Added: 1 year ago
From: kbsworld
Views: 391,196
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (280)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • actually the vid is a bit stretched sideways....sunhwa is a actually a bit thinner than average....

  • hahahahahahahah at "FAT" .... come on really, finally some healthy folks :)

  • They AREN'T FAT PEOPLE! STOP Hatin' PLEASE?! I rather Prefer those Legs then Skinny-Ass Legs that can be easily Breakable

  • That choreo is just too good and really good live singing voice.

  • LOL, the camera added 10 pounds but only to their legs. 

  • These girls are so underrated. Talented and Beautiful! Lol my dog hates when i play this song, as soon as it comes on and i start dancing she groans really load.

  • jieun so pretty

  • Thin girls are not attractive at all,.... maybe they look good on camera but at real life,. i would call anyone who likes a thin, anorexic girls a necrophiliac ,...... this is what SEXY actually means,.

  • 1:30 HYOSUNG IS MY SEXY ICON <3

  • To whomever call them "fat" ever thought about it being because of the camera or the quality of the video?

  • Tsktsk to ppl who are defending secret and saying that they're not fat but call slim girls sticks shame.

  • I wouldn't be delusional and say that they have bodies that are proportional but they have great live singing.

  • i used to say "i would die to have the body of girl's day members", now i see this and i really like THIS kind of body! they look so good! love it

  • How can people call these girls fat?

    Dear whom ever called them fat

    For your information their what we call real girls... I donno what world you're in but we're in the realistic world and these girls have the perfect bodies.

    The K-Pop girl groups that have stick-like-legs just makes me wonder if their company are actually forcing them to starve.

    To be honest Secret is my rolde model because their actually PERFECT!!! <3 <3 <3

    Love you Secret... Keep the good work up and be who you are!!! <3

  • That is the most movement in a performance i've ever seen a female kpop group do, what a workout!

  • IMO...Secret is by far the sexiest kpop girl group. Its so refreshing to see real women on stage.

  • LOVE THEM! I mean just look at their style/ voices / swag and BODIES WWHOA!!!!!

  • Zinger's body is the TRUTH.

  • MA DOLLAH DOLLAH MA DOLLAH DOLLAH DOLLAAAA

  • They are definetly not fat, but they're not skinny, or perfectly proportioned either. They clearly have very toned, muscular bodies, which is very attractive!

  • fat ???!!! no way this is fat !! than i want to be fat!

  • secret is perfectly proportion!! ppl obviously blind or just loves anorexic legs..

  • WHAT who said that they are fat ._.' ?

    if have that body means to be fat i wanna be fat too

  • they r not fat. even if im not a fan i still think they r quite pretty and btw the reason y they look fat here is because this video is stretched out. its not the real them

  • so what if they were fat? so what if they were skinny? I just come for them, their music, and dancing.

  • Secret is sexy.

    You are just always watching the girls who were actually "THIN" and skinny, not sexy.

  • THEY ARE NO WHERE NEAR FAT!! they are healthy and beautiful 8D

  • Ji Eun has a really strong and stable voice all throughout the entire dance. Wow. Just wow. <3

  • FINALLY! REAL BODIES!!

  • 2:02

    an earthquake ?

    I get carsick.

  • Secret is not fat. They are athleticly built. :D:D

  • Secret has the sexiest bodies of all the kpop girl groups!!!

  • this is one of the things that's wrong with society today...thinking that these girls are fat. Are you out of your mind? ...I suppose anyone who isn't 5'6'' and 100 pounds is fat then...Ridiculous -___-

  • SECRET! <3

  • they're not fat...more like the ideal type lol

  • please watch my kpop dance covers ^-^ hehe =]

  • i love zinger's rap !!! 

  • fat? I wish i could have those legs O.O

  • couldnt care less about some random peoples opinion! my fav kpop group... looks, voices, dancing very catchy songs!

  • this is my 3rd fave girl band 1st kara 2nd snsd i am girl to tell you! iam not lesbian

  • secretサイコ―!!

  • i love them. They look more normal and healthy than ANYother K-girl group! and they are tallented

  • they have pretty bodys most k~pop singers are vary thin these girls are better

  • this song bcmes my newest addiction apart from chitty chitty bang bang hyori!!!!!! go secret~!!!!!!!!!!

