Granada (original)

[dukesofapollo]

i enjoyed this.

[musicbeyondall]

@TheAxeMutant No, I don't know it all. In fact I don't know enough to give lessons on youtube and pose as a composer. I studied just enough music to know the basics of a good composition. But you don't need to know that in order to enjoy music. So do enjoy it my friend!

[gbshellas]

... yes instruments can be taught, also composition can be taught, but in my opinion if you want to create music that comes from inside you and not just play it then I believe this will happen, no matter if you have not got any lessons or teachers. From the other side you can have thousand of teachers and play great music which has been written by others... not bad, but the greatest is the Creator...

@csybu I Like your Music

[oa02071970]

You´re great, reallly, without lessons at school thats fantastic, don´t listen do stupid guys. You´re better than most of em!

Keep goin on! ;o)

Nice girls on guitar are very rare ;-)

[musicbeyondall]

@oa02071970 I agree! Who needs schools? Only ugly girls should take lessons, the pretty ones will be celebrated no matter what :-) (also, if you're not careful enough, in certain schools you may end up learning how to spell)

[fisherboy1289]

Dope, @musicbeyondall has been commenting on here for over 8 months, obviously they keep coming back here for a listen!

[wendellb36]

I don't have any musical ability .you do and these critics don't either .keep it up you are gifted!

[viarnay]

good skill but keep need more practice

[musicbeyondall]

@RachelX55v You're wrong sweetie...that was a suggestion :-)...thank you anyway, the same to you....The reality is that she's not a skilled composer, and she knows it. But it seems that a lot of people enjoy her playing, and that's the main thing! If she studied composition, a different set of people would enjoy her music, and she may lose some of her present fans, who care more about her pretty smile than chops -- which is also perfectly fine by the way,

[samira169465]

this paints a beautiful picture for me! I think it's a lovely original, composed by a true artist. BRAVO!

[1inmessiah]

3:14 and 3:46 speak to my soul...You have a G-d given talent and you don't waste it!! Keep up the guitar playing and the composing, I love your music!

~Marie

[guitaro5000]

Look up "Turn your guitar into a drumset" It's friggin nuts!!!!

[vlastyr]

wow! im in love with you

[TheDarkKhaos]

Don't listen to negative ramblings........they are posted by people who have not or will never come close to reaching musical success. It's not a competition....it is art.

peace

[Tinweluine]

@TheDarkKhaos I totally agree... I would just add that the joy that playing an instrument can give you is the thing that matters

[shankaraist]

Great stuff. Here is how to apply guitar on stage for monetizing:

youtube.com/watch?v=b9aUG__FYG­U&feature=related 

[csybu]

@musicbeyondall I dont have any chance to get into a music school, I failed all the time when I wanted to learn. So I will find my way to play and compose.

[crpdst2003]

@csybu you're right....find your way.. I quit 30 years ago after death of a fellow guitar friend of mine..... I reqret that...now its been 5 years since I started playing and my progress amazes me...maybe I am more patient and practise alot more just being older but I think I play for myself and I feel good if I learn something ....thats my aim and if I get better at it OK, if I don't OK it still makes me feel better.... I wish I was young like you a playing guitar...keep going...

[gawunkelle]

@musicbeyondall you forgot one scale: enjoying. on a scale of five of enjoying i give 5 which is the most important thing

[cannonj16]

@musicbeyondall music is not defined by set rules this is a buetiful peice of art and how do you know its random?? this is an awsome song people make music from garbage cans, random things from arround the house and what you call constructive critisicism is not "useful" things like this need to be praised there should be alot more people playing music. music is a form of soul that everyone els can feel by hearing it and its why you can tell when someone really enjoys it or only for money

[musicbeyondall]

@cannonj16 What I'm trying to say is if she studied music formally she could compose much better pieces. You need to know musical forms, harmony, etc....You don't want to go to a dentist who learned his skills in his bedroom, right? Or I may be wrong...he could still pull out a bad tooth or two...:-) But hey, if you enjoy it, that's all that matters!

