Melinda Doolittle on American Idol - My Funny Valentine (HQ) with judges comments

[10RidiculousReasons]

Who won her season?? I cant remember.... I just remember her, lol

[theytrebel]

@10RidiculousReasons Jordin Sparks was the winner.

[MyWordsAreTheTruth]

She is a great singer. It really saddens me that she chose to sing mostly gospel music which doesn't suit the majority of population. She could have been much more successful had she chose either POP or ROCK. Ughh....

[Mrwheelchairwill]

she was very good but a little bit rebotic

[lalambe1]

Belinda is simply fabulous! I love this performance. It was so wonderful. The best contestant on American Idol history!!!

[chillchi]

i just listen to the lucie jones version of funny valentine...and i must say...she hit some good notes but over all her rendition was a hot mess. on the stay part she was more pitchey than a processional baseball player. anybody who thinks she's better than malinda is most likely a drug addict a racist or both.

[chillchi]

goawaylisa...says lucie is better than malinda on this song...well i think she should make like her name and just go away. malinda is the best singer on this planet...as far as im concerned and who the hell is lucie anyway?

[eugenechandra]

I just watched top 24 idol 2010, girls performance..

and how much I miss this kind of performance on top 24...

and Lakisha 'when I'm telling you...'

[goawaylisa]

lucie jones sang this song way better on x factor 2009

[SuperPanetone]

@goawaylisa

not really. lucie dont put as much soul as melinda. also, when lucie hit the second "staaay" is just awfull, sorry.

[chillchi]

you must be smoking crack...no one not even the writer of this song. has ever sung it better than malinda....you must be tone death or retarded...go listen to taylor swift or some other no talent.

[goawaylisa]

@chillchi ...tone death! Whatever, lucie is hotter!

[vocalmajor2008]

she is a BEAST!!!.. why didnt she win???

[Detomidine]

It was an incredible performance!

And that pant suit she's wearing, it's absolutely perfect for her. She should wear something like that more often!

[ExcellenceExacution]

i know her

[roselovesclay]

I adore her,,,she is marvelous,,and makes me cry she is so good,,,,

[Yameley]

For me... Unforgettable!! I always come back to see this performance!

[renov93]

2:30 - unbelieveable!

[tim1dogg]

thats when the rest of the contestants started shitting themselves haha

[obbeachbum69]

Best performance I have ever seen on American Idol. I mean really, it was simply perfect! 2:08 has been burned in my mind for a year now LOL. Her only problem was that she peaked too soon. I am ashamed that Jordan Sparks won over her. A travesty.

[pythonsfor6]

Of all the finalists, her album is one I would buy. LOVED HER and this was her best performance!!!!!

[sarahmarkever]

MELINDA ROCKS!!

[nathers27]

Ridiculous to think she didn't win. Just, ridiculous. I mean, Jordin's good, but Melinda's in a totally different league! Can I just say, quite apart from the performance itself, the quality of the video is amazing! Most stuff on youtube isn't that brilliant, even in HQ!

[deeteetwo]

No one has come close to this voice on AI. Thanks for the post.

[arnoldreyes2002]

Just finished watching American Idol, and guess what? Nobody has come close to Melinda's performance so far.

[prettyreeses]

Melinda is the best there is. She should have won hands down.

[ld1994mrp]

HER CD IS VERY GOOD!!! But, I would have loved to have this song on the CD

[theytrebel]

I agree, although this was released as a single on cd if you are interested.

[barryxf]

Great performance - thanks for posting.