This makes me so happy! :) It's a pleasure to watch her conduct. I showed this to my granny, who is a musician, and she said she was fabulous, especially for an amateur. She really has musical talent!
bloody hell! what happened to the passion of the peices. Her interpretation is horrible. She has no style! She totally degraded Stravinsky! This was the worst I have ever seen. I would have no respect for this conductor whatsoever.
You're right, but don't forget this is a TV show (it's made to entertain!) and she's not a conductor... she's not even a musician! If you see it with a bit of perspective it's quite good for an amateur.
NOOOO she killed the ending, one of my most favorite parts in all the world of music. it was played well, but she drained it of the super-extreme intensity that is Stravinsky
i think what killed the intensity was the tempo she took at 2:33..... gave no room for a dramatic ritard poco a poco....she drug out the end... otherwise it was fairly decent in my opinion
What's the point of this..? It sounds so much.. worse than the original Firedbird. Also... is she actually conducting or waving her hand around just to show how much sound should be produced...?
Esse comentário vai ter que ser em português hehehe.... enquanto aqui a gente tem que aguentar os BBB da vida, os reality shows lá são disputa entre maestro.. puta paisinho de merda o nosso viu , kkkkkkkkk
mais algum músico brasileiro ai ???
sensacional o vídeo e o programa ( não digo o mesmo da regência... rss)
This was a brave choice, but she carried it well. Her Beethoven 5th was very very good too so I am glad she won. But thats taking nothing away from Goldie, I would sill happily pay to hear a night at the proms conducted by him! He was expressive and made a wonderful connection with the pieces he conducted. Sue was better though in my opinion.
It took some guts to choose that piece with Vengerov there, and Sue brought it off with elan. This and her Beethoven 5 were the two most impressive performances of the series I felt. The Beethoven, in particular, showed Sue's true potential as a sculptor in sound.
Goldie produced thrilling performances but some slow passages were tricky for him - though he coped well with Nimrod.
For me, it was Sue's ability to subtly vary the dynamics that gave her the edge, and she was a worthy winner.
Hmmm. the part at 2:50 onwards seemed to lack direction. It needed to bemore punchy and bold (detached) in my view.
PianoKwanMan 8 months ago
This makes me so happy! :) It's a pleasure to watch her conduct. I showed this to my granny, who is a musician, and she said she was fabulous, especially for an amateur. She really has musical talent!
EmmyNeander 10 months ago
bloody hell! what happened to the passion of the peices. Her interpretation is horrible. She has no style! She totally degraded Stravinsky! This was the worst I have ever seen. I would have no respect for this conductor whatsoever.
AspieHospitesMundi 2 years ago
You're right, but don't forget this is a TV show (it's made to entertain!) and she's not a conductor... she's not even a musician! If you see it with a bit of perspective it's quite good for an amateur.
crotchet66 2 years ago 3
NOOOO she killed the ending, one of my most favorite parts in all the world of music. it was played well, but she drained it of the super-extreme intensity that is Stravinsky
otherjoe1234 2 years ago
i think what killed the intensity was the tempo she took at 2:33..... gave no room for a dramatic ritard poco a poco....she drug out the end... otherwise it was fairly decent in my opinion
trumpetdudeman07 2 years ago
I'm confused.
What's the point of this..? It sounds so much.. worse than the original Firedbird. Also... is she actually conducting or waving her hand around just to show how much sound should be produced...?
Jiyounglovesyou 3 years ago
really well done but im kinda disappointed that the horn solo was left out at the beginnning :(
shinnicko5 3 years ago 2
yeah, especially considering the horn solo pretty much starts the finale
otherjoe1234 2 years ago
Esse comentário vai ter que ser em português hehehe.... enquanto aqui a gente tem que aguentar os BBB da vida, os reality shows lá são disputa entre maestro.. puta paisinho de merda o nosso viu , kkkkkkkkk
mais algum músico brasileiro ai ???
sensacional o vídeo e o programa ( não digo o mesmo da regência... rss)
lucianodomenico 3 years ago
Bravo,
Magnificent!
soundviewbx 3 years ago
What was the "boo-boo"?
Dashing24 3 years ago
This was a brave choice, but she carried it well. Her Beethoven 5th was very very good too so I am glad she won. But thats taking nothing away from Goldie, I would sill happily pay to hear a night at the proms conducted by him! He was expressive and made a wonderful connection with the pieces he conducted. Sue was better though in my opinion.
brickmakers 3 years ago 2
It took some guts to choose that piece with Vengerov there, and Sue brought it off with elan. This and her Beethoven 5 were the two most impressive performances of the series I felt. The Beethoven, in particular, showed Sue's true potential as a sculptor in sound.
Goldie produced thrilling performances but some slow passages were tricky for him - though he coped well with Nimrod.
For me, it was Sue's ability to subtly vary the dynamics that gave her the edge, and she was a worthy winner.
ftumschk 3 years ago 9
Thank you for uploading this! Couldn't believe she chose this, I thought she did an absolutely brilliant job.
eyemonster12 3 years ago 8