hahaha I can't believe I just saw a David Gilmour Vs Kurt Cobain argument. I mean no disrespect by this, but Kurt isn't a great guitar player, just a good songwriter. Gilmour plays with soul, Cobain does not. Even Dave is probably better at guitar.
Are you seriously saying that slash is a better guitarist than the likes of jimmy page? Or angus young?
He plays everything in the same key ¬_¬ That list is out of date. It hasnt got Matthew bellamy or jack white on there but I cant see any reason why slash should be on there. Hes good technicaly but he cant improvise for shit :)
@bmiester2003 I agree on Matt and Jack, but what you're saying about Slash is wrong. He is not playing everything in the same key, that would be Angus, and you clearly stated that Angus is a better guitarist. Also, He's not that much of a technical player as you're saying. Most of his live solos have TONS of improv.
dude that guitar solo was great!! Its not just about technical and fast you can get. he played soo smoothly, and the note choices. if you were a fan of pink floyd you would understand..
gilmour is amazing player, otherwise comfortably numb wouldnt (on numerous occassions) be voted best guitar solo ever. still hats off to cobain, SLTS is one of the most recognisable riffs ever!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
dudes wtf ur arguin bout who's better kurt or gilmour wel obvious kurt he's a legend no 1 cares or givs 2 shits or even no's who david gilmour is so just stop arguin da ansers simple!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Are you kidding? David Gilmour was a better singer, guitarist, and musician than Kurt by a million miles. Honestly, most people can get better than Cobain at guitar within 2 years of playing. How can you say that no one knows who Gilmour is? He's one of the most famous musicians of the last century... Also, learn how to spell.
..I mean I really like Nirvana, they are among my favourite bands, but if you don't know who David Gilmour or Pink Floyd are, sir, if you don't mind, step out of the internet.
o dude for real david gilmour can do circles around kurt cobain on guitar. cobain good write good songs, with 4 chords that could really rock. gilmour could play guitar and blow minds
not the best guitar player but certainly better then many. i agree with the1nameless and tango616. great guitar players play with their souls not just the guitar. dragonforce are flashy but have no soul in their music.
i agree with u too, when u get lost in ur own stuff, its unexplainable. And good guitarists always get lost in their music, its all about the soul, dragon force just play fast as they can.
hmm i must say that Dave Grohl isnt the best guitar soloist out there... But the Foo Fighters still fukn rock!!! And well it appears that Dave's improved on his soloing from when he first started so thats awesum!!!!! FOO FIGHTERS ROCK!!!!!!
Jimi Hendrix. Without Jimi, all those "incredible" guitarists you people rattle on about, would either never have picked up guitar (Satriani) or would of played something totally different (Blackmore, Stevie Ray and Jimmie Vaughn, and many more artists.)
i AM into metal music but im diff. than the people who listen to nothing but metal i listen to everything sept country, rap, and stupid hip-hop and stuff like that...i still like some of the foo's songs but hes got nothing on synister gates
true i belive the note thing that you said. BUT jack white plays like hardly any notes but there all with alot of soul but alot of them still suck...and dragonforce solos have a million notes but they have NO soul, so again they suck...you gotta find a happy medium...like johnny demaro...greatest player ever
because rolling stone's list is by popular vote and is complete and utter bullshit. for instance, slash isnt even on it, and it lists 100 guitarists. that list can suck a dick.
hahaha I can't believe I just saw a David Gilmour Vs Kurt Cobain argument. I mean no disrespect by this, but Kurt isn't a great guitar player, just a good songwriter. Gilmour plays with soul, Cobain does not. Even Dave is probably better at guitar.
Chispatr 4 months ago
i love tony Iomii, but Randy freakking Rhoads!!!! sick
kadrock 10 months ago
GEORGE HARRISON
TDubsesbueno 1 year ago
@bobdolecult
Are you seriously saying that slash is a better guitarist than the likes of jimmy page? Or angus young?
He plays everything in the same key ¬_¬ That list is out of date. It hasnt got Matthew bellamy or jack white on there but I cant see any reason why slash should be on there. Hes good technicaly but he cant improvise for shit :)
bmiester2003 1 year ago
@bmiester2003 I agree on Matt and Jack, but what you're saying about Slash is wrong. He is not playing everything in the same key, that would be Angus, and you clearly stated that Angus is a better guitarist. Also, He's not that much of a technical player as you're saying. Most of his live solos have TONS of improv.
qwertuyop 10 months ago
@bmiester2003
WRONG
musefoos10 5 months ago
oh my fucking God, is this a concert or a cell phone commercial??
