very cool... i was at that show. i remember that song and, right where the tape ends, he looked right at my friends and i, shouting and waving... i'm somewhat touched and amazed by this. first time i've seen it.
thanks so much for sharing this unique piece of music with the rest of the world! it's people like you that make sharing and youtube so great! thanks again!
Wow this video footage looks very good. The sound is not soundboard quality? The Beatles and Pauls solo material was damn good. John did pretty good with his solo band as well. I prefer Pauls stuff with Wings.
Oddly, this was the first time i heard this song was from "Wings Over America", then i heard The Beatles version. For some reason, it just seems to me this song works better as a Wings song than a Beatles song. I know that opinion isnt too popular.
@DerekBayRoberts1 , no you're absolutely correct on that one. I was thinking the same thing. This performance arrangement sounds more like the song should be rather than the Beatles single, which is allright. This recording has horrible audio for some reason, but its the right sound
Another Beatles' Song he should've done at that concert would be "Got To Get You Into My Life", because it wouldv'e sounded perfect with Howie Casey's horn section he had at the time.
Hey, thanks for posting. One correction, though, it's in St. Paul, not Minneapolis. I should know - - I was there! St. Paul Civic Center, June 4, 1976. I was 11 years old!
His voice seems different. But I'm definitley not one of those idiotic people saying it's Billy Shears. Puh, Paul is the only one that6 could pull this off!!! Wait, nevermind. The other beatles can sing this, too!!!
No way! :). Paul had many different singing voices... it's something I'm quite amazed by.
Here is what Paul said about Lady Madonna:
"Lady Madonna was me sitting down at the piano trying to write a bluesy boogie-woogie thing ... It reminded me of Fats Domino for some reason, so I started singing a Fats Domino impression. It took my voice to a very odd place"
he didn't transpose it up, that's just how the the recording comes out sometimes. I watched him do jet from this exact concert and I watched the same thing from a different video. it was different keys.
i wish paul would use the same ending to lady madonna as he did on this clip and the '76 tour...that little end bit ...he has shortened it so if you read this paul please consider...thanks
Paul McCartney has never played Minneapolis. This was from the Saint Paul Civic Center in '76. Even as a Beatle his concert was in Bloomington, MN not Minneapolis.
nobodyabcd12345 you are a complete ass. This is 16MM footage shot with a Super8 camera in the photographer's pit. The guy had access to the pit when he shot this. There is nothing fake, this is the raw footage.
there have been home movie cameras scince like the 20s man, its good sound it actually looks like you tapes it off a tv screen and did your own zoomin to make it look real, and from the sounds of it, sped it up alittle
Plenty of people do that... What the hell do you mean it's not plausable?! Look at his face during the performance. When he blinks, it's not "rapid-fire"... THAT is how I know this isn't sped up...
look at it like this, this is nearly 10 years after the recording of lady madonna, why would he go up in key, rather than stay in "A" or even go down a key or two depending on how time has effected the mans voice, and why when he plays the song now days, its in the original "A" key
You have no clue about singing voices. Paul's tenor voice is in his prime here. The tenor voice doesn't fully mature until the late 20's/early 30's. Read a book.
why go up for one year of touring, just to bring it back down, now if the internet and a paul mccartney video is gonna make you fire back another ignorant comment, i would like to hear it, if anything just for a laugh lol
ok one more thing, i cant even see him blink once, and if his eyes where doing this "rapid fire" as you say, he'd sound like a frickin chip munk, not one or two keys higher, also if you would listen a bit more cloesly you can hear the sound skip ahead fragments of a second, like little bits are cut out, so maybe this was done on some sort of home movie camera, but the song being played in a higher up key, may or may not be the case
Listen- how about this... It's 1976... P.A.s (the vocal "amplifiers") were not as advanced. It's hard to hear yourself when you are singing in a low key with a band of 6 or more people. It's easier to hear yourself in a higher key, therefore singing out of key is sure not to happen. Perhaps he raised the key that way he could stay in key? Also, listen to him introduce the song- his voice is deep. And he DOESN'T sound like a chipmunk at all through-out the whole song...
to be honest, i really dont even care anymore, and changing the key by 1 or 2 definatley aint gonna make much difference hearing yourself through the PA, as i am someone who often uses a PA in performance, but honestly, who cares what key its in or how it was filmed, McCartney is a great musician, and the video is cool either way, so ROCK ON
I prefer it in this key. Most of the songs in Wings Over America are in a different key. I don't know if that's intentional or because of the recording.
