahaha.. not a fair match? oh god you have ineffcient ears..
@carshe209 really? lmao. way to go off topic here haha. your comment is entirely irrelevant. i dont think this is a match where mariah carey is brought up, at all. and my ears are inefficient? hmm.... who is known more for their live performance? beyonce. serioiusly, get off your computer, stop trolling, walk outside, and see the fucking sunshine... you are entirely irrelevant. so therefor, nothing you bitch about matters. :)
@jordangossman1 asshole.. youre so freakin idiot..whats the relevance of grammy's in this video anyway???? hahahahahahahahahaha!!!! yes beyonce is known for her live performance.. the rigorous dancing, lip synching, numerous slutty wardrobe change, back up dancers, head banging with her 2 kilos wigs.. and so-called singing.. using echo effects.. hahaha.. you mad???
@carshe209 I'm sorry, but is it at all possible for you to construct a proper sentence? I don't understand your idiocracy, but I would like to be able to so I can respond accordingly. So go get your dictionary, and hey, I'm sure you can even get a teacher to help you formulate a grammatically correct sentence and then I'd be more than happy to come back and continue this "debate".... k?
@jordangossman1 Can we stop mocking grammar when you're stanning for an artist? I highly doubt any of us really give a damn about it. Besides, you're fluent. He's not. I can understand that sentenc, so shall you. I advice you to find something else to mock.
@kellyclarksonismygd this whole thing has gone too far. I think Beyonce is better, you think Kelly is better. Cool, awesome. I'm done with this. I have a life to live, I dont live vicariously through youtube. All I did was state an opinion, and my opinion has not been swayed. I still love Kelly, she's amazing, but I prefer Beyonce to her because the genre of music. I advice people to stop jumping in on this, because any comments that come after this, will not be pleasant.
@kellyclarksonismygd Excuse me, first off, dont use the word "retarded" because thats hurtful to more people than you know. How old are u, 12? Life isn't about comebacks! Secondly, someone disagreed with you, oh no! :O BUILD A BRIDGE AND GET THE FUCK OVER IT! Yep, I've come to the conclusion that you are 12 years old. Hey you've got puberty to look forward to :) And if you aren't 12, then you have got some MAJOR growing up to do!
@jordangossman1 you're terrible.. you are taking all these very personal.. you should have known the difference about virtual life and REAL life outside youtube.. just because you don't have any word against other people arguements.. then you have to argue with their grammar? too bad! english is not my language.. you just stated your opinion.. but you suck to defend your point and you just showed that you know nothing about this matter.. then your opinion is INVALID.. stay mad haha
@jordangossman1 Honestly, all this just because I used the "R" word. Look, I wasn't even calling you retarded. My whole point is that your conclusion was very stupid and I stand by my statement.
@jordangossman1 . english is not my language.. not even my 2nd or third language.. lmfao.. just because you can't back up your arguement.. so you have to talk about grammar? hahahahaha....
upper chest register: kellyC coz she her belts sound full/thick/resonant (apart from abusing the countless echo machines, her mic is also heavily EQ-ed and bey's F5 from 'speechless' is the perfect example of that) the 'RTW' note is a F5 btw.
falsetto/head voice register: G5 - tie A5 - beyonce(only coz of the heavily EQ-ed mic) C6 - tie
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Haha, Kelly doesn't use any effects. She's known to keep things VERY simple. Unless it's on TV shows, but even then it's to make sure we can actually hear her haha. Anyhoo, thank you so much for commenting :) And about the G5 from respect. Before I cam along, everybody usd it. I mean, every non kelly fanatic uses it. I get it, it's great but I just feel that there are a lot of G5 (literally thousands) to pick from haha. I like mixing it up. ;)
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Haha, well. I personally don't like the Walk Away G5s because she hits them for quantity reasons which leave wishing for more. But, god. I've usd so many. When it comes to picking which G5 I like the most I just go with my mood haha. It's not like certain artists who only have like 5 of them. Kelly has thousands in hundreds of different songs. I went with sustainability and support for this video. Haha.
and i agree with what you say about kellyC... she BARELY uses any effects/EQing of mics. bey stans say we are just talking abt the echo machines like HELL NO! in PA there's also such thing as increasing the bass/increasing the EQ. beyonce ABUSES the PA system to make her voice sound powerful when it is shrill/heavily-mixed... no one abuses the PA system like she does... FACT! echo machines are common but 4/5 of them? i dont think so...
@carshe209 Beyonce's belts B4 - F5 have much better quality, resonance and power then Kelly's shouted notes, thats a fact. Kelly's lower register is non existent, Beyonce's SLAYS her, this video dosent even began to capture the ease she has down there. Bey's head voice is also a lot more resonant and comes with much more ease. I mean, Kelly has only done like three sustained head voice notes in her whole career, LOL. Stay pressed over the queen, no one checking for Kelly.
@MimiDahhling30 Besides, I only blocked one who kept repeating that I was pathetic and delusional when I never even interacted with him/her. I'm sorry, I'm going to keep drama to a minimum. At least have some respect. The ones that were blocked previous to this video, if read the description I said I'd unblock them if they contact me with another account. Calling one, several. Fuck you Kenny.
