Added: 4 years ago
From: kittybabe05
Views: 235,219
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (255)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i like it more than original...is it she singing or not?

  • this is beautiful for anyone who likes more of a rock vibe checkj out valkila sky's cover its great

  • I hate the original, but this is good.

  • i think mandy did a nice rendition of the song. sure, its not the upbeat version but i think she made it more adult contemporary-like. its soothing.

  • Where can i download it ?

  • no offense but you'd have to be an idiot to think this was slowed down. and this is mandy moore...

  • this is not rihanna...its the beautiful mandy moore

  • Love it but this is not rihanna

  • @Powzer19 Rihanna Jay SeaN, Kareena Kapoor, Julia Roberts, Shakira, Imran Khan full interview on HOTCHAAT. Search HOTCHAAT for 30 min show with Imran Khan. HOTCHAAT stars Masala T (hot,sexy) and Alisha (cool). HOTCHAAT is top bollywood/hollywood show.

  • nice but i love the sweet voice of rihanna

  • it's so beautiful, who is the singer??

  • it's so beautiful,

  • I LOVE IT <3

  • I LOE IT <3

  • shes not singing

  • very good! Bette than the original ♥ Like it!

  • isnt Mandy Moore like Miley's bestfriend and backup dancer??

  • @HomeBoundWolvess Not that's Mandy Jiroux. This is Mandy Moore and she was on stage since 2000.

  • @HomeBoundWolvess no rthats not this mandy. This Mandy is an actress and a singer.

  • Bello!!!

  • sehr schön (:

  • waaauw .

    i like it . xddd

  • whoa shes good

  • its mandy moore, i watch it 2 years ago

  • I like this so much 

    very good version

  • It isn't Rihanna

  • @Kazuha99  really?

  • What a wunderful song.

  • What a wunderful song.

  • What a wunderful song.

  • this is pretty, but I still think I like the original better...or maybe I'm just more used to it. C:

  • you could stand under my umbrella ella ella eh eh eh...........

  • better as the orginal

  • Love it really muchhhh!

    I think I'm gonna sing it in a live show on school! =D

  • h3 t00k ur heart nd nw ur under his umbrella!!!!_DOMINIQU3

  • I really like this!!!!

    awesome

  • this is better then the origional

  • @ilychb4eva עפתם.

  • wow i was looking for this aloooooooaaat ty man

  • it's mandy moore xd

  • Yeah, I love this version but, no, it's not Rihanna. It's Mandy Moore covering this song wonderfully...

  • This isn't Rihanna.....

  • Greaat..........

    why dont you make youre own clip?

  • even better than the original... great.

  • Not Rihanna....O_o

    But its nice anyway. Manydy Moore is a good singer :)

  • that is not rihanna???

  • its mandy moore

  • oh thank very much!!!:) you're very nice thank!

  • sounds nice Ilike it

  • that is so not rihanna

  • its mandy moore? ;b

  • I think this song's beautiful, but who's the man singing with her at one point?

  • GREAAT

  • Rihanna has a new version of this song like this except better, just search for Rihanna - Umbrella 2009 version. I freakin love it.

  • Comment removed

  • its mandy moore!!

    She sings it beautiful

  • Its Mandy Moore : )

  • this isn't beyonce...its some other girl, forgot her name though...

  • mandy moore x

  • perfeitOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOO

  • i lv this song

    every1 says i am gd at singin it

    i dnt think i am lol

    x <3

  • yes chel u ok .,... hha u r gd at singin this man

  • haha louise ya okk ya hed huni sum vids cumin on ere 4 das to see

  • Wow I was going to do a slow cover of it, and see if it was done and too bad it was

  • I really like it :)

  • i think this is very peaceful

  • WAY TOO SLOW I LIKE THE NORMAL VERSION

  • omg I love this version too... sounds so.... hmm.. wonderfull :) more then a love song

  • love it! the video goes with the version really well!

  • ii Love This! <3 x

  • I love the slow version

    but when rihanna sings it, she makes it sound different...I love this too but i like rihannas slow version better

  • Amazing

  • luv it!!

  • This it´s Mandy Moore

  • this version is great :)

    but i really like the video too :) good job!

    i especially like the parts when rihanna is dancing in the rain ..!!

  • Mandys bloody awesome!

  • If You Like This By Mandy Moore, Listen To 'Top Of The World' By Mandy Moore. Its Brill! Thumbs Up If Yhoo Think Its Good!!!!

  • i looove it. its so much better than the original. (L)

    wonderful voice

  • This is from Mandy Moore... great Version... i like it more then the original... ;c)

  • luv this version like all u ppls vvvvvvvv

  • i love the slow version,too=D

  • luv the slow version :)

  • anyone got the mp3 of this version?

  • oooooh i love it

    thank you . (:

  • go mandy!!!!

  • Mandy Moore.!

  • I think I prefer this version

  • You do know that that is mentioned in the description box?

  • love this version (:

  • this version is better

  • better version

  • look eingelijk had them this way singing because better snappie had then been

  • this was a really good effort, mandy moore is okay in my book

    but i think this one was probably better in theory...

  • i like rihana's version better. Its more popish and this is more slow and R&B.

  • this is mandy moore,not rihanna.