44eelz 1 year ago
engaged to play the drums.
chabon88 1 year ago
Now that Gibson is one sexy guitar.
pakvasevigreste 1 year ago
dude that guitar solo was great!! Its not just about technical and fast you can get. he played soo smoothly, and the note choices. if you were a fan of pink floyd you would understand..
wenser13 1 year ago 2
.....where was the solo.....
Gibsonbloos 1 year ago
tht was some sweet guitar playing, but yeah, he jus rocks the fuck outta those drums!!!!!
StadiumArcadium1234 1 year ago
is that a fender starcaster he is using here? and i dont mean the new line of cheapies. i mean the 70s hollowbody one.
VincentValentineXIII 1 year ago
didnt he play drums for nirvana?
wmt1234567 2 years ago
he did
ajaxrulzz 2 years ago
gilmour is amazing player, otherwise comfortably numb wouldnt (on numerous occassions) be voted best guitar solo ever. still hats off to cobain, SLTS is one of the most recognisable riffs ever!!
ijfox87 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dudes wtf ur arguin bout who's better kurt or gilmour wel obvious kurt he's a legend no 1 cares or givs 2 shits or even no's who david gilmour is so just stop arguin da ansers simple!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Minter090 2 years ago
Are you kidding? David Gilmour was a better singer, guitarist, and musician than Kurt by a million miles. Honestly, most people can get better than Cobain at guitar within 2 years of playing. How can you say that no one knows who Gilmour is? He's one of the most famous musicians of the last century... Also, learn how to spell.
TheStraightGuys 2 years ago
So you've never heard of Pink Floyd?
jasonR85 2 years ago
..I mean I really like Nirvana, they are among my favourite bands, but if you don't know who David Gilmour or Pink Floyd are, sir, if you don't mind, step out of the internet.
frunchzz 2 years ago 5
@Minter090
wtf gilmour is a legend
musefoos10 5 months ago
enough of this gimour vs kurt cobain stuff they were both amazing
Rabby0605 2 years ago 2
o dude for real david gilmour can do circles around kurt cobain on guitar. cobain good write good songs, with 4 chords that could really rock. gilmour could play guitar and blow minds
TheGsxrDemon 2 years ago 3
no kurt was way better at guitar if you listen to nirvana's early live stuff kurt goes crazy on the guitar.Much better then in this video
macymayo 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david gilmour can suck my cock pink floyd is overrated as shit
dave isnt that good hes not as good as kurt cobain on guiter
lovernamedloveseth 2 years ago
i go 2 school wit his neice
grndayblinks44times 3 years ago
dave is obviously a better drummer than a guitarist
powertothechord 3 years ago 33
I COMPLETELY agree
lejejzerman 2 years ago 2
agreed, but how many people can play EVERY insrument in a band at an excellent level?
shultzie445 2 years ago 2
exactly, it is incredible, thats why he is one of my favorite musicians, that and i like his style of playing/singing
dannyboy6907 2 years ago
Awesome! XD Dave Grohl rox!! He's got his Gibson DG-335 and a very nice guitar solo.
RasachiSenseiUch2 3 years ago
not the best guitar player but certainly better then many. i agree with the1nameless and tango616. great guitar players play with their souls not just the guitar. dragonforce are flashy but have no soul in their music.
rock on dave
hoonda89 3 years ago 3
i agree with u too, when u get lost in ur own stuff, its unexplainable. And good guitarists always get lost in their music, its all about the soul, dragon force just play fast as they can.
tatersalad4real 2 years ago 3
This guy is like some kind of musical Swiss Army knife. He can play pretty much any instrument out there and is a damn good singer.
All things considered, him being an above average guitarist as well is a huge achievement.
rawrghblarghwaurgh 3 years ago 3
personally, I think Dave Grohl is a damn good drummer but when it comes to guitar he isn't anything special.
mexicanstinkypants 3 years ago
hmm i must say that Dave Grohl isnt the best guitar soloist out there... But the Foo Fighters still fukn rock!!! And well it appears that Dave's improved on his soloing from when he first started so thats awesum!!!!! FOO FIGHTERS ROCK!!!!!!
gweetarshredder 3 years ago
dave g is the greatest guitarist IMO, the g stands for gilmour tho!
irishmusicman88 3 years ago
Why thumbs down??