@MimiDahhling30 kelly's belts in this video doesnt have certain loudness and intensity to be called shout.. if theres a shouter here its yonka..resonant than kelly?.. beyonka's resonance relied on reverb,echo,and delay enhancements.. i can give her c#5, puhlease.. kelly's full bodied, sustained.. and agile belts.. vs beyonce's pathetic little breathy, airy, convulsioning wavy vibrato belting? beyonce head voice? her c#6 and a5.. are pretty good.. her c6 is nothing but overly connected NOISE
@MimiDahhling30 beyonce queen? like whtney and mariah? haha those are real queens.. dont ever start arguement about RESONANCE, coz im a fan of mariah, whitney, aretha.. and i know what is resonance.. unfortunately yonka's relied her resonance on enhancements.. echo will always gave certain amount of volume and layers in any sound, stay mad.. you cant get it twisted.. in any form kelly will demolish yonka's limited vocals.. deal with it!!!
@kellyclarksonismygd Are you telling me BZBlaner is the ONLY Beyonce fan you've EVER blocked? I hardly believe that, and you've actually talked about others you have blocked before lol.
@MimiDahhling30 I only block people when they offend me instead of attacking the integrity of the vocals. From this video I only blocked one, for the reason stated above. I believe it's very disrespectful to attack the video maker in such ways especially when it's out of the blue. If they are blocked it was for a reason. Furthermore, when did I ever state that Bzblaner was the only user I ever blocked. You're putting words in my comments. Oh, and don't get me started why I blocked you.
@kellyclarksonismygd I never said users in general, I said BEYONCE FANS lol. Also, the person you're referring too didn't attack you personally. They attacked some of you're crazy beliefs about vocals including Kelly's 'screams' as part of her range. A personal attack would be exposing their personal info and calling them rude names, does that sound familiar? Oh and I was blocked for saying Kelly didn't belt the C6 lmao.
@MimiDahhling30 Crazy beliefs? I'd love to hear the concept behind that statement. Beyonce fans like to attack Kelly in general. It wouldn't surprise me if I blocked them over the whole C6 thing. Which, I'm giving them a chance to be unblocked. I love how you are stirring the pot as much as possible. Acting like I'm doing anything evil. If they are blocked, it wouldn't be because of THIS particular video. Furthermore, do you have the exact quote? How do you know what actually happened?
@MimiDahhling30 Furthermore, coming from the person who a year ago, in our first interaction said he was going to "get my billions youtube friends to dislike this. Toddles" on a video which took a month to complete earlier in the year, just because I disagreed with his views (after I helped him get a note btw). Hypocrisy comes nothing close to what you're doing now.
@kellyclarksonismygd The crazy beliefs are the fact that you think random squeals, grunts and screams are a part of someones singing range lmao. Anyways, the exact quote? what are you talking about lol.. you've made it quite clear of 'the group' of people you hate, which several, happen to be Beyonce fans. Also, about the dislike thing that was because I disagreed with you on including screams in Kelly's range (which many other people believed) and you weren't having it.
@MimiDahhling30 I completely disagree, I composed in several replies that a lot of those were simply included to fill in gaps and not to bee taken seriously. Not to mention that thos screams were filled under exclamations to begin with, and that, in the vido itslf. I didn't consider any of them as actually being whistles and head voice tones. You were just blind with rage that I went against your uneducated opinion. Furthermore, I did ancknowledge however that a lot could be considered.
@MimiDahhling30 You also made it quite clear that in your eyes Kelly is no better than a lot of singers today. You undermind her like nothing else. In relation to the quote, I'm asking what you heard from the beyonce fan that got blocked because of this videeo. He called me pathetic, delusional and that i was crazy for thinking that Kelly was better than Beyonce. I have a right to my own opinion and to keep away time wasters from my videos.
@kellyclarksonismygd (cont) So you decided to attack me personally, calling me clueless and ignorant. AFTER, I even said I really enjoyed the video and was being nice to you, I just didn't agree with the screams. You can't really compare that, with what you did with BZBlaner. Also, this was just ONE video.. you ended up puting a ton of dislikes every single video I uploaded.
@MimiDahhling30 I did not attack you personally. Last time I checked, I said you were being a hater, nothing else. And when you actually handed that completely disgusting threat I actually stated that I simply make videos. Which is what this should be about. Not crazy fan wars. Can you tell which note is which without asking others, viewing in other videos or using tuners?
@MimiDahhling30 Continuation: I had no other choice. You were the one who played dirty to begin with. As a matter of fact, my following videos which when I uploaded got dislikes almost instantly. I can only assume it was either from you or your followers. And as I recall I did not dislike your videos right away. It was after I got 18 dislikes in that single video and 5 additional to several of mine.
Kelly sings WAY better. WAY.
mrjean321 2 days ago
@kellyclarksonismygd Try to reread it, because it isn't that hard to understand -_-
SuperPianogirl123 3 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 *don't care what Kelly fans think
SuperPianogirl123 3 days ago
@kellyclarksonismygd I actually enjoy Kelly, and not once said that I didn't like her, while you have stated that you don't like Beyonce. MY comments are retarded? When according to you, saying that I don't know what Kelly fans think about Beyonce's originality makes me have something against the video(which, again, I never said <_<), again, you try to switch the roles in this argument
SuperPianogirl123 3 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 Ugh... What?
