The Correct way of Saying Tashahhud - Shaykh Dr. Bilal Philips

[ByChoiceMuslim]

@DanishRiyaz So all the Muslims "Kaafir" part from few because if somebody die doing Shirk we are supposed to assume he died as a disbeliever and live it to God to judge. This can be easily refuted but all I am doing is trying to make you think.

[mrdax004]

so is he saying the imams did shirk?

[DanishRiyaz]

@mrdax004 No, but when a person is convinced after showing him/her the proof, then the sin is written on his/her account. Hadeeth compilation started after them...

[mrdax004]

@DanishRiyaz i understand but please explain when Abdullah ibn Masood mentioned what bilal philips is saying then why did he not teach it to his students? Imam abu hanifah was taught by those who where taught by this great sahaba and others.

[DanishRiyaz]

@mrdax004 Prophet (sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam) taught this tashah-hud to the sahaabah and then in his relation Sahaabah understood that instead of "Alayka..." they used to say when he was alive but after his death they said "Alann...". So this is not in contradiction with what Prophet said but this is the 'ijmaa' of the Sahaabah and 'ijmaa' is one of the source of Islaam.

[ByChoiceMuslim]

@DanishRiyaz So till then All the Muslims are Non-Muslim but not "Kaafir" because they are doing shirk unknowingly. Wow that's a massive claim because that is all of them part from Shaikh Albani and few others who follow that opinion. What about the Sahabas who were living in different city during the time of the Prophet and still saying "Peace be upon you O prophet" in the prayer although the Prophet was not there.

[DanishRiyaz]

@ByChoiceMuslim You don't worry about those people whom the message didn't reach, worry about your Islaam, this is not just about Imaam Al-albaanee ('alayhi rahmah) but this was the ijmaa' among the sahaabah according to this hadeeth.

[ByChoiceMuslim]

Bidah

[DanishRiyaz]

@ByChoiceMuslim : What is Bid'ah?

[MaR2307]

@DanishRiyaz Innovation

[DanishRiyaz]

@MaR2307 : What is bid'ah in this video?

[MaR2307]

I am confused. What is he saying to say in Tashahud for Salah?

[DanishRiyaz]

@MaR2307 : Read video detail and listen to shaykh keenly.