@radwigs ;great comments from you.Iagree that this is simply brilliant and cant find anything on Youtube that she performs which is otherwise.This is definitely a gifted and beautiful colaratura soprano who should be getting more world recognition.
this is the weirdest version of this song i've ever seen LOL. She's hilarious. I like patricia but i dont think i like this one, too bizarre. I know this song is silly and absurd but i've seen better version and this is just too wacky. it's fun to watch though.
When I first watched this, I thought it was goofy and over-the-top, even ridiculous. That was about 30 views ago. Now I think it's absolutely sublime. Needless to say she grew on me. She just has this magnetic quality that keeps me coming back for more.
No sir I don't like it . It's a nice voice, certainly. I found the performance of it tacky and she slowed down in certain parts that I can't tell if she did it purposely of just couldn't handle the runs a tempo. but she's hot so most people won't care
Could you guys loose this annoying habit to say that a woman is "hot" when you think she is good-looking ? Sluts and porn stars may be hot. This woman isn't hot, she is pretty, that's a very different thing.
@colombineann Could you lose "loose" when you mean "lose"? I agree with your point, but when you are lecturing people in English, it works much better if you get it right.
Une cabaretiste? Si vous voulez, mais une très grande chanteuse aussi. J'admets qu'ici, elle cabotine, c'est son moindre défaut. Mais l'avez-vous regardée chanter ce rôle nue ou plutôt en costume de femme nue? Elle ne cabotine plus du tout, et fait de l'automate un personnage à part entière.
This is a bad transcription with a whining noise influencing the overall sound. Her voice is perfect for this role as is her expression. Try to find a better transcription before you judge!
yep, she is excaggerated as a mechanical doll but her voice is really astonishing...i mean i found someone who is almost near to be something that resemples natalie dessay....maybe because this ms petitbon received the same french singing training that dessay revceived
I'm not sure you got the point here, because, according to the offenbach's opera, she IS a mechanical doll. So the interpretation is completely right here.
haha ^_^ im afraid that it is you who didnt get what i mean; i know that she is supposed to be a mechanical doll, the fact is that i think that she is TOO EXAGGERATED even for being a mechanical doll...she did put too much emphasis in the "being mechanical"
En général, j'aime beaucoup ce qu'elle fait, et j'admire les artistes qui se permettent de revisiter ce genre de trucs, mais là... Je trouve pas ça terrible. Un peu lourd.
Beaucoup de travail et d'originalité mais c'est quand même très osée, la partition est très déformée et la voix n'est pas toujours là...sûrement du talent pourtant.
The best thing about Patricia Petibon is that she isn't the typical soprano ,she have bright personality but at the same time she still have talent and classical technique.not like all those "classical-crossover" sopranos who can't sing a note like filipa giordano or sarah brightman who can sing but is not possible to uderstand what is she singing
beaucoup trop de bouffonnades... pour une voix qui reste un peu trop guturale... pour faire le clown il faut posséder l'excellence de la technique et un timbre parfait !!! ça n'est pas son cas... ce qui est permis à Dessay n'est pas donné à tout le monde !!!
Je suis d'accord avec vous, à ceci prés que je n'apprécie guère Natalie Dessay qui est bien trop médiatisée et mise en avant, et ayant pourtant une voix assez ordinaire.
J. Offenbach et son inspirateur ETA Hoffmann demandent justement du burlesque, de la fantaisie, de la gaité, de la féérie drôlatique...Patricia interprète tout ça dans le bon sens. C'est enlevé, c'est vif et humoristique ! Actrice, poupée et chanteuse tout à la fois. En tout cas, chanté par la Petibon, il me ragaillardit cet air-là !
En réponse à Senaforever, Insaneoperapixie et quelques autres États-Uniens pissefroids : par pitié, ne prenez pas les Contes d'Hoffmann pour le Parsifal de Wagner ! On n'est pas sur le même terrain musical, ni la même esthétique.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think this is the worst thing I have ever heard next to Hannah Montana and chinese opera. I think this is a cross between the two,and an agrivated miniture poodle...