David Gilmour is probably the greatest guitar player of all time..
doufeel 2 years ago
van halen
tatersalad4real 2 years ago
Jimi Hendrix. Without Jimi, all those "incredible" guitarists you people rattle on about, would either never have picked up guitar (Satriani) or would of played something totally different (Blackmore, Stevie Ray and Jimmie Vaughn, and many more artists.)
pangborn25 2 years ago 2
good fucking point man thumbs up
wmt1234567 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the greatest guitarist ever is Jack Black. No contest man.
drunkobongo 3 years ago
hey!! i want the whole damn song <,<
Calimero987 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
my friend actually thinks that this guy is better than synyster gates LMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
GotNothinBetter2Do 4 years ago
ur friends stupid then
lilchankstas 3 years ago
dave grohl is a drummer, guitar is his 2nd instrument, of course hes worse
drummerjonathanp 3 years ago
dave's far better than that guy though...
I mean, what's so good about that sloppy shredding?
his solos sound like a 11 year old XD
sixnuggets 3 years ago
no...just...no
tango616 3 years ago
isn't that because youre just into metal music?
sixnuggets 3 years ago
i AM into metal music but im diff. than the people who listen to nothing but metal i listen to everything sept country, rap, and stupid hip-hop and stuff like that...i still like some of the foo's songs but hes got nothing on synister gates
tango616 3 years ago
well, to me, the fact that you limit the area of your musical preferences is really sad.
hmm why don't you try to have benevolence to embrace as much musical genres as possible?
SO, why dont we stop this conversation and ask each other some kind questions? haha
whos your fav guitarist?
sixnuggets 3 years ago
ummm id say michel anigilo baito, alexi laiho, eddie van halen, mark mortan, willie adler, and dimebag darrel... how bout you bro?
tango616 3 years ago
yea dude, i love dave grohl, but hes not that great of a guitarist
sharty5000 3 years ago
lol your not really different judging from your fav guitarists
and you know i like alexi (COBHC!!!!) n eddie
but recently iv bin thinking that maybe what makes a guitarist great is not how many notes he can play but the songs he writes
the1nameless 3 years ago
true i belive the note thing that you said. BUT jack white plays like hardly any notes but there all with alot of soul but alot of them still suck...and dragonforce solos have a million notes but they have NO soul, so again they suck...you gotta find a happy medium...like johnny demaro...greatest player ever
tango616 3 years ago
yeah yeah i mean like its about the songs you write rather than amount of notes like jack whites songs suck and he cnt shred so he sucks
dragonforce can shred but there songs are all the same ( although herman ri is soo cool =P )
so yeah you gotta be able to write good songs
and bein able 2 shred never hurt either =)
the1nameless 3 years ago
cheers dude
tango616 3 years ago
jack white is only second to one man
that man is dave grohl.
TregosMusic 3 years ago
HAHAHAHA
tango616 3 years ago
Than heavens for the Foo Fighters. Grohl is far more talented than Cobain ever thought of being.
tkmslee 4 years ago 4
more talented technically than kurt. kurt is a better writer. and I'm a huge fan of both.
hanusanus666 3 years ago
yeah, so why isn't Dave at #12 on Rolling Stone's guitar list instead of kurt, 58 places higher than Eddie Van Halen?
Dabomb782 3 years ago
because rolling stone's list is by popular vote and is complete and utter bullshit. for instance, slash isnt even on it, and it lists 100 guitarists. that list can suck a dick.
bobdolecult 3 years ago 16
well said sir.
hanusanus666 3 years ago 2
but slash does suck...well no but hes way to overrated...he can play very well but he is still way to overated
tango616 3 years ago
@bobdolecult obviously. its just PR for the magezine. they dont want slash cuz of legal troubles.
narutokiller9 1 year ago
@bobdolecult
No fuckin' way, really? If there's no Slash on the list, then it ain't worth a lousy dime.
pakvasevigreste 1 year ago
@bobdolecult slash is a crap guitarist
hazetubist 8 months ago
Better view and camera than mine at The Fab Forum show on Wed night. Gr8 show!!
cota2007 4 years ago
he did the exact same thing in Omaha!
Lynz2Gerard 4 years ago
omg i was there to at the oracle arena in oakland on feb 2nd 2008
BlackVomit9 4 years ago
OMG i was there!
it eas soooo great!
thyanic 4 years ago
i fuckin loved the show alsone...i loved how active he was... then how he went behind stage and was taunting us... then he played 3 more songs
draetalk123 4 years ago
dave is fuckin hilarious
ajaguilera 4 years ago
yea by far the most amazing concert ive ever seen
flamintacohole 4 years ago
I went to that show....wow! THE best concert i've ever been to!
r0ysapp 4 years ago
I think you were right next to me
gabegrote 4 years ago