  • These idiots probably don't realize that the video's aspect ratio is off, which makes the girls horizontally stretched / wider than they appear. Even so, they're all curvy and gorgeous, people really need to reassess their beliefs before blindly following the media.

  • im a guy and i love zinger's body.. you need some fat to be "sexy".. i like it better than skinny body

  • Secret is hot, hot, hot!!

  • actually they look kind of chubby in this video... I think it's the video itself and not them... anyway, even if they were "fat" (if you can call it that) they still can dance and sing like that!

    Secret rocks ! XD

  • I don't think they're fat... and I heard someone call sunhwa too skinny once

  • People who say they're fat are loners..They're just CURVY.At least it's better than being so skinny like a skeleton..some female idols get so skinny that they look anorexic .But it's just because they got a lot of schedules and probably think they're fat so they're going on a diet.I don't want Secret to look skinny.They're already perfect like that.I don't want them to think that us fans are making them look fat,and go on a diet.Imagine if you were treated like that..

  • they are not fat ppl they got curves and that's sexy . and they sing and dance at the same time and it turns out great! daebak i love you girls

  • JIEUN VOICE ! <33333

  • Okay I understand where the fat comments come from. If you look at my channel, I'm all about being thin and prefer to have a slim body type. But these girl CAN sing. They look sexy and it matches their style. They're women and its great the song is Madonna because Secret is the super female group! ;)

  • Can someone give me the names of the members? I really like the girl with the Black hair, but I don't know her name...

  • check out my shy boy dance cover ^ㅇ^

  • Wow! I'm always amazed at how well they can sing. You know, compared to American singer. Not saying all, but some. Some can't sing ANYWHERE close to how they sound on their CDs. But these guys? SO AMAZING AND AWESOME! :D

  • They all have sexy legs, but damn, Zinger's O.O I love her egs. I'm totally being homo about them over here. Sexiest legs, I've ever seen.

  • they slimed down a lot now

  • I like the way Hyosung says * Trendy Hot style* she makes it sound so smooth and cool

  • Secret is not fat girls, they are HEALTHY, there is a difference. the difference is that healthy means your thick and proud of it. these girls dont have to rely on their looks for attention, they have massive talent originally

  • SUNHWA <3

  • かわいい!!

    

  • seriously, i freaking adore zinger's legs!! it's super HOT compared to other idols who had super skinny legs.

  • This is DAMN RIGHT S-LINES RIGHT HERE!(:<3 I Want their BODY! SO SEXY UNNIES"!!(:

  • Wow people actually look at this video and say these girls are fat and can't sing?

    What kind of world are you living in.

    This is what a female body looks like everyone, healthy, sexy, beautiful.

    I mean, if skeletons are your thing than wow buddy that's not my business.

    And also this is what you call TALENTED.

    Try singing while dancing like that. You'll fail miserably. These girls managed to do it, which I find amazing.

    TL;DR: Get out more, learn what healthy women look like, stop being a bitch

  • @Yoonatica I really like them, but I have to admit this song sucks, not because of them, they should fire the choreographer. I agree, how are the fat?! They're already skinnier than half the american population, and the korean population isn't exactly that thin either.

  • I LOVE THEIR LEGS!

    Finally, some REAL girls, with REAL bodies!

    None of this skinny-as-a-stick business.

  • I miss this. ♥

  • dang they sound terrible i thought they would be better live still love the song tho

  • omg secret's members have best legs in kpop world

  • All people calling them fat have gotten to used to legs like SNSD's (which in my opinion are 0% fat or muscle, 100% bones, sorry SNSD!). These girls are probably the best bodies in k-pop, because they're HEALTHY. I would rather have any of the girls legs (say hyosung) than almost every other kpop girl group (except miss a, they also have great bodies). and if you don't find these girls hot, you must be jealous or gay ;)

  • Honestly, I'd rather see some healthy, fit idols than the skinny, deprived ones that make up most of the K-pop industry right now.. There's a clear line between FAT and MUSCULAR. And I doubt any manager would let their singers get too loose with their tight meal or exercise regime for them to be anything but thin. Respect for these girls. SECRET is talent and natural beauty <3

  • hurr ,

  • damn, hyosung has nice legs and a NICE ASS!!! I'd tap her...hard.