Décidemment, il n'y a pas moyen de mettre une réponse au bon endroit (Au niveau d'un commentateur précis) sur ce site étasunien.
Je voulais répondre à "Latraviata"
Je sais bien que "Des Contes d'Hoffmann" est d'Offenbach qui bien que compositeur du 19è siècle est nettement supérieur aux navrants "Bel Cantistes".C'est d'ailleurs l'avis de ETA Hoffmann, compositeur autrement plus inventif et savant que les compositeurs de la péninsule...
Take out the joke and she's still an exemplary artist of the traditional French coloratura: nasal and very bright (you might say harsh) on notes above C. Oh and I love her singing Baroque BTW !
OMG it must be hard to sing while shaking hands and jumping so much... She is definitely great, although I think that she went too far in this interpretation.
Seeing this video makes me want to hate her and dismiss her as amateur, but her technique is legitimate and she sounds great (when she's not doing that awful squeaky voice).
A full-length CD-set exists of the Tales of Hoffmann with Petibon playng Olympia. To be sure, her rendition of the Doll Song is quite different from that which most of us have heard over the years. I find the lady interesting!
2:23 for squeaky dog toy :-D
jfichter69 1 week ago in playlist Vocals
The freakest version I've ever watched *-*
LacrimaLunaMortua 2 weeks ago
AWESOME I LOVE IT :D
HeidelbergSoprano 2 months ago
Comment removed
pipari44 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nossa adoro a Patricia...gosto muito das músicas dela *-*
Brasil torce por você Patricia Petibon
Stephannycristina 4 months ago
Comment removed
Stephannycristina 4 months ago
ottima performance, ma no si poteva utilizzare un pianoforte vero anzichè quella schifezza dello yamaha?
pinintra 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Che schifo!!!! Orrible! Terrible!
galziale 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Che schifo!!!! Orrible! Terrible!
galziale 5 months ago
Les oiseaux dans la charmille
Dans les cieux l'astre du jour,
Tout parle à la jeune fille d'amour!
Ah! Voilà la chanson gentille
La chanson d'Olympia! Ah!
YaelCapitan 6 months ago
слишком много баловства!Натали-непревзойденная Кукла!!!
TheNattella 9 months ago
@TheNattella Мне нравится
orlandomonjoie 4 months ago
She`s adorable and she must be very brave to make her voice so thin at will! As this is not her natural voice... nevertheless, a true doll!
Transoxiana94 1 year ago 4
Reminds me of a sex-with-a-marionette scene in a Fellini film... I can't remember which one it was.
DieSonneSinkt 1 year ago
3:04 to3:12 is just plain amazing
woundedheart132 1 year ago
Love it!!!!! It is a song being done by a doll, how serious should it really be? I think she is brilliant!
radwigs 1 year ago
@radwigs ;great comments from you.Iagree that this is simply brilliant and cant find anything on Youtube that she performs which is otherwise.This is definitely a gifted and beautiful colaratura soprano who should be getting more world recognition.
HaberfieldChiro 1 year ago
Che schifo!!!! Orrible! Terrible!
AndreaNozzari 1 year ago
this is the weirdest version of this song i've ever seen LOL. She's hilarious. I like patricia but i dont think i like this one, too bizarre. I know this song is silly and absurd but i've seen better version and this is just too wacky. it's fun to watch though.
acladiva 1 year ago 2
LOL at the performance and peoples comments !!!!!!! This is really cool!
osbornd89 1 year ago
When I first watched this, I thought it was goofy and over-the-top, even ridiculous. That was about 30 views ago. Now I think it's absolutely sublime. Needless to say she grew on me. She just has this magnetic quality that keeps me coming back for more.
evolve749 1 year ago
她應該是我看過手最忙的女高音了~= =
l51660322 1 year ago
c'est une blague, nest ce pas...?
dubonetducon 1 year ago
Bwhahahahahaha this totally cracked me up.
Diva2themax 1 year ago
is lovely!! <3
sucubodream 1 year ago
Super comme d'habitude =D Elle me fait bien rire !! Toujours des superbes interpretation j'adore
noccioza 1 year ago
unusual....
but she has a nice voice
FDGDSFg332 1 year ago
She needs to work on her intonation. But I guess that isn't important.