[cannonj16]

@musicbeyondall from as far as i can tell she just wants to make music and share it with others music isn somthing to take stress over and taken serously when played i meen it could be but that takes away the pleasure of music then it becomes a chore a job and for most people music is an escape and a pleasure and you shouldnt ever try and take that from some one

[cannonj16]

@musicbeyondall you cant compare dentestry work with music music is not really somthing you can teach its a part of your soul yeah you can show people the chordes of a guitar the keys to a piano and all that jazz but when it comes down to it you ither have it in you or you dont you can see that she really puts her heart and soul into playing guitar and you are correct by saying its a matter of opionion and your entitled to it BUT she doesnt need to study books to be good

[spyclanhectic]

@musicbeyondall just because she is not a professional doesn't mean that the piece is not well constructed. on a scale of five i give composition a 4. this piece uses flamenco techniques with a chord progression that is not very flamenco so it may sound weird but it fits. on technique a 4 and performance a 1 cuz she's in her room with the lights dim haha. i like this piece

[ElizabethSouth]

This is absolutely beautiful!!! Great job!

[Mpoiuz]

Wow, excellent! Fascinating from the beginning to the last note! Congrats!

[robbourassaguitarist]

Great stuff.

[bhaktajose]

Very sweet performance!

[HungryEars]

Hi Edina,

Thank you for posting this performance. It is such a beautiful composition! I am going to feature it, and four more of your original compositions, on my channel this week. I hope you don't mind.

[jblackmd1]

Beautiful

[remoods]

Really great ... we love your playing !!!

REMOODS

[jorgeanayaperez]

aplauso aplauso!!  =)

[thenatureway]

awesome!

[jayj420]

you are so beautiful i love your smile and your talent shows off the beauty on the inside! i wish i could find somebody as passionate about what they love as you are about ur music.

[memoriasdosilencio]

I love tour music and your smiles and your style too! :) you will be my teacher in next mouths ;P

[Mr5stevenr]

very nice piece composition. it should be called "butterfly over a pond." steve.

[AsMUSICASdoMUNDO]

Melodia muy linda y agradable :) *****

[benitogoesyoutubing]

vey nice indeed - i picture a Mountain Trail with this. when is your CD coming out?

[sajiguitarist]

very nice...

[hichem1000]

bravo edina

[karkazi]

you'll progress faster , if you borrow a teacher ;)

[Techmonkey]

beautiful - your ear and passion are fantastic. i went to granada once... what a beautiful place - i went to the mirador de san nicholas in the arabic quadrant (i think) and watched the sunset there, there were a couple of flamenco guitarists there - i hope you take your guitar up there sometime!

[theuglyfolkers]

your fantastic...

[debbieswinyer]

Great job keep it up!

[mariolokovaldez]

very nice edina!! great harmony, take care hope ur doing well.

mario

[ojomanuk]

Magnificent!

[CallejonParaGuitarra]

hypnotic and tranquil, thankyou

[letmebe1990]

this sounds awsome

[zawhein2000]

beautiful!

[murdelabop]

So it's not pure Flamenco. So what? It's nice, and if you enjoy composing it and playing it then so much the better. Let it not be Flamenco. Let it be your own!

[Lostplacer]

Nicely played. You really are selftaught? Hard to believe ;-)...

BTW, like your smile :-)

Greetings from Germany...

[csybu]

@Lostplacer not completely. But at the first 6 years I was and than I had lessons for 1 year... and became selftaught again... I prefer that way! But I know I needed a teacher to get the right technic.

[TheAlexjiments]

Very Good guitar player, you are very beautiful too.

Sorry for my poor English.

[key2kingdom]

Hi Edina, thanks for this tune. I particularly enjoyed the stream that began running at 0:52

[TheAviationDreamer]

please no tabs or sheet

please

[lucisuciu]

,,,I liked your composition ....and usually I don't like flamenco ,,,lol ....keep the faith !

[edituxe]

Really really good song. You playing so fast, cant believe ;D

u are so good at it :) Respect

[Cyrloud]

hello nice EDina, How are you ?

[classical0612]

its beautiful song!

I can feel wind of granada.

[marchhare63]

One of your best so far!

[gigantin]

Szia Edina nagyon szepen játszol jo hallgatni egy olyan not játszani akinek szive is van a zenehez  csak igy tovább isten áldjon .

