Ok, I didn't think that was bad. You have a nice voice. But I don't know how that 'music expert' can say you hit the notes better than Amy did though, not to say you didn't hit them well, because you did. But Amy is the one who sang the song, and I'm quite sure the 'expert' has no idea of how high Amy intended to go. That has really annoyed me. I think she should watch 'Weight of the World' or 'Whisper' live before she criticises Amy's four-octave vocal range, saying she can't go that high.
OMG OMG OMG! This is the best cover of this song I have ever heard. One of my all time FAVORITES from Evanescence and you totally nailed it. *puts into favorites*
You have a sweet voice! This sounded so awesome! I can sing, but Amy's music is too hard for me to get the notes right. lol, I'm better at songs by guys. Perhaps we could sing together some time? ;p I just need recording stuff. But GREAT JOB. :D
im kinda a music expert also, and I think she was in tune execpt some of the low parts, but she hits the high notes better than amy herself!!! amy's more of an alto, and mellisa's and soprano, definatly... so if u attept a song with lots of low notes, ur fans still love u mellisa!!! we give u kudos for trying, so people who pick of peoples weaknesses and not their strengths are weak and bullies!!! great job mellisa, (again!!)
don't work with low notes; and when you sing the chorus...be a bit more powerful, and sing it out loud...not 'almost' under your breath. and try working on your vibratto. then it'll be awesome...but it's good :]
You're a good singer. Honestly, I don't think this was your best. It's just the low parts, like you said, sounded off. You did alot better with the other songs. Also, some of the words sounded like you weren't exactly sure what to say. I'm not trying to be mean. Whoever said you were off key was wrong. The only time you were off key was when it went too low for you. The rest of the song was good. For a music expert, they sure don't know much.
You people need to get lives. Seriously. If you're such a 'music expert', why the HELL are you saying Melissa is butchering Amy's songs?! If anything, she's making people appreciate them more. I suggest you shut your goddamn traps and stop bullying people you don't know. Awesome work, Melissa, as always!
You know what..the stupid girls that come on here and post mean things need to seriously get a life! I think you did okay. It wasn't like totally bad...
HuskyRae Rae and PyroTink need to shut the hell up cuz ur voice is great, and they're just jeleous cuz they're both gay and molest eachother, so they need to shut the fuck up and u need to keep singing:)
Now, it's not her fault. My ex-best friend had(still has)the same problem(her voice problem had nothing to do with us not being friends anymore, she a spoiled brat and a total bitch who wants everything to go her way otherwise she just leaves so she won't have to deal with it). Voice lessons did absolutely nothing to help, because that's a serious problem. It's not her or the way she sings the song. It's her voice. It's naturally off key and annoying. That's not something that can be fixed.
Also, I'm not saying that she should stop singing. If she likes singing, she should keep with it (and if anyone tries to make her stop they should get stabbed), I'm just asking that she stop publicly butchering Evanescence songs. PUBLICALLY. It's okay if she sings them in the privacy of her own home or community. Just not online. Please.
*cough* Just because I'm bi-sexual doesn't mean I would molest Rae, I'd molest her for the hell of it *cough* and I know more then any of you about music besides Racha-chan(Rae) and that guy treeoak who agrees with us and Stepha-chan who awlays gets into the school play and vocal choirs when she tries out and there extremely hard to get into. SO please stop singing on here or I will come to your house and try to molest you because i'm good like that dear.
Hi Ame-chan(Ameko)! She really is good at that y'know. Connections too. She will find you, and I'll help. Muhahaha. and it's not molesting if I'm okay with it. So it's not molesting. Muhahahaha...
you suck. I'm PyroTink's freind, the music expert. you are way off key and it's really annoying. Stop putting Evanescence songs on You Tube. No one with ears or a brain wants to hear. Voice lessons can't help the problem you have.
Your pretty good at singing. Are you in a band or something cause if you are what is it called. Well you don't have to answer that if you don't want to.
You butchered it deary. HOW DO YOU DO THAT??! Well I can because i'm not a singer but my friend is an awesome piano player/guitar/clarinet/anything really. we both agree your singing is annoying and I don't get how your an awesome singer or how people you think you sing like amy lee because news flash you don't! Yeah i had to turn of the song about a few second after i listened to you, now that is bad. *gives a weird smile*
Aww thank you so much! You know, with spreading my videos around to your friends. You always come back to see my new videos even though you "hate" my voice. I consider you one of my biggest fans!
Your voice is not bad, but you need much more experience. Low notes sounds not right and here and there seems like you are in a hurry.
