Do you think that if these techniques were used on American soldiers that they would be totally unacceptable and even criminal? ASHCROFT: as Attorney General, by the definitions that, waterboarding, as described in the CIA's request, is not torture

[crowesam]

I look forward to seeing these guys get what they deserve. everything will be known in the end and when people say "I don't recall" under questioning this is a classic way of lying about something to cover up the truth.

[SteveWrathall]

The considerations of the Geneva Convention only apply to enemy combatants caught in uniform who follow the rules of war (not targeting civilians, etc). America would be entirely within its rights to summararily execute terrorist scum.

[Gee741852963]

What terrorist scum are you talking about?

The US terrorists?

Because US invaded their country!

It wasn't because they had weapons of mass destruction or had something to do with 9/11!!!

They are just defending what's theirs as you would if some other country invaded yours!

And talking about following the rules.

Kidnapping, torture, rape, killing of civilians, using illegal weapons (depleted uranium) looks to you like following the rules? What about "drop weapons" - another bent rule?

[Raptoreyes]

Congress needs to regain the power to ask questions about classified data. Respect of the law should not entail the executive withholding info from legislative branch of government.

[CircaRigeI]

Those meetings should be de-classified.

[CircaRigeI]

Waterboarding is wrong... plain and simple, and it's in violation of Geneva conventions. Interesting that he "isn't authorized" to answer so many questions. In a regular court, they call it taking the 5th... but he's not doing that.

[moon0007]

thks 4 sharing!

[gzyyy6]

they wrote the laws to justify themselvws

[falzaabi]

hahaha Obaid karki taking notes , haha , whalha i love you man , 25/10/2008 zawajy ragaaann t3all

[mebeur]

How convenient,no answers to any of your questions?

[ooglebydoogleby]

water boarding is morally indifencible.

[almulla]

He could be waay over his retirement age or that he is very stupid or he is a bad lair.

[Dutchdrummer99]

Very interesting... Would really like to know what happened in all those meatings!