[gspottopsg]

very nice!

[beedeetripo]

Congratulations on you wonderous composition!!! You play very well and with great feeling!!!greetings and respect from Bram D., Holland

[BESTEVAAR]

You and Delboy are so nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wow. This is so great to see!!!!!!!!

I hope that you both do well!!!

You are both fantastic in your own special ways. In Spain we say Muy Simpaticos!!!!!!

[sillykidssong]

beautiful composition....it has a rainy day feel to it.

[Fabyr]

Bravissima! You always play with great skill the guitar.

Really good! Ciao.

[DemolitionMarty18]

You have some of the most beautiful sounds i ever heard

[CassiusChrysanthe]

szep improvizacio! ugyeske{:

[sockenfrank]

a great one.

think i can learn a lot from you.

[delboy1978uk]

ole senorita ! very very nice! you had a good holiday then? :-D learn any new guitar tricks?

im going to spain in november now! cant wait! :-D

[csybu]

I am jealous! But you should be jealous as well since I will go to Rodrigo y Gabriela concert in November:))))) I cant wait!

[delboy1978uk]

i have seen them twice! and i have shook hands with rodrigo and high-fived gabriela! but i am still jealous, because i would love to see them again soon! x

[csybu]

wow this will be the first time for me... I cant wait!!!

[delboy1978uk]

get right down at the front next to them! you will have a great time!

[yokehuatgoh]

nice!!

[jardaczechguitar]

I like how you look, but how you play .... :-(

[jetadmin]

Fantastic creation! I love the arpeggio section! Very nice triplet and golpa integration.

[TheBrooklynRadio]

Lovely, beautiful tune, very hypnotic and dream-like.

Peace

BkRadio

[rolly11247]

Great music chica keep up the good work. God bless

[chertpert2001]

Very good, youve improved a lot.

[village5]

i don't feel nothing when i listen your videos ,

[rican69g]

amazing congratulations

[tottenhamx]

lovely

[edkim1220]

good one

[OneArmedMN]

very nice!

[millthor]

A beautiful song for such a beautiful place, but with this name I was thinking it was the famous classical guitar piece called Granada.

[xardas77]

The best! The musical passion can be heard, seen, and felt.

[MoltenPoo]

Simply beautiful. Thank you!

[go46go]

adorabile et brava musicista + bellissima

[gg401]

Bravo!!

[dkrapchetov]

Super! Will be tough to write tabs down for this piece, but if you do get around to it, I would love to have them! Thanks for putting this song out!

[underpolka]

sounds very cool :)

[XguitarrockerX]

Wow! I'm stunned, it's like a story on a guitar, it brings images in my head. I really like the diverse techniques you use. And the chord work too! love it

[Liranm89]

Hi! Where can I buy your CD? have you considered being a movie composer?

I think you're a genious, this is so great! the music is like a tale! favourited.

[csybu]

Thats very nice of yo! Thanks!!! Actually I want to learn composing for films! But it is a master course, and I dont have any qualification from music I am selftaght and once I had a guitar teacher who was selftaght!!! Grrr... But Maybe I will try to apply anyway.

How are you? Long time no speak.

[rafinhabertelli]

you play perfectly... you have too much talent, i love your songs, girl. you are perfect!

i'd like to know if you have any cd, or myspace. i'm sure that have a lot of people would like to download your musics.

continue playing... you are very goooood

[ladiiiis]

ole ole ole oleeeeeeee, que preciosidad cielo, que bonito, gracias por dejarte escuchar, gracias

[velspir]

i love your creativity it is very unique :)

[sharylc]

I see a lot of creativity in this one. Thanks for posting csybu!

[martintoque]

SWEEEEEET! I love it.

[Zander4724]

brilliant chords!

[horny4Utube]

Uou've got talent, I would work on polishing the technique.

[joefileman]

Music can be found all over the world. To find yourself in music is profound. 5 stars.

[swingbossa]

I am very impressed. I think it's your best one yet, and that it came from happiness is almost certainly part of the reason. (Yet we must know sadness to be able to appreciate happiness!) Worth the wait, and glad to hear that you are full of love and happiness!