kellyclarksonismygd 3 days ago
@kellyclarksonismygd This coming from a person who hates Beyonce enough to rate her below The Noise, you're the delusional one
SuperPianogirl123 3 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 Ugh, my personal preference is irrelevant to this commetory. I will say that i recently purchased 4 and enjoy a lot of the songs. Which is something that you cannot say about any of Kelly's albums which puts your reply in ridicule. Also, makes me unbiased oppose to you. Furthermore, I do not "hate" Beyonce, I do not know her. I like Christina's music. Your comments are truly retarded. If you have anything to against my video say so, my opinion stands.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 days ago
@BrenTheGorgeous And Beyonce IS a better vocalist than Kelly, better technique, More dynamics, Far more control, if you don't believe me: /watch?v=jaN2TbWMvuw
SuperPianogirl123 3 days ago
@BrenTheGorgeous There is not one moment when Beyonce screamed, for anything other than exclamations. Beyonce's belting is fine until after F#5, and her Head Voice goes up to E6(D6 live). Kelly has far more power and ease on G5 and G#5, but she is closer to screaming than Beyonce
SuperPianogirl123 3 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 You're so ignorant. A chose Byonce best notes, and Kelly's OK notes. And even with that difference you can see that Kelly reaches notes above the D5 with far more ease and control. If you watch or listen to any F5 or F#5 belt in the studio album "4" you will know that she is in fact screaming to reach those notes. If you think otherwise, you're delusional.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 days ago
@kellyclarksonismygd I'm an idiot for saying that Beyonce is better. I get that Kelly is your favorite, I like Kelly too, but Beyonce is a better vocalist all together
SuperPianogirl123 4 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 No .. No .. Beyonce is not. Beyonce is DEPENDANT on screaming to hit notes in her range.There is no such thing as a nice belt by Beyonce eb5, by then she is shouting and her headvoice cuts off at c#6,this exclamation crap is garbage. Beyonce may have nice lows and middle belts. But her high notes are a mess, screaming is not even mixed (so she can't have healthy mix), it's bad technique and makes singers not dependant on screaming better singers.Kelly wins
BrenTheGorgeous 3 days ago
@BrenTheGorgeous passed eb5*
BrenTheGorgeous 3 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 *YOUR
SuperPianogirl123 5 days ago
@kellyclarksonismygd The same Stans who start shit with Beyonce fans bitch @_@, it's YOU video, don't be a fucking idiot on it
SuperPianogirl123 5 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 Reading your initial and post reply, my initial and conclusive response is that the only idiot here is you.
kellyclarksonismygd 5 days ago
Beyonce, and before you Kelly fans start insulting me, i don't give a fuck about how you feel about Beyonce's "tone," or "originality." thank you
SuperPianogirl123 6 days ago
@SuperPianogirl123 Ugh, who the "fuck" cares about you hun, when 90% of the votes are for Kelly?
kellyclarksonismygd 5 days ago
this video should be revamped.. kelly has tons of sustained no strain F5's few months ago.. and that will left beyonce's c#5 is the only note she has on kelly.. lol
carshe209 2 weeks ago
@carshe209 Haha, I would revamp this but I got so many haters out of this concept, i don't know if I can go through that again. I'm generally not one to make hate videos. And I don't like beyonce, so no matter how unbiased I seem it will still have an effect on the video.
kellyclarksonismygd 2 weeks ago
@kellyclarksonismygd i understand.. :) btw stronger tour is a sea of F5 and F#5.. kelly just dethroned beyonce from being queen of F5, bwahahaha..
carshe209 2 weeks ago
I love you!! XD, I love that "the intro is too long, FUCK YOU!" hahhahah
and of course KELLY IS THE BEST! <3
kellymaniako 2 weeks ago
what performance is at 4:39 (MLWSWY-KELLY) what show is it on? :)
CabinCrewFly 2 weeks ago
@CabinCrewFly Operacion triunfo :)
kellyclarksonismygd 2 weeks ago
Kelly sounds best here
leandrooalmeida11 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BYEonce. Kelly on every belt. Fuller, more solid sound. I will only give F5 to Beyonce and this because I'm on a good day LMAO. Beyonce has an amazing low register (which Kelly lacks) and there it ends. She is nothing special in the rest registers. Kelly's beltings are fuller, sustained better and she doesn't have to add that annoying ass vibrato in every note. They both did ok in head voice. Still... belting wise... Kelly >>> Beyonce.
Luxiusta07 1 month ago 2
@Luxiusta07 I don't get why this comment was flagged as spam o.o
hessounusual95 5 days ago
KELLY GOT THIS BEYONCE IS ONLY GOOD AT POPPIN HER ASS AND HAVING A MILLION DANCERS DISTRACT FROM HER ACTUAL SINGING SORRY
NewOrleansKing2011 1 month ago
@NewOrleansKing2011 Thats why she has 10 vocal grammys which is more then all of kely hers combined :)
damskooo 1 month ago in playlist Meer video's van kellyclarksonismygd
This has been flagged as spam show
@damskooo This is because Kelly's dad is not a member of the Grammy Awards committee.
Luxiusta07 1 month ago 2
@damskooo LMFAO.. how many grammy's mariah whitney and celine has for decades? grammy nowadays is so fucked up..
carshe209 1 month ago
@damskooo THE GRAMMYS IS A POLLUTED POPULARITY CONTEST....
NewOrleansKing2011 1 month ago
@damskooo since when have the grammy's been credible? there have been so many artists that haven't gotten grammys because the grammy's are voted by out of touch old farts. the fact that the beatles, unanimously hailed as the best EVER, only has like 4 grammys. queen, the who, led zeppelin, buddy holly are just the some of the true legends of music to have never won a grammy. but i guess that means bey is better right?
agators212 1 month ago
@kellyclarksonismygd Well I think it's much closer than what people say. Kelly sustained her notes, which deff gives here the edge.
musicguy713 1 month ago
KELLY,KELLY,KELLY in my opinion is better, i think she can go high with more facility, I can hear her notes more clear, but Beyonce is really good too, but I prefer Kelly
luciarey1 1 month ago
lower register-Beyonce by far. Kelly's low register is pretty small, while bey has ease all the way to Bb2, just no competition there.
Mid belts- C#5, Eb5-Beyonce, D5-Tie, C5, E5-Kelly
Upper Belts-It close when kelly is on. F5 goes to bey. f#5 is tie. G5-G#5 is kelly.