  • 大人気の(笑)韓流グループにしてはデブ女がまざってるなw

    どうせみんな同じ顔(DNAの損傷?w)なので日本にはこなくて­いいです

  • comparing secret's thighs to other bands.... who cares... all i know is that they have the real strength...

    and why would anyone want overly skinny legs? seems not proportionate... e.g ( no offence, snsd )

    ... back to secret... they're the best girl idols out there!!!

  • I wonder when i will be able to read comments that don't compare secret to other girl bands or that talks about how they look. Seriously people just enjoy this performance and stop bashing on them. If you don't like them just leave, instead of starting a war between secret and another girl band.

  • It's nice to see some healthy girls with pop! Unlike those nine dancing skeletons! (Although I have to admit, I also like those dancing skeletons... especially during Halloween!)

  • @kixxxter

    lol at nine dancing skeletons

  • @TheKarin888 I just found out that their name stands for: Singing Nine Skeleton Dancers!

  • @kixxxter wait isnt it "Seo Nyeo Shi Dae"? cause in Korean that means Girl's Generation. Or are you just kidding? xD

  • Comment removed

  • @kixxxter LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO U cracked up, u made my day...next to watching Heartstrings ep 10

  • @mileytommy Thank you. I'm glad I was able to make you LOL! Just wondering, what specifically did you find amusing? Was it my definition of "SNSD" (Singing Nine Skeleton Dancers) or was it my Google Translate inquiry? I have another definition that I'd like to share. I originally posted it on another MV and it received over 200 thumbs up! It's "KPOP" (Korea's Perfection of Pop!)

  • @kixxxter SNSD lol

  • Zinger's LEGS are AMAZING!

  • まだ言っておくことがあります。彼女たちのプロポージョンはいい­のですから服のセンス何とかららないの。時代遅れです。振り付け­はだんだん良くなってきている。;韓国に若手の新進デザイナーい­ないんですか?早急に彼女の衣装をあっと驚くセンスに変えなさい­。振付と会ってない。違和感を覚えます。もしできなければ日本の­デザイナー起用しさい、

  • @to3nakajima

    ですねー

    今日びボディコンはないですよねw

    でも応援してます。シークレット

  • Zinger looks AWESOME!!!!

  • Hyosung is what a real woman should look like, I adore her and her gummy smile :D

  • they are totally not fat, and even if they were, they also have great talent, so in the end, they're perfect <3

  • When Zinger winked at the camera I died! ♥

  • Their legs being a bit larger than average also means that they're real, unlike some other artists who's legs are made out of plastic. And I'm sure they're working on it.

    SECRET HWAITING!!!!

  • @JudyKimBlueDolphin Yeah, that's real classy, calling other people plastic. How about love your group and stop hating on others. Plastic surgery requires a lot of healing time, time that most idols do not have because their schedules are packed and they are overworked as it is.

  • Don't compare them to SNSD. They are real, their best friend is not the plastic surgeon and food is their friend. I like SNSD but has anyone seen Yuri lately? Who wants them to become like that? If boys want girls like SNSD they should go live in the waiting room of a plastic surgeon or something. And after all it's about talent; and I think more people in this group can sing then in SNSD. In SNSD I find that only 2 have real talent (My opinion).

  • fave girl group

  • @eunhaelova OMGOMG yesssss! Someone that aggrees with meee!

  • Dayum Zinger move dem hips!!!

  • I kinda wanna kill the choreographer at the chorus but the song is super catchy and that girl with the side-braid kicks ass!

  • -.- oh God.. Look they are obviously skinny.. because as u can see they are not fat.. BUT i know they are not a walking skeleton.. people say that because they are just jealous of their gorgeous bodies & u are fat or suuper skinny & does nothing to make it better ... stop being immature & ignorant & stop criticizing people for no stupid reason.. GET A LIFE

  • i don't see why everyone compares all the other girl groups to snsd. i Love snsd but i think everyone else needs a chance too. and don't hate me for saying this but Zinger's pant look a little tight. i mean she's NOT fat she's beautiful!! but the short look tight.oh well secret fighting<3

  • 借我分享 謝!

  • Nice group ! Beazy

  • Prefer snsd legs

  • Uhmmm see them in real life. I've met them and talked to them and I thought they were a walking skeleton.

  • For all you ignorant fucks out there saying their legs are fat, they aren't. Their legs are muscular and with all the dancing they do they have built up a lot of muscles in that area, quite similar to professional swimmers and runners who work their legs HARD if you watch the Olympics at all. Go figure.