I've noticed a lot of the footage from the 76 tour seems speeded up. Try listening to the video for Maybe I'm Amazed here on Youtube. It was released as a single in 77 and sounds much higher and faster than the record released in 77.
very cool... i was at that show. i remember that song and, right where the tape ends, he looked right at my friends and i, shouting and waving... i'm somewhat touched and amazed by this. first time i've seen it.
317gregory 1 month ago in playlist 1 wings live
Paul plays this way fast like he's some maniacal barrelhouse piano player in an old black and white movie ..........
vampyros1 6 months ago
Paul doesn't need good sound quality on videos of him, his awesomeness stil shines trough.
OropherThranduil 1 year ago
thanks so much for sharing this unique piece of music with the rest of the world! it's people like you that make sharing and youtube so great! thanks again!
julianomnunes 1 year ago
WHAT A BAMF!!!!!!
gobamarama2008 1 year ago
Wow this video footage looks very good. The sound is not soundboard quality? The Beatles and Pauls solo material was damn good. John did pretty good with his solo band as well. I prefer Pauls stuff with Wings.
PearlJammer07 1 year ago
Oddly, this was the first time i heard this song was from "Wings Over America", then i heard The Beatles version. For some reason, it just seems to me this song works better as a Wings song than a Beatles song. I know that opinion isnt too popular.
DerekBayRoberts1 1 year ago
@DerekBayRoberts1 , no you're absolutely correct on that one. I was thinking the same thing. This performance arrangement sounds more like the song should be rather than the Beatles single, which is allright. This recording has horrible audio for some reason, but its the right sound
coffeecat73 6 months ago
paul is paul, and that's all.
ronedor 1 year ago
The mullet's gotta go but otherwise it's always great to see Paul!
emilieunlimited 1 year ago
it looks like he is pressing random keys and yet a great sound comes out!
starwarsfreak1111 1 year ago
This is from a super 8mm film??? Whoever filmed this did a beautiful job! The camera is almost as steady as a professional setup.
jaywhofan 2 years ago 2
this is better than great ! it's Magic...
bjoybeads 2 years ago
Another Beatles' Song he should've done at that concert would be "Got To Get You Into My Life", because it wouldv'e sounded perfect with Howie Casey's horn section he had at the time.
DerekBayRoberts1 2 years ago
Hey, thanks for posting. One correction, though, it's in St. Paul, not Minneapolis. I should know - - I was there! St. Paul Civic Center, June 4, 1976. I was 11 years old!
BoBo0807 2 years ago 2
I know your comment is 6 months old but I just had to say this: YOU ARE ONE LUCKY BASTARD!!!!
starwarsfreak1111 1 year ago
20M of awesome.
thanks for posting this :)
lloyd525 2 years ago 2
what year?
LesPaulDude999 2 years ago
his voice is so Awesome ! at 1:23 when he screams - why is that so hot ?!
bjoybeads 2 years ago
oh my gosh i know!
duranfan00 2 years ago
this is not on the dvd
poussyledzep 2 years ago
holy mother of god nice vid
thanks 4 sharing it
Frenchforever2009 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
TERRIBLE RECORDING.WHY EVEN POST IT?
marcmgm 2 years ago
Oh, please - We need this video back , it's awesome ! I want to see it , please !
bjoybeads 2 years ago
His voice seems different. But I'm definitley not one of those idiotic people saying it's Billy Shears. Puh, Paul is the only one that6 could pull this off!!! Wait, nevermind. The other beatles can sing this, too!!!
MollieMangoMadness 3 years ago
He makes his voice different for this song. Listen to the original.
rule914 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I thought George Harrison is singing in this song...
halferuga 3 years ago
No way! :). Paul had many different singing voices... it's something I'm quite amazed by.