Headvoice-Beyonce by far. Kelly never uses hers and beys tone up there is amazing.
Overall beyonce is more consistant and her range is more connected and her control is amazing. Kelly has a better voice IMO.
musicguy713 1 month ago
@musicguy713 I have to disagree. Kelly never uses her head voice but when sh does go up ther, sh can compete with Beyonce's. It's not like they're rough. It's amazing to me how kelly has only reach up there once on so many notes and they can still compete with people who use it, and hit those notes all the time. The lows: When you reach the F3 they are pretty much equal. High belts all I can give Beyonce is the C#5 and the F5 but that's just my opinion and I do respect yours btw.
kellyclarksonismygd 1 month ago
i know some of yall bitches aint comparing these two vocally kelly wins only after the f#5 note in belting thats it kelly clarkson couldnt sing love on to or i'd rather go blin like beyonce if we are talking about who's the better vocalist even kelly would say beyonce c'mon i know some of yallstill iol fans an love kelly but don't get shit twisted fa real
DOMINIW5 2 months ago
@DOMINIW5 Well, who wants to immitate another artist? Who wants to reproduce what others do? You're right. Kelly couldn't copy Beyonce in a million years. But you know why? Because Kelly is original enough to come up with her own composition. Also, Beyonce could never, in a million years reproduce what Kelly does during Since U Been Gone or the emotions she exhales when she sings Because Of You. But that's a good thing, they're both very different. Get your act together.
kellyclarksonismygd 2 months ago 12
@DOMINIW5 lmfao.. i don't think so.. bitch.. beyonce's songs like halo, and listen murdered by amateur singers in the philippines.. jonalyn viray, nina, rachel ann go.. and the best is floprice pempengco's version on glee.. she even covered halo in acapella.. not saying that they did BETTER, but they actually sang those songs in the same key, technique and everything but noit ORGINAL of course.. but it only shows how easy beyonces songs to be sang by amateurs hahaha..
pritykazy 2 months ago
@DOMINIW5 I think they're too stupid.. :D
GCassa94 2 months ago
I love both, beyonce is one of my favorites artist in the world and kelly is a GREAT singer i think this battle is for beyonce and kelly TRUE voices of our generation !!
demonialitytorture 2 months ago
btw, 7:56 is E5...she lowers the key to 'Listen" live.
mellynumerounoo 2 months ago
@mellynumerounoo My bad! I assumed she hit the F#5 live and only lowered it for the xfactor duet.
kellyclarksonismygd 2 months ago
Kelly DESTROYS.
mellynumerounoo 2 months ago 3
beyonce mixes to the extent that it is about to become head voice, her '1 + 1' performance backstage off-mic was really weak. even the C5s in 'halo' is super weak. it only sounds strong because the mic is heavily-EQed. true i dont like beyonce, but lets be real here. if you wanna compare kellyC's belts (with acoustic mic) with beyonce (overly-EQed/condenser mic + echo machine) belts, you know kellyC wins. there is no such thing as a perfect singing technique in pop btw...
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago 30
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow O.O Bee has the perfect mix! She can add head voice as much as her wants..Kelly? Not so much...
GCassa94 2 months ago
@GCassa94 kelly is chest dominant.. beyonce is heady.. thats why her upper register is airy breathy thin.. even her mid belts are airy breathy -----------------------> __/ a sit for you :)
carshe209 2 months ago
@carshe209
the perfect mix does not mean a head-dominant form of belting with the help of a condenser mic to make your sound powerful. of course its easy to maintain pitch with a SUPER head-dominant form of belting. hear '1 + 1' backstage, it was really weak coz she sings soft... #justsaying
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
@carshe209 No, she's not heady, her mix is perfect...and "thin"? Please...you better stop it....you don't like Bee? Ok, but her technique is amazingly perfect..that's the truth.
GCassa94 2 months ago
Beyonce's technique is something else, I'll give her that. She definately has that over Kelly. But she has nothing on Kelly's voice, regardless of that. And that's a fact. And actually, just to let you know, Kelly can mix just as well and consistantly as Beyonce if she chooses to actually. She's displayed that more than Donald Trump has displayed his stupidity (and that's a lot) Kelly's tone, control, and range are far out of Beyonce's league, althoguh Beyonce's pretty good too xD
lightningshock12 2 months ago 2
@GCassa94 You really think the G5s and G#5s showcased here are proof of Beyonce's amazingly perfect technique and perfect mixing ? Hmm...That's weird.
Luxiusta07 1 month ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow 'her 1+1 performance backstage off-mic was really weak' that's one of the most fucked up delusional things i've ever read from youtube. she was singing without a mic, projecting her notes in a room
kelvinpyaeko 3 days ago
@kelvinpyaeko
actually, i do know what im talkling about. her belts are HEAVILY MIXED throughout her register. and you can see that she was going to her fullest. her projection is really not that great, like kellyC, the sound is also very covered up. :/ no offence to you, coz your like an awesome friend! :)
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 days ago
for someone who dont like beyonce, this is actually the fairest vocal battle made. how is this hating?
