Is she foreign? She sounds like she has a slight accent. She has an amzing voice sure she belted at the end but it was tastefull and not overdone, I've definately heard it much worse with other performances. I would love to see the whole show, esspecially days of plenty, Somethings are meant to be and fire within me this is a very impressive cast
She has an unbelievable voice! I didn't think the end was too shouty, I am just so impressed at her belting skills and it fits the song. This is by far the best I have seen anywhere.
Sometimes an actress needs to sacrifice some of the prettiness in the singing in order to enhance the emotion behind the lyric. This song, and the entire character of Jo, also has an incredible passion and energy that was somewhat lacking here. But she has a great voice.
Great performance up to the screaming at the end. I didn't understand that...clearly the actress has the voice to sing those notes so I didn't understand opting to have her shout them instead. Other than that, very well sung.
hey i was wondering if you have the whole show to watch somewere i lvoe this show so much but havn't ever been able to see it. This version of astonishing is amazing!
Girl you can sing! In all of the youtube performances I've seen, yours is by far the best I've heard. The acting and the voice just go so well with the part. Your voice is AMAZING! My school just did the show in April and it was good, but my God! I'm just astonished. Good work!
Who disliked this??!
musicalgeek95 5 months ago
ohh myy goshh. <3
HEAD TOOO BROADWAY!
pleaase.
sunshinelizz8 7 months ago
I like the way she sings this strong and shows the personality of the character so well
CountryRebelAngel 7 months ago 2
amazing!^^
KarpfenKarpfen 9 months ago
oh, i really like how she kinda chased Laurie out. I remember playing Laurie and loved this scene, very well done :)
wallywolverine 1 year ago
amazing.
RandomRandommer 1 year ago
I like her better than Sutton. You go girl!
SondheimFanatic1 1 year ago
amazing :)
Bacardi22 1 year ago
Finally, someone really sings it.
EnchantedSilence 1 year ago 6
WellDoneee Mel :) , thats really really wow lol, see you saturdayy
MhbLovezRobPattinson 1 year ago
great :)
irishwhitie444 1 year ago
one word...... AMAZING :)
kirrajadeee 1 year ago
Best one I've seen online so far!
Chibihobbit 2 years ago
great performance, could have done without the pop reach to the audience on the last Astonishing, but great job!
slickqfoo22 2 years ago
Go to Broadway Girl!!!
retnecegatsnwod 2 years ago 4
Absolutely unbelievable. Best version of this song ever sang.
xlegendxzeldax 2 years ago 2
Dude, I'm in the pit for my high school's musical of this.
itskellyorsomething 2 years ago
Marry Me? :D
Love it!x
themusicalvidkid 2 years ago
brilliant!
chazaii 2 years ago
WOW
jastully 2 years ago
Is she foreign? She sounds like she has a slight accent. She has an amzing voice sure she belted at the end but it was tastefull and not overdone, I've definately heard it much worse with other performances. I would love to see the whole show, esspecially days of plenty, Somethings are meant to be and fire within me this is a very impressive cast
luverofbroadway 2 years ago
Ahhh, chills. Best version I've heard so far!
magiclydlcious 2 years ago
i would love for her to sing with natalie weiss
theaterzmylife 3 years ago
She has an unbelievable voice! I didn't think the end was too shouty, I am just so impressed at her belting skills and it fits the song. This is by far the best I have seen anywhere.
charstars3 3 years ago
Great singing! Well done!
sylvapen 3 years ago
That was the best Astonishing I've heard in a long time.
chjola1 3 years ago
Sometimes an actress needs to sacrifice some of the prettiness in the singing in order to enhance the emotion behind the lyric. This song, and the entire character of Jo, also has an incredible passion and energy that was somewhat lacking here. But she has a great voice.
majrdramaqueen22 3 years ago
Great performance up to the screaming at the end. I didn't understand that...clearly the actress has the voice to sing those notes so I didn't understand opting to have her shout them instead. Other than that, very well sung.
EdenMalfoy 3 years ago
its called belting fool, and that's the way the song is written..it's a very belty song especially at the end..and she has a great belt here
bwayindaburbs23 2 years ago
1. I'm not a fool. Thank you very much.
2. I said it was a great performance, but I didn't care for the musical choice at that one spot.
There's no need to be nasty to me, I complimented the performance and am entitled to my opinion without being called names.
EdenMalfoy 2 years ago
wow phenomenal
cteairhead 3 years ago
I saw Little Women on Broadway, BUT THIS IS FAR BETTER!!!
Evarkr374 3 years ago
i believe you are liz bright's sister, am i correct?
regardless your voice is bloody fantastic
joewilliams1987 3 years ago
yep joe you are correct that is my sibling lol. and hey! whats the regardless about lol xx
Brightstar7 3 years ago
wow that was amazing!!!
absolutely stunning
leamondrops17 3 years ago
hey i was wondering if you have the whole show to watch somewere i lvoe this show so much but havn't ever been able to see it. This version of astonishing is amazing!
EmmaJaneSmith 3 years ago
you are the best that ive ever sing this song!
theaterzmylife 3 years ago
ahh!
flippin awesome
theaterzmylife 3 years ago
Who is she? Where was this production? Fantastic! She's great!
Director didn't help her much, but she overcomes it. Love this performance!
kwjordy 3 years ago 2
Melanie.... Kirstie and Christina would be pissed off lol you are amazing
Beninjam91 3 years ago 2
i got the goosebumps.
by far the best.
i dont' get goosebumps from singers,
and you gave them to me.
nicely done.
hockeyhunn 3 years ago 2
amazing!!
RipperCanRiff 3 years ago 2
Girl you can sing! In all of the youtube performances I've seen, yours is by far the best I've heard. The acting and the voice just go so well with the part. Your voice is AMAZING! My school just did the show in April and it was good, but my God! I'm just astonished. Good work!
operadragon1121 3 years ago 2
brilliant, this girl is amazingly talented :)
lolovesmusicals 3 years ago 2
Great acting ha Jo is such a power character, I love her!! I love when Sutton Foster sings, what a performance to this girl!!
PrueStar 3 years ago 2