CatalinaDM56 1 year ago
freaky and not the best version i have heard!
neijsseni 1 year ago
Quelle voix!
paulinetalors 1 year ago
What a beautiful sense of humour and comedy!
AtahualpaGoldstein 1 year ago
No sir I don't like it . It's a nice voice, certainly. I found the performance of it tacky and she slowed down in certain parts that I can't tell if she did it purposely of just couldn't handle the runs a tempo. but she's hot so most people won't care
felicianomusic 1 year ago
@felicianomusic
Could you guys loose this annoying habit to say that a woman is "hot" when you think she is good-looking ? Sluts and porn stars may be hot. This woman isn't hot, she is pretty, that's a very different thing.
colombineann 1 year ago
@colombineann I was being facetious in my use of the word hot
felicianomusic 1 year ago
@colombineann Could you lose "loose" when you mean "lose"? I agree with your point, but when you are lecturing people in English, it works much better if you get it right.
donaldcallen 1 year ago
Pietosa...una cabarettista, non una cantante
carlo331 1 year ago
Une cabaretiste? Si vous voulez, mais une très grande chanteuse aussi. J'admets qu'ici, elle cabotine, c'est son moindre défaut. Mais l'avez-vous regardée chanter ce rôle nue ou plutôt en costume de femme nue? Elle ne cabotine plus du tout, et fait de l'automate un personnage à part entière.
MrBasilego 1 year ago
she is very player jajajajajajajaj i love her jajajajajaj
zasesdea 1 year ago
This is a bad transcription with a whining noise influencing the overall sound. Her voice is perfect for this role as is her expression. Try to find a better transcription before you judge!
AccessGuy11 2 years ago
nice voice as a matter of fact!
hochbar 2 years ago
It sounds like she has to urinate...really, really badly.
CatalinaDM56 2 years ago
Genial, i love it.
tipo11 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Disgusting!
cleanears 2 years ago
genial
edopiano88 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's mad... Terrible... An horror film...
gohar002 2 years ago
nope!
dynamicstuff73 2 years ago
Certified Intergalactic! What is it?
Dogaradodia 2 years ago
Me parece guapisima. La teatralidad con que canta me parece de lo mas original... y la verdad es que me pone como un perro.
Guitarrista 2 years ago
she looks like Amelié, and has a great voice!! that´s attitude... i luv her style!
destilar1 2 years ago 10
That's why I like hearing and watching her.
VeronicaSY 2 years ago
it just came to my mind exactly the same amelie with a grate voice ... but sumi jo is the best
birbanto24 2 years ago
she's so cute. i wanna mate with her
Bregowald 1 year ago
Me encanta ella!!! :D
crazytwinsinc 2 years ago
I love her voice and she's so cute!
TarjaSenpai 2 years ago 2
ME ENCANTA!!!!
josejuanparrasanchez 2 years ago
Quizá no sea la mujer más bella, no obstante, la más graciosa y encantadora.
ovleonmagno 2 years ago
Ni graciosa ni encantadora. Simplemente ridícula.
enerqe 2 years ago
As we say here in NYC, Tres Adorable!
LazlosPlane 2 years ago
she looks out of her mind.... and her voice is astonishingly out of this world!!!
cruxiagoth 2 years ago
a mi simplemente me encanta... hace una muy buena diferencia... y el aria se presta...
Elunatrece 2 years ago
Ouhaaaaaaaaahou !! je m'en remet pas !!!! elle est magnifique!!!! c'est merveilleux !!!
embargot 2 years ago
yep, she is excaggerated as a mechanical doll but her voice is really astonishing...i mean i found someone who is almost near to be something that resemples natalie dessay....maybe because this ms petitbon received the same french singing training that dessay revceived
killerbunny123123 2 years ago
I'm not sure you got the point here, because, according to the offenbach's opera, she IS a mechanical doll. So the interpretation is completely right here.
lolocemoi 2 years ago 2
haha ^_^ im afraid that it is you who didnt get what i mean; i know that she is supposed to be a mechanical doll, the fact is that i think that she is TOO EXAGGERATED even for being a mechanical doll...she did put too much emphasis in the "being mechanical"
killerbunny123123 2 years ago
OK, I've misunderstood what you were saying.