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Yeah, this video got out of hand by comments alone. Not the content of the video which I find hysterical.
kellyclarksonismygd 2 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd
ikr! as much as i dislike bey, i dont think i will ever make a vocal battle vid concerning her. coz i dont like her, why would i want her in my channel lol! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow OMG. This is exactly how I flt about her. I literally CANNOT stand her. But after the Beehives went after Kelly I had to prove my point. On thing is for sure though. I will not bother with her any longer.
kellyclarksonismygd 2 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd
lol! me too! and imma mariah lamb btw. but because i prefer christina to bey all lambs think imma mariah hater in disguise... LMAO! XD
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd
im one of many lambs who prefer christina over beyonce. literally 'because of you' LOL! im getting addicted into kellyC's music again after like 2-3 years lol! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
damn.... your comment section is a mess! :/
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
Kelly has more ease with her higher notes and can sustain notes past E5 longer than Bey (I think) , but I think that's due to having a naturally higher voice than Bey. I think they're pretty equal :)
LingLingRox 2 months ago
I love Kelly's resonance and she doesn't stress notes like she use to, but in this video she lacks versatility in the note when she hits it she does the same thing, Beyonce's has the ability to make her notes have different characteristics which adds to her versatile singing
STRATEKOOL15 2 months ago
@STRATEKOOL15 There was no d6 there ._. that was a c#6 and a bb5.. g#2 to c#6 .. still no d and e. Not held infact not even touched,probably an error in the video. Who cares I am moving on
Breniznit 2 months ago
STRATEKOOL15 2 months ago
Comment removed
STRATEKOOL15 2 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 What's more, I don't see Whitneys fans going around saying that she has notes in her range that are not actually in her range. Beyonce g#2 - c6, case closed.Kelly has a far bigger,far less restricted and way more comfortable head register then Beyonce could ever have.
Breniznit 3 months ago
@Breniznit g#2-d6
STRATEKOOL15 2 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 No I haven't and that is because Whitney cannot hit d6's just like your girl cannot hold d6's properly and requires autotuning.It's a fact that your girl has no control about c6,think what you want.You are clearly deluded, Do you even know what an exclamation is? Find me an example of Beyonce properly hitting and holding a d6 or e6 effortlessly with vibrato? You can't it does not exist, she has very little control in her head register.
Breniznit 3 months ago
what is ATRL? it's like xtina fans forum afterld or something?
kelvinpyaeko 3 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko It's an internet forum (message board) where fans of all pop artist go to meet and discuss amongst each other.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
Beyonce's vocals = way too much straining for aesthetics and human ears.
HabituallyObsessed 3 months ago 4
@HabituallyObsessed Beyonce isn't a strainer
STRATEKOOL15 2 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 I will be sure to report you to every youtube member I know. Including my friends, my combined subscribers (650) and release hell on you for making that thread on ATRl.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
What's ATRI?
lightningshock12 2 months ago
Stop using ECHOES AND AMPLIFIERS BEYONDSH(i)T! We wanna hear how you really sound like!
spidey678 3 months ago
Kelly's songwriting abilities >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BEYONDSH!TS Lying career.. And don't bring kelly's weight to this argument.. coz we all know that Adele slays all :D Without promo.. slaying beyondsh(i)t effortlessly.
spidey678 3 months ago
THE ONLY GOOD THING BEYONCE IS GOOD AT IS STEALING OTHER PEOPLE'S SONGS IDEAS, CREDITS, HARD EARNED WORK.. and the list goes on... PFFT LOL she can't even sell out 100k seats.. did you see that photoshopped booklet of her I Am Sasha Fierce World Tour? LOL.. so desperate to make it look like she sells out stadiums.. Poor beyonce.. she won't be a legend. coz nothing she does is special nor unique.
spidey678 3 months ago
And what the fk? Second Coming of Michael Jackson? Gurl, don't get me started. She's not even on Madonna's level yet. Beyonce doesn't work hard.. She just have a good marketing team. LMAO....
spidey678 3 months ago
Beyonce is such a try hard, buying all these awards for her.. Millenium Award? PFTTTTTTTTTTTT. HOW MUCH DID SHE BUY THAT FOR? 4 FLOPS SO HARD.. I should call it 4CLOSURE. LMAO.
spidey678 3 months ago
@spidey678 honey.. quit copying my posts on other videos..they might think that i'm you.. which is not.. coz your channel is full of hate on mariah.. sorry! im a lamb.. bitch! stop using kelly..
carshe209 3 months ago
KELLY WINS.. GURL BEYONCE IS A FAKE ASS BITCH WHO CANT EVEN SURVIVE A DECENT CONCERT WITHOUT INFECTING THE STAGE WITH HER BOOTY.. SHE SHAKES HER BOOTY AND SHE CALLS IT DANCING.. SHE CAN'T SING FOR HER LIFE.. SHE NEEDS AMPLIFIERS AND ECHOES TO MAKE HER SOUND MORE POWERFUL THAN SHE IS.
spidey678 3 months ago
dead at the atrl bee stans being pressed !!!
qizz619 3 months ago
@qizz619 This was posted on ATRL? LMAO. No wonder it skipped from 10 dislikes to 15.
PM what thread it's at!
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
Katy Perry's vocals slay these two irrelevant whores.
oguzhan979 3 months ago
Kisses to ATRL ;)
xluhcs 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 and funny how eevry stan of beyonce bash kelly's intonation calling it shitty.. keep in mind that kelly's genre is pop/rock the rise and fall of her voice and super controlled transitions is not necessary.. but it doesnt mean she can't!! coz there were songs like LIES, and her cover of ''I KNOW YOU WON'T'' has great projection, shifting and overall great intonation.. so the claims on her shitty intonation FAIL!
carshe209 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 I have watched roseland and i'm sorely disappointed that there was that much playback involved, I understand it was for DVD purposes somewhat but I wouldn't waste my money buying that. If i wanted to hear a bunch of playback I would just go listen to "4" Also her love on top performance at the VMA's is pre-recorded play.