  • It's like seeing a different group altogether.

  • 倖田來未みたいな下品なのがいっぱいw

    踊りヘンだよ。かなり。

  • ji eun is amazinggggg <3

  • I LOVE SECRET and im hyosung biased :))

  • dislike this when i read the top comment...

  • stop comparing pls! :)

  • Unique is every group.so while there is competition its still quality kpop from these girls!even thought i like snsd i think secret is good and different!rock on girls!

  • Man nobody is perfect so don't say secret is fat. And actually it just happened that SNSD debuted first and it just happened that their company is SM but wait if WONDER GIRLS didnt concentrate that much to their US debut do ya'll think that SNSD will be that popular?

    And @ sica4ever16 -- they've already proved themselves.. And they are good, VERY GOOD.. But im not sying SNSD is not. And i think even though ya'll compare them to each other SECRET WILL STILL STANDOUT IN AN OVERPOPULATED GI

  • So ya'll are like saying tht beyonce is fat because beyonce have thick thighs and muscular legs!! Omg, ya'll people should wake up or ya'll are just blind!?

    Comparing them to SNSD makes me piss. Im an snsd fan and a secret fan aswell, but i dont think ya'll need to compare them. Yes i like snsd but i never like their bodies. Honestly Most of them look like a stick and dont have curves.. So For me it doesnt look good at all and i bet snsd fans/sones just liked them bcoz of their LOOKS. Man no

  • like they have the best overall vocals as a group

  • Omo! they are so Fabulous!!.. they are pretty,sexy,can sing,can dance.. OMO! AWESOME! I LOVE SECRET!

  • Great Song! It kinda protrays Madonna. Secret is definitely the K-pop Madonna. Cute, witty, sexy and confident! Hwaiting!

  • Honestly, stop comparing girl groups. None are better than others. Different K-POP girl groups have their own style, and own look. They're all still pretty in their own way. You don't really need to care about they how look, or whatever because they already look pretty the way they are (even though appearance is important). And calling people fat is mean. Honestly, they're not fat. Do you guys even know what FAT means? At least Secret is pretty, and have good vocals. Stop comparing. It's stupid.

  • @Paduasaurus Here is an honest comparison: they all suck. Equally. Here is some more honest sentiment: guys watch kpop girl groups because they make them horny. Girls watch kpop girl groups because they are okay with that.

  • @Bulls910 Er. Lol. Your comparison is totally off-topic with mine. And even if they suck, whatever, that was not the point that I was talking about. I did not ask for an honest sentiment either. :P But thanks for a reply?

  • Seriously , why i'm watching other girl group and all the comment about comparing SNSD to them ? I'm a SONE myself and i think Secret do look sexy XD , they are my top2 :D

  • As a girl, I think they're sexy. Curves are better than stick you know. And SECRET's definitely got curves. I like their legs as well because it's not skinny, but not fat either. =)

  • their legs are not beautiful but very sexy

  • It's all because of the shorts they're wearing. If you guys check out their Madonna performance on Aug 20, 2010, you'll see that their legs aren't that thick. And what's up with the SNSD comparison? In my opinion, people need to stop thrashing because these girls are better than you anyway. Just because you're a SONE, doesn't mean you can go around acting like SNSD was the best girl group ever. Their debut came first, that's all. However, I'm not saying that SNSD isn't JUST some group. They're

  • these girls are pure beaut! <3 love themmm and their sexy honey thighs!

  • i like these girls they have great voices and as a girl myself i would like to say they are not fat they all have great bodies i am tired of people calling others fat its kinda annoying and i pretty sure half of these people dont have amazing bodies themselves (not dissing anyone in particular i am just saying)

    :)

  • Zinger's legs so fat.

  • run. And gosh, these girls are not only pretty but they can sing as well. It's hard to find that combination in the industry lately; Secret is an underrated jewel.

  • Wtf they're not thick at all o.o if you wear shorts like that it'll capture the fat below your butt which makes your legs look thicker. And fyi, camera = +10 pounds. Girls like snsd might look normal on tv but if you meet them irl I'm sure their thighs are the same size as your arms. I guess it's due to the evolution of fashion that made the if-you're-not-anorexic-looking­-you're-fat culture, the more skin is exposed the more self-aware you'll feel. I hope celebrities will be healthy in the long

  • Secret always perform with the best outfit. love their cody.