BreathOfWords 3 weeks ago
Omg! You just made me listen to this song without music! No one does that! Your so good!! Omg new amy lee? O.o
lebanese996 1 month ago
Ok, I didn't think that was bad. You have a nice voice. But I don't know how that 'music expert' can say you hit the notes better than Amy did though, not to say you didn't hit them well, because you did. But Amy is the one who sang the song, and I'm quite sure the 'expert' has no idea of how high Amy intended to go. That has really annoyed me. I think she should watch 'Weight of the World' or 'Whisper' live before she criticises Amy's four-octave vocal range, saying she can't go that high.
funkyfranx 1 month ago
Holy!! You're insanely good!!!!!
THEPrettiestLiar 7 months ago
your voice is so damn beautifull..
girl15alittlecrazy 4 years ago 4
OMG OMG OMG! This is the best cover of this song I have ever heard. One of my all time FAVORITES from Evanescence and you totally nailed it. *puts into favorites*
LycanHeritage 4 years ago 4
girl, your voice is amazing, but you have to learn to sing in your "chest voice"
sorry for my english =O
HadaMenhir 4 years ago
ur voicee is soOOo fucking perfect ♥
lamOtza 4 years ago
sounds like you had a cold when you recorded this ...
xXxRedxQueenxXx 4 years ago
actually she's not carrying her voice high enough - diaphram thats when it gets hard but this voice would so own amy lees xD
Celestialtears006 4 years ago
Good job... but it's difficult for you hit the low notes...
Musicfreak80 4 years ago
wow,awesome voice although i think some of the notes are a bit off but thats ok too!
devilofevanescence 4 years ago
Wonderful. My favorite song and you sung it beautifully.
BrokenHikari 4 years ago
DANG
You're really good...
This goes on my favorites :)
MelancholyOblivion 5 years ago
Yeah I figured that she was saying something, but was too lazy to upload it again. Too low of a song for me to sing again haha.
Inusgirl05 5 years ago
You have a very nice voice :)
PixieStorm 5 years ago
Most notes are good but there are some that are off. With a little more practice you could really make it probably =D
xEmptyParadisex 5 years ago
DAMN GIRL NICE VOICE!
lilqtlexi92 5 years ago
excellent!!!!
Odice 5 years ago
You have a sweet voice! This sounded so awesome! I can sing, but Amy's music is too hard for me to get the notes right. lol, I'm better at songs by guys. Perhaps we could sing together some time? ;p I just need recording stuff. But GREAT JOB. :D
Yuriko713 5 years ago
Wow
npope 5 years ago
clap clap clap :)
anime1245x 5 years ago
you werent given the curse of being tone deaf :) unlike me, lol... i can't do a cappella. good job. me likies...
lucidiquedreams 5 years ago
im kinda a music expert also, and I think she was in tune execpt some of the low parts, but she hits the high notes better than amy herself!!! amy's more of an alto, and mellisa's and soprano, definatly... so if u attept a song with lots of low notes, ur fans still love u mellisa!!! we give u kudos for trying, so people who pick of peoples weaknesses and not their strengths are weak and bullies!!! great job mellisa, (again!!)
tiffany02020 5 years ago
Thank you! I need to start recording stuff again...
Inusgirl05 5 years ago
this is my favorite evanescence song. u sound just like amy
punkrockpixie42 5 years ago
ur voice is pretty dang awesome. *nods*
darknesstakesoveru 5 years ago
^.^ OMG! You have an AMAZING voice... I want it! lol
Keep it up ;)
I also love the way you used the overlay btw, very nice idea xxx
LycanHeritage 5 years ago
VERY COOL
you sing really good damn
Vertpill 5 years ago
don't work with low notes; and when you sing the chorus...be a bit more powerful, and sing it out loud...not 'almost' under your breath. and try working on your vibratto. then it'll be awesome...but it's good :]
sacredtome 5 years ago
you got really good towards the middle :D
LostInWonderland 5 years ago
You're a good singer. Honestly, I don't think this was your best. It's just the low parts, like you said, sounded off. You did alot better with the other songs. Also, some of the words sounded like you weren't exactly sure what to say. I'm not trying to be mean. Whoever said you were off key was wrong. The only time you were off key was when it went too low for you. The rest of the song was good. For a music expert, they sure don't know much.
FullMoonLust 5 years ago
You people need to get lives. Seriously. If you're such a 'music expert', why the HELL are you saying Melissa is butchering Amy's songs?! If anything, she's making people appreciate them more. I suggest you shut your goddamn traps and stop bullying people you don't know. Awesome work, Melissa, as always!
scarletheartedliones 5 years ago
Why did you post a comment on other people's comments without replying to the people in particular? Just curious.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
I agree! I've been training for years and you're still better than me!