hessounusual95 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 there were times, like 2 or 3 times or maybe 5 times in beyonce's entire career that she hold those notes, not so long.. while kelly from 2002-2011 hits and sustained those notes..almost every night on her concerts..yes some are strained.. but i can still count on my fingers how many times she strained.. and its understandable for someone who doesnt ever lip synch! and for someone without enough vocal rest.. and it wasnt sounded like gutiral screaming.. so its ok..
carshe209 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 yes beyonce has good e5's.. but kelly has great eB5-g#5, untouchable compare to any other singers of her generation a fact. that has proof.. she can easily access those notes.. vigorously, sustained and she can hit those notes numerous times in chest dominant way.. without getting to much thin.. or getting it in a very head driven way i.e. beyonce, leona, and on past 3 years kelly has improved her BB4-D5.. before beyonce can kill kelly in midbelts but now! SHE CAN'T!
carshe209 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 Ugh, most of Roseland is lipped... sorry. Not trying to be mean or anything but it's alot of playback.
hessounusual95 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 kelly's genre is pop rock, melisma is not necessary.. she's more of a upperbelter, grunts,growls and riffs..can easily access upper register without holding back and usually sustained! fyi, there was kelly's songs that has great melisma, BOY (acapella) up to the mountain, cleopatra, and studio version of hazel eyes.. and songs that she sang wth Tony Bennet.. beyonce has good melisma (her genre is more of rhytim and blues) if she hasnt have that then she's shittier than rihanna
carshe209 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 whole world knows that note was lipped, anyway lipped or not.. that g5 from bleachyonce seems like it was just a cough, sneeze coming from kelly.. and no beyonce's resonance relied on echo/reverb/delay machine and enhancements giving it layers of sound.. very breathy airy.. and its a well known fact that yonka's belts above eb5 was thin!! and talking about runs.. kelly can hold ANY NOTE.. from fifth octave.. while yonka just barely touches notes above e5..
carshe209 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 Ugh, it's a known fact that the sugamama was lipped and so was Billboard's Run The World performance, but then again. You're a very delusional stan. Btw, moron, stop calling a quality by the plural. there's no such thing as "melismas". Melisma is a quality of a belt, not an outmost technique. God, stop copying what others write and think it's right. "Her voice and belts are juice more resonant and warm in general" LMAO. Cooking class now huh?
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
just
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
just*
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
@BeyonceLuvr93 Beyonce's head voice is terrible, It needs autotuning after c6 if she attempts to hold it and by e6 is simply exclamations. I am sorry but she has no control at all.Where she hold a resonant d6 with full vibrato for at least 1 second and then an e6 then it can be considered part of her range but if she has all this control like you say she does then why can't she hold a high d or e? Please exclaim..oops i meant EXPLAIN*
Breniznit 3 months ago
@Breniznit Beyonce has held and sustained a D6 here: /watch?v=mTQj1LbcTLg minute 5:09
STRATEKOOL15 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
and then theres head voice, beys head voice, once again, is much more resonant and operatic which I love. Her transitioning from chest to head voice is flawless and all her range is just so well connected. Beyonce wins hands down. Being able to belt higher doesn't make you a better singer.
BeyonceLuvr93 3 months ago
Lower register: Beyonce
Mid Chest: tie
Upper Chest: Kelly
Head Voice: Beyonce, but then again Kelly seldoms uses it.
Beyonce takes the lower register and gives a good fight up to F#5. Anything above that is Kelly's domain (I give F5, AND F#5 to Kelly, even though these are Bey's money notes). Beyonce has the better head register...but I wish Kelly would use hers more (but her stylings do not call for it) Overall Kelly basically ran over Bey over in this video.
Cxxlmanproductions 3 months ago
btw kelly clarkson owned that ass lol just sayin :)
KellyFan4Lyfe08 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd well, i dont want to be the guy who pisses everyone off by over-voicing my opinions. so, i'm just gonna say they're both great artists, both have incredible voices, and I think at the end of the day, it all comes down to genre preference. If you're more into rock pop, its gonna be kelly, if ur more into urban, it's gonna be beyonce. BUT, I do wanna say that it was a great video and I enjoyed the quality of it! :)
jordangossman1 3 months ago
@carshe209 Well, my policy has always been the same. If you don't give a fair chance to both opponents, even yourself don't believe that your favorite can beat their opponent. So, it has been always my goal to show the best in show for everybody being compared. Besides, i'm fully confident of Kelly's abilities. I don't need to cheat to make my point. However, in the same sense that I can make these fair, I can also make them biased.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 lmfao, grammy means nothing.. nowadays the credibility was already fucked up how many grammy's has taylor swift and lady gaga has? ..mariah only had 5 in 2 DECADES.. yet shes the greatest singer on this planet! hahahaha.. not a fair match? oh god you have ineffcient ears..
carshe209 3 months ago
@carshe209 really? lmao. way to go off topic here haha. your comment is entirely irrelevant. i dont think this is a match where mariah carey is brought up, at all. and my ears are inefficient? hmm.... who is known more for their live performance? beyonce. serioiusly, get off your computer, stop trolling, walk outside, and see the fucking sunshine... you are entirely irrelevant. so therefor, nothing you bitch about matters. :)
jordangossman1 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 asshole.. youre so freakin idiot..whats the relevance of grammy's in this video anyway???? hahahahahahahahahaha!!!! yes beyonce is known for her live performance.. the rigorous dancing, lip synching, numerous slutty wardrobe change, back up dancers, head banging with her 2 kilos wigs.. and so-called singing.. using echo effects.. hahaha.. you mad???
carshe209 3 months ago
@carshe209 I'm sorry, but is it at all possible for you to construct a proper sentence? I don't understand your idiocracy, but I would like to be able to so I can respond accordingly. So go get your dictionary, and hey, I'm sure you can even get a teacher to help you formulate a grammatically correct sentence and then I'd be more than happy to come back and continue this "debate".... k?