  • they're thin it just that they have big thigh..

  • wow.................

  • ok, i'm gonna give this group a thumbs up/ i didnt think any girl group was better than 2ne1/ although they are not better i will give them a close 2nd/ i havent seen any other korean female group that i liked besides these two..and i love their legs, these women are nice lookin and voluptous!! I have never been to korea but they always make asian women look like skinny sticks! This group here changes all that!!!

  • ok, i'm gonna give this group a thumbs up/ i didnt think any girl group was better than 2ne1/ although they are not better i will give them a close 2nd/ i havent seen any other korean female group that i liked besides these two..

  • which one is the leader?

  • @somebodyquiet hyosung

  • @somebodyquiet

    the one with purple-ish hair is the leader.

    her name is hyosung.^^

  • THEY'RE SINGING LIVE. GOOD GOD STOP ARGUING AND LISTEN CLOSELY. You can hear the backtrack at certain points where the choreo gets too hard for them to sing properly enough and they stop singing. =|

  • i like hyosung

  • Zinger has one of the sexiest lower halves I've seen in K-pop! What shape!!

  • AMAZING KOREAN GIRLS!!!

    U deserve to be Superstar !!!

  • Zinger is hot!

  • I Like them very much now!!!

  • Their legs aren't fat, they are MUSCULAR.

  • @MsNickthestar or female. but definitely not fat.. the community watching these videos is weird... I wonder how many of them have actually seen a girl in person

  • I really like these girls, but the fact that those two comments got so many thumbs up shows that their fanbase is composed of retards.

  • i think u ppl r all confused, secret are not chubbier or 'average sized. they r just as thin as most other k groups (of course w/ some exceptions) this videp only makes them appear wider, they r actually THIN

  • i love those thick legs damn boner

  • Go secret!! I luv u full.. XD.. Yeah, i aggreed with pervious comments..

    They're natural with their body or even their face so that they don't need any plastic surgery or hard 'diet' Wkwkwkwk...

    Go Secret!!

  • omg this girls are awsome they got great legs and thier not skinny like the snsd girls they make me sick with thir skinny ass body and other girls group actually have ass and the other have nothing

  • Yes! i love their looks! they have curves! and the leadger has a beautiful smile! it's great to found girls with shape and the most amazing thing is that they're going against structures for that! and they have real talent!

  • I agree on most comments here that they look really good...and that they actually EAT...it's sad that some celebs equate beauty with being skinny...the girls are glowing coz they look really healthy unlike some girl groups that are yes,skinny but looked really sick if not for the really thick make up..and i love their songs..it has a different vibe! go SECRET!

  • Surprises me that even if their asian they have legs

    & their skinney too but not to the extreme i think

    their just in good shape like that honestly (:

    i think it's the first korean group of girls

    that actually has legs,

    it gives moree shape to their body.

    haha, they are good singers too

    Wish you best of luck girls (:

  • Just noticed something. Most of the Kpop Groups Leaders is the one that's the most energetic among the group members. Like Hyosung unnie :) Love her !

  • Why are people hating on SNSD in this video? SNSD is phenomenal, and they have a lot of great performances and songs. Plus, several members are hilarious if you watch a lot of their variety shows with their appearances. Secret's looking good so far but gotta see how they are down the line. Can't be a one hit wonder no matter how nice their legs look.

  • i think their legs are what they call SEXY in western sight.. asians are too attached to the idea that thin=sexy.. im asian myself but i dont agree to that. Zinger's is quite above average though but it looks fine :)

  • damnnn ji eun can sing. and so can hyo sung. i LOVE it how they don't look anorexic ^^ they look like healthy girls with talent ^^

  • FLAWLESS. BETTER THAN SNSD.

  • Tha girl that raps her legs r THICK!! I like!!!

  • dem legs !!!!

  • sunhwa has pureness in her? obviously u havent seen her before she became a singer. whenever i see her, make me puke. thats all.

  • @jamisont1 nobody forced you to watch her. why go all the trouble to puke? just look in the mirror

  • @jamisont1 Why's that? Are you talking about her looks? She was adorable when she was a kid, a little chubby but nothing gross about her. Or are you talking about her personality? Anything I've seen or heard her in suggests she's anything but mean and nasty.