Here is what Paul said about Lady Madonna:
"Lady Madonna was me sitting down at the piano trying to write a bluesy boogie-woogie thing ... It reminded me of Fats Domino for some reason, so I started singing a Fats Domino impression. It took my voice to a very odd place"
rule914 3 years ago 3
No is not harrison, it's Ringo, I'm sure its all in one key.
musicthumbs 3 years ago
I read that Paul sang this song
halferuga 3 years ago
dayummm that piano! Wow... how do you play that well?? This is Paul McCartney... what can't he do? :)
Luv you!
abbyjewels315 3 years ago
Paul is such a ham. I love that man so much. I hope I'm lucky enough to cross paths with him some day.
blackspace007 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hey Paul... because of you I did not drink and drive. I threw my car keys off a cliff in to the Atlantic Ocean.
Expect a lawsuit soon to replace car.
You bastard!
keylargo333 3 years ago
Hey, why is it Paul's fault you don't have a car? YOU threw your keys off a cliff.
freakchic9 3 years ago
Hey Paul, if you read these comments you are as lonely as me. I love you man!
keylargo333 3 years ago 11
paul is ma g
crazyskater147 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow, stupid billy shears is havin fun bein paul mccartney huh? can't believe u guys believe this is paul mccartney...idiots.
Sappyspartan 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow, probably the best comment i ever read. its so meaningful. the best. very intellectual. very courteous.
alsan 3 years ago
wow i'm pretty sure ringo was billy shears but i guess sgt pepper lied
Xer086 3 years ago 3
Yea. Tested on piano, thats not A Major, its A# Major.. or Bb Major.
nicomeier333 3 years ago
he didn't transpose it up, that's just how the the recording comes out sometimes. I watched him do jet from this exact concert and I watched the same thing from a different video. it was different keys.
darkhorse46 4 years ago
i wish paul would use the same ending to lady madonna as he did on this clip and the '76 tour...that little end bit ...he has shortened it so if you read this paul please consider...thanks
MutantLarva 4 years ago
greatest rock voice ever
abbeyroad88 4 years ago 3
I didn't expect such a good quality. Audio's a bit shaky but overall very enjoyable.
spinalcrackerbox 4 years ago
As good as it gets, right there.
Any Questions?
vwtch 4 years ago
couldnt agree more :]]
boycrazie111 4 years ago
I love PAUL MCCARTNEY !!!!! He´s playing in a different key right ?
GRM07 4 years ago
Oh, definitely. Sounds like he transposed it one step up. Still, great performance, 'cause it's Wings. Joe's drumming made the song that much better.
karencarpenterfan 4 years ago
Any word on whether Paul will issue Wings Over America on DVD?
tikmol 4 years ago
There are some bits and pieces of Rockshow on the McCartney Years DVD no comment on the full version.
PaulMcCartneyFan 4 years ago
COOL!!
beatlesuploader8000 4 years ago
Business in the front...party in the back! LOL
GooglelyTube 4 years ago
Love this video. I know someone who was there.
beatle608 4 years ago
How did you digitize your 8mm tapes?
karencarpenterfan 4 years ago
i have one too how?
RiccardoDistefano55 4 years ago
awesome footage!
FreakyOrthopedic 4 years ago
I was there..front row..june 4th 1976..st paul civic center!
scornyman 4 years ago
whats happened to all the clips from the wings over america tour?
aj4als 4 years ago
Paul McCartney has never played Minneapolis. This was from the Saint Paul Civic Center in '76. Even as a Beatle his concert was in Bloomington, MN not Minneapolis.
turfclub9 4 years ago
Actually, he played the Metrodome once. Sometime in the 90s.
BoBo0807 2 years ago
Michael Jackson owns Lady Madonna : )
cut1ie 4 years ago
not anymore, MJ is broke, he certainly doesn't have his talent, and forever she is his
Stirphil 4 years ago
Wrong. MJ will lose the Beatles catalog in May 2008 if he can't pay his bills. As of now...he still owns Lady Madonna.
cut1ie 4 years ago
you're quite right, but, with all due respect to MJ, cos he used to be someone i liked, what are the chances...?