jordangossman1 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 Can we stop mocking grammar when you're stanning for an artist? I highly doubt any of us really give a damn about it. Besides, you're fluent. He's not. I can understand that sentenc, so shall you. I advice you to find something else to mock.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd this whole thing has gone too far. I think Beyonce is better, you think Kelly is better. Cool, awesome. I'm done with this. I have a life to live, I dont live vicariously through youtube. All I did was state an opinion, and my opinion has not been swayed. I still love Kelly, she's amazing, but I prefer Beyonce to her because the genre of music. I advice people to stop jumping in on this, because any comments that come after this, will not be pleasant.
jordangossman1 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 N'awww, you think you're the only one that has a life. Nobody forced you to comment. What a retarded come back.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd Excuse me, first off, dont use the word "retarded" because thats hurtful to more people than you know. How old are u, 12? Life isn't about comebacks! Secondly, someone disagreed with you, oh no! :O BUILD A BRIDGE AND GET THE FUCK OVER IT! Yep, I've come to the conclusion that you are 12 years old. Hey you've got puberty to look forward to :) And if you aren't 12, then you have got some MAJOR growing up to do!
jordangossman1 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 you're terrible.. you are taking all these very personal.. you should have known the difference about virtual life and REAL life outside youtube.. just because you don't have any word against other people arguements.. then you have to argue with their grammar? too bad! english is not my language.. you just stated your opinion.. but you suck to defend your point and you just showed that you know nothing about this matter.. then your opinion is INVALID.. stay mad haha
carshe209 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 Honestly, all this just because I used the "R" word. Look, I wasn't even calling you retarded. My whole point is that your conclusion was very stupid and I stand by my statement.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@jordangossman1 . english is not my language.. not even my 2nd or third language.. lmfao.. just because you can't back up your arguement.. so you have to talk about grammar? hahahahaha....
carshe209 3 months ago
Why didn't you use Kelly's Whistle notes??
KCfan008 3 months ago
@KCfan008
bey has no whistle notes
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow well then its ovb who won then isn't it :)
KCfan008 3 months ago
oh yeah.
falsetto/HV register: G#5 - kellyC Bb5 - kellyC C#6 - kellyC
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
lower register: beyonce except F3
upper chest register: kellyC coz she her belts sound full/thick/resonant (apart from abusing the countless echo machines, her mic is also heavily EQ-ed and bey's F5 from 'speechless' is the perfect example of that) the 'RTW' note is a F5 btw.
falsetto/head voice register: G5 - tie A5 - beyonce(only coz of the heavily EQ-ed mic) C6 - tie
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Haha, Kelly doesn't use any effects. She's known to keep things VERY simple. Unless it's on TV shows, but even then it's to make sure we can actually hear her haha. Anyhoo, thank you so much for commenting :) And about the G5 from respect. Before I cam along, everybody usd it. I mean, every non kelly fanatic uses it. I get it, it's great but I just feel that there are a lot of G5 (literally thousands) to pick from haha. I like mixing it up. ;)
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd
i purposely didnt use the 'walk away'/'SUBG' G5 coz i thought THOSE WERE THE OVERUSED ONES LOL! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Haha, well. I personally don't like the Walk Away G5s because she hits them for quantity reasons which leave wishing for more. But, god. I've usd so many. When it comes to picking which G5 I like the most I just go with my mood haha. It's not like certain artists who only have like 5 of them. Kelly has thousands in hundreds of different songs. I went with sustainability and support for this video. Haha.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd
no wonder... anyway, my next video will be 'kelly clarkson VS michelle williams vocal battle'... :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Ask me any questions haha. If you need notes, go ahead :)
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow
and i agree with what you say about kellyC... she BARELY uses any effects/EQing of mics. bey stans say we are just talking abt the echo machines like HELL NO! in PA there's also such thing as increasing the bass/increasing the EQ. beyonce ABUSES the PA system to make her voice sound powerful when it is shrill/heavily-mixed... no one abuses the PA system like she does... FACT! echo machines are common but 4/5 of them? i dont think so...
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
Beyonce has a nice voice...great technique, too. But Kelly destroys her in natural talent.
mellynumerounoo 3 months ago 5
you know kellys F#5 in SUBG peaked To G5 :)
DreamloverLambi1 3 months ago
@DreamloverLambi1 are you sure? which one theres 2 subg F#5s the ellen show and then sunrise on this video
KellyFan4Lyfe08 3 months ago
@KellyFan4Lyfe08 the sunrise one it was brief but it did peak to G
DreamloverLambi1 3 months ago
@DreamloverLambi1 nvm I hear it now its on the Sunrise F#5 the sunstained and the very end she touches a G5 I didnt notice that before lol
KellyFan4Lyfe08 3 months ago
lol at people trying to discredit Beyonce's vocals. You do not have to degrade anyone in a battle.
Scanned 3 months ago
I love both of them!!!! ^^
hyday94 3 months ago
@hyday94 Thanks for commenting :) They're both very talented.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
KELLY!
jonmid2010 3 months ago
@jonmid2010 Thank for commenting :)
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
kelly slays. beyonce's melisma is just too much and overwraught
Fkdls 3 months ago
Kelly Clarkson by far.
olhole 3 months ago
Kelly >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Beyonce
yaoianimefan3 3 months ago 12
@carshe209 Beyonce's belts B4 - F5 have much better quality, resonance and power then Kelly's shouted notes, thats a fact. Kelly's lower register is non existent, Beyonce's SLAYS her, this video dosent even began to capture the ease she has down there. Bey's head voice is also a lot more resonant and comes with much more ease. I mean, Kelly has only done like three sustained head voice notes in her whole career, LOL. Stay pressed over the queen, no one checking for Kelly.