Zelthie 5 years ago
You know what..the stupid girls that come on here and post mean things need to seriously get a life! I think you did okay. It wasn't like totally bad...
SexyPinkBunny69 5 years ago
that was great keep up the good work
ralucard 5 years ago
HuskyRae Rae and PyroTink need to shut the hell up cuz ur voice is great, and they're just jeleous cuz they're both gay and molest eachother, so they need to shut the fuck up and u need to keep singing:)
blossomel91 5 years ago
Haha! Thank you! I won't listen to them.
Inusgirl05 5 years ago
You, shut the fuck up. Obviously, you have no ears or a brain; otherwise you'd have the common sense to know that her voice sucks.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
Now, it's not her fault. My ex-best friend had(still has)the same problem(her voice problem had nothing to do with us not being friends anymore, she a spoiled brat and a total bitch who wants everything to go her way otherwise she just leaves so she won't have to deal with it). Voice lessons did absolutely nothing to help, because that's a serious problem. It's not her or the way she sings the song. It's her voice. It's naturally off key and annoying. That's not something that can be fixed.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
Also, I'm not saying that she should stop singing. If she likes singing, she should keep with it (and if anyone tries to make her stop they should get stabbed), I'm just asking that she stop publicly butchering Evanescence songs. PUBLICALLY. It's okay if she sings them in the privacy of her own home or community. Just not online. Please.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
*cough* Just because I'm bi-sexual doesn't mean I would molest Rae, I'd molest her for the hell of it *cough* and I know more then any of you about music besides Racha-chan(Rae) and that guy treeoak who agrees with us and Stepha-chan who awlays gets into the school play and vocal choirs when she tries out and there extremely hard to get into. SO please stop singing on here or I will come to your house and try to molest you because i'm good like that dear.
TrinityOfTyranny 5 years ago
Hi Ame-chan(Ameko)! She really is good at that y'know. Connections too. She will find you, and I'll help. Muhahaha. and it's not molesting if I'm okay with it. So it's not molesting. Muhahahaha...
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
lol i agree
tennantfan248 5 years ago
you suck. I'm PyroTink's freind, the music expert. you are way off key and it's really annoying. Stop putting Evanescence songs on You Tube. No one with ears or a brain wants to hear. Voice lessons can't help the problem you have.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
Well stop listening 2 it u sore loser. Her voice is simply amazing. Wondrous. Your suffering from envy. Keep Singing Melissa! Your the bomb!
dreameronherknees 5 years ago
I only listened to it once. I envy no one. I wouldn't care if I was the worst singer in the world. Really.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
Assuming ofcourse you can do a better job.
Which I can bet my bottom dollar you can't.
dreameronherknees 5 years ago
Can I have it?
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
I'm broke. Even though I'm not.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
Is that meant 2 make sense? I'm broke...even though i'm not? Whatev.
dreameronherknees 5 years ago
It's not meant to make sense. You should just ignore me, even I don't know what that means.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
Your pretty good at singing. Are you in a band or something cause if you are what is it called. Well you don't have to answer that if you don't want to.
Angelsoffire 5 years ago
Thank you. No I'm not in a band, wish I was though, but I can't ever find anyone who plays anything. Haha.
Inusgirl05 5 years ago
Yeah..most of the worlds talented ppl either quit or become hooked on drugs(Or magic markers.LOL)Or,some of them are just plain idiots.:D
Angelsoffire 5 years ago
I can play a lot of things. You'll have to work on the voice, though.
HuskyRaeRae 5 years ago
You're really good! You could use a little bit of training, but everyone with singing talent needs trainging to refine their voice. ^-^
AdamColeD 5 years ago
You butchered it deary. HOW DO YOU DO THAT??! Well I can because i'm not a singer but my friend is an awesome piano player/guitar/clarinet/anything really. we both agree your singing is annoying and I don't get how your an awesome singer or how people you think you sing like amy lee because news flash you don't! Yeah i had to turn of the song about a few second after i listened to you, now that is bad. *gives a weird smile*
PyroTink 5 years ago
Aww thank you so much! You know, with spreading my videos around to your friends. You always come back to see my new videos even though you "hate" my voice. I consider you one of my biggest fans!
Inusgirl05 5 years ago
lol. I love your comment, and you do have a pretty voice, it may not sound exactly like Amy Lee but you could pull it off.
butterflytear 5 years ago
You're pretty good. ;D
xxcortneyxx 5 years ago
WOW.. your really good. Great Job!!!
XxStar2344xX 5 years ago
OOh, it's really good! I can't hit those low notes at all haha.
LostVarekai 5 years ago
omg this is so cool!
InuxKag4eva 5 years ago