On another hand, I've seen her on stage at Paris Bercy in front of thousands of people. Her performance is not meant to be filmed so closely.
Finally it is of course, a question of appreciation.
lolocemoi 2 years ago
it is it is.....and i really love the voice of petitbone......she really has a clear voice and can reach high notes! very talented...
killerbunny123123 2 years ago
vicken massa skitsnack. Hon är ju dödsfestlig. Och fantastisk sopranröst. ren och klar.
akemilsson 2 years ago
Es una broma perfectamente expresada tanto en teatral como con la tecnica del instrumento.
Hay que tomarselo como lo que es, tambien hace cosas serias muy buenas.
Aprender a reir, sereis mas felices.
Eremita21 2 years ago
En général, j'aime beaucoup ce qu'elle fait, et j'admire les artistes qui se permettent de revisiter ce genre de trucs, mais là... Je trouve pas ça terrible. Un peu lourd.
MegaCawotte 2 years ago
Nice voice, but the performance is not good. She takes too many liberties.
nicevidbro 3 years ago
maybe a bit, it is just her interpretation
otacs2 2 years ago
I think Dessay own this piece. She made several interpretations on totally different productions and yet she always seems to get it right.
nicevidbro 2 years ago
Beaucoup de travail et d'originalité mais c'est quand même très osée, la partition est très déformée et la voix n'est pas toujours là...sûrement du talent pourtant.
sorbetkiwi 3 years ago 2
The best thing about Patricia Petibon is that she isn't the typical soprano ,she have bright personality but at the same time she still have talent and classical technique.not like all those "classical-crossover" sopranos who can't sing a note like filipa giordano or sarah brightman who can sing but is not possible to uderstand what is she singing
Heartlessiceboy 3 years ago 19
Mon Dieu! Pitoyable!!! Moche, mauvaise technique, commont a-t-elle pu passer aux informations national? C'est la honte national!!!!
cuniza 3 years ago
Tu est en train de critiquer sa personalité ! C'est une magnifique vision burlesque
atralfalgar 3 years ago
beurk !!
beaucoup trop de bouffonnades... pour une voix qui reste un peu trop guturale... pour faire le clown il faut posséder l'excellence de la technique et un timbre parfait !!! ça n'est pas son cas... ce qui est permis à Dessay n'est pas donné à tout le monde !!!
KOKAYT1 3 years ago
Le maître absolu a parlé...
bouzignac 3 years ago
Grand bien vous fasse !
KOKAYT1 3 years ago
Comment removed
Cosifantuttee 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Je suis d'accord avec vous, à ceci prés que je n'apprécie guère Natalie Dessay qui est bien trop médiatisée et mise en avant, et ayant pourtant une voix assez ordinaire.
Cosifantuttee 2 years ago
Quel plaisir que de revoir miss Petibon...
De plus est dans ce petit passage où la comédie, la voix, et la danse s'entremêlent avec aisance et humour!
C'est un sourire aux lèvres que je vous dis merci miss!..Merci!
PAUSEPAINT 3 years ago
GREAT GREAYT!!!!!!
baldandevil 3 years ago
I am in heaven...love u patricia...
CrebornR85 3 years ago
(suite & fin)
J. Offenbach et son inspirateur ETA Hoffmann demandent justement du burlesque, de la fantaisie, de la gaité, de la féérie drôlatique...Patricia interprète tout ça dans le bon sens. C'est enlevé, c'est vif et humoristique ! Actrice, poupée et chanteuse tout à la fois. En tout cas, chanté par la Petibon, il me ragaillardit cet air-là !
legrandchene 3 years ago 5
Au point de vous en faire oublier toute musicalité !
Si ça vous regaillardit ...
Moi elle me fait penser à ..... Vico la Reine de la patate ...une mauvaise chip's !