[chris88kolate]

i really like the part that starts at 3:13 -3:47

can you make an instructional video or post some tabs to that section?

[murdelabop]

Very nice!

[slickhaystacks]

That was absolutely fantastic!!!

The ending was the best.

[ibrahim3d]

I loved it.

One day, Al-Andalus will be home again.

[Fabyr]

Marvellous performance. Compliments for the piece and your way to give expression to the music that you play.

[walexey1985]

You got really better about your skill of playing guitar! And the composition is very beautifull!=)

In my opinion, you should work on some little technical mistakes in it, then record it with a good sound quality, which is not available through a camera=) And maybe to perform this piece at some music festival.

[csybu]

thanks so much my friend!!!

[krymell357]

where have you been Edina - we miss you so much!!!

[lichiarenz]

Realmente una maravillosa musica muy bien tocada.

Brava Edina!

5*

Fabrizio

[KenMiddletonUkulele]

A beautiful piece of music. You should be really proud of it. I particularly love the section that begins after about a minute.

A room full of stars.

[druhjt]

have you been in Granada? very nice place, full of Art, so much inspiring..

i like your composition, it'd be interesting to comment some more about this piece, but there are few lines to write.. keep on playin' like that !!! Salud!

[csybu]

yes yes. Well the only thing I can tell from this piece is that this is the first one that I did not write from depression, but from love and happiness maybe thats why it is so much better than my other compositions.. Thanks for your comment my friend!

[filometti1]

A beautiful inspiration for interpreter this magnificent composition --Compliments Edina

[csybu]

Thanks stweety!

[Leskaaaaaa]

It's SUPER!!! As always!

[MiguelMvM]

beautifull chords! very deep sound

[Adrain30]

very beautiful piece..Congratulations

[charmingdee]

that was awesome!

[AndanteLargo]

Dear Edina! How nice to hear a piece by you! It is very beautiful!! I love the arpeggio in the middle! Great harmonies there!! 5 stars and MORE!!

Hugs,

Per-Olov

[csybu]

thanks Per! The compliment is even better since it is coming from you!!!

[zigorly]

...che bello..sei davvero brava edina!

[zigorly]

...che bello edina, sei davvero brava!

[hamamedo]

so cute

always the best

[wolfofworld]

wow.

[wolfofworld]

Really great.

[rudimms]

excelent!!!

maravilhoso, perfeito!!!!

[xfgao3]

This is great.

[hersoveela]

Simply fabulous. I really love the ending.

[csybu]

Thanks master!

[GuildF40]

I just subbed to your channel

This flamenco stuff is easier to understand with someone like you doing the explaining .

Great passion 5*****

[downhill240]

Thank you for sharing your love of the guitar with us!

[Arundeep123ahluwalia]

nice!

[uncleparsnip]

that ending is fantastic. very impressive.

I am going to have to get my guitar now and have a go at it, and i was just about to go to bed.

[uncleparsnip]

nice piece edina - a few nice major sevenths in there. your rhythmic stuff is always great.

you do know there is already a flamenco piece called granada though by albeniz from his suite espanola. every piece in the suite is named after a region in spain.

I dont know if that matters or not. probably not

anyway. well composed and played.

5 stars

[csybu]

yes yes I know thats why it was so amezing when I was in the airport inb Madrid! There were flights to Asturias!!! Amezing!

[guitarflamenco77]

Very beautiful!

[BobMars1260]

That is so beautiful! Thank you for sharing. Most Sincerely...

[ahmed341]

what u got is not inspiration it's called "guitar lessons" for one year made ur playing much better and ur scope much wider!! well done edina

[aks73]

Nice arpeggios..well played.

[wsmondschein]

Nice compostion; very dynamic. Congratulations on breaking through your writer's block :)

[YaGonk101]

A very provocative piece Edina.....Thank you soooo mutch !! Charming !! :o) Kindest regard`s  Ben..

[ohioflyfisher]

Nice composition, I think you gave it that flamenco feel. And yes Granada is an amazing place.

[PabloFrozen]

Congrats Edina! Awesome !

[zawhein2000]

amazing!

[MagicAccent]

Interesting piece. Well done :)