Stirphil 4 years ago
zip.
cut1ie 4 years ago
Paul OWNS Lady Madonna. But then he's SIR Paul. Performance makes up for lack of audio.
JackAwful 4 years ago
If anybody wants to download this -- the whole film is now on Traders Den and Dime..
rockvideos 5 years ago
nobodyabcd12345 you are a complete ass. This is 16MM footage shot with a Super8 camera in the photographer's pit. The guy had access to the pit when he shot this. There is nothing fake, this is the raw footage.
Belexes 5 years ago
What venue was Paul playing in? Could this be from the St. Paul Civic Center? Or was it a venue in Minneapolis?
mjanovec 5 years ago
there have been home movie cameras scince like the 20s man, its good sound it actually looks like you tapes it off a tv screen and did your own zoomin to make it look real, and from the sounds of it, sped it up alittle
nobodyabcd12345 5 years ago
Uh... It's in a different key...
Codackussell 5 years ago
right but why would he re learn the song in a new key, its not plausable
nobodyabcd12345 5 years ago
Plenty of people do that... What the hell do you mean it's not plausable?! Look at his face during the performance. When he blinks, it's not "rapid-fire"... THAT is how I know this isn't sped up...
Codackussell 5 years ago
look at it like this, this is nearly 10 years after the recording of lady madonna, why would he go up in key, rather than stay in "A" or even go down a key or two depending on how time has effected the mans voice, and why when he plays the song now days, its in the original "A" key
nobodyabcd12345 5 years ago
You have no clue about singing voices. Paul's tenor voice is in his prime here. The tenor voice doesn't fully mature until the late 20's/early 30's. Read a book.
LonelyRoad1 5 years ago
why go up for one year of touring, just to bring it back down, now if the internet and a paul mccartney video is gonna make you fire back another ignorant comment, i would like to hear it, if anything just for a laugh lol
nobodyabcd12345 5 years ago
ok one more thing, i cant even see him blink once, and if his eyes where doing this "rapid fire" as you say, he'd sound like a frickin chip munk, not one or two keys higher, also if you would listen a bit more cloesly you can hear the sound skip ahead fragments of a second, like little bits are cut out, so maybe this was done on some sort of home movie camera, but the song being played in a higher up key, may or may not be the case
nobodyabcd12345 5 years ago
Listen- how about this... It's 1976... P.A.s (the vocal "amplifiers") were not as advanced. It's hard to hear yourself when you are singing in a low key with a band of 6 or more people. It's easier to hear yourself in a higher key, therefore singing out of key is sure not to happen. Perhaps he raised the key that way he could stay in key? Also, listen to him introduce the song- his voice is deep. And he DOESN'T sound like a chipmunk at all through-out the whole song...
Codackussell 5 years ago
to be honest, i really dont even care anymore, and changing the key by 1 or 2 definatley aint gonna make much difference hearing yourself through the PA, as i am someone who often uses a PA in performance, but honestly, who cares what key its in or how it was filmed, McCartney is a great musician, and the video is cool either way, so ROCK ON
nobodyabcd12345 5 years ago
If it makes any difference- I also use PAs in performance! But you are right- Paul rocks! And so does this song...
Codackussell 5 years ago
I prefer it in this key. Most of the songs in Wings Over America are in a different key. I don't know if that's intentional or because of the recording.
theunusualbreed 5 years ago
I've noticed a lot of the footage from the 76 tour seems speeded up. Try listening to the video for Maybe I'm Amazed here on Youtube. It was released as a single in 77 and sounds much higher and faster than the record released in 77.
JimR541 5 years ago
thats super 8mm sound film folks - there was no such thing as home video cameras in 1976!
MoontideJM 5 years ago
what exactly do you think is a fake? its a video of paul mccartney...
emirenfield 5 years ago
cheap fake!
juancabeatles 5 years ago
how do you know? it might not be.
bri92 5 years ago
cool
06coxk 5 years ago
stfu paul is campable of doing the unthinkable
streetrider1993 5 years ago
very cool!
roadcommander132 5 years ago
Nice
midithebeatles 5 years ago