KOKAYT1 2 years ago
En réponse à Senaforever, Insaneoperapixie et quelques autres États-Uniens pissefroids : par pitié, ne prenez pas les Contes d'Hoffmann pour le Parsifal de Wagner ! On n'est pas sur le même terrain musical, ni la même esthétique.
legrandchene 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think this is the worst thing I have ever heard next to Hannah Montana and chinese opera. I think this is a cross between the two,and an agrivated miniture poodle...
PBDsgirl 3 years ago
Chinese opera? How dare you! That's the most moronic comment I have ever read.
coy6642126 3 years ago
have no taste...
LevisOrdo 3 years ago
Décidemment, il n'y a pas moyen de mettre une réponse au bon endroit (Au niveau d'un commentateur précis) sur ce site étasunien.
Je voulais répondre à "Latraviata"
Je sais bien que "Des Contes d'Hoffmann" est d'Offenbach qui bien que compositeur du 19è siècle est nettement supérieur aux navrants "Bel Cantistes".C'est d'ailleurs l'avis de ETA Hoffmann, compositeur autrement plus inventif et savant que les compositeurs de la péninsule...
bouzignac 3 years ago
she is singing a song talking about a mechanical doll having short circuits
crystalcyt 3 years ago
What do know about Music ...?
This was a concert for fun.
Old taste.
bouzignac 3 years ago
Take out the joke and she's still an exemplary artist of the traditional French coloratura: nasal and very bright (you might say harsh) on notes above C. Oh and I love her singing Baroque BTW !
kngiht84 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think she is just nuts.
mrlammermoor 3 years ago
beerk
JTec92 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Really hideous, no technique at all.
SENAFOREVER 3 years ago
This is hideous.
SENAFOREVER 3 years ago
This is loveley
gentlecurve 3 years ago 2
you are so right
forcapower 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OMG !!!
she's totally destroying this song !
her voice is not as beautiful as it should be for this song.
seriously, she's not good enough to sing that.
she could take lessons.
lyak 3 years ago
still jealous...??
LevisOrdo 3 years ago
hi!!! she's amazing with that voice
someone, could tell me the name of the song? please!!!! thanks
LauraPlavalaguna 3 years ago
Les Oiseaux Dans La Charmille
VeronicaSY 3 years ago
revolting
vitroz 3 years ago
Patricia Petibon is so terrebly amazing in this video, she is totally my favorite opera singer she's the best.
texaswhitelobo 3 years ago
Hysterical. Love it. Only one thing missing: black Converse high-tops.
(always loved Ms. Petibon)
TheSolidGloryisJesus 3 years ago 2
She's great
Tanushkarus 3 years ago
OMG it must be hard to sing while shaking hands and jumping so much... She is definitely great, although I think that she went too far in this interpretation.
eXecutivedirectress 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
elle est carrément insupportable !
phirze 3 years ago
i do not agree with you at all.
silly acting? this is what offenbach whats his character to act - he whats this aria to be completely absurd. and she does this fantastic!!
so if you don't know the peace then don't wright such comments!
zvpxrpl 3 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is exactly the reason why French get on my nerves.
sapunica43 3 years ago
Yankee débile
bouzignac 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too bad! she have such a pure and beatifull voice and instand of showing us this talnet she looks so silly.
what is her point? she want to be unick by "acting" like this?
sopran21 3 years ago
She kicks ass!
katmonica 3 years ago 2
Seeing this video makes me want to hate her and dismiss her as amateur, but her technique is legitimate and she sounds great (when she's not doing that awful squeaky voice).
latraviata1853 3 years ago
The "musique" of Verdi is without any interest.
Remember that before judging...
No instrumentation and vulgar melodies.
Italian "Bel"Canto is shit.
bouzignac 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
odiosa
youfeda 3 years ago
A full-length CD-set exists of the Tales of Hoffmann with Petibon playng Olympia. To be sure, her rendition of the Doll Song is quite different from that which most of us have heard over the years. I find the lady interesting!
gmmix 3 years ago 3
she's amazig!
tangleduprecordlabel 3 years ago 4
Oh, yes. She's so beautiful and talented.
VeronicaSY 3 years ago