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 No, they do not.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 Besides, I only blocked one who kept repeating that I was pathetic and delusional when I never even interacted with him/her. I'm sorry, I'm going to keep drama to a minimum. At least have some respect. The ones that were blocked previous to this video, if read the description I said I'd unblock them if they contact me with another account. Calling one, several. Fuck you Kenny.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 kelly's belts in this video doesnt have certain loudness and intensity to be called shout.. if theres a shouter here its yonka..resonant than kelly?.. beyonka's resonance relied on reverb,echo,and delay enhancements.. i can give her c#5, puhlease.. kelly's full bodied, sustained.. and agile belts.. vs beyonce's pathetic little breathy, airy, convulsioning wavy vibrato belting? beyonce head voice? her c#6 and a5.. are pretty good.. her c6 is nothing but overly connected NOISE
carshe209 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 beyonce queen? like whtney and mariah? haha those are real queens.. dont ever start arguement about RESONANCE, coz im a fan of mariah, whitney, aretha.. and i know what is resonance.. unfortunately yonka's relied her resonance on enhancements.. echo will always gave certain amount of volume and layers in any sound, stay mad.. you cant get it twisted.. in any form kelly will demolish yonka's limited vocals.. deal with it!!!
carshe209 3 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko ? lol
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 oh i just love the way u comment ;)
kelvinpyaeko 3 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Well I gotta speak up and keep it real lmao, several Beyonce fans have been blocked from commenting, including me like 2 weeks ago.
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 Several? I'm sorry. I'm not letting any user who insulted me personally post on my videos. It's simply ridiculous.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd Are you telling me BZBlaner is the ONLY Beyonce fan you've EVER blocked? I hardly believe that, and you've actually talked about others you have blocked before lol.
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 I only block people when they offend me instead of attacking the integrity of the vocals. From this video I only blocked one, for the reason stated above. I believe it's very disrespectful to attack the video maker in such ways especially when it's out of the blue. If they are blocked it was for a reason. Furthermore, when did I ever state that Bzblaner was the only user I ever blocked. You're putting words in my comments. Oh, and don't get me started why I blocked you.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd I never said users in general, I said BEYONCE FANS lol. Also, the person you're referring too didn't attack you personally. They attacked some of you're crazy beliefs about vocals including Kelly's 'screams' as part of her range. A personal attack would be exposing their personal info and calling them rude names, does that sound familiar? Oh and I was blocked for saying Kelly didn't belt the C6 lmao.
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 And how would you know this? Do you have the exact quote? Thanks for disliking the video hun.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 Crazy beliefs? I'd love to hear the concept behind that statement. Beyonce fans like to attack Kelly in general. It wouldn't surprise me if I blocked them over the whole C6 thing. Which, I'm giving them a chance to be unblocked. I love how you are stirring the pot as much as possible. Acting like I'm doing anything evil. If they are blocked, it wouldn't be because of THIS particular video. Furthermore, do you have the exact quote? How do you know what actually happened?
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 Furthermore, coming from the person who a year ago, in our first interaction said he was going to "get my billions youtube friends to dislike this. Toddles" on a video which took a month to complete earlier in the year, just because I disagreed with his views (after I helped him get a note btw). Hypocrisy comes nothing close to what you're doing now.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd The crazy beliefs are the fact that you think random squeals, grunts and screams are a part of someones singing range lmao. Anyways, the exact quote? what are you talking about lol.. you've made it quite clear of 'the group' of people you hate, which several, happen to be Beyonce fans. Also, about the dislike thing that was because I disagreed with you on including screams in Kelly's range (which many other people believed) and you weren't having it.
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 I completely disagree, I composed in several replies that a lot of those were simply included to fill in gaps and not to bee taken seriously. Not to mention that thos screams were filled under exclamations to begin with, and that, in the vido itslf. I didn't consider any of them as actually being whistles and head voice tones. You were just blind with rage that I went against your uneducated opinion. Furthermore, I did ancknowledge however that a lot could be considered.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 You also made it quite clear that in your eyes Kelly is no better than a lot of singers today. You undermind her like nothing else. In relation to the quote, I'm asking what you heard from the beyonce fan that got blocked because of this videeo. He called me pathetic, delusional and that i was crazy for thinking that Kelly was better than Beyonce. I have a right to my own opinion and to keep away time wasters from my videos.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@kellyclarksonismygd (cont) So you decided to attack me personally, calling me clueless and ignorant. AFTER, I even said I really enjoyed the video and was being nice to you, I just didn't agree with the screams. You can't really compare that, with what you did with BZBlaner. Also, this was just ONE video.. you ended up puting a ton of dislikes every single video I uploaded.
MimiDahhling30 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 I did not attack you personally. Last time I checked, I said you were being a hater, nothing else. And when you actually handed that completely disgusting threat I actually stated that I simply make videos. Which is what this should be about. Not crazy fan wars. Can you tell which note is which without asking others, viewing in other videos or using tuners?
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 Continuation: I had no other choice. You were the one who played dirty to begin with. As a matter of fact, my following videos which when I uploaded got dislikes almost instantly. I can only assume it was either from you or your followers. And as I recall I did not dislike your videos right away. It was after I got 18 dislikes in that single video and 5 additional to several of mine.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 That's when I could not stand for it anymore, and quit being the grown up and asked a few friends to do exactly what you did to me.
kellyclarksonismygd 3 months ago