  • This one's sung by Mandy Moore on TV.. just search for it on Youtube, then you'll see.

  • some time ago i heard this song on mtv (masters), and a boy sings it. The version was very slow and beautiful. but i don't know who that was. :'-(

  • Scott simmons x

  • this is better than the original song bc now it has meaning lol

  • How does this have more meaning? Same lyrics.....just a different vibe. The style doesn't change what the song writer is trying to say....

  • It's actualy sang by mand moore-it says on the info bit (:

  • This is much better than the Rihanna 1.ive just downloaded mine.x

  • This is amazing,does anyone know when i can download it??????

  • This version is sung by Natalie Gauci she was the winner of Australian Idol 2007

    Awesome version

  • This version is SOOO GOOD.. . (: could u possibly sent it to me?

  • is this even her?

  • Lol no I don't think so

  • actually its classic not slow

  • hey i really like this!! can you send this version to me??

  • i got goose bumps, its amazing <3 omg :P

  • This is Mandy Moore :)

  • i perfure this it a more emotion i fink it brings out wot shees trying to say by this solower version

  • That Song Could Better is rihanna Sing ! I`m Not so Good To english .

    I`m From Norway

  • it would be alot better with Rihanna's own acoustic version that she did for the UK iTunes.

  • is this mandy moore

  • yeah

  • i like this better

  • WOW!

  • i love this version really good i think the lyrics have more meanin when its slowed down

  • Is this recorded or sang live?

  • it`s mandy moore, and it`s a live performance for Yahoo music

  • Hmmm... I don't like this version.

    Rihanna is just better! ^^

  • i love it. thumbs down all you like its my opinion lol. i like the original too.

  • It's Mandy Moore..

  • it doesnt even look like the voice of rihanna...

  • MANDY MOORE...

  • Geez, well I like BOTH versions of this song. They're both very nice. Of course, I tend to like almost everything under the sun, so maybe I'm just a small percentage that likes everything I listen to.

  • where can i found the faster version?

  • dats mandy moore

  • Rihanna's version sounds better. It's more this generation mmusic

  • mandy morre is so sensative rihannas is so like hyper this sounds like a country song

  • MANDY DIDN'T! RIHANNA DID!

    The song was originally recorded by Mandy but no one knows that since Rihanna is the one that really got it out there. IN reality, Rihanna's version is the cover.

  • twilightfreak145 if u put in the search box mandy moore umbrella listen 2 the 5 minute long version she actually says she's covering rihanna!

  • i like the original song better with Rihanna singing it, but this sounds great too! :)

  • sorry but i don't like it, the original version is much better... btw i like rihanna's voice a lot more than mandy moore's...

  • I just find it sad that songs have to be slow tempoed for people to see the meaning. Umbrella, with a title like it has, the meaning was apparent just listening to it? Is it a crime to be able to move to the song.

    I think it sounds nice either way, but the up tempo makes it easier to relate to this generation. It's like the 'Lean on Me' of the 2000's

  • I agree. "Umbrella" is a beautiful song about friendship.

    Also, a lot of the singers that cover this don't get the meaning. "In the dark, you CAN see shiny cars" makes this apparent. The original was a metaphor for how in the darkest times, the material things won't matter. These covers, including Mandy's, say superficiality is what you need when the cards are down. I love Mandy, but to say this has more meaning than Rihanna's is like saying Madonna's "American Pie" meant more than Don McLean's

  • I just caught that. I don't know if it was because of her accent or what, but they don't seem to understand that she said you "can't see shiny cars".

  • mandy  more

  • who actually made the song first????

  • it's rihanna who did it first... this is a cover by mandy moore oh rihanna's

  • That is NOT rihanna, its Mandy Moore!

  • she is so beautiful and even more in the slow version.

  • This. one is so better then the other.. Good song!!

  • i like both of them but i definently like this one better

  • i love this

  • this is better it matches the lyrics, the song is a love song, the words have so much meaning to it that it should be sung like this, however i don't really care for mandy moores voice but i like it better slower it matches the lyrics and makes it more meaningful then just singing it with a good fast beat

    even tho i absolutely love the beat, i stil think that this is better cuz it jst makes the song more meaningful

  • THATS MANDY MOORE SINGING

  • gdgd i like it!

  • Echo423, next time audition for American Idol so you can hear it from Simon himself, singing is not for you

  • Next time don't use the name os a horrible singer who couldn't even make it onto American Idol

    On a side note American Idol sucks balls.

  • I tried to sing this slow,if you guys wana know wether i did it justice then the video is in my profile

  • this is way better than the original :]

  • this is soo good i love it :) .ox

  • Cool...I like Rihanna more cause its faster and sounds more...well I don know but I like Rihanna better

  • i love this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!x-x

  • 351 919 933 pleaaaase send somebody me this song!!!

  • great voice!!!

  • good idea playing this is pretty calm but very beautiful i like the other version too. i sing it in choir and it like slower than the real version and a little faster than this version bc it's on the piano lol.

  • Awesome ^^ Thanx

  • wow great voice

  • Calm...Pretty. But, I like fast stuff!!

  • Mandy Moore did say she like this song,only make sense she make a nice, remix, I like it, It's calmful